Battle

Battle of Didao 狄道之戰

About this event

The Battle of Didao was the battle in which, in the 8th month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan of Wei (255; the 18th year of Yanxi of Shu), Jiang Wei of Shu, together with Xiahou Ba, Zhang Yi and others, came out to Didao, heavily defeated Wei's Inspector of Yong Province Wang Jing at Taoxi and besieged the city of Didao, then withdrew in the 9th month when the relief army of the General Who Conquers the West Chen Tai and Deng Ai arrived. Badly beaten, Wang Jing defended the city of Didao with some ten thousand men, and when Chen Tai climbed the high mountains southeast of Didao by night and announced the relief with beacon fires and drums, Jiang Wei lifted the siege and stopped at Zhongti. It was one of the battles of Jiang Wei's Northern Expeditions, and the Wei court, saying that the officers and men killed in the battle of Taoxi numbered in the thousands, consoled their families. Records, Wei 4 §57–58Records, Wei 22 §43 · 49–50Records, Shu 14 §37Records, Shu 15 §15

Chen Shou recorded this battle in detail in the Annals of the Three Young Emperors in Records of Wei 4 and the Biography of Chen Tai in Records of Wei 22, and also divided it among the Biography of Deng Ai in Records of Wei 28 and, in the Records of Shu, the Biography of the Later Ruler in volume 3, the Biography of Jiang Wei in volume 14 and the Biography of Zhang Yi in volume 15. The Romance depicts this battle in the latter part of Chapter 110, "Wen Yang Drives Back a Mighty Host Single-Handed; Jiang Wei Fights with His Back to the River and Crushes a Great Foe," and continues with its aftermath at the opening of Chapter 111. Records, Wei 4 §57–59Records, Wei 22 §42–53Records, Wei 28 §63Records, Shu 3 §35Records, Shu 14 §37Records, Shu 15 §15–16Romance, Ch. 110 §34–44Romance, Ch. 111 §1

Course of events in the Records

In the 17th year of Yanxi (254) Jiang Wei went out to Longxi, received the surrender of Li Jian, Chief of Didao County, and brought back the people of the three counties of Heguan, Didao and Lintao. The following spring Zhang Yi, who had returned to Chengdu with Jiang Wei, alone argued at court, when Jiang Wei discussed sending out troops again, that the state was small and the people weary, so force should not be used recklessly. Jiang Wei did not listen and set out taking Zhang Yi and others with him, promoting Zhang Yi to Senior General Who Guards the South. Records, Shu 14 §36Records, Shu 3 §34Records, Shu 15 §15

In Wei, when the General of Chariots and Cavalry Guo Huai died in the 1st month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255), Chen Tai succeeded him as General Who Conquers the West, commanding the troops of Yong and Liang provinces. The Inspector of Yong Province Wang Jing proposed sending out troops in divisions, saying that Jiang Wei and Xiahou Ba intended to head for Mount Qi, Shiying and Jincheng by three routes, but Chen Tai, judging that the enemy could not come by three routes, replied that he should advance only after the forces of east and west had joined. When Jiang Wei and the others, leading tens of thousands of men, reached Fuhan and headed for Didao, Chen Tai ordered Wang Jing to advance and station himself at Didao to wait for the main army, and he himself advanced to Chencang. Records, Wei 4 §54Records, Wei 22 §42–43

On the xinhai day of the 8th month Jiang Wei invaded Didao. When the armies under Wang Jing fought the enemy at Guguan and fared badly, Wang Jing crossed the Tao River on his own initiative, fought Jiang Wei at Taoxi and was heavily defeated; he returned with some ten thousand men to defend the city of Didao, while all the rest fled and scattered. The Biography of Jiang Wei puts the dead among Wang Jing's forces at tens of thousands, and the Biography of Zhang Yi records that those who died in the Tao River were counted by the ten thousand. Zhang Yi said that this was the time to stop and that going further might ruin this great achievement, but Jiang Wei was furious and in the end besieged Wang Jing at Didao. Records, Wei 4 §57Records, Wei 22 §43–44Records, Shu 14 §37Records, Shu 15 §15–16

On the xinwei day the Wei court had Deng Ai, Colonel of the Changshui Cavalry, act as General Who Pacifies the West and join forces with Chen Tai to resist Jiang Wei, and had the Grand Commandant Sima Fu follow behind. Chen Tai stationed himself at Shanggui, divided his troops to guard the strategic points and pressed forward day and night, and when Deng Ai, Hu Fen and others arrived, he divided them into three armies and advanced to Longxi. Deng Ai and the others proposed avoiding the edge of Jiang Wei, who was riding on his victory, holding the rugged places and waiting for the enemy to tire. Chen Tai said that Jiang Wei was being worn down beneath a high wall and his supplies were not keeping up, so that now was the time to advance quickly and defeat him, and that since the Tao River encircled them on the outside, if they seized the heights and looked down on them, the enemy would flee without a battle. Records, Wei 4 §57Records, Wei 22 §44–48

