Xiahou Shang 夏侯尚

RecordsRomance Wei Courtesy name 伯仁 Boren하후상백인

Profile
OccupationRGeneral · General-in-Chief Who Conquers the SouthFactionWei
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wei
BornNative placePei Commandery Qiao County Unverified
Cause of deathRIllness Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR32

Profile

Xiahou Shang, courtesy name Boren, was the nephew of Xiahou Yuan. He was a close friend of Emperor Wen (Cao Pi), and from the time Cao Cao pacified Ji Province he followed the campaigns at the head of cavalry. Records, Wei 9 §92

When Emperor Wen took the throne, as General Who Conquers the South and Inspector of Jing Province he commanded the armies of the south; he defeated Shangyong, where Liu Bei's detached force was, pacified three commanderies and nine counties, and was raised to General-in-Chief Who Conquers the South. In the 3rd year of Huangchu (222) he besieged Jiangling together with Cao Zhen. In the 6th year of Huangchu (225) he fell gravely ill and returned to the capital, and after his death he received the posthumous title Marquis Dao. Records, Wei 9 §93–98

In his assessment, Chen Shou, the author of the Records, named him together with Xiahou Dun, Xiahou Yuan, Cao Ren, Cao Hong, Cao Xiu and Cao Zhen as men who, being close kinsmen and old friends, assisted the great enterprise at their lord's side and achieved merit. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 70 as a general whom Cao Hong sends to help Zhang He, and he appears in 5 of its 120 chapters; there is no chapter with his name in its title. Records, Wei 9 §132Romance, Ch. 70 §30

In the Records

Xiahou Shang, courtesy name Boren, was the nephew of Xiahou Yuan. He was a close friend of Emperor Wen. When Cao Cao pacified Ji Province he became Army Major and followed the campaigns at the head of cavalry; later he became Literary Scholar to the General of the Household for All Purposes, and when the state of Wei was first established he was transferred to Gentleman of the Yellow Gate. When the barbarians of Dai Commandery rebelled, he took part in the army of Cao Zhang, Marquis of Yanling, pacified the land of Dai and returned. When Cao Cao died at Luoyang, Xiahou Shang, holding the Staff of authority, escorted the imperial coffin back to Ye. Records, Wei 9 §92

Because Xiahou Shang was very close to the Crown Prince, Du Xi told Cao Cao that he was not a beneficial friend and did not deserve special treatment, and Emperor Wen was at first greatly displeased. Xun Yu's son Xun Yun, who was friendly with Cao Zhi and on bad terms with Xiahou Shang, was deeply resented by Emperor Wen. Records, Wei 23 §43Records, Wei 10 §45

With his earlier merits recorded together, he was enfeoffed as Marquis of Pingling Precinct, and after serving as Cavalier Regular Attendant he became Central Commander of the Army. When Emperor Wen took the throne, he was re-enfeoffed as Marquis of Pingling Village, and as General Who Conquers the South concurrently serving as Inspector of Jing Province he was given the Staff and commanded the armies of the south. Xiahou Shang reported that at Shangyong, where Liu Bei's detached force was, the mountain roads were steep and the enemy was not on guard, so if a surprise force were sent secretly to come out where they did not expect it, victory could be won. He then led the armies to defeat Shangyong, pacified three commanderies and nine counties, and was raised to General-in-Chief Who Conquers the South. The Biography of Liu Feng records that Xiahou Shang, General Who Conquers the South, and Xu Huang, General of the Right, attacked Liu Feng together with Meng Da, and that when Shen Yi turned against him, Liu Feng was defeated and fled to Chengdu. Records, Wei 9 §93–94Records, Shu 10 §6 · 15

Emperor Wen issued Xiahou Shang an edict telling him to 'wield authority and bestow favour, put men to death and let men live'. Xiahou Shang showed it to Jiang Ji, and when Jiang Ji said that these were words that ruin a state, which the Book of Documents warns against, Emperor Wen sent someone to take back the earlier edict. Records, Wei 14 §119–120

