RAssigned the civil and military officials he selected according to their abilities, without partialityWu 7 §30
NReceived men of talent at the guest hall and had them recommended; opposed the appointment of Lu XunCh. 38 §26Ch. 83 §35
| Occupation | RNOfficial · Chancellor | Faction | Wu |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wu |
| Born | R168 Unverified | Native place | Wu Commandery Wu County |
| Died | R243 Unverified | Place of death | |
| Cause of death | RIllness Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R28 |
Gu Yong, courtesy name Yuantan, was a man of Wu County in Wu Commandery. In his youth he studied the zither and letters under Cai Yong, and after serving as chief of several counties he became Assistant to Sun Quan, who concurrently held the post of Administrator of Kuaiji, and carried out the duties of Administrator on his behalf. Records, Wu 7 §27
After Sun Quan became King of Wu, Gu Yong served as Grand Judge and Minister of Rites (fengchang) and concurrently as Prefect of the Masters of Writing, and in the 4th year of Huangwu (225) he succeeded Sun Shao as Chancellor. He served as Chancellor for 19 years and died in the 6th year of Chiwu (243) at the age of seventy-six. Records, Wu 7 §28 · 30 · 34Records, Wu 2 §52
Chen Shou, the author of the Records, wrote in his assessment that because Gu Yong relied on his family's long-standing calling and added wisdom and capacity to it, he was able to enjoy his honored position to the end. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 29 as a man whom Zhang Hong recommends to Sun Quan, and appears in 14 of its 120 chapters. His name is not in any chapter title, and he appears as a civil official who repeatedly offers plans at Sun Quan's councils. Records, Wu 7 §100Romance, Ch. 29 §50Romance, Ch. 56 §4Romance, Ch. 98 §31
Gu Yong, courtesy name Yuantan, was a man of Wu County in Wu Commandery. When Cai Yong returned from Shuofang, he once stayed in Wu to escape his enemies, and Gu Yong studied the zither and letters under him. The province and commandery recommended him in memorials, and at about twenty he became Chief of Hefei; he was later transferred to Lou, Qu'e and Shangyu, and governed each with distinction. Records, Wu 7 §27
Sun Quan held the post of Administrator of Kuaiji concurrently but did not go to the commandery, and made Gu Yong his Assistant to carry out the duties of Administrator. Gu Yong suppressed the bandits, the commandery became peaceful, and officials and people submitted to him; after several years he was brought in as Major of the Left. When Sun Quan became King of Wu, Gu Yong was promoted repeatedly to Grand Judge and Minister of Rites (fengchang), concurrently held the post of Prefect of the Masters of Writing, and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Yangsui Village. Even when he returned to his office after receiving the marquisate, his household did not know of it, and they were astonished only when they heard of it later. Records, Wu 7 §27–28
In the 4th year of Huangwu (225), when Gu Yong brought his mother from Wu, Sun Quan went to congratulate him and personally bowed to his mother in the courtyard; the ministers and high officials all gathered, and later the Crown Prince also went to offer congratulations. Gu Yong did not drink wine, spoke little, and acted as the occasion required. Sun Quan once sighed, 'Lord Gu does not speak, but when he speaks he is always on the mark.' When banquets grew merry, those around him feared that Gu Yong would see them err in drink and dared not indulge themselves, and Sun Quan too said, 'When Lord Gu is present, he keeps people from enjoying themselves.' Records, Wu 7 §29–30
That year he was moved to Minister of Ceremonies, promoted to Marquis of Liling, and succeeded Sun Shao as Chancellor, concurrently overseeing the affairs of the Masters of Writing. The Biography of the Lord of Wu records that in the 5th month of the 4th year of Huangwu the Chancellor Sun Shao died, and in the 6th month the Minister of Ceremonies Gu Yong was made Chancellor. The Biography of Zhang Zhao records that after Sun Shao died the officials again recommended Zhang Zhao, but Sun Quan appointed Gu Yong, saying that Zhang Zhao was unbending by nature and that if what he said were not adopted, resentment and blame would arise. Records, Wu 7 §30 · 9Records, Wu 2 §52
