RUrged Sima Shi to campaign in person, and returned to Luoyang with Sima Zhao to secure the succession of powerWei 21 §95
NNo direct record — estimated from his advice not being adoptedCh. 108 §7
| Occupation | RNOfficial · Master of Writing | Faction | Wei |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | R209 Unverified | Native place | Beidi Commandery Niyang County |
| Died | R255 Unverified | Place of death | |
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R25 |
Fu Gu, courtesy name Lanshi, was a man of Niyang County in Beidi Commandery and a descendant of Fu Jiezi. He began his career as a clerk under Chen Qun, Minister of Works, and rebutted the evaluation law drawn up by the Cavalier Attendant-in-Ordinary Liu Shao; in the Zhengshi era he warned Cao Shuang's younger brother Cao Xi against He Yan and was dismissed from office by He Yan and his associates. Records, Wei 21 §81–82 · 87
After Cao Shuang was executed he became Intendant of Henan and then Master of Writing. When Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin rebelled in the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255), he urged Sima Shi to take the field in person, went with him and contributed plans, and when Sima Shi died he returned straight to Luoyang with Sima Zhao. He died that same year at the age of forty-seven. Records, Wei 21 §88 · 95–96
In his assessment Chen Shou, author of the Records, wrote that 'Fu Gu rose to prominence through his talent.' In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 108 as a Master of Writing and features in 2 of its 120 chapters; no chapter title bears his name. Both times he offers plans at councils convened by Sima Shi. Records, Wei 21 §99Romance, Ch. 108 §7Romance, Ch. 110 §11
Fu Gu, courtesy name Lanshi, was a man of Niyang County in Beidi Commandery and a descendant of Fu Jiezi. His paternal uncle Fu Xun served as Palace Attendant and Master of Writing in the Huangchu era. Fu Gu became known around the age of twenty, and Chen Qun, Minister of Works, summoned him as a clerk. Records, Wei 21 §81
At that time the Cavalier Attendant-in-Ordinary Liu Shao drew up an evaluation law, and when the matter was sent down to the Three Offices, Fu Gu rebutted Liu Shao's argument. The Zhou, he said, had established feudal lords outside and various offices within, so that the land had fixed tribute and offices had settled rules, and reviewing merit and dismissing or promoting officials could be carried out easily; but Wei, from Jian'an to Qinglong, had been busy putting down disorder and had not been able to perfect its institutions. Establishing offices and apportioning duties was the root, and examining reality against names was the branch; to put evaluation first without establishing the main principles of the root, he feared, would not suffice to tell the worthy from the foolish. Moreover, since the selection of talent was now entrusted solely to the Ministry of Personnel, an evaluation that ranked officials lowest and highest could not bring talent fully to light. Records, Wei 21 §82–86
At the beginning of Zhengshi he became a Gentleman of the Secretariat and was transferred to Gentleman of the Yellow Gate. At that time Cao Shuang held power and He Yan was Master of Writing for Personnel; Fu Gu told Cao Shuang's younger brother Cao Xi, 'He Pingshu is calm outside but sharp and cunning within; he loves profit and has no thought of attending to fundamentals,' and said he feared that He Yan would first lead the brothers astray, so that benevolent men would keep their distance and the government of the court would collapse. He Yan and his associates then fell out with Fu Gu and dismissed him from office over a trifling matter. Recalled from his home, Fu Gu was appointed Administrator of Xingyang but did not take up the post. Records, Wei 21 §87
The Grand Tutor Sima Yi asked for him as an Attendant Gentleman on his staff. After Cao Shuang was executed he became Intendant of Henan and was transferred to Master of Writing. Fu Gu always held that Qin had abolished the feudal lords and set up governors, so that offices were no longer as in antiquity, and Han and Wei had followed this; yet Confucian scholars sought to fit it to the rites of the Three Dynasties, so that affairs were at odds with the institutions and names did not match realities. He wished to reform the system of offices thoroughly and correct its foundations on the model of antiquity, but said that, the imperial house facing many difficulties, the reform could not yet be made. Records, Wei 21 §88–89
At that time there were proposals to attack Wu, and the plans submitted by the three campaign generals all differed, so an edict asked Fu Gu's opinion. Fu Gu said that Sun Quan had died and entrusted his young son to Zhuge Ke; if Wu corrected its harsh rule and those within and without became of one mind, it would be enough to prolong its life beyond the deep river. Plans to launch boats and cross straight over to sweep through Jiangnan, or to advance together by four routes and attack the forts, would hardly succeed, he answered; only advancing the army and setting up large military farms was most complete and secure. Citing how Ji Bu rebuked Fan Kuai to his face when Fan Kuai proposed sweeping through the Xiongnu with a host of a hundred thousand, he urged that the laws be made clear and the soldiers drilled, and that plans be laid where complete victory was assured. Records, Wei 21 §90–93