Although Sun Quan called himself a vassal, Xiahou Shang strengthened his preparations for attack all the more, and Sun Quan later did indeed prove two-faced. In the 3rd year of Huangchu (222), when Emperor Wen went to Wan, Xiahou Shang led the armies and besieged Jiangling together with Cao Zhen. When Sun Quan's general Zhuge Jin entered an islet in the middle of the river and divided his naval forces in midstream, Xiahou Shang prepared many oil-soaked boats at night, crossed secretly downstream with more than 10,000 infantry and cavalry, burned the boats on both banks of the river, and defeated Zhuge Jin by attacking on land and water together. Records, Wei 9 §94–95

Jiangling, however, did not fall, and as a great epidemic broke out, Emperor Wen issued an edict ordering Xiahou Shang to bring his troops back. According to the Biography of Dong Zhao, when Xiahou Shang used boats to station infantry and cavalry on the islet and meant to build a floating bridge to go back and forth, Dong Zhao submitted a memorial saying that this was something military men avoid, and Emperor Wen had them withdraw quickly. When the Wu army advanced from both sides, the generals Shi Jian and Gao Qian barely escaped with their lives, and ten days after the troops came out the river suddenly rose. The Biography of Zhu Ran also records that Xiahou Shang and the others could not win and withdrew. Records, Wei 9 §95Records, Wei 14 §73–76Records, Wu 11 §18

600 households were added to his fief, making 1,900 in all, and he was given the battle-axe and raised to Governor of Jing Province. Jing Province was desolate, it bordered Wu along the Han River, and most of its former inhabitants lived south of the Yangtze; Xiahou Shang opened a road of more than 700 li westward from Shangyong, and within five or six years several thousand households of mountain people and Man tribes came over to him. In the 5th year of Huangchu (224) he was transferred to the fief of Marquis of Changling Village. Records, Wei 9 §95–96

Xiahou Shang had a favourite concubine whom he favoured above his principal wife, and because the principal wife was a daughter of the Cao family, Emperor Wen sent someone to strangle the concubine. Xiahou Shang fell ill with grief and became confused in mind, and even after the concubine was buried he could not bear his longing to see her and dug her up again to look at her. Emperor Wen was angry and said that Du Xi had had good reason to call Xiahou Shang frivolous, but because he was an old servant, did not reduce his favour toward him. Records, Wei 9 §97

In the 6th year of Huangchu (225) Xiahou Shang fell gravely ill and returned to the capital, and Emperor Wen visited him in person several times, holding his hand and shedding tears. When Xiahou Shang died he was given the posthumous title Marquis Dao, and his son Xiahou Xuan succeeded him. In the 4th year of Zhengshi (243) he was enshrined in the temple of Taizu together with Cao Zhen, Cao Xiu and others. Records, Wei 9 §97–98Records, Wei 4 §14

In his assessment, Chen Shou said that because the Xiahou and Cao families had intermarried for generations, Xiahou Dun, Xiahou Yuan, Cao Ren, Cao Hong, Cao Xiu, Xiahou Shang, Cao Zhen and others were all esteemed in their time as close kinsmen and old friends, and that all of them assisted the great enterprise at their lord's side and achieved merit. Records, Wei 9 §132

In the Romance

In Chapter 70 of the Romance, after Zhang He has lost to Huang Zhong again and again, Cao Hong, following Guo Huai's advice, gives 5,000 troops to 'Xiahou Shang, nephew of Xiahou Dun' and to Han Hao, younger brother of the surrendered general Han Xuan, and sends them to help. Xiahou Shang and Han Hao pursue Huang Zhong, who is feigning retreat, one stage after another and seize his camps, and when Zhang He warns them that there must be a trick, they rebuke him: 'It is because you are timid that you keep losing battles.' They also say there is nothing to worry about at Mount Michang, since his uncle Xiahou Yuan is guarding it. Romance, Ch. 70 §30 · 33–34 · 40

