Battle
Cao Pi's invasions of Eastern Wu 曹丕伐吳
About this event
Cao Pi's invasions of Eastern Wu were the campaigns in which Cao Pi, Emperor Wen of Wei, attacked Sun Quan from the 3rd year of Huangchu (222) to the 6th (225). When Sun Quan did not send his son as a hostage, in the autumn of the 3rd year of Huangchu Cao Pi sent Cao Xiu, Zhang Liao and Zang Ba to Dongkou, Cao Ren to Ruxu, and Cao Zhen, Xiahou Shang, Zhang He and Xu Huang to Nan Commandery. At Dongkou the wind scattered the Wu army's boats, but Jiangling held out for six months, and when Cao Ren's army was defeated at Ruxu in the 3rd month of the following year, the Wei armies all withdrew. In the 5th and 6th years of Huangchu Cao Pi advanced in person as far as Guangling, but went back without crossing the river. Records, Wu 2 §42 · 47 · 49Records, Wu 11 §17Records, Wei 2 §46 · 50
Chen Shou recorded these campaigns in the Annals of Emperor Wen (Records of Wei 2) and the Biography of the Lord of Wu (Records of Wu 2), and also included them in scattered places such as Records of Wei 9, 14 and 17 and Records of Wu 10 and 11. The Romance has Cao Pi send out troops along three routes at the end of Chapter 84, all three routes are defeated in Chapter 85, and Chapter 86, "Defeating Cao Pi, Xu Sheng Uses a Fire Attack," depicts the fighting at Guangling. Records, Wei 2 §41–50Records, Wu 2 §42–51Records, Wei 9 §57 · 94–95Records, Wei 14 §121–123Records, Wu 10 §85–86Records, Wu 11 §16–18 · 49–52Romance, Ch. 84 §11–12Romance, Ch. 85 §6–14Romance, Ch. 86 §26–46
Course of events in the Records
Sun Quan outwardly served Wei but not sincerely. When Wei sent the Palace Attendant Xin Pi and the Master of Writing Huan Jie to swear a covenant and demand a hostage, Sun Quan politely declined. The Annals of Emperor Wen record that in the 10th month of the 3rd year of Huangchu (222), when Sun Quan rebelled again, Cao Pi set out on a southern campaign from Xuchang with the various armies advancing together, while Sun Quan held the river and defended it. In the 11th month Cao Pi went to Wan. Records, Wu 2 §42Records, Wei 2 §41
According to the Biography of the Lord of Wu, in the 9th month Wei sent Cao Xiu, Zhang Liao and Zang Ba out to Dongkou and Cao Ren to Ruxu, and had Cao Zhen, Xiahou Shang, Zhang He and Xu Huang besiege Nan Commandery. Sun Quan had Lü Fan and others lead five armies to oppose Cao Xiu and the others with a fleet, sent Zhuge Jin, Pan Zhang and Yang Can to relieve Nan Commandery, and had Zhu Huan, Area Commander of Ruxu, oppose Cao Ren. When Sun Quan sent a humble letter, Cao Pi replied that if he sent his son Sun Deng, he would recall his troops that very evening, but Sun Quan changed the era name and held the river. Records, Wu 2 §42–47
At Dongkou a great wind blew in the 11th month and several thousand of Lü Fan's soldiers drowned, and Cao Xiu had Zang Ba raid Xuling with 500 light boats and 10,000 men ready to die. The biographies of Cao Xiu and Zang Ba record that they defeated Lü Fan and the others at Dongpu. At Nan Commandery Xiahou Shang crossed downstream at night in oiled boats and defeated Zhuge Jin's army, but Zhu Ran, defending Jiangling, held out for six months, and when a great epidemic happened to break out, Xiahou Shang withdrew his army by imperial order. Records, Wu 2 §47Records, Wei 9 §57 · 94–95Records, Wei 18 §29Records, Wu 11 §16–18
In the 3rd month of the 2nd year of Huangwu (223), Cao Ren had General Chang Diao attack the Middle Isle of Ruxu in oiled boats and had his son Cao Tai attack Zhu Huan, but the Wu army defeated Chang Diao and the others, and that month the Wei armies all withdrew. Jiang Ji had warned that going onto the sandbar was walking into a hell of one's own making, but Cao Ren did not listen and was defeated. In the 3rd month Cao Pi returned from Wan to Luoyang, and that month a great epidemic broke out. Records, Wu 2 §49Records, Wu 11 §51–52Records, Wei 14 §121Records, Wei 2 §42
In the 8th month of the 5th year of Huangchu (224), Cao Pi formed a navy and, riding the dragon boat in person, went along the Cai and Ying rivers out onto the Huai to Shouchun, and in the 9th month he reached Guangling. The Biography of the Lord of Wu says that Cao Pi gazed at the great river and went back, saying that there were men over there and Wu could not be taken; the Biography of Xu Sheng records that he withdrew because he was startled by the ramparts and false watchtowers stretching several hundred li that Xu Sheng had built from Jianye, and because the river was in high flood. Records, Wei 2 §46Records, Wu 2 §51Records, Wu 10 §86
