Battle
Battle of Wancheng 曹操與張繡的戰爭
About this event
The Battle of Wancheng was the fighting from the 2nd year (197) to the 4th year (199) of Jian'an between Cao Cao and Zhang Xiu, who was based at Wan in Nanyang Commandery. When Cao Cao reached Wan in the 1st month of the 2nd year of Jian'an, Zhang Xiu surrendered to him but soon turned against him and attacked Cao Cao's camp; Cao Cao was hit by a stray arrow and lost his eldest son Cao Ang, his nephew Cao Anmin and his commander Dian Wei. Zhang Xiu then moved to Rang, allied with Liu Biao and opposed Cao Cao year after year, but in the 11th month, in winter, of the 4th year of Jian'an, at Jia Xu's urging, he led his followers to surrender to Cao Cao. Records, Wei 1 §43 · 55Records, Wei 8 §57–58Records, Wei 18 §65–66
Chen Shou recorded this fighting in the Annals of Emperor Wu, Records of Wei 1, and in the biography of Zhang Xiu in the Biographies of the Two Lis, Zang, Gongsun, Tao, Si and Zhang, Records of Wei 8, and also distributed it among the biography of Jia Xu in Records of Wei 10, the biography of Dian Wei in Records of Wei 18, the biography of Yu Jin in Records of Wei 17, and others. The Romance depicts the first battle in Chapter 16, "Lü Fengxian Shoots the Halberd at the Camp Gate; Cao Mengde Loses His Army at the Yu River," the renewed expedition against Zhang Xiu in Chapters 17 and 18, and Zhang Xiu's submission in Chapter 23. Records, Wei 1 §42–47Records, Wei 8 §55–58Records, Wei 10 §74–80Records, Wei 18 §64–66Records, Wei 17 §29–31Romance, Ch. 16 §40–57Romance, Ch. 17 §40–42Romance, Ch. 18 §1–13Romance, Ch. 23 §2–5
Course of events in the Records
Zhang Xiu was a clan nephew of the General of Agile Cavalry Zhang Ji (張濟). Zhang Ji, stationed at Hongnong, attacked Rang to the south when his soldiers were starving and was killed by a stray arrow, and Zhang Xiu took command of his followers, stationed himself at Wan and allied with Liu Biao. Liu Biao, saying that Zhang Ji had come out of desperation and it was because the host had failed in courtesy that swords had been crossed, accepted only condolences and took in Zhang Ji's followers. Jia Xu secretly made common cause with Zhang Xiu and went to him, and Zhang Xiu treated Jia Xu with the courtesy of a son or grandson. Records, Wei 8 §56–57Records, Wei 6 §84Records, Wei 10 §74–75
In the 1st month of the 2nd year of Jian'an (197), when Cao Cao advanced south and halted his army on the Yu River, Zhang Xiu and the others surrendered with all their followers. The biography of Dian Wei records that when Cao Cao invited Zhang Xiu and his commanders to a banquet, Dian Wei stood behind him holding a great axe and glaring, so that none of them dared raise their heads. When Cao Cao took Zhang Ji's widow, Zhang Xiu bore a grudge, and when Cao Cao, hearing of this, secretly planned to kill Zhang Xiu and the plan leaked out, Zhang Xiu made a surprise attack on Cao Cao some ten days later. Cao Cao was hit by a stray arrow, his eldest son Cao Ang and his nephew Cao Anmin were killed, and Dian Wei died after holding the camp gate and receiving dozens of wounds. Records, Wei 8 §57Records, Wei 18 §64–66Records, Wei 1 §43
Cao Cao withdrew to Wuyin. Amid the confusion in the army, Yu Jin led the several hundred men under him back without letting them scatter, attacked the Qingzhou troops who were plundering, and set up camp against the enemy before explaining himself. Cao Cao defeated Zhang Xiu's cavalry when it came raiding, and Zhang Xiu fled to Rang and joined Liu Biao. Cao Cao said that he had come to this pass through the mistake of not taking hostages at once after receiving the surrender of Zhang Xiu and the others, and that from now on he would not be defeated again. Records, Wei 17 §29–31Records, Wei 1 §43
When Cao Cao went back from Wuyin, the counties of Nanyang and Zhangling rebelled again and went over to Zhang Xiu; Cao Hong attacked them without success, halted at She County, and was repeatedly raided by Zhang Xiu and Liu Biao. In the 11th month, in winter, Cao Cao campaigned south in person and reached Wan, captured alive Liu Biao's commander Deng Ji, who held Huyang, and took Wuyin. The biography of Cao Ren records that when Cao Cao attacked Zhang Xiu, Cao Ren separately overran the neighboring counties and took more than 3,000 men and women captive. Records, Wei 1 §45Records, Wei 9 §31
