Zhong Yao 鍾繇

RecordsRomance Wei Courtesy name 元常 Yuanchang종요원상钟繇

Profile
OccupationRNOfficial · Grand TutorFactionWei
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wei
BornR151 UnverifiedNative placeYingchuan Commandery Changshe County
DiedR230 UnverifiedPlace of death
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR62

Profile

Zhong Yao, courtesy name Yuanchang, was a man of Changshe County in Yingchuan Commandery. While serving the Han court as Gentleman of the Yellow Gate, he persuaded Li Jue and Guo Si, who held Chang'an, to let Cao Cao's envoys through, and helped the emperor escape from Chang'an. Records, Wei 13 §2–4

As Colonel-Director of Retainers in charge of the land within the passes, he pacified Ma Teng and Han Sui and sent horses for the battle of Guandu, and in the state of Wei he served as Grand Judge (dali) and Chancellor of State (xiangguo). He became Grand Commandant under Emperor Wen and Grand Tutor under Emperor Ming, and died in the 4th year of Taihe (230). Records, Wei 13 §5 · 9–10 · 18

In his assessment, Chen Shou, the author of the Records, called him "open-minded and capable in handling affairs," and wrote that together with Hua Xin and Wang Lang, as outstanding men of their age, he rose to the Three Excellencies when Wei was first founded. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 56 among the civil officials presenting poems at the banquet on the Bronze Sparrow Terrace and appears in 7 of its 120 chapters; his name is not in any chapter title. In Chapter 58 he appears as the governor of Chang'an who loses the city to Ma Chao's troops. Records, Wei 13 §99Romance, Ch. 56 §18Romance, Ch. 58 §14 · 18

In the Records

Zhong Yao, courtesy name Yuanchang, was a man of Changshe County in Yingchuan Commandery. Once, going to Luoyang with his clansman uncle Zhong Yu, he met a physiognomist on the road who said he had the look of one who would become noble but would meet misfortune in water; before they had gone ten li, his horse took fright as they crossed a bridge and he fell into the water and nearly died. When the physiognomist's words came true, Zhong Yu valued Zhong Yao all the more, paid for his studies and let him devote himself to learning. Recommended as Filial and Incorrupt (xiaolian), he became Gentleman of the Masters of Writing and Prefect of Yangling but left because of illness, and on being summoned by the Three Excellencies he became Supervisor of the Commandant of Justice (tingwei zheng) and Gentleman of the Yellow Gate. Records, Wei 13 §2–3

At this time Emperor Xian, Liu Xie, was in Chang'an, where Li Jue, Guo Si and others had caused disorder, and contact with the east of the passes had been cut off. When Cao Cao, holding the post of Governor of Yan Province, first sent an envoy with a letter to the throne, Li Jue and Guo Si wished to detain the envoy, claiming that the east of the passes meant to set up its own emperor. Zhong Yao persuaded them that among all the heroes who falsely claimed the emperor's commands, only Cao of Yan Province had his heart set on the royal house, and that they should not rebuff his loyalty; thanks to this, Cao Cao's mission got through. Cao Cao, who had often heard Xun Yu's praise of Zhong Yao, esteemed him all the more for this. Later, when Li Jue held the emperor under duress, Zhong Yao made plans together with the Gentleman of the Masters of Writing Han Bin, and his efforts helped the emperor escape from Chang'an. He became Palace Assistant Imperial Clerk and then Palace Attendant and Deputy Director of the Imperial Secretariat, and, his earlier merit also being recorded, was enfeoffed as Marquis of Dongwu Village. Records, Wei 13 §3–4

Within the passes, Ma Teng, Han Sui and others commanded strong forces and fought among themselves. Cao Cao, worried about the west because of his affairs east of the mountains, memorialized that Zhong Yao should, as Palace Attendant, act as Colonel-Director of Retainers, gave him the Credential to supervise the armies within the passes, and freed him from the usual regulations. From Chang'an Zhong Yao sent letters to Ma Teng and Han Sui explaining the consequences of disaster and good fortune, and the two each sent a son to serve at court. When Cao Cao was facing Yuan Shao at Guandu, Zhong Yao sent him more than two thousand horses, and Cao Cao wrote to him that it was his achievement that the west had been pacified and there was no need to look back westward, comparing him to Xiao He, who had held the land within the passes. Records, Wei 13 §5–6

