RTook none of the enemy's goods for himself, but surrendered to Guan Yu after the floodWei 17 §36Wei 17 §35Wei 17 §38
NJealously held back Pang De's merit, and when captured prostrated himself and begged for his lifeCh. 74 §20Ch. 74 §24Ch. 74 §36
| Occupation | RGeneral · General of the Left NGeneral · General Who Conquers the South | Faction | Wei |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | Native place | Taishan Commandery Juping County | |
| Cause of death | NIllness Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R50 |
Yu Jin, courtesy name Wenze, was a native of Juping County in Taishan Commandery. When the Yellow Turbans rose up he followed Bao Xin, and when Cao Cao took charge of Yan Province he went to him with his band and became a squad leader (dubo). He won merit in the fighting against Lü Bu, Zhang Xiu, and Yuan Shao and rose to General of the Left. Records, Wei 17 §27–37
In the 24th year of Jian'an (219), while helping Cao Ren at Fan, he surrendered to Guan Yu after the Han River overflowed in the heavy rains and seven armies were submerged. He stayed in Wu until, after Cao Pi took the throne, Sun Quan sent him back; seeing the scene of his own surrender painted at the Gao Mausoleum, he fell ill from shame and resentment and died. Records, Wei 17 §38–40
In his assessment, Chen Shou wrote that among the five finest generals of the day Yu Jin was the most renowned for being resolute and weighty, but that he failed to end well. In the Romance he first appeared in Chapter 10 and featured in 28 of its 120 chapters, and in Chapter 74, whose title is "Guan Yunchang Releases the Waters to Drown the Seven Armies," he held back Pang De's merit and then prostrated himself before Guan Yu, begging for his life. Records, Wei 17 §74Romance, Ch. 10 §24Romance, Ch. 74 §24 · 36
When the Yellow Turbans rose up, Bao Xin gathered a following, and Yu Jin joined him. When Cao Cao came to govern Yan Province, Yu Jin went to him with his band, became a squad leader (dubo), and was placed under General Wang Lang. Wang Lang recommended him as a man with the talent to serve as a grand general, and Cao Cao summoned him, spoke with him, and made him a Major (jun sima). He went to Xu Province, took Guangwei, and became Commandant Who Breaks Through Formations (xianzhen duwei). Records, Wei 17 §27
When Lü Bu was attacked at Puyang, Yu Jin separately broke two of Lü Bu's camps south of the city, and he defeated Gao Ya at Shouchang. He attacked Shouzhang, Dingtao, and Lihu, and besieged Zhang Chao at Yongqiu, taking them all. In the campaign against the Yellow Turbans Liu Pi and Huang Shao, when Huang Shao and his men raided Cao Cao's camp by night, Yu Jin led his own troops against them, beheaded Huang Shao and the others, and made all their followers surrender, for which he became Colonel Who Pacifies the Caitiffs (pinglu xiaowei). At Ku he beheaded Qiao Rui and three other commanders. Records, Wei 17 §28
When Zhang Xiu, who had surrendered at Wan, rebelled again and Cao Cao was defeated and fell back to Wuyin, the army was thrown into disorder and everyone made his own way by byroads to find Cao Cao, but Yu Jin alone kept the few hundred men under him in order and withdrew while fighting. On the road he saw people who had been plundered by the Qingzhou troops, and declaring that the Qingzhou troops, whom Cao Cao had treated leniently, had instead turned to banditry, he attacked them and denounced their crimes. The Qingzhou troops ran off and accused him before Cao Cao, but Yu Jin, saying that the enemy was behind them, first dug trenches and finished setting up camp before going to see Cao Cao. Cao Cao said, "In the crisis at the Yu River I was in dire straits, yet you, General, kept your army in order amid the chaos; how could even the famous generals of old surpass this?" and enfeoffed him as Marquis of Yishou Precinct. Records, Wei 17 §29–31
He followed in attacking Zhang Xiu at Rang and capturing Lü Bu at Xiapi, and together with Shi Huan and Cao Ren he beheaded Sui Gu at Shequan. When Cao Cao attacked Yuan Shao, Yu Jin volunteered for the vanguard, held Yanjin with 2,000 foot soldiers, and fended off Yuan Shao's attack. Then, with Yue Jin and others, he took 5,000 foot and horse along the Yellow River as far as Ji and Huojia, struck Yuan Shao's detached camps, burned more than thirty strongholds, and received the surrender of more than twenty of Yuan Shao's officers. At Guandu, when Yuan Shao's archers shot from earthen mounds and the army was afraid, Yu Jin guarded the earthen mound and fought hard, and after Yuan Shao was defeated he became Lieutenant General (pian jiangjun). Records, Wei 17 §32–34
