RRepeatedly rebutted the Erudites' answers in debates on the classicsWei 4 §65Wei 4 §70
NCould not answer when Sima Zhao took him to task over the poemCh. 114 §7
| Occupation | RNRuler · Emperor | Faction | Wei |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | R241 N? Unverified | Native place | Pei Commandery Qiao County Unverified |
| Died | R260 N(same) Unverified | Place of death | Nthe Southern Gate Towers |
| Cause of death | RKilled NKilled Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R29 |
Cao Mao, courtesy name Yanshi, was a grandson of Emperor Wen of Wei and the son of Cao Lin, Prince Ding of Donghai. In the 5th year of Zhengshi (244) he was enfeoffed as Duke of Gaogui Village in Tan County, and in the 6th year of Jiaping (254), when the General-in-Chief Sima Shi deposed the emperor Cao Fang, he became emperor of Wei by order of the Empress Dowager as the successor of Emperor Ming. Records, Wei 4 §44 · 46 · 48–49
Throughout his reign the General-in-Chief brothers Sima Shi and Sima Zhao held power. In the 5th month of the 5th year of Ganlu (260) he set out at the head of his attendants with his sword drawn, was struck down by Cheng Ji, Retainer of the Heir Apparent, and died at the age of twenty. Records, Wei 4 §55 · 98 · 101 · 107
In his assessment Chen Shou said that his talent and intelligence matured early, that he loved asking questions and esteemed literary composition, but that he was rash, impetuous and unable to restrain his anger, and so walked into great disaster of his own accord. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 109 as the person set up as the new ruler after Sima Shi deposes Cao Fang, and he appears in 4 of its 120 chapters; his name is in the title of Chapter 114, 'Cao Mao Drives Out in His Carriage and Dies at the Southern Gate'. Records, Wei 4 §153Romance, Ch. 109 §43–44Romance, Ch. 114 §10 · 13
The Duke of Gaogui Village was named Mao, with the courtesy name Yanshi; he was a grandson of Emperor Wen and the son of Cao Lin, Prince Ding of Donghai. In the 5th year of Zhengshi (244) he was enfeoffed as Duke of Gaogui Village in Tan County. From childhood he loved learning and matured early. In the autumn of the 6th year of Jiaping (254), when the General-in-Chief Sima Shi deposed the emperor Cao Fang, the Empress Dowager issued an order saying that among the sons of Cao Lin, Prince of Donghai, the Duke of Gaogui Village, Cao Mao, had the capacity to achieve great things, and made him the heir of Emperor Ming. Wang Su, concurrently serving as Minister of Ceremonies, took the imperial carriage of state to Yuancheng to welcome him. Records, Wei 4 §44 · 46 · 48Records, Wei 13 §93
When he reached the Xuanwu Lodge in the 10th month, the ministers asked him to stay in the front hall, but he stayed in the western wing, saying the hall had been used by the late emperor, and he also declined their offer to welcome him with the imperial carriage of state. On entering Luoyang, when the ministers bowed to him south of the Xiye Gate, he bowed in return despite the master of ceremonies' attempt to stop him, saying, 'I am a subject.' At the Zhiche Gate he got down from his carriage and, saying he had only been summoned by the Empress Dowager and did not yet know for what, walked to the Eastern Hall of the Taiji Palace to see her. That day he ascended the imperial throne in the front hall of the Taiji Palace, and all the officials in attendance rejoiced. He changed the era name to Zhengyuan, reduced spending on the imperial carriages, robes and harem, and stopped the Imperial Workshops and the Imperial Treasury from making luxurious articles. Records, Wei 4 §48–49 · 52–53
In the 10th month of the 1st year of Zhengyuan (254) he granted the General-in-Chief Sima Shi the yellow battle-axe and allowed him not to hurry with small steps when entering court, and to ascend the hall wearing his sword and shoes. In the 1st month of the following year, when Guanqiu Jian and Wen Qin rebelled, Sima Shi attacked them, and when Sima Shi died at Xuchang, in the 2nd month Cao Mao made Sima Zhao, General of the Guards, General-in-Chief and Intendant of the Affairs of the Imperial Secretariat. Records, Wei 4 §53–55