Gu Yong assigned the civil and military commanders and officials he selected each according to their abilities, and was impartial at heart. From time to time he made inquiries among the people, and whenever he found something fitting for the government he reported it in secret; if it was adopted he gave the credit to the sovereign, and if it was not used he never let it leak out. When he spoke at court his words and expression were gentle, but what he held to was upright. When Sun Quan asked about the successes and failures of his government, Zhang Zhao said that the laws were too dense and the punishments somewhat heavy; when Sun Quan turned to Gu Yong and asked him, Gu Yong answered that what he had heard was the same as Zhang Zhao's words. Sun Quan thereupon reviewed criminal cases and lightened punishments. Records, Wu 7 §30–31
In the 2nd year of Jiahe (233), when Sun Quan intended to send the Minister of Ceremonies Zhang Mi and others across the sea to Gongsun Yuan with 10,000 soldiers, gold, silver and treasures, and the gifts of the Nine Bestowments, the high ministers of the whole court, from the Chancellor Gu Yong down, remonstrated that Gongsun Yuan could not yet be trusted and that the favor shown him was too generous, but Sun Quan would not listen in the end. In the 6th year of Jiahe (237), when Hu Zong proposed the death penalty for local officials who broke the prohibition and rushed home on a death in the family, the Chancellor Gu Yong memorialized that his proposal be adopted. Records, Wu 2 §73 · 75 · 81 · 84–85
Later the Palace Secretaries Lü Yi and Qin Bo took charge of examining the documents of the various government offices, provinces and commanderies, gradually wielded power, slandered high ministers and framed the innocent, and Gu Yong and others were also denounced and reprimanded. When Lü Yi memorialized that the Chancellor Gu Yong, the General of the Left Zhu Ju and others be investigated and had them all detained, the Gentleman-in-Attendance of the Yellow Gate Xie Gong said that if Gu Yong were dismissed Pan Jun would get his post, and that Pan Jun, who always ground his teeth at Lü Yi, would soon strike at him. Lü Yi was greatly afraid and dropped the case against Gu Yong. This is recorded in the Biography of Pan Jun. Records, Wu 7 §32Records, Wu 16 §4–5
When Lü Yi's wicked crimes came to light and he was handed over to the Commandant of Justice, Gu Yong went to judge the case. Gu Yong kept a mild expression as he questioned him on his statement, and as he was leaving asked Lü Yi whether there was anything he wished to say. When the Gentleman of the Masters of Writing Huai Xu openly reviled and insulted Lü Yi, Gu Yong rebuked Huai Xu, saying, 'The government has proper laws; why go this far?' The Biography of the Lord of Wu records Lü Yi's execution under the 1st year of Chiwu (238). Records, Wu 7 §32–33Records, Wu 2 §87–88
Gu Yong served as Chancellor for 19 years and died in the 6th year of Chiwu (243) at the age of seventy-six. When his illness was still slight, Sun Quan sent the physician Zhao Quan to examine him and appointed his youngest son Gu Ji as Cavalry Commandant; Gu Yong grieved, saying that Zhao Quan was good at telling life from death, so he himself would not recover, and that the sovereign wished to let him see Gu Ji's appointment while he was still alive. Sun Quan attended the mourning in white clothes and gave him the posthumous name Marquis Su. The Biography of the Lord of Wu records that he died in the 11th month, in winter, and in the following year, the 7th year of Chiwu, Lu Xun succeeded him as Chancellor. Records, Wu 7 §34Records, Wu 2 §99Records, Wu 13 §52