After Ji Province was pacified, Chang Xi rebelled again and Yu Jin attacked him, and Chang Xi, an old friend, came to Yu Jin to surrender. The generals said he should be sent to Cao Cao, but Yu Jin said that Cao Cao's standing order was not to pardon those who surrendered after being besieged, and, shedding tears, he beheaded him. Cao Cao sighed that it was fate that Chang Xi had come over to Yu Jin rather than to himself, and valued Yu Jin all the more. Records, Wei 17 §34–36
He became General of Tiger-like Might (huwei jiangjun) and attacked Mei Cheng together with Zang Ba and others. When Zhang Liao was locked in a standoff with Chen Lan, Yu Jin kept the provisions coming without a break, enabling Zhang Liao to behead Chen Lan and Mei Cheng. At this time Yu Jin was counted among the famous generals together with Zhang Liao, Yue Jin, Zhang He, and Xu Huang, and on each of Cao Cao's campaigns they took turns leading the vanguard and guarding the rear. He ran his army strictly and took none of the enemy's goods for himself, so he received especially large rewards, but because he governed his subordinates by the law he did not greatly win the hearts of his troops. When Cao Cao wished to take over Zhu Ling's camp, he sent Yu Jin, who commanded awe, with a few dozen horsemen to seize it, and no one dared move. He was promoted to General of the Left and granted the staff and axe of authority (jia jieyue). Records, Wei 17 §36–37
In the 24th year of Jian'an (219) Cao Cao had Cao Ren attack Guan Yu at Fan and sent Yu Jin to help him. In autumn heavy rains fell and the Han River overflowed, so that the water rose several zhang even on level ground and all seven armies of Yu Jin and the others were submerged. Yu Jin climbed to high ground with his generals and looked out over the water, but there was nowhere to escape, and when Guan Yu came to attack on large boats, he surrendered. Only Pang De refused to bend and died. Cao Cao grieved for a long time and said, "I have known Yu Jin for thirty years; how could I have imagined that in the face of danger he would prove inferior to Pang De?" Records, Wei 17 §38
Guan Yu sent the captured Yu Jin and the others to Jiangling, and when Sun Quan took Jiangling, Yu Jin came to be in Wu. When Sun Quan rode out with Yu Jin at his side, their horses' heads side by side, Yu Fan rebuked Yu Jin, asking how a surrendered captive dared ride abreast of his lord. After Cao Pi took the throne and Sun Quan declared himself a vassal, in the 8th month of the 2nd year of Huangchu (221) Sun Quan sent Yu Jin and the others back. Records, Wu 2 §26–27Records, Wu 12 §9Records, Wei 17 §39Records, Wei 2 §21 · 27
When Cao Pi summoned him, Yu Jin's beard and hair had turned white and his face was haggard, and he wept and knocked his head on the ground. Cao Pi consoled him with the old stories of Xun Linfu and Meng Mingshi and appointed him General Who Pacifies Distant Lands (anyuan jiangjun). Intending to send him as an envoy to Wu, Cao Pi had him first go north to Ye to pay his respects at the Gao Mausoleum, having arranged beforehand for the mausoleum building to be painted with scenes of Guan Yu winning the battle, Pang De in his fury, and Yu Jin surrendering. On seeing this, Yu Jin fell ill from shame and resentment and died, and he was posthumously named Marquis Li. Records, Wei 17 §39–40
In his assessment, Chen Shou wrote that when Cao Cao achieved his military feats, five men stood first among the fine generals of the day, and that Yu Jin was the most renowned for being resolute and weighty, but failed to end well. Records, Wei 17 §74
In Chapter 10 of the Romance, Yu Jin came to Cao Cao leading a few hundred troops, and, being skilled in archery and horsemanship and outstanding in martial arts, he was made Major of Troop Inspection (dianjun sima). Soon he became part of the vanguard of the Xu Province expedition together with Xiahou Dun and Dian Wei; in Chapter 11 he fought Zhang Fei, was beaten, and fled, and at Puyang he proposed attacking Lü Bu's western camp. Romance, Ch. 10 §24 · 34Romance, Ch. 11 §27 · 50
