Guo Jia 郭嘉

RecordsRomance Wei Courtesy name 奉孝 Fengxiao곽가봉효

Profile
OccupationRStrategist · Libationer of the Army under the Minister of Works NStrategist · Major LibationerFactionWei
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wei
BornR170 UnverifiedNative placeYingchuan Commandery Yangdi County
DiedR207 UnverifiedPlace of death
Cause of deathRIllness NIllness Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR35

Profile

Guo Jia, courtesy name Fengxiao, was a man of Yangdi County in Yingchuan Commandery. He first went north to meet Yuan Shao but left him, saying that Yuan Shao did not understand the essentials of employing men; later, on the recommendation of Xun Yu, he met Cao Cao and became Libationer of the Army under the Minister of Works. Records, Wei 14 §31–32

When Cao Cao attacked Lü Bu, Guo Jia urged him to press the assault; he had him wait for the brothers Yuan Tan and Yuan Shang to quarrel with each other, and he urged the campaign against the Wuhuan of the Three Commanderies. In the 12th year of Jian'an (207), returning from Liucheng after the attack on the Wuhuan, he fell gravely ill and died at the age of thirty-eight. His posthumous title was Marquis Zhen. Records, Wei 14 §33 · 36–38 · 41–42Records, Wei 1 §97 · 101

In his assessment, Chen Shou, the author of the Records, called him, together with Cheng Yu, Dong Zhao, Liu Ye and Jiang Ji, an outstanding scholar of the age in talent and strategy. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 10 as a man whom Cheng Yu recommends to Xun Yu, and he appears in 16 of its 120 chapters; his name is in the title of Chapter 33, 'Guo Jia Leaves a Plan That Settles Liaodong'. Records, Wei 14 §158Romance, Ch. 10 §22Romance, Ch. 33 §40 · 47

In the Records

Guo Jia, courtesy name Fengxiao, was a man of Yangdi County in Yingchuan Commandery. He first went north to meet Yuan Shao, and told Yuan Shao's advisers Xin Ping and Guo Tu that a wise man must be careful in judging his lord. Lord Yuan, he said, merely wished to imitate the Duke of Zhou in humbling himself before scholars, but did not understand the essentials of employing men; his affairs had many threads but few essentials, and he liked to scheme but lacked decision, so it would be hard to settle the great enterprise of a hegemon with him. And so he left. Records, Wei 14 §31

Before this, Xi Zhicai of Yingchuan, whom Cao Cao valued highly, had died young, and Cao Cao wrote to Xun Yu asking who could succeed him; Xun Yu recommended Guo Jia. After discussing the affairs of the realm with Guo Jia, Cao Cao said, 'The one who will enable me to achieve the great enterprise will surely be this man,' and Guo Jia too rejoiced, saying, 'He is truly my lord.' Cao Cao submitted a memorial making him Libationer of the Army under the Minister of Works. Records, Wei 14 §32

When Cao Cao attacked Lü Bu, he won three battles, but Lü Bu withdrew to hold fast, and as the soldiers were exhausted Cao Cao wanted to turn his army back. Guo Jia, together with Xun You, persuaded him that Lü Bu was brave but without strategy, that having lost all three battles his spirit was broken, and that Chen Gong had wisdom but was slow, so a swift attack could bring them down. They then drew the Yi and Si Rivers to flood the city of Xiapi and captured Lü Bu. The Annals of Emperor Wu records that the flooding was done 'using the plans of Xun You and Guo Jia'. Records, Wei 14 §33Records, Wei 10 §57Records, Wei 1 §49

When Cao Cao sent Liu Bei to Xu Province to block Yuan Shu, Guo Jia, together with Cheng Yu, said that if he were lent troops now he would surely harbour other intentions. Cao Cao regretted it and had him pursued, but could not catch him, and Liu Bei killed Che Zhou in Xu Province and turned against Cao Cao. In the 1st month of the 5th year of Jian'an (200), when Cao Cao intended to go east in person to attack Liu Bei, the generals feared that Yuan Shao would strike from behind, but Guo Jia also urged Cao Cao to march, and in the end he defeated Liu Bei. Records, Wei 14 §15–16Records, Wei 1 §56 · 58

