RArrogant, he sent unsigned letters seeking favors and was delighted to receive treasuresWei 12 §80Wei 14 §89
NNo direct record — estimated from a single-line mentionCh. 29 §1
| Occupation | RGeneral · General Who Subdues Barbarians | Faction | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | |
| Cause of death | RExecuted Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R24 |
Liu Xun was a former subordinate of Yuan Shu, who made him Administrator of Lujiang after Sun Ce took Lujiang from its Administrator Lu Kang. He has no biography of his own in the Records and appears in the biographies of Sun Ce, Liu Ye, Sima Zhi and others. After Yuan Shu's death he intercepted and captured Yuan Shu's followers on the road, and for a time his army was the strongest between the Yangtze and the Huai. Records, Wu 1 §27 · 34Records, Wei 14 §88
In the 4th year of Jian'an (199), at Sun Ce's urging, he set out to attack the clan communities of Shangliao, and while he was away Sun Ce took Lujiang by surprise; having lost all his followers, he took refuge with Lord Cao together with several hundred of his own men and was enfeoffed as a full marquis. He later became General Who Subdues Barbarians but was executed on a charge of plotting rebellion. Records, Wu 1 §34Records, Wu 2 §3Records, Wei 1 §57Records, Wei 12 §80–81
In the Romance he appears only in a single line at the beginning of Chapter 29, which says that in the 4th year of Jian'an Sun Ce took Lujiang by surprise and defeated Liu Xun; he appears in this one chapter of the 120, and his name is in no chapter title. Romance, Ch. 29 §1
Yuan Shu first said he would make Sun Ce Administrator of Jiujiang but appointed Chen Ji instead. Later, when he sent Sun Ce to attack Lu Kang, Administrator of Lujiang, he said, 'If you now take Lu Kang, Lujiang will truly be yours,' but when Sun Ce attacked Lu Kang and took the city, he again made his former subordinate Liu Xun the administrator. Sun Ce was all the more disappointed. Records, Wu 1 §26–27
When Yuan Shu died, his Chief Clerk Yang Hong, his commander Zhang Xun and others meant to lead his followers to Sun Ce, but Liu Xun, Administrator of Lujiang, attacked them on the road, captured them all, and took their treasures back with him. According to the Biography of Yuan Shu, Yuan Shu's wife and children also took refuge with his former subordinate Liu Xun. Records, Wu 1 §34Records, Wei 6 §80
Liu Ye, who had killed Zheng Bao, a strongman of Yang Province, and taken over his retainers, saw the Han imperial house growing weaker, and since he was a collateral member of the imperial house he did not wish to command troops, so he handed the retainers over to Liu Xun, Administrator of Lujiang. When Liu Xun wondered at his reason, Liu Ye replied that those men had always lived by plunder, and that if he, who had no wealth, tried to bring them into order, they would bear resentment and it could not last long, so he was handing them over. At this time Liu Xun's army was the strongest between the Yangtze and the Huai. Records, Wei 14 §86–88
Sun Ce, who hated Liu Xun, made a false pact of friendship with him and sent an envoy with humble words and rich gifts to persuade him by letter. He wrote that the clan communities (zongmin) of Shangliao had repeatedly slighted his own state and that he wished to borrow the strength of the great state to attack them, adding that Shangliao was very rich and that taking it would enrich the state. At this time more than ten thousand households of the clan communities of Shangliao in Yuzhang were in Jiangdong. Liu Xun believed him, and was delighted to receive pearls and treasures and fine ge and Yue cloth from Sun Ce. Records, Wei 14 §88–89Records, Wu 1 §34
Everyone within and without congratulated him, but Liu Ye alone did not. Liu Ye warned him that although Shangliao was small its walls were strong and its moats deep, so it could not be taken within ten days, and that if Sun Ce struck while the troops were worn out abroad and the state left empty at home, Liu Xun would be defeated by the enemy if he advanced and have nowhere to return to if he withdrew. Liu Xun did not listen. Records, Wei 14 §89–90
In the 4th year of Jian'an (199), when Liu Xun set out to attack Shangliao, Sun Ce raced day and night with a lightly armed force, took Lujiang by surprise and captured it. Liu Xun's followers all surrendered, and Liu Xun alone, with several hundred of his own men, took refuge with Lord Cao. The Biography of the Lord of Wu records that this year Sun Quan followed Sun Ce in attacking Liu Xun, Administrator of Lujiang. The biography of Zhou Yu records that Liu Xun was defeated near Xunyang, and the biography of Dong Xi that he was attacked at Xunyang. Yuan Shu's wife and children, when Sun Ce defeated Liu Xun, were taken in again and cared for. Records, Wu 1 §34Records, Wei 14 §90Records, Wu 2 §3Records, Wu 9 §6Records, Wu 10 §46Records, Wei 6 §80