In Chapter 16, after the defeat at Wancheng, when the Qingzhou troops under Xiahou Dun plundered the common people, Yu Jin, Colonel Who Pacifies the Caitiffs, struck them down and calmed the villagers. When the Qingzhou troops claimed that Yu Jin had rebelled, he said that explaining himself was a small matter and driving off the enemy a great one, set up his camp first, then led the way in stopping the attacking troops of Zhang Xiu and chased them for more than a hundred li. Cao Cao gave him a set of gold vessels and enfeoffed him as Marquis of Yishou Precinct. Romance, Ch. 16 §54–57
In Chapter 41, on Cao Cao's orders, he pursued and killed Liu Cong and Lady Cai, who were on their way to Qing Province. In Chapter 45, after Cai Mao and Zhang Yun were killed, he became a chief commander of the navy together with Mao Jie, and in Chapter 48 he reported to Cao Cao that all the ships, large and small, had been linked together with iron chains. Romance, Ch. 41 §27–28Romance, Ch. 45 §57Romance, Ch. 48 §18
In Chapter 74 he was made General Who Conquers the South and set out leading seven armies to relieve Fancheng, and, heeding Dong Heng's words, he asked Cao Cao whether it was right to use Pang De as the vanguard. When Pang De hit Guan Yu with an arrow, Yu Jin, fearing that Pang De would win great merit and overshadow him, sounded the gong to recall the troops, and he stationed Pang De behind a valley so that he could not win merit. He also rebuked and dismissed Cheng He, who warned that the river would rise. When Guan Yu released the waters he had dammed and the seven armies were submerged, Yu Jin surrendered and prostrated himself before Guan Yu, begging for his life. Guan Yu said that killing him would only soil his blade and had him locked in the prison of Jing Province. Romance, Ch. 74 §1–3 · 20–21 · 24 · 27–28 · 30 · 36
In Chapter 79, Cao Pi buried Cao Cao at the Gao Mausoleum in Ye Commandery and had Yu Jin oversee the affairs of the mausoleum. On the white walls of the mausoleum building were painted Guan Yu's drowning of the seven armies and capture of Yu Jin, including Yu Jin prostrate on the ground begging for his life. The Romance says that Cao Pi, despising him for having lost the battle, failed to die, surrendered, and then come back, made him see it on purpose, and Yu Jin, ashamed and indignant, fell ill and died not long after. Romance, Ch. 79 §4–5
How he came to Cao Cao: In Chapter 10 of the Romance, Yu Jin came to Cao Cao leading a few hundred troops and was made Major of Troop Inspection. In the Records, he had followed Bao Xin, and when Cao Cao took charge of Yan Province he went to him with his band, became a squad leader under General Wang Lang, and on Wang Lang's recommendation became a Major. Romance, Ch. 10 §24Records, Wei 17 §27
The Qingzhou troops: In Chapter 16 of the Romance, Yu Jin struck down the Qingzhou troops under Xiahou Dun, and after setting up his camp he led the way in stopping Zhang Xiu's troops and chased them for more than a hundred li. The Records says that he attacked the Qingzhou troops whom Cao Cao had treated leniently and denounced their crimes, and records only that he withdrew while fighting and set up camp, with no record of his counterattacking and pursuing Zhang Xiu. Romance, Ch. 16 §54–56Records, Wei 17 §29–31
Liu Cong and his mother: In Chapter 41 of the Romance, Yu Jin pursued and killed Liu Cong and Lady Cai on Cao Cao's orders. In the biography of Liu Biao in the Records, Cao Cao made Liu Cong Inspector of Qing Province and enfeoffed him as a full marquis. Romance, Ch. 41 §27–28Records, Wei 6 §94
Who doubted Pang De: In Chapter 74 of the Romance, Dong Heng told Yu Jin that Pang De must not be used as the vanguard, and Yu Jin reported this to Cao Cao. In the biography of Pang De in the Records, the generals below Fan doubted Pang De because his elder brother was in Hanzhong, and Dong Heng and Dong Chao, trying to surrender when the flood came, were beheaded by Pang De. Romance, Ch. 74 §2–3Records, Wei 18 §71–72
Holding back Pang De: In Chapter 74 of the Romance, Yu Jin, jealous of Pang De's merit, sounded the gong and stationed him behind a valley. In the biography of Pang De in the Records, it was Cao Ren who stationed Pang De ten li north of Fan, and neither the biography of Yu Jin nor that of Pang De says anything about Yu Jin being jealous of Pang De. Romance, Ch. 74 §20 · 24Records, Wei 18 §72 · 67–75Records, Wei 17 §26–40
