Zhu Zhi 朱治

RecordsRomance Wu Courtesy name 君理 Junli주치군리

Profile
OccupationRNOfficial · Administrator of Wu CommanderyFactionWu
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wu
BornR156 UnverifiedNative placeDanyang Commandery Guzhang County
DiedR224 UnverifiedPlace of death
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR18

Profile

Zhu Zhi, courtesy name Junli, was a man of Guzhang County in Danyang Commandery. He followed Sun Jian on his campaigns, and after Sun Jian's death he assisted Sun Ce and urged him to return and pacify Jiangdong. After defeating Xu Gong at Youquan, he entered Wu Commandery and took charge of the affairs of its Administrator, and he remained in the commandery for thirty-one years until his death in the 3rd year of Huangwu (224). Records, Wu 11 §2 · 3 · 4 · 9

In the 7th year of Jian'an (202) he became Administrator of Wu Commandery on Sun Quan's memorial; in the 1st year of Huangwu (222) he was enfeoffed as Marquis of Piling, and the following year he became General Who Pacifies the State (Anguo jiangjun) and his fief was moved to Guzhang. Whenever he came to an audience, Sun Quan always went out to greet him in person. Records, Wu 11 §5 · 6

In his assessment, Chen Shou, who wrote the Records, said that he and Lü Fan 'were employed as old retainers.' In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 15 as a former Attendant Officer of Sun Jian who comes to Sun Ce, weeping under Yuan Shu, and urges him to go to Jiangdong; he appears in 2 of the 120 chapters, and no chapter title bears his name. In Chapter 44 he serves with Lü Fan as Patrol Commissioner of the Four Quarters. Records, Wu 11 §67Romance, Ch. 15 §11–12Romance, Ch. 44 §38

In the Records

Zhu Zhi, courtesy name Junli, was a man of Guzhang County in Danyang Commandery. He first served as a county clerk, was later recommended as Filial and Incorrupt (xiaolian), and was summoned by the province as an Attendant Officer, in which post he followed Sun Jian on his campaigns. In the 5th year of Zhongping (188) he was appointed Major (sima) and campaigned against the bandits Zhou Chao, Su Ma and others of the three commanderies of Changsha, Lingling and Guiyang; for this merit Sun Jian memorialized that he be made acting Commandant (duwei). After defeating Dong Zhuo at Yangren and entering Luoyang, he was made acting Colonel Supervising the Army on Sun Jian's memorial, and leading a separate force of infantry and cavalry he went east to help Tao Qian, Governor of Xu Province, suppress the Yellow Turbans. Records, Wu 11 §2

When Sun Jian died, Zhu Zhi assisted Sun Ce and went with him to rely on Yuan Shu. Later, realizing that Yuan Shu's government and virtue did not stand firm, he urged Sun Ce to return and pacify Jiangdong. At that time the Grand Tutor Ma Midi, who was at Shouchun, summoned him as a clerk (yuan), and he was then transferred to Commandant of Wu Commandery. While Sun Ce was attacking Lujiang on Yuan Shu's behalf, Liu Yao, fearing that he would be swallowed up by the Yuan and Sun families, finally fell out with them. Since Sun Ce's family were all at the provincial seat, Zhu Zhi sent men to escort the Dowager Consort and Sun Quan and his brothers from Qu'e, and he served, aided and protected them with very deep kindness and devotion. Records, Wu 11 §3–4

When Zhu Zhi sought to advance from Qiantang to Wu, Xu Gong, Administrator of Wu Commandery, blocked him at Youquan, and Zhu Zhi fought him and inflicted a heavy defeat. Xu Gong went south to rely on the mountain bandit Yan Baihu, and Zhu Zhi entered the commandery and took charge of the affairs of its Administrator. After seizing Kuaiji and defeating Yan Baihu and others, Sun Ce replaced all the senior officials and made Zhu Zhi of Danyang Administrator of Wu Commandery. When Sun Quan was fifteen, Zhu Zhi recommended him as Filial and Incorrupt, and when Sun Ce died he joined Zhang Zhao and others in honoring and upholding Sun Quan. Records, Wu 11 §4Records, Wu 1 §31

