Shen Pei 審配

RecordsRomance Courtesy name 正南 Zhengnan심배정남审配

Profile
OccupationRGeneral NStrategistFaction
AppearsRNBiography in
BornR? UnverifiedNative placeWei Commandery
DiedR204 UnverifiedPlace of deathRNYe County
Cause of deathRExecuted NExecuted Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR23

Profile

Shen Pei was a retainer of Yuan Shao. He has no biography of his own in the Records and appears in the Biography of Yuan Shao, the Annals of Emperor Wu, the Biography of Xun Yu and elsewhere. When Yuan Shao, having defeated Gongsun Zan, prepared to attack Xu, he and Feng Ji were put in overall command of the army. Records, Wei 6 §49

When Yuan Shao died, he and Feng Ji supported his youngest son Yuan Shang as successor. In the 9th year of Jian'an (204), while Yuan Shang was away attacking Yuan Tan, he held Ye and was besieged there by Cao Cao; in the 8th month, when his elder brother's son Shen Rong opened a city gate, he was captured and beheaded. Records, Wei 6 §60 · 63 · 66Records, Wei 1 §81 · 84

Chen Shou left no separate assessment of him, but recorded that the captured Shen Pei was firm and stirring in voice and spirit and never uttered a word of submission, so that all who saw him sighed. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 13 as Yuan Shao's adviser and appears in 7 of its 120 chapters; no chapter title bears his name. In Chapter 32 he refuses to the end to surrender and dies kneeling toward the north. Records, Wei 6 §66Romance, Ch. 13 §2Romance, Ch. 32 §51–52

In the Records

After defeating Gongsun Zan at Yijing and absorbing his followers, Yuan Shao entrusted Qing Province to his eldest son Yuan Tan, You Province to his second son Yuan Xi, and Bing Province to his nephew Gao Gan. His host numbered several hundred thousand; he put Shen Pei and Feng Ji in overall command of the army, made Tian Feng, Xun Chen and Xu You his chief strategists and Yan Liang and Wen Chou his generals, and prepared to attack Xu with 100,000 picked troops and 10,000 cavalry. Records, Wei 6 §49

According to the Biography of Xun Yu, Kong Rong told Xun Yu at this time that Yuan Shao would be hard to defeat, since Tian Feng and Xu You, men of wisdom and stratagem, planned for him, while Shen Pei and Feng Ji, loyal ministers, carried out his affairs. Xun Yu replied that Shen Pei was autocratic but lacked stratagem, and that Feng Ji was bold but self-willed. He added that if these two were left behind in charge of affairs, they would not overlook it when Xu You's household broke the law, and Xu You would then surely turn against Yuan Shao. Records, Wei 10 §29–30

In the 5th year of Jian'an (200) Yuan Shao fought Cao Cao at Guandu, lost Chunyu Qiong and others, and withdrew. The Biography of Xun Yu goes on to record that when Shen Pei arrested Xu You's wife and children on the grounds that his household had broken the law, Xu You in anger betrayed Yuan Shao. Chen Shou noted that this, together with the beheading of Yan Liang and Wen Chou in battle and the death of Tian Feng for his remonstrance, all came about just as Xun Yu had reckoned. Records, Wei 10 §31–32

Yuan Shao loved his youngest son Yuan Shang and wished to make him his heir, but had not yet made this known. Shen Pei and Feng Ji contended for power with Xin Ping and Guo Tu; Shen Pei and Feng Ji sided with Yuan Shang, and Xin Ping and Guo Tu with Yuan Tan. When Yuan Shao died in the 7th year of Jian'an (202), people wished to set up Yuan Tan as the eldest. Fearing that if Yuan Tan were set up Xin Ping and the others would harm them, Shen Pei and his allies invoked Yuan Shao's long-held wishes and supported Yuan Shang as Yuan Shao's successor. Yuan Tan styled himself General of Chariots and Cavalry, and from this a rift opened between the two brothers. Records, Wei 6 §58 · 60

When Cao Cao marched north against Yuan Tan and Yuan Shang, Yuan Tan, stationed at Liyang, asked for more troops, but Shen Pei and the others conferred and refused them. In anger Yuan Tan killed Feng Ji, whom Yuan Shang had sent along with him. When Cao Cao crossed the Yellow River to attack Yuan Tan, Yuan Shang left Shen Pei to hold Ye and went himself with troops to aid Yuan Tan. Records, Wei 6 §61