Why the seven armies were submerged: In Chapter 74 of the Romance, Guan Yu dammed the outlets and then released the water to submerge the seven armies. In the Records, the Han River overflowed in the autumn rains and the water rose several zhang even on level ground. Romance, Ch. 74 §27Records, Wei 17 §38
After the surrender: In Chapter 74 of the Romance, Yu Jin prostrated himself before Guan Yu, begged for his life, and was locked in the prison of Jing Province. The biography of Yu Jin in the Records says only that he surrendered. The biography of the Lord of Wu says that he was sent to Jiangling and released when Lü Meng took Jiangling, and Sun Quan released him and received him, and Yu Fan even rebuked him for riding with his horse's head abreast of his lord's. Romance, Ch. 74 §36Records, Wei 17 §38Records, Wu 2 §26–27Records, Wu 12 §9
The paintings at the Gao Mausoleum: In Chapter 79 of the Romance, after burying Cao Cao, Cao Pi had Yu Jin oversee the affairs of the mausoleum and, despising him, made him see the paintings. In the Records, after Cao Pi took the throne and Sun Quan declared himself a vassal, Cao Pi appointed the returned Yu Jin General Who Pacifies Distant Lands and had him pay his respects at the Gao Mausoleum before sending him as an envoy to Wu. The Records does not say why Cao Pi had the paintings made. Romance, Ch. 79 §4–5Records, Wei 17 §39–40
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RTook none of the enemy's goods for himself, but surrendered to Guan Yu after the floodWei 17 §36Wei 17 §35Wei 17 §38
NJealously held back Pang De's merit, and when captured prostrated himself and begged for his lifeCh. 74 §20Ch. 74 §24Ch. 74 §36
RKept his army in order amid the defeat at the Yu River and was praised as unsurpassed even by famous generals of old; assessment: most renowned for being resolute and weightyWei 17 §31Wei 17 §36Wei 17 §74
NTurned defeat into victory at the Yu River, but camped on low ground at Zengkouchuan and the seven armies were submergedCh. 16 §57Ch. 74 §27Ch. 74 §28
RNo direct record — estimated from his role in seizing Zhu Ling's camp and placing it under his commandWei 17 §37
NTried to remove Pang De from the vanguard, blocked his merit, and rejected Cheng He's adviceCh. 74 §3Ch. 74 §23Ch. 74 §28
RJudged it best to set up camp first against pursuit; Taizu's memorial said his planning was thoroughWei 17 §31Wei 17 §21
NProposed the raid on Lü Bu's western camp and took it, but ignored the warning of a flood attackCh. 11 §50Ch. 74 §28
RIn the campaign against Chen Lan, kept the provisions coming without a break, supporting Zhang Liao's victoryWei 17 §36
NNo direct record — estimated from his attacking the plundering Qingzhou troops and calming the villagersCh. 16 §54
RTaizu lamented that in a crisis he proved inferior to Pang De; assessment: failed to end wellWei 17 §38Wei 17 §74
NSurrendered when hemmed in on all sides, and after returning died in shame under Cao Pi's contemptCh. 74 §30Ch. 79 §5
RTaizu's memorial said his martial strength was great; struck and beheaded Huang Shao, who had raided by night, and made his followers surrenderWei 17 §21Wei 17 §28
NSaid to be skilled in archery and horsemanship and outstanding in martial arts, yet was beaten back by Zhang Fei and could not stop Lü BuCh. 10 §24Ch. 11 §27Ch. 11 §53
RGoverned his subordinates by the law and did not greatly win the hearts of his troopsWei 17 §37
NRebuked his subordinate Cheng He, who warned of the flood, threatening to behead him, and sent him awayCh. 74 §28
RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a warrior who ran his army strictlyWei 17 §36
NNo direct record — estimated from the record that he was a warrior taken on for his martial skillCh. 10 §24
RNo direct record — estimated since there is no record beyond Chang Xi surrendering to him out of old friendshipWei 17 §34
NNo direct record — estimated since there is no record beyond his words begging for his life before Guan YuCh. 74 §36
NSkilled +10 Taken on by Cao Cao, who saw how skilled he was at archery and horsemanshipCh. 10 §24
NSkilled +10 Taken on by Cao Cao, who saw how skilled he was at archery and horsemanshipCh. 10 §24
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).