Later, when the Xiongnu chanyu rebelled at Pingyang, Zhong Yao led the various armies to besiege him but could not take the city, and Guo Yuan, the Administrator of Hedong appointed by Yuan Shang, arrived with a large host. When the generals proposed lifting the siege, Zhong Yao said that if they showed weakness the people would all become their enemies, and that Guo Yuan, stubborn and eager to win, could be heavily defeated if they struck as he crossed the Fen River. Zhang Ji persuaded Ma Teng, and Ma Teng sent his son Ma Chao with elite troops. Guo Yuan did indeed try to cross the Fen carelessly, and was attacked before half his men were across, heavily defeated and beheaded, and the chanyu surrendered. Records, Wei 13 §6–8Records, Wei 15 §39–40

Later, when Wei Gu of Hedong plundered together with Zhang Sheng, Zhang Yan, Gao Gan and others, Zhong Yao again led the generals and crushed them. After the emperor had moved west, Luoyang was left without people; Zhong Yao brought in people from within the passes and called in fugitives and rebels to fill it, and within a few years the households gradually increased. Cao Cao drew on these resources when he campaigned within the passes, and memorialized to make Zhong Yao Military Adviser of the Front. Records, Wei 13 §8

In the 3rd month of the 16th year of Jian'an (211), Cao Cao sent Zhong Yao to attack Zhang Lu in Hanzhong and had Xiahou Yuan and others meet him in Hedong. Gao Rou remonstrated that Han Sui and Ma Chao would think the move was aimed at them and would rebel, and that they should first call together the Three Adjuncts (sanfu). When Zhong Yao entered the land within the passes, the generals there suspected he meant to attack them, and Ma Chao rebelled together with Han Sui and others. Records, Wei 1 §109–110Records, Wei 24 §27

When the state of Wei was first established, he became Grand Judge, and in the 8th month of the 21st year of Jian'an (216) he became Chancellor of State. Cao Pi, then in the Eastern Palace, gave Zhong Yao a five-flavor cauldron and composed an inscription for it saying, "Its chancellor is Lord Zhong, truly a pillar of heart and backbone." In the 9th month of the 24th year of Jian'an (219), implicated in the plot of Wei Feng, Official of the Western Bureau, he was dismissed and withdrew to his home. Records, Wei 13 §9Records, Wei 1 §154 · 169

When Cao Pi ascended the throne as king, Zhong Yao again became Grand Judge, and when Cao Pi took the imperial throne he was made Commandant of Justice and advanced to Marquis of Chonggao District. In the 8th month of the 4th year of Huangchu (223) he became Grand Commandant and was transferred in fief to Marquis of Pingyang District. When he thus became one of the Three Excellencies together with Hua Xin, Minister over the Masses, and Wang Lang, Minister of Works, Emperor Wen said, "These three excellencies are the great men of an age; later generations will find it hard to follow them." When Emperor Ming took the throne, Zhong Yao was advanced to Marquis of Dingling with a fief of 1,800 households, and in the 12th month of the 7th year of Huangchu (226) he was transferred to Grand Tutor. Because a knee ailment made it hard for him to bow and rise, he and Hua Xin, who was also ill, were carried to court audiences in carriages and lifted up into the hall by the Rapid as Tigers guards, which afterwards became the custom for the Three Excellencies. Records, Wei 13 §9–10Records, Wei 2 §44Records, Wei 3 §4

Zhong Yao repeatedly argued that some death sentences should be replaced by the ancient mutilating punishments. The matter was discussed under Cao Cao and under Emperor Wen, but each time it was dropped. In the Taihe era he memorialized that if those facing the death penalty who so wished were instead given the punishment of cutting off the right foot, three thousand lives could be saved every year. The Minister over the Masses Wang Lang said that if mutilating punishments were used again, word of it would spread to their enemies, and proposed substituting head-shaving and hard labor; of the more than one hundred who took part in the debate, many sided with Wang Lang. Emperor Ming set the matter aside because Wu and Shu had not yet been pacified. Records, Wei 13 §11–17

Zhong Yao was close to Xun You of Yingchuan. When Xun You died first, leaving a young son, Zhong Yao looked after his family. Hu Zhao was skilled in calligraphy and was famous alongside Zhong Yao, Handan Chun, Wei Ji and Wei Dan. Records, Wei 29 §40–41Records, Wei 11 §109

When Zhong Yao died in the 4th month of the 4th year of Taihe (230), Emperor Ming wore plain mourning clothes and came in person to offer condolences, and gave him the posthumous title Marquis Cheng. His son Zhong Yu succeeded him. Earlier, Emperor Wen had divided Zhong Yu's fief to enfeoff Zhong Yao's younger brother Zhong Yan, his son Zhong Shao and his grandson Zhong Yu as full marquises. Records, Wei 13 §18Records, Wei 3 §18