After Sun Ce had taken all of Jiangdong, he heard that Cao Cao was in a standoff with Yuan Shao at Guandu and meant to cross the Yangtze and make a surprise attack on Xu, and everyone was afraid. Guo Jia reckoned that those Sun Ce had killed in newly bringing Jiangdong under his control were all heroes able to win other men's loyalty unto death, while Sun Ce was rash and unprepared, and so he would surely die at the hands of a common man. Sun Ce reached the river, and before he could cross he was indeed killed by the retainers of Xu Gong. Records, Wei 14 §34–35

Guo Jia followed Cao Cao in defeating Yuan Shao, and after Yuan Shao died they attacked Yuan Tan and Yuan Shang at Liyang and won several times. When the generals wanted to press the attack while victory was with them, Guo Jia said that Yuan Shao had loved his two sons and had not settled the succession, and that Guo Tu and Feng Ji would set them against each other; pressed hard they would hold together, but left alone a contentious spirit would arise between them. So he proposed heading south as if to attack Liu Biao of Jing Province and waiting for things to change. When the army reached Xiping, Yuan Tan and Yuan Shang did indeed fight over Ji Province, and Yuan Tan sent Xin Pi to ask to surrender. Guo Jia followed Cao Cao in pacifying Ye, attacked Yuan Tan at Nanpi and pacified Ji Province, and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Weiyang Precinct. Records, Wei 14 §36–37

When Cao Cao intended to attack Yuan Shang and the Wuhuan of the Three Commanderies, many of his subordinates feared that Liu Biao would have Liu Bei make a surprise attack on Xu. Guo Jia said that the barbarians, trusting in their remoteness, would not be prepared, so a sudden attack could defeat them, and that if Yuan Shang and his brother were left alone, Qing and Ji Provinces might be lost. He also said that Liu Biao was a man who only sat and talked; if he gave Liu Bei heavy responsibility he would fear being unable to control him, and if he gave him light responsibility Liu Bei would not be willing to serve, so there was nothing to worry about even if they emptied the state to campaign far away. Records, Wei 14 §38–39

When they reached Yi County, Guo Jia said that in war speed is what matters most, and proposed leaving the baggage train behind and sending light troops at double speed to fall on the enemy when they least expected it. Cao Cao secretly went out through the Lulong Pass and headed straight for the Chanyu's court, and beheaded Tadun and the noble kings beneath him. Yuan Shang and his elder brother Yuan Xi fled to Liaodong. Records, Wei 14 §40

Chen Shou wrote that Guo Jia had a deep understanding of principles, was resourceful, and grasped the true state of affairs, and Cao Cao said, 'Only Fengxiao can understand my intentions.' At the age of thirty-eight Guo Jia fell gravely ill while returning from Liucheng, and the messengers Cao Cao sent to ask after him crossed one another on the road. When he died, Cao Cao attended the mourning in person and grieved deeply, telling Xun You and others that they were all of his own generation and only Fengxiao was the youngest, so he had meant to entrust him with what came after once the affairs of the realm were settled, but he had died young in the prime of life. Records, Wei 14 §41

Cao Cao submitted a memorial saying that in the eleven years since the Army Libationer Guo Jia began following him on campaign, at every great deliberation he had faced the enemy and responded to change, and that whenever Cao Cao's own plans were unsettled Guo Jia had always brought them to completion; he asked that 800 households be added to Guo Jia's fief to make 1,000. His posthumous title was Marquis Zhen, and his son Guo Yi succeeded him. Guo Yi became Literary Scholar to the Crown Prince but died young, and his son Guo Shen and grandson Guo Lie inherited the title in turn. Records, Wei 14 §42–43

Earlier, Chen Qun had several times accused Guo Jia at court of not restraining his conduct, but Guo Jia remained unperturbed. Cao Cao valued Guo Jia all the more, but also thought that Chen Qun upheld what was right and liked him as well. Later, returning from the campaign against Jing Province, Cao Cao met with an epidemic at Baqiu and burned his ships, and sighed, 'Had Guo Fengxiao been alive, he would not have let me come to this.' Records, Wei 14 §43