In the 2nd month of the 9th year of Jian'an (204), when Yuan Shang again attacked Yuan Tan at Pingyuan, he left Su You and Shen Pei to hold Ye. When Cao Cao reached the Huan River, 50 li from Ye, Su You tried to act as an inside collaborator, but the plot leaked; he fought Shen Pei within the city, was defeated, and fled to Cao Cao. When Cao Cao dug tunnels, Shen Pei countered by digging trenches inside the city. Shen Pei's general Feng Li opened a sally gate and let in more than 300 of Cao Cao's soldiers, but Shen Pei detected it and from atop the wall struck the palisade gate inside the sally gate with great stones to shut it, and all who had entered perished. Records, Wei 1 §81Records, Wei 6 §63

Cao Cao encircled Ye with a trench forty li around, at first digging it shallow so that it looked easy to cross. Shen Pei watched and laughed at it, and did not come out to contend. In a single night Cao Cao had it dug two zhang wide and deep and breached the Zhang River to flood the city; from the 5th month to the 8th month more than half of those in the city starved to death. Yuan Shang came to the rescue with over 10,000 troops and raised fires as a signal, and Shen Pei sent troops out of the north of the city to break the siege from within and without, but he was defeated by Cao Cao and returned. Yuan Shang was also defeated and fled to Zhongshan, and when Cao Cao showed the families in the city the seal, ribbon, tally and axe of Yuan Shang that he had seized, morale within the city collapsed. Records, Wei 6 §64–65Records, Wei 1 §82–83

In the 8th month, Shen Rong, the son of Shen Pei's elder brother, opened the east gate he was guarding at night and let in Cao Cao's troops. Shen Pei fought them within the city and was captured. Chen Shou recorded that Shen Pei was firm and stirring in voice and spirit and never uttered a word of submission, so that there was no one among those who saw him who did not sigh. Cao Cao at last beheaded him, and Ye was pacified. Records, Wei 1 §84Records, Wei 6 §66

His name appears in later records as well. Dissuading Cao Cao from restoring the ancient Nine Provinces, Xun Yu said that when Yuan Shang had recently been routed and Shen Pei captured, the whole realm had trembled. According to the Biography of Wang Xiu, under the Yuan family's lenient government those with office and power had amassed great wealth, and the household property of Shen Pei and others that Cao Cao confiscated after taking Ye was counted in the tens of thousands. Records, Wei 10 §36Records, Wei 11 §63

Chen Shou gave no separate assessment of Shen Pei. The assessment in the Biography of Yuan Shao records that Yuan Shao had talented men but could not use them and heard good counsel but could not accept it, and that he set aside his rightful heir for a younger son and abandoned propriety to exalt favor, so that the overthrow of his heirs and the toppling of his state were not a matter of misfortune. Records, Wei 6 §96

In the Romance

In Chapter 13 of the Romance, when Cao Cao and Lü Bu face off, Yuan Shao's adviser Shen Pei says that Lü Bu is like a jackal or tiger and, if he gains Yan Province, will surely covet Ji Province, so they should help Cao Cao; Yuan Shao sends Yan Liang with 50,000 troops. In Chapter 22, when Yuan Shao, having received Zheng Xuan's request, discusses attacking Cao Cao, Shen Pei opposes Tian Feng's proposal to prepare over a span of years, saying that attacking the traitor Cao Cao is as easy as turning over one's hand. Yuan Shao makes Shen Pei and Feng Ji commanders-in-chief and raises 300,000 picked troops. Romance, Ch. 13 §2Romance, Ch. 22 §5–6 · 9

In the battle of Guandu in Chapter 30, Shen Pei places 10,000 crossbowmen in ambush on both wings and 5,000 archers inside the gate banners, and when Cao Cao's troops charge the formation he has signal cannons fired, driving Cao Cao back to Guandu. He then proposes building earthen mounds in front of Cao Cao's camp to shoot down from above, and more than fifty mounds are raised, but when Liu Ye's stone-throwing carts smash the towers, he offers another stratagem, the 'tunneling corps' that digs underground passages. Romance, Ch. 30 §5 · 7–9 · 11–12

In the same chapter Shen Pei says that since the grain is stored at Wuchao it must be guarded with a large army, but Yuan Shao sends him back to Ye to oversee grain supplies. A letter from Shen Pei at Ye reports that Xu You, while in Ji Province, had taken bribes from the people and his sons and nephews had levied heavy taxes, so he has thrown them into prison; on reading it, Yuan Shao drives Xu You away. Romance, Ch. 30 §20 · 23–24