Chen Tai crossed the Gaocheng Ridge and advanced in secret, reaching the high mountains southeast of Didao by night, where he raised many beacon fires and sounded drums and horns. The officers and men in the city were roused at the sight of the relief army, and Jiang Wei's side, which had thought the relief troops would come only after all their forces had gathered, trembled from top to bottom. When Chen Tai pretended to take the southern road, Jiang Wei laid an ambush for three days, but Chen Tai's army came out secretly to the south of it. When Jiang Wei charged along the mountain, Chen Tai met him in battle and Jiang Wei withdrew. When the troops of Liang Province came south from Jincheng to Wogan Slope and Chen Tai secretly agreed with Wang Jing to head together for Jiang Wei's line of retreat, Jiang Wei and the others, hearing of it, fled, and the officers and men in the city were able to come out. Wang Jing lamented that they had had less than ten days of food left. Records, Wei 22 §49–50

On the jiachen day of the 9th month Jiang Wei withdrew and stopped at Zhongti. When the siege of Didao was lifted and Jiang Wei withdrew, Deng Ai became General Who Pacifies the West, was granted the tally of authority and concurrently served as Colonel Protector of the Eastern Qiang, while Chen Tai consoled his officers and men and sent them home, repaired the walls and fortifications, and returned to garrison Shanggui. Earlier the court had argued for waiting until great armies had gathered from all sides, but the General-in-Chief Sima Zhao said that the city would not fall suddenly and the shortage of supplies was the urgent matter, so it was the best plan for the General Who Conquers the West to hurry to the rescue. He called Chen Tai, who had not asked for more troops, calm, brave and decisive. Records, Wei 4 §58Records, Shu 3 §35Records, Shu 14 §37Records, Wei 28 §63Records, Wei 22 §51–53

In the 10th month the Wei court, saying that the officers and men who died in the battle of Taoxi numbered in the thousands, had their families consoled and exempted from corvée for a year, and in the 11th month it pardoned the relatives of those in the four commanderies of Longyou and in Jincheng who had fled or surrendered to the enemy, and had the bodies sought out and buried at the battlefield and along the Tao River. Deng Ai, saying that the defeat at Taoxi was no small setback, cited five reasons why the Shu army would surely come again, and the following year, when Jiang Wei came out again, he crushed him at the Battle of Duangu. Records, Wei 4 §58–59Records, Wei 28 §63–65

In the Romance

In Chapter 110 of the Romance, when Sima Shi died and Sima Zhao took supreme power, Jiang Wei petitioned to use the opportunity to attack Wei. In Hanzhong, Zhang Yi tried to dissuade him, saying that the land of Shu was narrow and its wealth and grain scarce, but Jiang Wei said he would carry on the purpose of the Chancellor, who had marched out to Mount Qi six times, and Xiahou Ba proposed going out first to Fuhan with light cavalry. Jiang Wei headed for Fuhan with 50,000 troops, and the Inspector of Yong Province Wang Jing came to meet him with 70,000 cavalry and infantry. Romance, Ch. 110 §30–34

Jiang Wei sent Zhang Yi and Xiahou Ba off with plans and himself deployed with his back to the Tao River. Wang Jing, saying that since the Shu army had its back to the water it would all drown if defeated, sent out four commanders, Zhang Ming, Hua Yong, Liu Da and Zhu Fang. Jiang Wei fought a few bouts and fled, and on reaching the water's edge cried, "The situation is urgent!" While his commanders turned back and charged, Zhang Yi and Xiahou Ba burst out by two routes behind the Wei army and surrounded it. The Wei troops trampled one another, countless drowned in the Tao River, and more than ten thousand heads were taken. Wang Jing fled with a hundred horsemen to the city of Didao, closed the gates and held out. Romance, Ch. 110 §34–37

Zhang Yi remonstrated that if they did not stop here it might be like drawing a snake and adding legs, but Jiang Wei, saying Didao could easily be taken, attacked the city. Deng Ai, Inspector of Yan Province, who had come to Chen Tai, said that since the enemy, instead of gathering the Qiang and contending for Guanzhong and Longyou, was aiming at a strong city, it would only waste its strength, and proposed deploying troops at Xiang Ridge before attacking. Chen Tai hid twenty units of fifty men each, carrying flags, drums and beacon fires, in the deep valleys of the high mountains southeast of the city of Didao, and he and Deng Ai advanced, each leading 20,000 men. Romance, Ch. 110 §38–41