In his assessment, Chen Shou called Cheng Yu, Guo Jia, Dong Zhao, Liu Ye and Jiang Ji outstanding scholars of the age in talent, strategy and planning. He wrote that in upright governance and virtuous conduct their achievements differed from those of Xun You, but in devising plans and weighing affairs they were of his kind. Records, Wei 14 §158

In the Romance

In Chapter 10 of the Romance, Cheng Yu tells Xun Yu that Guo Jia, a man from the same home region, is a worthy scholar of the age and should be invited, and Xun Yu reports this to Cao Cao, who summons Guo Jia to Yan Province to discuss the affairs of the realm with him. Guo Jia in turn recommends Liu Ye, a direct descendant of Emperor Guangwu. In Chapter 14, after Cao Cao has established himself at Xudu, Guo Jia becomes Major Libationer (sima jijiu). Romance, Ch. 10 §22–23Romance, Ch. 14 §34

In Chapter 11, when Cao Cao attacks Xu Province, Guo Jia advises him to answer Liu Bei's letter with kind words to put him off his guard, and when Lü Bu raids Yan Province, he tells Cao Cao to withdraw his troops as if doing Liu Bei a favour. In Chapter 16, when Xun Yu urges that Liu Bei be killed, he objects that if a hero who has come for refuge in his distress is killed, the resourceful scholars of the realm will not come. In Chapter 17, when Cao Cao has trampled a wheat field and is about to cut his own throat, Guo Jia stops him by citing the principle of the Spring and Autumn Annals that 'the law is not applied to the most honoured'. Romance, Ch. 11 §33 · 37Romance, Ch. 16 §38–39Romance, Ch. 17 §37

In Chapter 18, when Cao Cao receives an arrogant letter from Yuan Shao, Guo Jia tells him that Yuan Shao has ten points of defeat and Cao Cao ten points of victory, naming the Way, righteousness, governance, magnanimity, strategy, virtue, benevolence, discernment, civil affairs and martial affairs. In Chapter 19, when Xiapi has not fallen after two months and Xun You has dissuaded Cao Cao from withdrawing, Guo Jia says he has a plan worth more than 200,000 troops, and when Xun Yu asks whether he means breaking open the waters of the Yi and Si Rivers, he laughs and says yes. Romance, Ch. 18 §17–18Romance, Ch. 19 §43–44

In Chapter 21, together with Cheng Yu, he questions the sending of Liu Bei with troops, saying, 'Let an enemy go for one day, and it becomes a trouble for ten thousand generations,' and Cao Cao sends Xu Chu to pursue Liu Bei. In Chapter 24 he says that if Cao Cao attacks Liu Bei in the east he can pacify him in a single battle. In Chapter 29, Sun Ce flies into a rage on hearing from an envoy returned from Xuchang that Guo Jia had called his valour that of a common man and said he would surely die at the hands of a petty man. Romance, Ch. 21 §28–29Romance, Ch. 24 §13Romance, Ch. 29 §9–10

In Chapter 32, when Ji Province has been attacked for many days without falling, he says that if the Yuan brothers are pressed hard they will help each other, but if left alone they will fight each other, so they should head toward Jing Province and wait for things to change. In Chapter 33, when Cao Cao asks him for a plan to attack Yuan Shang, he says to have the Yuan clan's surrendered generals Jiao Chu, Zhang Nan and others attack him, and when Cao Hong and others try to dissuade Cao Cao from the campaign against the Wuhuan, he urges the campaign, saying that Liu Biao is a man who only sits and talks. In the desert, unsuited to the water and climate, he lies ill on a cart, yet still says that in war divine speed is what matters, and advises advancing with light troops but finding guides. Cao Cao leaves Guo Jia at Yizhou to recuperate. Romance, Ch. 32 §15Romance, Ch. 33 §22 · 30–34