In Chapter 32, when Lady Liu asks the dying Yuan Shao, who is vomiting blood, whether Yuan Shang may succeed him, Yuan Shao nods, and Shen Pei writes out his testament at the bedside. Shen Pei and Feng Ji set up Yuan Shang as Grand Marshal General, also holding the governorships of four provinces. When Yuan Tan asks for relief, Shen Pei says that Guo Tu is full of schemes and that they should send no relief troops but use Cao Cao's strength to do away with Yuan Tan. When Yuan Tan invites Yuan Shang to a banquet to harm him, Shen Pei sees this as Guo Tu's scheme and instead has Yuan Shang attack Yuan Tan, pursuing him as far as Pingyuan. Romance, Ch. 32 §2 · 5 · 12 · 16 · 18 · 20

When Yuan Shang sets out again to attack Pingyuan, he leaves Shen Pei and Chen Lin to hold Ji Province. Shen Pei makes the laws very strict and severely punishes Feng Li, commander of the east gate, for neglecting his patrol while drunk. Feng Li, bearing a grudge, surrenders to Cao Cao and comes in through a tunnel with 300 strong men, but Shen Pei, seeing that there are no lights outside the city, detects it and drops the sluice gate of the sally gate with stones, so that all die in the earth. Laughing at the shallow trench Cao Cao has dug and making no preparations, he finds the trench deepened overnight and the waters of the Zhang River flooding into the city. When Xin Pi, outside the city, holds up Yuan Shang's seal, ribbon and clothing and urges surrender, Shen Pei has more than eighty members of Xin Pi's family beheaded on the wall and throws down their heads. Romance, Ch. 32 §32 · 36–37 · 46–47

When Shen Pei's nephew Shen Rong, a close friend of Xin Pi, opens the west gate and lets in Cao Cao's troops, Shen Pei comes down from the wall and fights to the death, but is captured by Xu Huang. Asked by Cao Cao whether he will surrender, he refuses, saying 'Alive I am a subject of the Yuan, dead I shall be a ghost of the Yuan', and when he is about to be executed, saying 'My lord is in the north; you must not make me die facing south', he kneels facing north and receives the blade. A poem by a later writer appended at the end of the chapter calls him 'Shen Zhengnan', and Cao Cao, pitying his loyalty, has him buried north of the city. Romance, Ch. 32 §48–53

Where the Romance differs

Helping Cao Cao: In Chapter 13 of the Romance, on Shen Pei's advice, Yuan Shao gives Yan Liang 50,000 troops to help Cao Cao against Lü Bu. In Chen Shou's text, Shen Pei first appears in the passage where he takes overall command of the army after Yuan Shao defeats Gongsun Zan, and Yan Liang first appears in the battle of Baima in the 5th year of Jian'an (200). Romance, Ch. 13 §2Records, Wei 6 §49 · 51

Kong Rong's words: In Chapter 22 of the Romance, Kong Rong calls Xu You, Guo Tu, Shen Pei and Feng Ji all men of wisdom and stratagem. In the Biography of Xun Yu in the Records, Kong Rong distinguishes Tian Feng and Xu You as men of wisdom and stratagem from Shen Pei and Feng Ji as loyal ministers. Xun Yu's remark that Shen Pei was autocratic but lacked stratagem is the same in both works. Romance, Ch. 22 §30Records, Wei 10 §29–30

Stratagems at Guandu: In Chapter 30 of the Romance, the crossbow ambush, the earthen mounds and towers, and the tunnels are all Shen Pei's stratagems. The Biography of Yuan Shao in the Records says only that Yuan Shao raised high towers and earthen mounds to shoot arrows and dug tunnels, and Shen Pei does not appear in its account of the battle of Guandu. Romance, Ch. 30 §5 · 8 · 12Records, Wei 6 §52

Xu You's family: In Chapter 30 of the Romance, Shen Pei imprisons Xu You's sons and nephews. In the Biography of Xun Yu in the Records, Shen Pei arrested Xu You's wife and children on the grounds that his household had broken the law. Romance, Ch. 30 §23Records, Wei 10 §32

Setting up Yuan Shang: In Chapter 32 of the Romance, Yuan Shao nods before his death to approve Yuan Shang as heir, and Shen Pei writes out his testament. In the Records, Yuan Shao died without making his wishes known, and Shen Pei and others supported Yuan Shang by invoking Yuan Shao's long-held wishes. Romance, Ch. 32 §2Records, Wei 6 §58 · 60