Later, when the Wu senior general Zhuge Ke, fresh from his victory at Dongguan, loudly proclaimed that he would ride his success toward Qing and Xu Provinces, the court prepared to defend against him. Fu Gu said that the Huai and the sea were not routes the enemy could travel lightly, and that the troops Sun Quan had once sent out to sea had been drowned in the waves with almost none surviving. Zhuge Ke, he predicted, would merely send commanders familiar with naval warfare to make a show of moving on Qing and Xu, while he himself combined his forces and came toward Huainan. Zhuge Ke did indeed later move against Xincheng, failed to take it, and went home. Records, Wei 21 §94
Fu Gu often discussed the sameness and difference of talent and nature, and Zhong Hui collected and discussed these views. At the end of Jiaping he was granted the rank of Marquis Within the Passes, and when Cao Mao, Duke of Gaogui Village, took the throne, he was advanced to Marquis of Wuxiang Neighborhood. Wang Ji wrote a letter of admonition to Sima Shi, who had newly taken charge of the government, saying that Xu Yun, Fu Gu, Yuan Kan and Cui Zan were all upright men of their age with whom he could share the affairs of state, and Sima Shi accepted his words. Records, Wei 21 §95Records, Wei 27 §59
When Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin rebelled in the spring of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255), some said that Sima Shi should not go in person and could send the Grand Commandant Sima Fu, but Fu Gu and Wang Su alone urged him to go himself. Sima Shi set out at last, and had Fu Gu go east with him as acting Supervisor of the Masters of Writing. Chen Shou wrote that Fu Gu's plans had a part in the defeat and collapse of Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin. Records, Wei 21 §95–96
When Sima Shi died at Xuchang, an edict from within the palace was sent to the Master of Writing Fu Gu, ordering that the General of the Guards Sima Zhao remain stationed at Xuchang for the time being and that Fu Gu lead the armies back. Zhong Hui plotted with Fu Gu and had him submit a memorial, and Fu Gu returned straight to Luoyang with Sima Zhao. The court appointed Sima Zhao General-in-Chief to assist in the government. When Zhong Hui showed signs of pride over this, Fu Gu warned him, 'Your ambition is greater than your capacity, so it will be hard for you to achieve great deeds. Can you afford not to be careful?' Records, Wei 21 §96Records, Wei 28 §96–97
For his merit Fu Gu was advanced to Marquis of Yang Village and given an additional 600 households, bringing his fief to 1,200 households with the earlier ones. He died that year at the age of forty-seven, was posthumously granted the title of Minister of Ceremonies, and received the posthumous name Marquis Yuan. His son Fu Zhi succeeded him, and when the five ranks of nobility were newly established in the Xianxi era, Fu Zhi's fief was changed to Viscount of Jingyuan because Fu Gu had shown distinguished merit under the previous reign. Records, Wei 21 §96–97
In his assessment, after discussing the men of this volume in turn, Chen Shou wrote that 'Fu Gu rose to prominence through his talent.' Records, Wei 21 §99
In Chapter 108 of the Romance, when news reaches Luoyang that Sun Quan has died and Zhuge Ke has made Sun Liang emperor, Sima Shi discusses raising troops to attack Wu. The Master of Writing Fu Gu says that Wu has the natural barrier of the Yangtze, that the late emperors attacked it many times without ever achieving their aims, and that the best plan is for each side to guard its own borders. Romance, Ch. 108 §7
Sima Shi replies that the Way of Heaven changes once every thirty years, so the three states cannot stand like the legs of a tripod forever, and declares that he will attack Wu. When Sima Zhao adds that Sun Liang is young and weak, so this is an opening to exploit, Sima Shi gives Wang Chang, Hu Zun and Guanqiu Jian a hundred thousand troops each to advance by three routes and makes Sima Zhao Grand Area Commander. Romance, Ch. 108 §8
In Chapter 110, when Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin rebel, Zhong Hui says it would be unwise to send someone else to repel them, and Sima Shi sets out in person at the head of a great army. When Guanqiu Jian hears that Sun Jun of Wu is coming to raid Shouchun and falls back to Xiangcheng, Sima Shi gathers his officials for a council. Romance, Ch. 110 §6 · 9–11
