Battle
Battle of Que 曲阿之戰
About this event
The Battle of Que was the fighting in Sun Ce's conquests in Jiangdong in which Sun Ce, who had become Colonel Who Breaks Assaults on Yuan Shu's memorial, crossed the Yangtze and drove out Liu Yao, the Inspector of Yang Province, who had made Qu'e his seat. Sun Ce defeated Liu Yao's commanders Zhang Ying, Fan Neng and others at Hengjiang and Dangli, crossed the river and attacked Ze Rong and Xue Li at Moling, then took Hushu and Jiangcheng and entered Qu'e. Liu Yao abandoned his army and fled, and Sun Ce's following had already reached several tens of thousands. Records, Wu 1 §28–30Records, Wu 9 §3
Chen Shou's text does not give the year of this battle. The Annals of Emperor Wu, Records of Wei 1, records under the 4th year of Chuping (193), "in this year," that Sun Ce crossed the Yangtze on Yuan Shu's orders and within a few years came to hold Jiangdong, while the Biography of Sun Ce, Records of Wu 1, places it after Sun Ce joined Yuan Shu in the 1st year of Xingping (194). Chen Shou distributed this battle among the Biography of Sun Ce, the Biographies of Liu Yao, Taishi Ci and Shi Xie in Records of Wu 4, which contain the biographies of Liu Yao and Taishi Ci, the biography of Zhou Yu in Records of Wu 9, the biography of Cheng Pu in Records of Wu 10, and others. The Romance depicts this battle in Chapter 15, "Taishi Ci Fights the Little Conqueror to His Heart's Content; Sun Bofu Fights a Great Battle with Yan Baihu." Records, Wei 1 §27Records, Wu 1 §25–30Records, Wu 4 §4–5 · 27–28Records, Wu 9 §3Records, Wu 10 §3Romance, Ch. 15 §20–42
Course of events in the Records
Liu Yao became Inspector of Yang Province by imperial edict, but because Yuan Shu was in Huainan he was afraid and did not dare go to the province, and Wu Jing and Sun Ben welcomed him and settled him at Qu'e. The biography of Sun Ce records that the provincial seat, Shouchun, was already held by Yuan Shu, so Liu Yao crossed the Yangtze and made Qu'e his seat. Liu Yao pressed and drove out Wu Jing and Sun Ben, who had been appointed by Yuan Shu, and stationed Fan Neng, Zhang Ying and others along the Yangtze to resist Yuan Shu. Yuan Shu set up his former subordinate Hui Qu as Inspector of Yang Province and had Wu Jing and Sun Ben attack Zhang Ying and the others, but they could not win for more than a year, and the court added the posts of Governor and General Who Invigorates Martial Might for Liu Yao, whose following numbered several tens of thousands. Records, Wu 4 §4–5Records, Wu 1 §28
Sun Ce, disappointed in Yuan Shu, asked to help Wu Jing and the others pacify Jiangdong. Yuan Shu memorialized to make him Colonel Who Breaks Assaults and acting General Who Exterminates Bandits; he had barely a thousand soldiers and a few dozen horsemen, and several hundred retainers who wished to follow him. By the time he reached Liyang his following had grown to five or six thousand, and Zhou Yu also came with troops to meet Sun Ce. According to the Biographies of Consorts, when Xu Kun, short of boats, wanted to halt the army, his mother told him to cut reeds and make rafts to cross; Sun Ce followed this, and his whole force crossed the river. Records, Wu 1 §27 · 29Records, Wu 9 §3Records, Wu 5 §11–12
Sun Ce attacked Hengjiang and Dangli, took them both and defeated Zhang Ying and the others. He then crossed the river, attacked Moling and defeated Ze Rong and Xue Li, turned to take Hushu and Jiangcheng, and advanced into Qu'e. The biography of Cheng Pu records that Cheng Pu earned merit in the taking of Moling, Hushu, Jurong and Qu'e alike, and the biography of Wu Jing records that when Sun Ce was wounded at Niuzhu the bandits who had surrendered rebelled again, but Wu Jing captured every one of them. Records, Wu 9 §3Records, Wu 10 §3Records, Wu 5 §4
Taishi Ci, a man of the same commandery as Liu Yao, had returned from Liaodong and come to Qu'e to see Liu Yao, and before he left he met Sun Ce. When someone urged Liu Yao to make Taishi Ci his Grand General, Liu Yao said that Xu Zijiang would laugh at him, and had him merely scout the enemy's strength. Taishi Ci was riding with a single horseman when he ran into Sun Ce leading thirteen riders and fought him; Sun Ce stabbed Taishi Ci's horse and snatched his hand halberd, and Taishi Ci seized Sun Ce's helmet. Records, Wu 4 §27–28
Liu Yao fled to Dantu, then went up the Yangtze to hold Yuzhang in the south and stationed himself at Pengze. The biography of Sun Ce records that when Liu Yao abandoned his army and fled, the administrators of the various commanderies also abandoned their cities and ran away, and that because Sun Ce's military orders were strict the people turned to him. Sun Ce pacified Moling and Qu'e, took in the remaining followers of Ze Rong and Liu Yao, and gave Lü Fan an additional 2,000 soldiers and 50 cavalry horses; when his following reached several tens of thousands, he told Zhou Yu that with this force it was enough to take Wu Commandery and Kuaiji and pacify the Shanyue, and sent him back to guard Danyang. Records, Wu 4 §5Records, Wu 1 §29–30Records, Wu 11 §34Records, Wu 9 §3–4