Su You: In Chapter 32 of the Romance, Su You appears only once, as a general who holds Ji Province with Shen Pei when Yuan Shang leaves for Liyang. In the Biography of Yuan Shao in the Records, Su You, while holding Ye, tried to act as Cao Cao's inside collaborator, and when the plot leaked he fought Shen Pei within the city, was defeated, and fled to Cao Cao. Romance, Ch. 32 §13Records, Wei 6 §63Records, Wei 1 §81

Feng Li: In Chapter 32 of the Romance, Feng Li is punished by Shen Pei, leaves the city and surrenders, then dies when the sluice gate closes as he comes in through a tunnel. In the Records, Shen Pei's general Feng Li opened a sally gate and let in more than 300 of Cao Cao's soldiers, and Shen Pei struck the palisade gate shut with great stones so that all who had entered perished. Feng Li's punishment and the tunnel are absent from this passage. Romance, Ch. 32 §36–37Records, Wei 6 §63

Xin Pi's family: In Chapter 32 of the Romance, Shen Pei beheads more than eighty members of the family of Xin Pi, who urges surrender, on the city wall. This incident is absent from the Biography of Yuan Shao and the Annals of Emperor Wu in Chen Shou's text, and from the Biography of Xin Pi. Romance, Ch. 32 §47Records, Wei 6 §63–66Records, Wei 1 §81–84Records, Wei 25 §2–7

Shen Rong opens the gate: In Chapter 32 of the Romance, Shen Rong opens the west gate out of resentment over the deaths of Xin Pi's family. The Records say only that Shen Rong opened the east gate he was guarding at night, without giving a reason. Romance, Ch. 32 §48Records, Wei 6 §66Records, Wei 1 §84

His end: In Chapter 32 of the Romance, Shen Pei is captured by Xu Huang, refuses to surrender before Cao Cao and dies facing north, and Cao Cao buries him north of the city. The Records say only that he fought within the city, was captured, never uttered a word of submission, and was beheaded, without recording the general who captured him, his facing north, or his burial. Romance, Ch. 32 §49–53Records, Wei 6 §66Records, Wei 1 §84

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA6570+5
  • STR4045+5
  • INT2565+40
  • POL4050+10
  • CHA4545±0
  • VIR6285+23
  • ADP3035+5
  • SCH3838±0
  • DIP3838±0
  • DIS4040±0
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

VirtueR62N85 +23

RNever yielded and was called a stirring, loyal minister, though he amassed wealthWei 6 §66Wei 10 §29Wei 11 §63

NSaid 'alive a subject of the Yuan, dead a ghost of the Yuan', and was praised as loyal, upright and incorruptibleCh. 32 §51Ch. 32 §53

PoliticsR40N50 +10

RArrested Xu You's family for breaking the law, but amassed great wealth as a Yuan officialWei 10 §32Wei 11 §63

NStressed the importance of grain, and handled grain transport and Xu You's family's misconduct at YeCh. 30 §20Ch. 30 §23

7 similar abilities — show evidence
  • LeadershipR65N70 +5

    RHeld overall command of the army, and at Ye shut the sally gate to kill 300 and held out from the 5th to the 8th monthWei 6 §49Wei 6 §63Wei 6 §64

    NRouted Cao Cao with a crossbow ambush and held Ye firmly under strict lawsCh. 30 §5Ch. 30 §8Ch. 32 §36

  • StrengthR40UnverifiedN45 +5

    RNo direct record — little beyond fighting back within the cityWei 6 §66

    NCame down from the wall to fight to the death and was captured by Xu HuangCh. 32 §49

  • CharismaR45UnverifiedN45Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — nothing beyond the record of his nephew opening the gateWei 6 §66

    NNo direct record — estimated from his firm defense of Ji ProvinceCh. 31 §21

  • AdaptabilityR30N35 +5

    RFearing harm, set up Yuan Shang and split the brothers, and denied Yuan Tan troopsWei 6 §60Wei 6 §61

    NUrged not relieving Yuan Tan but attacking him; rightly advised rest after defeatCh. 32 §12Ch. 32 §18Ch. 31 §45

  • ScholarshipR38UnverifiedN38Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his role in overall command of the armyWei 6 §49

    NNo direct record — estimated from his conduct as an adviserCh. 22 §6

  • DiplomacyR38UnverifiedN38Unverified ±0

    RNo direct recordWei 6 §60

    NNo direct record — little beyond records of offering stratagems to Yuan ShaoCh. 13 §2

  • DiscernmentR40UnverifiedN40Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his role as a senior minister under Yuan ShaoWei 10 §29

    NNo direct record — estimated from his role in overall command of the armyCh. 22 §9

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (7)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Related events (3)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).