The Master of Writing Fu Gu says that Guanqiu Jian's troops have withdrawn because he fears the men of Wu will raid Shouchun, so he will surely return to Xiangcheng and divide his forces to defend it; if one army takes Yuejia City, one Xiangcheng and one Shouchun, the soldiers of Huainan will surely fall back. He adds that Deng Ai, Inspector of Yan Province, is resourceful and full of stratagems, so if he is sent straight against Yuejia with a large force in support, defeating the rebels will not be difficult. Sima Shi follows his advice and urgently sends a dispatch ordering Deng Ai to attack Yuejia City with the troops of Yan Province. This scene is Fu Gu's last appearance in the Romance. Romance, Ch. 110 §11–12
The debate on attacking Wu: In Chapter 108 of the Romance, Fu Gu cites the natural barrier of the Yangtze and says the best plan is for each side to guard its own borders. In the Records, answering an edict that sought his views on the plans of the three campaign generals after Sun Quan's death, Fu Gu rejected the plans to cross the river and sweep through or to attack together by four routes, and proposed advancing the army and setting up large military farms. Romance, Ch. 108 §7Records, Wei 21 §90–92
His prediction about Zhuge Ke: In the Records, Fu Gu foresaw that Zhuge Ke's talk of heading for Qing and Xu Provinces after his victory at Dongguan was a feint and that he would actually come to Huainan, and Zhuge Ke did indeed attack Xincheng. In the Romance, Fu Gu appears only in Chapters 108 and 110, and this episode is absent. Records, Wei 21 §94Romance, Ch. 108 §7Romance, Ch. 110 §11
Who urged the personal campaign: In the Records, when Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin rebelled, Fu Gu and Wang Su alone urged Sima Shi to go in person. In Chapter 110 of the Romance, after Zhong Hui says that sending someone else would be unwise, Sima Shi rises and declares that he will go himself. Records, Wei 21 §95Romance, Ch. 110 §6
His plan in Huainan: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Fu Gu proposes attacking Yuejia City, Xiangcheng and Shouchun by three routes and entrusting Yuejia to Deng Ai. Fu Gu's biography in the Records says only that his plans had a part in the defeat of Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin, without giving their content. Romance, Ch. 110 §11Records, Wei 21 §96
Sima Zhao's return: In the Records, after Sima Shi's death the edict was sent to the Master of Writing Fu Gu, who plotted with Zhong Hui, submitted a memorial and returned straight to Luoyang with Sima Zhao. In Chapter 110 of the Romance, the edict is sent to Sima Zhao, the one who urges him to return is Zhong Hui, and Fu Gu does not appear. Records, Wei 21 §96Records, Wei 28 §96–97Romance, Ch. 110 §29
The quarrel with He Yan: In the Records, Fu Gu warned Cao Xi against He Yan and was dismissed by He Yan and his associates. The Fu Gu of the Romance has no such episode. Records, Wei 21 §87Romance, Ch. 108 §7Romance, Ch. 110 §11
Later years: In the Records, Fu Gu warned the boastful Zhong Hui, was made Marquis of Yang Village for his merit, and died that year at forty-seven. The Romance does not portray Fu Gu after Chapter 110 and does not record his death. Records, Wei 21 §96Romance, Ch. 110 §11
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RUrged Sima Shi to campaign in person, and returned to Luoyang with Sima Zhao to secure the succession of powerWei 21 §95
NNo direct record — estimated from his advice not being adoptedCh. 108 §7
RRebutted the evaluation law and discussed the foundations of the official system; Intendant of Henan and Master of WritingWei 21 §82Wei 21 §88
NNo direct record — estimated from his office as Master of WritingCh. 108 §7
RSaw through Zhuge Ke's feint and contributed plans to the suppression of Guanqiu JianWei 21 §94Wei 21 §96Wei 21 §99
NRead Guanqiu Jian's intention in withdrawing and proposed a three-pronged attackCh. 110 §11
RDiscussed the sameness and difference of talent and nature; assessment: rose to prominence through talentWei 21 §95Wei 21 §99
NNo direct recordCh. 110 §11
RSpoke frankly about the danger posed by the powerful He Yan and was dismissedWei 21 §87
NNo direct recordCh. 108 §7
RSaw in advance He Yan's cunning and that Zhong Hui's ambition exceeded his capacityWei 21 §87Wei 21 §96
NRecommended Deng Ai for the attack on Yuejia, citing his wisdom and resourcefulnessCh. 110 §11
RBecame known around the age of twenty, and Chen Qun summoned him to officeWei 21 §81
NNo direct recordCh. 108 §7
RNo direct record — estimated from his accompanying Sima Shi's eastern campaignWei 21 §95
NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil official and Master of WritingCh. 110 §11
RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil officialWei 21 §87
NNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil officialCh. 108 §7
RWarned Cao Xi of the danger posed by He Yan, but was not heededWei 21 §87
NCited the barrier of the Yangtze and advised that guarding the borders was the best planCh. 108 §7
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
| Relatives | Fu Xun Records |
|---|
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.