While Zhu Zhi still had no son, when Zhu Ran, the son of his elder sister and originally surnamed Shi, turned thirteen, Zhu Zhi petitioned Sun Ce asking to make him his heir. Sun Ce ordered Danyang Commandery to summon Zhu Ran with sheep and wine. Zhu Ran later, after completing the mourning for Zhu Zhi, asked to return to his original surname, but Sun Quan did not permit it. Records, Wu 11 §12 · 30

In the 7th year of Jian'an (202) Sun Quan memorialized that Zhu Zhi be made Administrator of Wu Commandery and acting General Who Upholds Righteousness (Fuyi jiangjun), and he set aside Lou, Youquan, Wuxi and Piling as his fief, with senior officials appointed there. Zhu Zhi campaigned against the Yi and Yue, helping to pacify the southeast, and captured or beheaded the Yellow Turban remnants Chen Bai, Wan Bing and others. In the 1st year of Huangwu (222) he was enfeoffed as Marquis of Piling and continued to govern the commandery as before; the following year he was appointed General Who Pacifies the State (Anguo jiangjun), received a gold seal and purple ribbon, and his fief was moved to Guzhang. Records, Wu 11 §5–6

From the time Sun Quan rose through the rank of senior general until he became King of Wu, whenever Zhu Zhi came to an audience Sun Quan always went out to greet him in person. They bowed to each other holding their tablets, and in the banquets and gifts bestowed his kindness and respect were especially generous; even the officials who accompanied Zhu Zhi were all able to present gifts and have private audiences. Sun Quan favored him exceptionally, personally ordering an Army-Supervising Censor to handle the documents of the subordinate cities, so that Zhu Zhi only oversaw the taxes of four counties. Records, Wu 11 §6 · 8

Sun Quan's younger brother Sun Yi was sharp and hot-tempered and gave free rein to his joy and anger; Zhu Zhi repeatedly rebuked and instructed him and admonished him with moral principles. It was also the Administrator Zhu Zhi who recommended Sun Yi as Filial and Incorrupt. Sun Ben, Administrator of Yuzhang and Sun Quan's elder cousin, had a daughter who was the wife of a son of Cao Cao; when Cao Cao broke Jing Province and his might shook the southern lands, Sun Ben grew afraid and wished to send his son as a hostage. Hearing of this, Zhu Zhi went to see Sun Ben and explained to him what made for safety and danger, and Sun Ben therefore gave up the idea. Sun Quan often praised Zhu Zhi for his anxious diligence in the royal affairs. Records, Wu 11 §7Records, Wu 6 §34

Zhu Zhi was frugal by nature, and though he held a rich and honored position, he kept carriages and clothing only to what his duties required. Many sons of the ruling clan and of the four great families of Wu went out to serve in the commandery, so that its officials always numbered in the thousands; every few years Zhu Zhi sent several hundred of them to the royal court, and each year and season he presented tribute, and Sun Quan's return gifts were excessively generous. Records, Wu 11 §7–8

Zhu Zhi, Administrator of Wu Commandery, was the man who had recommended Sun Quan. Sun Quan had once held a grievance against him, but because he had always shown him respect he found it hard to reproach him himself, and his resentment did not subside. Zhuge Jin divined the reason, and in Sun Quan's presence he wrote a letter discussing the principles of things at large and gauging Zhu Zhi's feelings; reading it, Sun Quan laughed with pleasure and said, 'My mind is at ease.' Records, Wu 7 §52–53