When Cao Cao returns from Liucheng to Yizhou, Guo Jia has already been dead for several days and his coffin lies in the government office. Cao Cao weeps bitterly, crying, 'Fengxiao is dead! Heaven is destroying me!' and receives a letter that Guo Jia had sealed before he died. When Gongsun Kang of Liaodong sends the heads of Yuan Xi and Yuan Shang, Cao Cao shows the letter, saying, 'It did not go beyond Fengxiao's reckoning!' The Romance records that he died at thirty-eight and performed many remarkable deeds in the eleven years he followed the campaigns. In Chapter 50, after his defeat at Chibi, Cao Cao beats his breast and weeps bitterly, saying, 'If only Fengxiao were alive.' Romance, Ch. 33 §40 · 46–48Romance, Ch. 50 §33–34

Where the Romance differs

Coming to Cao Cao: In Chapter 10 of the Romance, Cheng Yu recommends Guo Jia to Xun Yu, and Guo Jia is summoned to Yan Province. In the Records, Guo Jia first met Yuan Shao and then left him, and when Xi Zhicai, whom Cao Cao valued, died young, Xun Yu recommended Guo Jia. His leaving Yuan Shao does not appear in the Romance. Romance, Ch. 10 §22Records, Wei 14 §31–32Records, Wei 10 §16

His office: In Chapter 14 of the Romance he becomes Major Libationer. In the Records, Cao Cao submitted a memorial making him Libationer of the Army under the Minister of Works, and Cao Cao's memorial after his death also calls him Army Libationer. Romance, Ch. 14 §34Records, Wei 14 §32 · 42

The recommendation of Liu Ye: In Chapter 10 of the Romance, Guo Jia recommends Liu Ye. In the Biography of Liu Ye in the Records, Liu Ye offered Cao Cao, who had come to Shouchun, a plan for attacking Chen Ce, and Cao Cao, on his return, summoned him as Clerk of the Granary Bureau under the Minister of Works. There is no mention of Guo Jia recommending him. Romance, Ch. 10 §23Records, Wei 14 §91–93

The ten points of victory: The 'ten victories and ten defeats' that Guo Jia speaks of in Chapter 18 of the Romance are not in the main text of the Biography of Guo Jia written by Chen Shou. Romance, Ch. 18 §17–18Records, Wei 14 §30–43

The proposal to kill Liu Bei: In Chapter 16 of the Romance, Xun Yu urges that Liu Bei be killed and Guo Jia objects. In the Biography of Cheng Yu in the Records, it was Cheng Yu who urged that Liu Bei be killed, and Cao Cao did not listen; this debate does not appear in the Biography of Guo Jia. Romance, Ch. 16 §38–39Records, Wei 14 §15 · 30–43

The waters of Xiapi: In Chapter 19 of the Romance, after Xun You dissuades Cao Cao from withdrawing and urges a swift attack, Guo Jia puts forward a separate plan, and Xun Yu realises that he means breaking open the waters. In the Biography of Xun You in the Records, Xun You and Guo Jia together urged a swift attack and then drew the Yi and Si Rivers to flood the city, and the Annals of Emperor Wu calls it 'the plan of Xun You and Guo Jia'. Xun Yu does not appear in this passage. Romance, Ch. 19 §43–44Records, Wei 10 §57Records, Wei 1 §49

Reading Sun Ce: In the Records, when Sun Ce meant to make a surprise attack on Xu and everyone was afraid, Guo Jia reckoned that he would die at the hands of a common man, and Sun Ce was killed by the retainers of Xu Gong before he could cross the river. In Chapter 29 of the Romance, Sun Ce, already wounded by the retainers of Xu Gong, hears Guo Jia's words from an envoy and flies into a rage. Romance, Ch. 29 §4–6 · 9–10Records, Wei 14 §34–35

Leaving the Yuan brothers alone: In Chapter 32 of the Romance he says this after Ji Province has been attacked for many days without falling. In the Records he said it when, after successive victories at Liyang, the generals wanted to press the attack while victory was with them. Romance, Ch. 32 §14–15Records, Wei 14 §36