In the Battle of Rang in the 3rd year of Jian'an (198), Cao Cao surrounded Zhang Xiu at Rang in the 3rd month, but in the 5th month Liu Biao came to Zhang Xiu's rescue and cut off the army's rear; at Anzhong Cao Cao dug tunnels, hid surprise troops and heavily defeated the troops of Zhang Xiu and Liu Biao, and in the 7th month he returned to Xu. The biography of Zhang Xiu records that Zhang Xiu went back and held Rang, and that Cao Cao attacked him year after year without success. According to the biography of Jia Xu, when Cao Cao, after attacking Zhang Xiu repeatedly, suddenly withdrew one morning, Zhang Xiu ignored Jia Xu's advice, pursued him and was defeated, then pursued again with his scattered troops as Jia Xu advised and won. Records, Wei 1 §46–47Records, Wei 8 §57Records, Wei 10 §75–77
When Cao Cao was facing Yuan Shao at Guandu, Yuan Shao sent a man to summon Zhang Xiu and also sent a letter to Jia Xu. Jia Xu, at Zhang Xiu's seat, refused Yuan Shao's envoy, asking whether one who could not tolerate his own brother could tolerate the worthy men of the realm, and urged following Cao Cao, saying that Lord Cao supported the Son of Heaven, that because his strength was weak he would welcome them, and that one with the ambition of a hegemon or king would set aside private grudges. In the 11th month, in winter, of the 4th year of Jian'an (199), Zhang Xiu led his followers to surrender and was enfeoffed as a full marquis; Cao Cao took his hand and feasted with him, took Zhang Xiu's daughter as a wife for his son Cao Jun, and appointed Zhang Xiu General Who Displays Martial Might. Zhang Xiu fought hard at Guandu and earned merit. Records, Wei 10 §78–80Records, Wei 1 §55Records, Wei 8 §58
In the Romance
In Chapter 16 of the Romance, Zhang Xiu, nephew of Zhang Ji (張濟), takes Jia Xu as his adviser, allies with Liu Biao and stations himself at Wancheng, and Cao Cao raises 150,000 troops and attacks him in person. Zhang Xiu, who surrenders at the Yu River on Jia Xu's advice, is enraged when Cao Cao takes Zhang Ji's widow, Lady Zou; he plans with Jia Xu and raids the camp at night, and while Dian Wei, Cao Anmin and Cao Ang are killed, Cao Cao escapes with an arrow in his right arm. When Yu Jin attacks the Qingzhou troops, sets up camp and drives off Zhang Xiu's pursuit, Zhang Xiu goes to Liu Biao. Romance, Ch. 16 §40–56
In Chapter 17, when Zhang Xiu, allied with Liu Biao, runs rampant again, Cao Cao sets out on another southern campaign in the 4th month, in summer, of the 3rd year of Jian'an and surrounds the city of Nanyang, and in Chapter 18 Jia Xu sees that Cao Cao is aiming at the southeast corner and heavily defeats him with an ambush. Zhang Xiu, beaten by Cao Cao at Anzhong, pursues the withdrawing Cao Cao a second time on Jia Xu's advice and wins. Romance, Ch. 17 §31–34 · 40–42Romance, Ch. 18 §1–13
In Chapter 23, Cao Cao sends Liu Ye to win Zhang Xiu over, and Jia Xu, tearing up the letter in front of Yuan Shao's envoy, gives three reasons why they should follow Cao Cao. Zhang Xiu goes to Xudu with Jia Xu and others and surrenders, and Cao Cao, telling him not to dwell on small faults, makes him General Who Displays Martial Might. Romance, Ch. 23 §2–5
Where the Romance differs
The reason for the betrayal: In Chapter 16 of the Romance, Zhang Xiu, enraged when Cao Cao takes Lady Zou, makes a plan with Jia Xu and attacks. In the biography of Zhang Xiu in the Records, Zhang Xiu bore a grudge when Cao Cao took Zhang Ji's widow, and attacked when Cao Cao's secret plan to kill him leaked out. Romance, Ch. 16 §44–47Records, Wei 8 §57
The battlefield of the second expedition: In Chapters 17 and 18 of the Romance, Cao Cao surrounds the city of Nanyang and is heavily defeated by Jia Xu's ambush. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, Cao Cao surrounded Zhang Xiu at Rang, had his rear cut off by Liu Biao's relief force, and defeated them at Anzhong. Romance, Ch. 17 §41–42Romance, Ch. 18 §1–4Records, Wei 1 §46–47
Who urged the submission: In Chapter 23 of the Romance, Liu Ye, sent by Cao Cao, wins Zhang Xiu over, and Jia Xu tears up Yuan Shao's letter. In the biography of Jia Xu in the Records, Yuan Shao first sent a man to summon Zhang Xiu, and Jia Xu, at Zhang Xiu's seat, refused the envoy and urged Zhang Xiu to follow Cao Cao. Romance, Ch. 23 §2–5Records, Wei 10 §78–80
Zhang Xiu's treatment: In Chapter 23 of the Romance, Cao Cao makes Zhang Xiu General Who Displays Martial Might. In the Records, Zhang Xiu was enfeoffed as a full marquis and became General Who Displays Martial Might, Cao Cao took Zhang Xiu's daughter as a wife for his son Cao Jun, and Zhang Xiu, having fought hard at Guandu, was promoted to General Who Smashes the Qiang. Romance, Ch. 23 §5Records, Wei 1 §55Records, Wei 8 §58
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Belligerents
| Item | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| Factions | Wei | Zhang Xiu faction, Liu Biao faction |
| Commanders | Cao Ang, Cao Cao, Cao Hong, Dian Wei, Yu Jin, Cao Ren | Jia Xu, Liu Biao, Zhang Xiu(張繡) |
Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 1 §55