In his assessment, Chen Shou said that Zhong Yao was open-minded and capable in handling affairs, and wrote that he, Hua Xin and Wang Lang were all outstanding men of their age, who first rose to the Three Excellencies when Wei was founded—a splendid thing. Records, Wei 13 §99

In the Romance

In Chapter 56 of the Romance, when Cao Cao held a banquet on the Bronze Sparrow Terrace, civil officials such as Wang Lang, Zhong Yao, Wang Can and Chen Lin composed and presented poems, many of them praising Cao Cao's merit and virtue as so lofty that he ought to receive the Mandate of Heaven. Romance, Ch. 56 §18

In Chapter 58 Zhong Yao appears as the governor of Chang'an. He clashed with Ma Dai, the vanguard of the Xiliang army, was defeated and fled before a single bout was over, and was besieged in Chang'an by Ma Chao and Han Sui. After he had held out for ten days, Ma Chao's troops withdrew on Pang De's plan, and while Zhong Yao opened the gates to let the soldiers and people gather firewood and water, they came back five days later. His younger brother Zhong Jin, who guarded the west gate, was cut down by Pang De, who appeared inside the city, and Zhong Yao abandoned the city through the east gate and fled to hold Tong Pass. Cao Cao sent Cao Hong and Xu Huang to hold Tong Pass in his place. Romance, Ch. 58 §14–19

In Chapter 68, in the 5th month of the 21st year of Jian'an (216), Emperor Xian, Liu Xie, had Zhong Yao draft the edict establishing Cao Cao as King of Wei, and Cao Cao accepted after feigning refusal three times. In Chapter 69, in the 1st month of the 23rd year of Jian'an (218), after the failed rising of Geng Ji and others, Cao Cao made Zhong Yao Chancellor of State and Hua Xin Imperial Counselor. Romance, Ch. 68 §28Romance, Ch. 69 §25 · 43

In Chapter 91, when Cao Rui took the throne, Zhong Yao became Grand Tutor. In Chapter 94, when Zhuge Liang invaded, the Grand Tutor Zhong Yao said that Cao Zhen was no match for Zhuge Liang, and staking the lives of his entire household, recommended reinstating the General of Agile Cavalry Sima Yi, who had been dismissed because of rumors. When Cao Rui asked where Zhongda was, he answered that he was living at leisure in Wancheng. Romance, Ch. 91 §19Romance, Ch. 94 §25–26

In Chapter 107, Xiahou Ba introduced Zhong Hui, a young talent of Wei, to Jiang Wei as "the son of the Grand Tutor Zhong Yao," and told how, when Zhong Yao brought his two sons to see Emperor Wen, the eight-year-old Zhong Yu sweated in fear, while the seven-year-old Zhong Hui answered, "I tremble with fear, so the sweat dare not come out." Romance, Ch. 107 §35–36

Where the Romance differs

The loss of Chang'an: In Chapter 58 of the Romance, Zhong Yao, as governor of Chang'an, was defeated by Ma Dai within a single bout and lost Chang'an, and his younger brother Zhong Jin was killed by Pang De. In the Records, when Cao Cao sent Zhong Yao to attack Zhang Lu in the 16th year of Jian'an (211), the generals within the passes suspected the move and Ma Chao rebelled, and Ma Chao and the others encamped at Tong Pass. Neither Zhong Yao's biography nor the Annals of Emperor Wu mention Zhong Yao losing Chang'an or his younger brother Zhong Jin being killed. Romance, Ch. 58 §14 · 18Records, Wei 1 §109–110Records, Wei 13 §1–18

Relations with Ma Chao: In the Romance, Zhong Yao meets Ma Chao's side only as an enemy, in Chapter 58. In the Records, Ma Chao, sent earlier by Ma Teng, attacked Guo Yuan and Gao Gan at Pingyang together with Zhong Yao, and Ma Chao's officer Pang De cut off Guo Yuan's head. This battle does not appear in the Romance. Romance, Ch. 58 §14Records, Shu 6 §26Records, Wei 13 §7–8

The investiture as King of Wei: In Chapter 68 of the Romance, Emperor Xian had Zhong Yao draft the edict. The Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records say only that in the 5th month of the 21st year of Jian'an (216) the emperor raised the Duke to King of Wei, without naming who drafted it, and Zhong Yao went from Grand Judge to Chancellor of State in the 8th month of that year. Romance, Ch. 68 §28Records, Wei 1 §154

When he became Chancellor of State: In Chapter 69 of the Romance, Zhong Yao became Chancellor of State after Geng Ji's rising in the 1st month of the 23rd year of Jian'an (218). In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, the Grand Judge Zhong Yao became Chancellor of State in the 8th month of the 21st year of Jian'an (216). Romance, Ch. 69 §25 · 43Records, Wei 1 §154