His eldest son Gu Shao died young and his second son had a grave illness, so his youngest son Gu Ji succeeded him, but Gu Ji had no heir and the line was cut off. In the 1st year of Yong'an (258) an edict praised Gu Yong for having assisted the state with propriety through supreme virtue, loyalty and worth, and had his second son inherit the title of Marquis of Liling. Records, Wu 7 §34–35
In his assessment Chen Shou wrote that because Gu Yong relied on his family's long-standing calling and added wisdom and capacity to it, he was able to enjoy his honored position to the end. Records, Wu 7 §100
He first appears in Chapter 29 of the Romance as a man whom Zhang Hong recommends to Sun Quan. The Romance introduces him as a disciple of the Gentleman of the Palace Cai Yong, a man of few words who does not drink and is stern, upright and magnanimous, and Sun Quan makes him Assistant to carry out the duties of Administrator. In Chapter 38, Sun Quan opens a guest hall in Wuhui and has Gu Yong and Zhang Hong receive guests from all quarters. Romance, Ch. 29 §50Romance, Ch. 38 §26
In Chapter 43, when Sun Quan is about to raise troops after hearing Zhuge Liang, Gu Yong, following Zhang Zhao, also argues that Liu Bei, having been defeated by Cao Cao, wants to borrow the troops of Jiangdong to resist him, so Sun Quan should not let himself be used and should listen to Zhang Zhao. In Chapter 44 he goes with Zhang Zhao, Zhang Hong and Bu Zhi to Zhou Yu to urge surrender, and when Zhou Yu asks whether they are all of one mind, he answers that what they have discussed is all the same. Romance, Ch. 43 §45–47Romance, Ch. 44 §3–4
In Chapter 56, to keep Cao Cao and Liu Bei from joining hands, he proposes sending a memorial to Xudu to have Liu Bei made Governor of Jing Province and afterwards using a stratagem of sowing discord to set the two against each other, and recommends Hua Xin as the envoy. In Chapter 61 he proposes seizing the chance while Liu Bei is away in Xichuan to cut off the river mouth on his way back and attack Jingxiang, but when Dowager Wu emerges from behind a screen and scolds him for trying to endanger her daughter's life, Sun Quan gives in to her. Romance, Ch. 56 §4–5Romance, Ch. 61 §8–9
In Chapter 68, when Sun Quan has faced Cao Cao at Ruxu for more than a month without winning, he and Zhang Zhao urge peace, and Sun Quan sends Bu Zhi to Cao Cao's camp. In Chapter 73 he says of Cao Cao's letter brought by Man Chong that it is a persuader's talk but has reason in it, and proposes making an agreement with Cao Cao while sending someone to observe Guan Yu's movements. Romance, Ch. 68 §25Romance, Ch. 73 §19–20
In Chapter 82, when the Emperor of Wei enfeoffs Sun Quan as king, he remonstrates that Sun Quan should style himself Supreme General and Lord of the Nine Provinces and should not accept Wei's enfeoffment, but Sun Quan does not follow him, saying that the Lord of Pei too had accepted enfeoffment from Xiang Yu. In Chapter 83, when Kan Ze recommends Lu Xun, he joins Zhang Zhao and Bu Zhi in objecting that Lu Xun is young and of slight reputation and that the lords will not obey him. Romance, Ch. 82 §16Romance, Ch. 83 §34–35
In Chapter 86, he and Zhang Zhao ask that the era name be changed, and it is changed to the 1st year of Huangwu. At news that Cao Pi's great army is coming, he proposes writing to Zhuge Liang to have him send troops out through Hanzhong and stationing a senior general at Nanxu to resist, and says that Lu Xun, who is guarding Jing Province, cannot be moved lightly. In Chapter 96 he advises that only Lu Xun can bear the great task of meeting Cao Xiu. In Chapter 98, after Sun Quan takes the imperial throne, he becomes Chancellor and, together with the Supreme General Lu Xun, assists the Crown Prince in guarding Wuchang. Romance, Ch. 86 §1 · 29–30Romance, Ch. 96 §25Romance, Ch. 98 §27 · 31
His recruitment: In Chapter 29 of the Romance, Zhang Hong recommends Gu Yong to Sun Quan. In the Records, Gu Yong became Chief of Hefei on the recommendation of the province and commandery and governed several counties, after which Sun Quan, who concurrently held the post of Administrator of Kuaiji, made him his Assistant. Zhang Hong's recommendation is not in the Biography of Gu Yong. Romance, Ch. 29 §50Records, Wu 7 §26–35