At this time there were a good many treacherous rebels in the remote interior of Danyang, and Zhu Zhi, growing old, longed for the ways of his native land, so he memorialized on his own initiative asking to be stationed at Guzhang to pacify the Shanyue. When the elders and old friends came to his gate, Zhu Zhi received them all and drank and feasted with them, and the people of his home district regarded this as an honor. After more than a year at Guzhang he returned to Wu, and he died in the 3rd year of Huangwu (224). He had been in the commandery for thirty-one years and was sixty-nine years old. His son Zhu Cai inherited his title. Records, Wu 11 §8–10

In his assessment, Chen Shou said that Zhu Zhi and Lü Fan were employed as old retainers, while Zhu Ran and Zhu Huan became known for their courage and vigor. Records, Wu 11 §67

In the Romance

In Chapter 15 of the Romance, when Sun Ce, depressed by Yuan Shu's arrogant treatment, paces the courtyard in the moonlight and breaks into loud weeping, a man enters laughing loudly. It is Zhu Zhi of Guzhang in Danyang, a former Attendant Officer of Sun Jian. He urges Sun Ce to borrow troops from Yuan Gonglu and go to Jiangdong, outwardly under the pretext of rescuing Wu Jing but in reality to pursue a great enterprise. When Lü Fan, who enters next, worries that Yuan Shu may not lend the troops, Sun Ce says he will offer the Imperial Seal as a pledge, and the three settle on the plan. Romance, Ch. 15 §11–14

When Yuan Shu accepts the seal and lends him 3,000 troops and 500 horses, Sun Ce raises his army, taking with him Zhu Zhi, Lü Fan and his father's old generals Cheng Pu, Huang Gai, Han Dang and others. When he meets Zhou Yu at Liyang, Sun Ce introduces him to Zhu Zhi, Lü Fan and the others. After defeating Yan Baihu and pacifying the whole eastern route, Sun Ce has his uncle Sun Jing guard it and makes Zhu Zhi Administrator of Wu Commandery. Romance, Ch. 15 §15 · 17 · 63–64

In Chapter 44, when Zhou Yu, setting out to attack Cao Cao, issues orders to his generals at the field headquarters, Lü Fan and Zhu Zhi are made Patrol Commissioners of the Four Quarters, charged with urging on and supervising the government troops of six commanderies so that they advance together by land and water and all assemble by the deadline. In the Romance Zhu Zhi does not appear again after this chapter. Romance, Ch. 44 §37–38

Where the Romance differs

What he urged on Sun Ce: In Chapter 15 of the Romance, Zhu Zhi urges Sun Ce to borrow troops from Yuan Shu and go to Jiangdong under the pretext of rescuing Wu Jing to pursue a great enterprise. The Records state only that, realizing Yuan Shu's government and virtue did not stand firm, he urged Sun Ce to return and pacify Jiangdong; borrowing troops and the pretext of rescuing Wu Jing are not part of his words. Romance, Ch. 15 §12Records, Wu 11 §3

His post under Sun Jian: Chapter 15 of the Romance calls Zhu Zhi a former Attendant Officer of Sun Jian. In the Records, Attendant Officer was the post to which the province summoned him; following Sun Jian, he was appointed Major and then, on Sun Jian's memorials, served as acting Commandant and acting Colonel Supervising the Army. Romance, Ch. 15 §12Records, Wu 11 §2

Sun Ce's family: In Chapter 15 of the Romance, Sun Ce asks Yuan Shu for troops on the grounds that his aged mother and family are at Qu'e and will come to harm. In the Records, when a rift opened with Liu Yao, Zhu Zhi sent men to escort the Dowager Consort and Sun Quan and his brothers from Qu'e. Romance, Ch. 15 §14Records, Wu 11 §3

How Wu Commandery was won: In Chapter 15 of the Romance, Sun Ce makes Zhu Zhi Administrator of Wu Commandery after defeating Yan Baihu and pacifying the eastern route. In the Records, Zhu Zhi defeated Xu Gong, Administrator of Wu Commandery, at Youquan and entered the commandery to take charge of the Administrator's affairs, and Sun Ce made him Administrator of Wu Commandery after seizing Kuaiji. The Romance has no battle between Zhu Zhi and Xu Gong. Romance, Ch. 15 §63–64Records, Wu 11 §4Records, Wu 1 §31