Illness and death: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, he falls ill in the desert and gives his advice lying on a cart, then stays behind at Yizhou to recuperate and dies before Cao Cao returns. In the Records, he advised leaving the baggage train behind when they reached Yi County, fell gravely ill while returning from Liucheng, and Cao Cao attended his mourning in person. Romance, Ch. 33 §32–34 · 40Records, Wei 14 §40–41

The heads from Liaodong: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, Gongsun Kang sends the heads of Yuan Xi and Yuan Shang just as the letter Guo Jia left before he died said he would. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, Cao Cao himself says that he will have Gongsun Kang behead them and send their heads, explaining that if pressed they would join forces but if left alone they would scheme against each other. The Biography of Guo Jia has no letter left behind. Romance, Ch. 33 §47Records, Wei 1 §101–102Records, Wei 14 §30–43

Cao Cao's lament: In Chapter 50 of the Romance, Cao Cao, defeated at Chibi, calls out Guo Jia's name and weeps bitterly at a banquet in Nan Commandery. In the Records, returning from the campaign against Jing Province, he met with an epidemic at Baqiu, burned his ships, and sighed, 'Had Guo Fengxiao been alive.' Romance, Ch. 50 §33–34Records, Wei 14 §43

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA4038−2
  • STR3130−1
  • INT9594−1
  • POL4042+2
  • CHA5558+3
  • VIR3855+17
  • ADP8558−27
  • SCH4062+22
  • DIP6062+2
  • DIS7082+12
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

AdaptabilityR85N58Unverified −27

RSaw Yuan Shao's limits, left him and chose Taizu, and stayed unperturbed under accusationWei 14 §31Wei 14 §43

NNo direct record — estimated from his putting forward plans for the expedition even while illCh. 33 §32

ScholarshipR40UnverifiedN62 +22

RNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as an adviser with a deep understanding of principlesWei 14 §41

NA poem says he held the classics and histories within him, and he was said to be fit for reciting compositionsCh. 33 §49Ch. 23 §13

VirtueR38N55Unverified +17

RChen Qun accused him several times of not restraining his conductWei 14 §43

NNo direct record — estimated from the record of his merits in following the campaignsCh. 33 §48

6 similar abilities — show evidence
  • LeadershipR40UnverifiedN38Unverified −2

    RNo direct record — estimated from the record of his following the campaigns for eleven yearsWei 14 §42

    NNo direct record — estimated from the record of his following the campaigns for eleven yearsCh. 33 §48

  • StrengthR31UnverifiedN30Unverified −1

    RNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as an adviserWei 14 §41

    NNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as an adviserCh. 33 §32

  • IntelligenceR95N94 −1

    RForesaw the Yuan clan's infighting and the Wuhuan expedition, and Taizu said his merit in planning was the highestWei 14 §36Wei 14 §42Wei 14 §158

    NWith the ten victories and ten defeats and his last letter, foresaw that Gongsun Kang would send the Yuan headsCh. 18 §18Ch. 33 §47Ch. 33 §49

  • PoliticsR40UnverifiedN42 +2

    RNo direct record — estimated from his career as Libationer of the Army under the Minister of WorksWei 14 §32

    NReturned after inspecting money and grain together with Cheng YuCh. 21 §28

  • CharismaR55N58 +3

    RWhen he fell gravely ill, the messengers Taizu sent to ask after him crossed one another on the roadWei 14 §41

    NCao Cao wept bitterly at his death, and wept for him again after the defeat at ChibiCh. 33 §40Ch. 50 §34

  • DiplomacyR60N62 +2

    RPersuaded the weary Taizu to press the attack on Lü Bu and capture himWei 14 §33Wei 14 §37

    NPersuaded Cao Cao not to send Liu Bei awayCh. 21 §29Ch. 24 §29

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (16)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wei · Records · Records vol. 14 「軍祭酒郭嘉,自從征伐,十有一年」

Related events (5)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).

Related works (1)

Linked via Wikidata "depicts" and character names in titles (unverified) — not yet reviewed.