The Annals of Emperor Wu record that when Liu Xun, Administrator of Lujiang, came to surrender with his followers, Lord Cao enfeoffed him as a full marquis. Records, Wei 1 §57
Liu Xun, who later became General Who Subdues Barbarians, was honored and favored, and arrogant and overbearing. When Sima Zhi was Prefect of Guangping, Liu Xun had once been his commandery general, and Liu Xun's retainers and the young men of his family repeatedly broke the law within the county. Liu Xun sent him letters without signing his name, making many requests, but Sima Zhi did not answer them and dealt with everything according to the law. Later, when Liu Xun was executed on a charge of plotting rebellion, all who had dealings with him were punished, and Sima Zhi was praised for this. The Records do not give the year of his execution. Records, Wei 12 §80–81
In the Romance, Liu Xun appears once, at the beginning of Chapter 29. It says that Sun Ce, having become master of Jiangdong with crack troops and ample provisions, took Lujiang by surprise in the 4th year of Jian'an and defeated Liu Xun, and then had Yu Fan carry a proclamation to Yuzhang, whereupon Hua Xin, Administrator of Yuzhang, surrendered. As Sun Ce's fame and power rose greatly as a result, Cao Cao sighs, 'It is hard to contend with a lion cub.' The Romance does not say whose subordinate Liu Xun was or what became of him afterward. Romance, Ch. 29 §1
How Lujiang was lost: Chapter 29 of the Romance says only that Sun Ce took Lujiang by surprise and defeated Liu Xun. In the Records, Sun Ce made a false pact with him and urged him to attack the clan communities of Shangliao, and took Lujiang by surprise while Liu Xun was away at Shangliao. The biography of Zhou Yu gives the place where Liu Xun was defeated as near Xunyang. Romance, Ch. 29 §1Records, Wu 1 §34Records, Wei 14 §88–90Records, Wu 9 §6
Liu Ye's warning: Liu Ye does not appear in Chapter 29 of the Romance. In the Biography of Liu Ye in the Records, Liu Ye handed Zheng Bao's retainers over to Liu Xun and warned him that if he attacked Shangliao, Sun Ce would strike him from behind, but Liu Xun did not listen. Romance, Ch. 29 §1Records, Wei 14 §87–90
Relations with Yuan Shu: The Romance does not mention that Liu Xun was a former subordinate of Yuan Shu, or that he captured Yuan Shu's followers after Yuan Shu's death. In the Records, Yuan Shu made him Administrator of Lujiang, and when Yuan Shu died Liu Xun captured the followers of Yang Hong, Zhang Xun and others, and Yuan Shu's wife and children also took refuge with him. Romance, Ch. 29 §1Records, Wu 1 §27 · 34Records, Wei 6 §80
Afterward: The Romance does not say what became of Liu Xun after his defeat. In the Records, he took refuge with Lord Cao together with several hundred of his own men and became a full marquis, rose to General Who Subdues Barbarians, and was executed on a charge of plotting rebellion. Romance, Ch. 29 §1Records, Wu 1 §34Records, Wei 1 §57Records, Wei 12 §80–81
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RArrogant, he sent unsigned letters seeking favors and was delighted to receive treasuresWei 12 §80Wei 14 §89
NNo direct record — estimated from a single-line mentionCh. 29 §1
RRejected Liu Ye's warning, fell for Sun Ce's lure, attacked Shangliao and lost LujiangWei 14 §89Wu 1 §34
NNo direct record — estimated from the record of his collapse under a surprise attackCh. 29 §1
RHis army was the strongest between the Yangtze and the Huai; intercepted and captured Yuan Shu's former followers on the roadWei 14 §88Wu 1 §34
NNo direct record — estimated from the record of Sun Ce's surprise attack on LujiangCh. 29 §1
RSurrendered to Cao Cao and became a full marquis, but was executed for plotting rebellionWei 1 §57Wei 12 §81
NNo direct record — estimated from a single-line mentionCh. 29 §1
RNo direct record — estimated from his career as General Who Subdues BarbariansWei 12 §80
NNo direct record — estimated from a single-line mentionCh. 29 §1
RNo direct record — estimated from the record of his receiving Sun Ce's envoyWei 14 §88
NNo direct record — estimated from a single-line mentionCh. 29 §1
RReceived Liu Ye's retainers but did not use his counselWei 14 §87
NNo direct record — estimated from a single-line mentionCh. 29 §1
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).