Chen Shou assessed Liu Yao as a man who cultivated his reputation and conduct and loved to judge the good and bad in people, but said that holding a territory of ten thousand li in a time of turmoil was not his strength. Records, Wu 4 §51
In the Romance
In Chapter 15 of the Romance, Sun Ce, who has been relying on Yuan Shu, consults Zhu Zhi and Lü Fan, pledges the Imperial Seal his father left him as security, and borrows 3,000 troops and 500 horses on the pretext of rescuing his maternal uncle Wu Jing. At Liyang Zhou Yu joins him, and Sun Ce invites Zhang Zhao and Zhang Hong to discuss attacking Liu Yao. Romance, Ch. 15 §11–19
Liu Yao's commander Zhang Ying is fighting Huang Gai at Niuzhu when he collapses and flees because of a fire that Jiang Qin and Zhou Tai have set behind his camp, and Sun Ce confronts Liu Yao at Shenting Ridge. The day after Sun Ce, who has gone to the shrine of Emperor Guangwu on the ridge, fights Taishi Ci, Liu Yao withdraws his troops on hearing that Zhou Yu has made a surprise attack on Qu'e and that Chen Wu has opened the city to welcome him, and that night he is heavily defeated by Sun Ce's surprise attack. Romance, Ch. 15 §20–36
With Chen Wu as his vanguard, Sun Ce is attacking Xue Li at Moling when he hears that Liu Yao and Ze Rong are attacking Niuzhu; he turns back, crushes one of Liu Yao's commanders to death under his arm, and with a single shout makes Fan Neng fall from his horse and die. From then on people call Sun Ce the Little Conqueror, and Liu Yao and Ze Rong flee to Yuzhang to seek refuge with Liu Biao. At Moling Sun Ce is hit in the left leg by an arrow, spreads a rumor that he has died to lure Xue Li out, and Xue Li dies in the confused fighting. Romance, Ch. 15 §37–42
Having captured and taken in Taishi Ci at Jing County, Sun Ce forbids his soldiers to plunder, so the people of Jiangdong welcome him and call him Sun Lang; he lets those of Liu Yao's former soldiers who wish to follow him do so, and rewards the rest and sends them back to farming. Romance, Ch. 15 §43–48
Where the Romance differs
How the troops were obtained: In Chapter 15 of the Romance, Sun Ce pledges the Imperial Seal as security and borrows 3,000 troops and 500 horses from Yuan Shu. In the biography of Sun Ce in the Records, Sun Ce asked to help Wu Jing and the others pacify Jiangdong and became Colonel Who Breaks Assaults; he set out with about a thousand soldiers and a few dozen horsemen, and by the time he reached Liyang he had five or six thousand. Romance, Ch. 15 §13–15Records, Wu 1 §29
Liu Yao's position: In Chapter 15 of the Romance, Liu Yao was at Shouchun as Inspector of Yang Province and came to Qu'e after being driven out by Yuan Shu. In the biography of Liu Yao in the Records, he was afraid of Yuan Shu and could not go to the province, and Wu Jing and Sun Ben welcomed him and settled him at Qu'e, while the biography of Sun Ce records that Shouchun was already held by Yuan Shu. Romance, Ch. 15 §20Records, Wu 4 §4Records, Wu 1 §28
How Qu'e was won: In Chapter 15 of the Romance, when Zhou Yu makes a surprise attack on Qu'e, Chen Wu opens the city to welcome him. In the biography of Zhou Yu in the Records, Zhou Yu met Sun Ce at Liyang and entered Qu'e with him by way of Hengjiang, Dangli, Moling, Hushu and Jiangcheng, and the biography of Chen Wu records that Chen Wu went to call on Sun Ce when Sun Ce was at Shouchun and crossed the river with him. Romance, Ch. 15 §35Records, Wu 9 §3Records, Wu 10 §34
Jiang Qin and Zhou Tai: In Chapter 15 of the Romance, the two have been plundering on the Yangtze, set fire to Zhang Ying's camp at Niuzhu and come over to Sun Ce. In the Records, Jiang Qin followed and served Sun Ce from the time Sun Ce made his surprise attack on Yuan Shu, and Zhou Tai attended Sun Ce at his side together with Jiang Qin. Romance, Ch. 15 §23Records, Wu 10 §21 · 27
Xue Li and Ze Rong: In Chapter 15 of the Romance, Xue Li falls into Sun Ce's ambush and dies in the confused fighting, and Ze Rong flees to Yuzhang with Liu Yao. In the biography of Ze Rong in the Records, Xue Li was killed by Ze Rong, and Ze Rong killed the Administrator of Yuzhang, Zhu Hao, was then defeated by Liu Yao, fled into the mountains and was killed by the local people. Romance, Ch. 15 §40–42Records, Wu 4 §6 · 9
Sun Ce's wound: In Chapter 15 of the Romance, Sun Ce is hit in the left leg by an arrow below the walls of Moling. The biography of Wu Jing in the Records records that Sun Ce was wounded at Niuzhu. Romance, Ch. 15 §40Records, Wu 5 §4
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Belligerents
| Item | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| Factions | Sun Ce faction | Liu Yao faction |
| Commanders | Sun Ce, Zhou Yu, Cheng Pu, Wu Jing, Sun Ben | Liu Yao(劉繇), Taishi Ci, Ze Rong, Zhang Ying, Fan Neng, Xue Li |
| Strength | 比至歷陽,衆五六千 | 漢命加繇為牧,振武將軍,眾數萬人 |
Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wu 9 §3
Sub-events and Romance scenes (1)
- Taishi Ci Duels the Little Conqueror Romance ch. 15