In the 6th year of Huangchu (225), when Cao Pi meant to attack Wu again, Xin Pi said they should nourish the people for ten years before using them, and Bao Xun remonstrated that in a former year the dragon boat had drifted onto the southern bank, putting the emperor in danger. In the 10th month of winter Cao Pi reached the old city of Guangling and displayed his forces by the river with more than 100,000 soldiers and banners stretching several hundred li, but that year a great cold froze the waterways and the boats could not enter the river, so he went back. The biography of Jiang Ji, without giving the year, records that during the progress to Guangling several thousand warships were held up in the waterways, and when the water dried up at Jinghu on the way back, Jiang Ji dug channels and brought them out into the Huai. Records, Wei 25 §13–15Records, Wei 12 §72–73Records, Wei 2 §50Records, Wei 14 §122–123
In the Romance
In Chapter 84 of the Romance, Cao Pi, seeing that Liu Bei has strung his camps along 700 li, predicts that he will be defeated by Lu Xun, and says that when the Wu army has gone deep into Xichuan and the country is left empty, he will take Wu by attacking along three routes on the pretext of helping in the fight. Cao Ren goes out to Ruxu, Cao Xiu to Dongkou and Cao Zhen to Nan Commandery, and Lu Xun, anticipating this, sends troops ahead to block them. Romance, Ch. 84 §10–12 · 48–49
In Chapter 85 Cao Pi ignores the protests of Jia Xu and Liu Ye and sets out in person. At Ruxu Zhu Huan lays down his flags to make the city look empty and then beheads the vanguard Chang Diao; Cao Zhen and Xiahou Shang, besieging Nan Commandery, are defeated by a pincer attack from inside and outside by Lu Xun and Zhuge Jin; and Cao Xiu is defeated by Lü Fan. When a great epidemic in the summer kills six or seven in ten of his soldiers, Cao Pi returns to Luoyang. Romance, Ch. 85 §6–14
In Chapter 86, when Wu and Shu join hands again, Cao Pi overrides Xin Pi's objection and in the 8th month of autumn of the 5th year of Huangchu reaches Guangling with ten dragon boats and more than 300,000 troops on land and water. Xu Sheng startles Cao Pi by putting up false walls stretching several hundred li south of the river, and when a fierce wind threatens to capsize the dragon boat, Wen Pin carries Cao Pi out on his back. When Cao Pi turns his army back at the news that Zhao Yun has come out of Yangping Pass, Sun Shao (孫韶) and Ding Feng pursue him and set fires, and Zhang Liao, hit by Ding Feng's arrow, returns to Xuchang and dies. Romance, Ch. 86 §26–29 · 38–46
Where the Romance differs
What prompted the invasion: In Chapter 84 of the Romance, Cao Pi aims for the moment when the Wu army has gone to Xichuan and the country is empty. In the Biography of the Lord of Wu in the Records, Wei sent out troops when Sun Quan did not accept the covenant and the demand for a hostage, and Cao Pi said he would recall his troops if Sun Deng were sent. Romance, Ch. 84 §11–12Records, Wu 2 §42 · 46
Victory and defeat at Dongkou: In Chapter 85 of the Romance, Cao Xiu is defeated by Lü Fan. In the Records, the biographies of Cao Xiu, Zang Ba and Jia Kui say that they defeated Lü Fan at Dongpu, and the Biography of the Lord of Wu records that several thousand of Lü Fan's soldiers drowned in a great wind. Romance, Ch. 85 §14Records, Wei 9 §57Records, Wei 18 §29Records, Wei 15 §78Records, Wu 2 §47
The fighting at Nan Commandery: In Chapter 85 of the Romance, Cao Zhen and Xiahou Shang are defeated by a pincer attack from inside and outside by Lu Xun and Zhuge Jin. In the Biography of Xiahou Shang in the Records, Xiahou Shang defeated Zhuge Jin's army, the man who held the city was Zhu Ran, and the Wei army withdrew because of a great epidemic. Romance, Ch. 85 §13Records, Wei 9 §94–95Records, Wu 11 §16–18
Zhang Liao's death: In Chapter 86 of the Romance, Zhang Liao is hit by Ding Feng's arrow at Guangling and dies at Xuchang. In the Biography of Zhang Liao in the Records, Zhang Liao went with Cao Xiu to Hailing, and in the year they defeated Lü Fan his illness grew grave and he died at Jiangdu. Romance, Ch. 86 §45–46Records, Wei 17 §17
Why he withdrew from Guangling: In Chapter 86 of the Romance, Cao Pi turns his army back at the news that Zhao Yun has come out of Yangping Pass. In the Records, in the 5th year of Huangchu he withdrew because of Xu Sheng's ramparts and the swollen river (Biography of Xu Sheng), and in the 6th year he went back because a great cold froze the waterways (Annals of Emperor Wen). Romance, Ch. 86 §43Records, Wu 10 §86Records, Wei 2 §50
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Belligerents
| Item | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| Factions | Wei | Wu |
| Commanders | Cao Pi, Cao Ren, Cao Xiu, Cao Zhen, Xiahou Shang, Zang Ba, Zhang Liao, Xu Huang, Zhang He | Lü Fan, Sun Quan, Sun Shao(孫韶), Zhu Huan, Zhu Ran, Zhuge Jin, Xu Sheng, Quan Cong, Pan Zhang |
Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wu 2 §49
Sub-events and Romance scenes (4)
- Battle of Ruxu 222~223
- Battle of Dongkou 222
- Battle of Jiangling 222~223
- Incident at Guangling 224~225