Arguing for surrender before Red Cliffs: In Chapters 43 and 44 of the Romance, Gu Yong urges Sun Quan and Zhou Yu to follow Zhang Zhao's advice and surrender. The Biography of Gu Yong in the Records has nothing on his deeds around the time of Red Cliffs. Romance, Ch. 43 §47Romance, Ch. 44 §4Records, Wu 7 §26–35
Sending Hua Xin: In Chapter 56 of the Romance, Gu Yong recommends Hua Xin as the envoy to carry the memorial making Liu Bei Governor of Jing Province. In the Biography of Hua Xin in the Records, Cao Cao, while at Guandu, had the Emperor summon Hua Xin by memorial, and when Sun Quan was reluctant to let him go, Hua Xin persuaded him himself and departed. Gu Yong does not appear. Romance, Ch. 56 §5Records, Wei 13 §31
The appointment of Lu Xun: In Chapter 83 of the Romance, Gu Yong joins Zhang Zhao and Bu Zhi in opposing the use of Lu Xun. The Biography of Lu Xun in the Records says only that in the 1st year of Huangwu (222) Sun Quan made Lu Xun Grand Commander to resist Liu Bei, and no ministers who opposed it appear. Romance, Ch. 83 §35Records, Wu 13 §17
Wei's enfeoffment: In Chapter 82 of the Romance, Gu Yong remonstrates with Sun Quan not to accept Wei's enfeoffment but to style himself Supreme General and Lord of the Nine Provinces. This is not in the Biography of Gu Yong in the Records. Romance, Ch. 82 §16Records, Wu 7 §26–35
When he became Chancellor: In Chapter 98 of the Romance, Sun Quan makes Gu Yong Chancellor after taking the imperial throne. In the Records he had become Chancellor earlier, in the 6th month of the 4th year of Huangwu (225), succeeding Sun Shao. Romance, Ch. 98 §27 · 31Records, Wu 2 §52Records, Wu 7 §30
His years as Chancellor and his death: The Romance stops dealing with Gu Yong after Chapter 98, so his being denounced by Lü Yi and detained, his judging of Lü Yi's case, and his death do not appear. In the Records, Gu Yong served as Chancellor for 19 years and died in the 6th year of Chiwu (243). Romance, Ch. 98 §31Records, Wu 7 §32–34Records, Wu 16 §4–5
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RAssigned the civil and military officials he selected according to their abilities, without partialityWu 7 §30
NReceived men of talent at the guest hall and had them recommended; opposed the appointment of Lu XunCh. 38 §26Ch. 83 §35
RGoverned several counties with distinction; as Chancellor for 19 years he made inquiries among the people and lightened punishmentsWu 7 §27Wu 7 §30Wu 7 §31
NActed as Administrator as Assistant; later became ChancellorCh. 29 §50Ch. 98 §31
RActed as the occasion required; gentle in word but upright in what he held toWu 7 §29Wu 7 §31
NJoined the call for surrender before Red Cliffs; his proposal for peace at Ruxu was adoptedCh. 43 §47Ch. 68 §25
RGave the credit to the sovereign and never leaked matters; an edict praised his supreme virtue and loyaltyWu 7 §30Wu 7 §35
NSpoke little, did not drink, and was stern and uprightCh. 29 §50
RSuppressed bandits in Kuaiji and brought peace to the commanderyWu 7 §27
NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a civil officialCh. 29 §50
ROfficials and people submitted to him; those around him held him in awe and dared not act freelyWu 7 §27Wu 7 §29
NNo direct record — estimated from his role in receiving guests under Sun QuanCh. 29 §50
RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil officialWu 7 §27
NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a civil officialCh. 29 §50
RStudied the zither and letters under Cai YongWu 7 §27
NA disciple of Cai YongCh. 29 §50
RNo direct record — estimated from his sparing words in court deliberationsWu 7 §31
NRecommended Hua Xin as envoy; remonstrated against accepting the Emperor of Wei's enfeoffmentCh. 56 §5Ch. 82 §16
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
| Children | Gu Shao Records |
|---|
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).