But when Huang Zhong opens the pass at night, comes down and breaks their camps, Xiahou Shang and Han Hao barely escape with their lives, and when Huang Zhong attacks Mount Tiandang, Han Hao is cut down in a single bout. Zhang He and Xiahou Shang, unable to look after front and rear, abandon Mount Tiandang and flee to Xiahou Yuan at Mount Dingjun. Romance, Ch. 70 §38 · 44 · 46

In Chapter 71, following Xiahou Yuan's plan, Xiahou Shang feigns defeat to lure out Chen Shi of Shu and have him captured. When Xiahou Yuan ignores Zhang He's objections and sends Xiahou Shang out to fight, Huang Zhong captures Xiahou Shang in a single bout. The next day Chen Shi and Xiahou Shang are exchanged in front of the lines, and just as Xiahou Shang nears the gate of his own lines he is struck in the middle of the back by an arrow shot by Huang Zhong, and returns so. Romance, Ch. 71 §15–16 · 18 · 20–22

In Chapter 76, Cao Cao makes Xu Huang General Who Pacifies the South and has him guard Xiangyang together with Xiahou Shang to hold off Lord Guan's army. In Chapter 79, as Xiahou Shang and Xu Huang set out from Xiangyang to take the counties of Shangyong, Meng Da comes over to them, and when Meng Da feigns defeat to draw out Liu Feng, Xiahou Shang strikes from the left and Xu Huang from the right, and they inflict a heavy defeat on Liu Feng. Romance, Ch. 76 §24Romance, Ch. 79 §33–35

In Chapter 85, when Cao Pi attacks Wu along three routes, a report comes in that Cao Zhen and Xiahou Shang besieged Nan Commandery but were heavily defeated when Lu Xun from within and Zhuge Jin from without, having laid ambushes, attacked them from both sides. Xiahou Shang does not appear in the Romance after this, and his death is not recorded. Romance, Ch. 85 §13

Where the Romance differs

Whose nephew: Chapter 70 of the Romance introduces him as 'nephew of Xiahou Dun', yet in the same chapter Xiahou Shang calls Xiahou Yuan 'my uncle'. The Records says he was the nephew of Xiahou Yuan. Romance, Ch. 70 §30 · 40Records, Wei 9 §92

The fighting in Hanzhong: In Chapters 70 and 71 of the Romance, Xiahou Shang loses to Huang Zhong at Mount Tiandang, and at Mount Dingjun he is captured, exchanged for Chen Shi and struck by an arrow. The Biography of Xiahou Shang in the Records has no fighting in Hanzhong; it records his part in the attack on the barbarians of Dai Commandery and his escorting Cao Cao's coffin to Ye. Romance, Ch. 70 §46Romance, Ch. 71 §20–22Records, Wei 9 §91–98

Defending Xiangyang: In Chapter 76 of the Romance, Xiahou Shang guards Xiangyang together with Xu Huang and holds off Lord Guan. This is not in the Biography of Xiahou Shang in the Records; he became General Who Conquers the South and Inspector of Jing Province after Emperor Wen took the throne. Romance, Ch. 76 §24Records, Wei 9 §92–93

The attack on Shangyong: In Chapter 79 of the Romance, Xiahou Shang and Xu Huang come out from ambush and defeat Liu Feng together with Meng Da. In the Records too, Xiahou Shang and Xu Huang attacked Liu Feng together with Meng Da, and the Biography of Xiahou Shang records that the attack on Shangyong began with Xiahou Shang's own proposal and pacified three commanderies and nine counties. The Biography of Liu Feng records that Liu Feng was defeated because Shen Yi turned against him. Romance, Ch. 79 §33–35Records, Wei 9 §93–94Records, Shu 10 §6 · 15

The battle of Jiangling: In Chapter 85 of the Romance there is only a report that Cao Zhen and Xiahou Shang were heavily defeated at Nan Commandery by the pincer attack of Lu Xun and Zhuge Jin. In the Biography of Xiahou Shang in the Records, Xiahou Shang crossed downstream at night with oil-soaked boats and defeated Zhuge Jin's troops, but could not take the city, and when an epidemic broke out he returned by edict. In the Biography of Dong Zhao, the withdrawal followed Dong Zhao's memorial warning that stationing troops on the islet was dangerous. Romance, Ch. 85 §13Records, Wei 9 §94–95Records, Wei 14 §73–76