Around Chibi: In Chapter 44 of the Romance, Zhu Zhi serves with Lü Fan as Patrol Commissioner of the Four Quarters and supervises the government troops of six commanderies. In the Biography of Zhu Zhi in the Records, the only event of this period is his visit to dissuade Sun Ben, who wished to send his son as a hostage after Cao Cao broke Jing Province; there is no record of his taking part in the fighting against Cao Cao. Romance, Ch. 44 §38Records, Wu 11 §7 · 1–10

Later years and death: In the Romance, Zhu Zhi does not appear after Chapter 44, and neither Sun Quan's honors to him nor his death are recorded. In the Records he rose to General Who Pacifies the State and Marquis of Guzhang, and died in the 3rd year of Huangwu (224) at the age of sixty-nine. Romance, Ch. 44 §38Records, Wu 11 §6 · 9

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA6245−17
  • STR4538−7
  • INT6662−4
  • POL6248−14
  • CHA6642−24
  • VIR7458−16
  • ADP6245−17
  • SCH3535±0
  • DIP6045−15
  • DIS6038−22
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

CharismaR66N42Unverified −24

RSun Quan always greeted him in person, and his home district counted feasting with him an honorWu 11 §6Wu 11 §9

NNo direct record — estimated from his deedsCh. 15 §12

DiscernmentR60N38Unverified −22

RRecommended Sun Quan and Sun Yi as Filial and IncorruptWu 11 §4Wu 6 §34

NNo direct record — estimated from his deedsCh. 15 §17

LeadershipR62N45 −17

RFollowed Sun Jian in defeating bandits and Dong Zhuo, crushed Xu Gong and beheaded Yellow Turban remnantsWu 11 §2Wu 11 §4Wu 11 §5

NWith Lü Fan, supervised the government troops of six commanderies as Patrol Commissioner of the Four QuartersCh. 44 §38

AdaptabilityR62N45Unverified −17

RSaw that Yuan Shu's government did not stand firm and had Sun Ce returnWu 11 §3

NNo direct record — estimated from his deedsCh. 15 §12

VirtueR74N58 −16

RDevotedly protected the Sun family and was frugal; assessment: an old retainerWu 11 §4Wu 11 §7Wu 11 §67

NHelped Sun Ce as a former Attendant Officer of Sun JianCh. 15 §12

DiplomacyR60N45Unverified −15

RWent to Sun Ben, who meant to send a hostage, and persuaded him to stopWu 11 §7

NNo direct record — estimated from his persuasion of Sun CeCh. 15 §12

PoliticsR62N48 −14

RAdministrator of Wu Commandery for 31 years; volunteered to pacify the ShanyueWu 11 §8Wu 11 §9

NSun Ce made him Administrator of Wu CommanderyCh. 15 §64

3 similar abilities — show evidence
  • StrengthR45UnverifiedN38Unverified −7

    RNo direct record — estimated from his military serviceWu 11 §2

    NNo direct record — estimated from his standing as an old generalCh. 15 §15

  • IntelligenceR66N62 −4

    RSaw Yuan Shu's limits and urged the pacification of Jiangdong; explained safety and danger to Sun BenWu 11 §3Wu 11 §7

    NUrged Sun Ce to borrow troops from Yuan Shu and pursue a great enterprise in JiangdongCh. 15 §12

  • ScholarshipR35UnverifiedN35Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his background as a military manWu 11 §2

    NNo direct record — estimated from his deedsCh. 15 §12

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (2)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history Changed allegiance 2 times

  1. Wu · Records · Records vol. 56 「權表治為」
  2. Sun Ce faction (~200) · Records · 「會堅薨,治扶翼策」
  3. Sun Jian faction (~192) · Records · 「隨孫堅征伐」

Family

RelativesZhu Ran Records

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (1)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).