Dismissal: In the Records, Zhong Yao was dismissed as Chancellor of State in the 9th month of the 24th year of Jian'an (219) for his implication in Wei Feng's plot, and returned as Grand Judge when Cao Pi became king. Neither Wei Feng's plot nor Zhong Yao's dismissal appears in the Romance, and in Chapter 91 he simply becomes Grand Tutor. Records, Wei 1 §169Records, Wei 13 §9Romance, Ch. 91 §19

Recommending Sima Yi: In Chapter 94 of the Romance, Zhong Yao staked the lives of his entire household to recommend reinstating Sima Yi. Zhong Yao's biography in the Records has no such episode; as his effort in the Taihe era it records his memorial calling for the revival of mutilating punishments. Romance, Ch. 94 §25–26Records, Wei 13 §1–18

The two sons: Chapter 107 of the Romance tells of the exchange about sweat between Zhong Yu and Zhong Hui when Zhong Yao brought his two sons to see Emperor Wen. Zhong Yao's biography in the Records says only that his son Zhong Yu succeeded him, and this anecdote is absent. Romance, Ch. 107 §35–36Records, Wei 13 §18

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA6635−31
  • STR3122−9
  • INT7658−18
  • POL8655−31
  • CHA6245−17
  • VIR6255−7
  • ADP6445−19
  • SCH7265−7
  • DIP8260−22
  • DIS4568+23
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

LeadershipR66N35 −31

RLed the armies of several commanderies to strike and behead Guo Yuan as he crossed the Fen, and crushed Wei Gu's risingWei 13 §7

NBadly defeated by Ma Dai, and lost Chang'an by opening the gates, falling for Pang De's ruseCh. 58 §14Ch. 58 §18Ch. 58 §19

PoliticsR86N55Unverified −31

RIncreased the households by resettling people from within the passes and was likened to Xiao He; the assessment calls him capable in handling affairsWei 13 §8Wei 13 §6Wei 13 §99

NNo direct record — estimated from his rise to Chancellor of State and Grand TutorCh. 69 §43Ch. 91 §19

DiscernmentR45UnverifiedN68 +23

RNo direct record — estimated from his command of the generals within the passesWei 13 §8

NJudged Cao Zhen no match for Zhuge Liang and recommended Sima YiCh. 94 §25

DiplomacyR82N60 −22

RPersuaded Li Jue and Guo Si to let Cao Cao's mission through, and had Ma Teng and Han Sui send sons to serve at courtWei 13 §3Wei 13 §5

NPersuaded Cao Rui to reinstate Sima Yi, who had been set asideCh. 94 §25

AdaptabilityR64N45 −19

RHelped the emperor escape Chang'an under Li Jue's rule, and returned as Grand Judge after his dismissalWei 13 §4Wei 13 §9

NAbandoned the city, fled through the east gate, held Tong Pass and sent an urgent reportCh. 58 §18Ch. 58 §19

IntelligenceR76N58 −18

RSeeing that the land within the passes was secretly in touch with the Yuan, prevented a retreat and won by striking Guo Yuan halfway across the riverWei 13 §7Wei 13 §8

NDoubted Ma Chao's retreat yet was deceived, but saw through Zhuge Liang's rumorsCh. 58 §16Ch. 94 §26

CharismaR62N45Unverified −17

RXun Yu praised him repeatedly, and Emperor Wen called him a great man of his ageWei 13 §4Wei 13 §10

NNo direct record — estimated from his treatment as an elder statesmanCh. 94 §25

3 similar abilities — show evidence
  • StrengthR31UnverifiedN22 −9

    RNo direct record — estimated from his leading the generals as a civil officialWei 13 §8

    NClashed with Ma Dai and was badly defeated and fled before a single bout was overCh. 58 §14

  • VirtueR62N55 −7

    RReceived an inscription praising his diligence and reverence day and night, but was dismissed for implication in Wei Feng's plotWei 13 §9

    NPresented poems praising Cao Cao's merit and virtue, and staked his whole household's lives to vouch for Sima YiCh. 56 §18Ch. 94 §25

  • ScholarshipR72N65 −7

    RAn edict called him superior in learning and high in talent; argued for reviving mutilating punishments by citing the classicsWei 13 §15Wei 13 §12

    NComposed and presented poems with the civil officials, and drafted the edict establishing Cao Cao as King of WeiCh. 56 §18Ch. 68 §28

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (7)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wei · Records · Records vol. 13 「太祖領兖州牧,始遣使上書」

Family

SiblingsZhong Jin(鍾進) Romance
ChildrenZhong Hui Novel & History, Zhong Yu Novel & History

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.