Offices: The Romance does not state Xiahou Shang's offices. In the Records he rose from General Who Conquers the South to General-in-Chief Who Conquers the South, and was given the battle-axe and made Governor of Jing Province. Romance, Ch. 70 §30Romance, Ch. 76 §24Records, Wei 9 §93–95

His end: The Romance does not depict Xiahou Shang after Chapter 85. In the Records, after his favourite concubine was killed on Emperor Wen's orders he fell ill with grief, and in the 6th year of Huangchu (225) he fell gravely ill, returned to the capital and died, receiving the posthumous title Marquis Dao. Romance, Ch. 85 §13Records, Wei 9 §97–98

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA7838−40
  • STR4535−10
  • INT7525−50
  • POL6235−27
  • CHA6038−22
  • VIR3240+8
  • ADP4528−17
  • SCH5032−18
  • DIP3830−8
  • DIS4030−10
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

IntelligenceR75N25 −50

RHis plan for a surprise attack on Shangyong succeeded, and he prepared in advance for Sun Quan's duplicityWei 9 §93Wei 9 §94

NFailed to see through Huang Zhong's feigned defeat and said Mount Tiandang was in no dangerCh. 70 §34Ch. 70 §40

LeadershipR78N38 −40

RBroke Shangyong to pacify three commanderies and nine counties, and defeated Zhuge Jin's army on land and waterWei 9 §94Wei 9 §95

NGrew slack, lost his camps to Huang Zhong, and abandoned Mount Tiandang to fleeCh. 70 §38Ch. 70 §46Ch. 85 §13

PoliticsR62N35Unverified −27

ROpened a road over 700 li and brought several thousand households of Man tribes to submitWei 9 §96

NNo direct record — estimated from the record of his garrisoning XiangyangCh. 79 §33

CharismaR60N38Unverified −22

RMountain people and Man tribes submitted to him, and he was so close to the emperor that the emperor held his hand and weptWei 9 §96Wei 9 §97

NNo direct record — estimated from the record of his being charged with supervising Zhang HeCh. 70 §30

ScholarshipR50N32Unverified −18

RBecame Literary Scholar to the General of the Household for All PurposesWei 9 §92

NNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as a military commanderCh. 70 §30

AdaptabilityR45N28 −17

RBecame confused in mind over his concubine, but kept the emperor's favour as an old servantWei 9 §97

NGrew slack when the enemy did not come out for days, and suffered a night attackCh. 70 §38

StrengthR45UnverifiedN35 −10

RNo direct record — estimated from the record of his following the campaigns at the head of cavalryWei 9 §92

NJoined Han Hao in attacking Huang Zhong for more than ten bouts, but was captured in a single boutCh. 70 §33Ch. 71 §20

DiscernmentR40UnverifiedN30 −10

RNo direct record — estimated from his career as commander in Jing ProvinceWei 9 §95

NDismissed Zhang He's warning and urged him to win merit togetherCh. 70 §34

2 similar abilities — show evidence
  • VirtueR32N40 +8

    RDug up his favourite concubine's grave to look at her, and Emperor Wen called him frivolousWei 9 §97

    NShamed Zhang He by rebuking him as a coward for his warningCh. 70 §34

  • DiplomacyR38UnverifiedN30Unverified −8

    RNo direct record — estimated from his career administering Jing ProvinceWei 9 §93

    NNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as a military commanderCh. 70 §30

Special — talents Records +10 · Romance +0

  • Naval warfare

    RSkilled +10 Crossed secretly at night in oil-soaked boats, burned Zhuge Jin's boats and attacked on land and waterWei 9 §95

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (5)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wei · Records · 「文帝踐阼,更封平陵鄉侯,遷征南將軍」

Family

SiblingsXiahou De Romance
ChildrenXiahou Xuan Records
RelativesXiahou Yuan Records

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (3)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).