When Jiang Wei had attacked for many days without taking the city, the two armies of Chen Tai and Deng Ai arrived. Jiang Wei had Zhang Yi attack the city and sent Xiahou Ba against Chen Tai while he himself went out to face Deng Ai, but to the southeast, with a cannon blast, drums sounded and fires flared, and on every side were Wei banners. Saying he had fallen into Deng Ai's trap, Jiang Wei abandoned Didao and withdrew, and only on entering Jiange did he learn that the fires and drums in over twenty places had been false. Jiang Wei garrisoned Zhongti, and the Later Ruler made him General-in-Chief for his achievement at Taoxi. At the opening of Chapter 111 Wang Jing bowed to Chen Tai and Deng Ai, who had lifted the siege, and Deng Ai became General Who Pacifies the West. Romance, Ch. 110 §41–44Romance, Ch. 111 §1

Where the Romance differs

Troop strength: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Jiang Wei faced Wang Jing with 50,000 men, and Wang Jing faced him with 70,000 cavalry and infantry. In the Records, the Biography of Chen Tai says only that Jiang Wei and the others numbered tens of thousands and does not give Wang Jing's strength, and the defeated Wang Jing defended the city of Didao with some ten thousand men. Romance, Ch. 110 §34Records, Wei 22 §43

The battle of Taoxi: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Jiang Wei deployed with his back to the Tao River, feigned flight and then turned to fight, while Zhang Yi and Xiahou Ba struck the Wei army from behind. The Records contain no such stratagem, recording that after faring badly at Guguan, Wang Jing crossed the Tao River on his own initiative, fought Jiang Wei and was heavily defeated. Romance, Ch. 110 §34–37Records, Wei 22 §43Records, Wei 4 §57

Wei's losses: Chapter 110 of the Romance says more than ten thousand heads were taken. In the Records, the Biography of Jiang Wei puts the dead among Wang Jing's forces at tens of thousands and the Biography of Zhang Yi says those who died in the Tao River were counted by the ten thousand, while the Wei court said the officers and men who died numbered in the thousands. Romance, Ch. 110 §37Records, Shu 14 §37Records, Shu 15 §15Records, Wei 4 §58

Zhang Yi's remonstrance: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Zhang Yi tried to dissuade Jiang Wei from the expedition in Hanzhong, and after the victory tried to stop the attack on the city, calling it like adding legs to a snake. In the Biography of Zhang Yi in the Records, Zhang Yi argued at court in Chengdu before the troops set out, and after Wang Jing was defeated he said that this was the time to stop. Romance, Ch. 110 §31 · 38Records, Shu 15 §15–16

The relief plan: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Deng Ai devised the plan, and Chen Tai hid twenty units in the mountains southeast of the city of Didao to frighten the enemy with drums and fires. In the Biography of Chen Tai in the Records, Deng Ai and the others proposed holding the rugged places and waiting, and Chen Tai rejected this and in person climbed the high mountains southeast of Didao by night, raised beacon fires and beat the drums. Romance, Ch. 110 §39–40Records, Wei 22 §44–49

Jiang Wei's retreat: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, Jiang Wei, startled by the false banners and drums on every side, withdrew without fighting. In the Records, he laid an ambush for three days in response to Chen Tai's feigned march and withdrew after fighting Chen Tai, then, hearing that his line of retreat was to be cut, fled and stopped at Zhongti. Romance, Ch. 110 §42–43Records, Wei 22 §50Records, Shu 14 §37

General-in-Chief: In Chapter 110 of the Romance, the Later Ruler made Jiang Wei General-in-Chief for his achievement at Taoxi. The Biographies of the Later Ruler and of Jiang Wei in the Records state that Jiang Wei was promoted to General-in-Chief in the spring of the following year, the 19th year of Yanxi (256). Romance, Ch. 110 §44Records, Shu 3 §36Records, Shu 14 §38

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsWeiShu
CommandersChen Tai, Deng Ai, Wang Jing, Hu FenJiang Wei, Xiahou Ba, Zhang Yi(張翼)
Strength維等將數萬人至枹罕
Casualties經眾死者數萬人

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 4 §57 · Wei 22 §50

Sub-events and Romance scenes (1)

Romance chapters (2)

Records volumes (6)