In the 8th month of the 2nd year of Zhengyuan (255), Jiang Wei, General-in-Chief of Shu, invaded Didao, and Wang Jing, Inspector of Yong Province, was heavily defeated at Taoxi. Cao Mao issued an edict saying that, lacking virtue, he had failed to stop the bandits and let thousands of officers and soldiers die, and ordered that their families be comforted and exempted from corvée and taxes for a year. In the 11th month, grieved that the bones of those who had drowned in the Tao River lay abandoned in the fields, he ordered the Generals Who Conquer the West and Who Pacify the West to search for the bodies, gather them and bury them. Records, Wei 4 §57–59
In the 4th month of the 1st year of Ganlu (256) he visited the Imperial Academy, had the scholars lecture on the Book of Changes, the Book of Documents and the Book of Rites, and questioned them himself. He asked why, if Zheng Xuan's combining of the 'Tuan' and 'Xiang' commentaries with the text of the classic made it easier to study, Confucius had not combined them himself, and he challenged them on Yao's testing Gun in office for nine years, asking how in that case Yao could be called sage and wise. The Erudites Chunyu Jun and Yu Jun could not answer him fully in the end and drew back, saying it was beyond the reach of their understanding. Records, Wei 4 §62–65 · 67 · 70–72
In the 6th month of that year he changed the era name to Ganlu, and in the 8th month he added the title of Grand Commander and the yellow battle-axe for Sima Zhao. In the 5th month of the 2nd year of Ganlu (257) he visited the Biyong and had his ministers compose poems, and when the Palace Attendant He You, the Master of Writing Chen Qian and others were slow and the officials in charge asked for their dismissal, he pardoned them, saying that he had sought poems widely only because he loved literary refinement. Records, Wei 4 §75 · 77 · 81
That same month, when Zhuge Dan refused the summons to become Minister of Works and rebelled, Cao Mao issued an edict citing how Emperor Gaozu of Han had taken the field in person against the rebellion of Qing Bu and how Emperor Ming had personally campaigned against Wu and Shu, and declaring that he would go to the front together with the Empress Dowager. The imperial carriage stopped at Xiang, and in the 2nd month of the 3rd year of Ganlu (258) Sima Zhao took the city of Shouchun and beheaded Zhuge Dan. Cao Mao had Qiutou, where Sima Zhao had encamped, renamed Wuqiu. In the 5th month he made Sima Zhao Chancellor of State, enfeoffed him as Duke of Jin and added the Nine Bestowments, but Sima Zhao declined nine times and it was dropped. In the 8th month he made Wang Xiang the Thrice Venerable and Zheng Xiaotong the Fivefold Experienced, and performed the ancient rites in person. Records, Wei 4 §82–83 · 85 · 88–90 · 93–94
In the 1st month of the 4th year of Ganlu (259) two yellow dragons appeared in a well in Ningling County. In the 4th month of the 5th year of Ganlu (260) he had the officials in charge carry out the earlier order and again raised Sima Zhao to Chancellor of State, enfeoffing him as Duke of Jin and adding the Nine Bestowments. Records, Wei 4 §96–97
On the jichou day of the 5th month, the Duke of Gaogui Village died. He was twenty. The Empress Dowager issued an order stating that he was violent by nature and slandered her, shot at her palace with a crossbow, and bribed her attendants to put poison in her medicine. It further stated that he had summoned the Palace Attendant Wang Chen, the Cavalier Regular Attendant Wang Ye and the Master of Writing Wang Jing, shown them an edict on yellow silk from the fold of his robe and said he would carry it out that very day, but Wang Chen and Wang Ye informed the General-in-Chief, and he led his attendants out of the Yunlong Gate, beating the drums, drew his sword himself and entered among the ranks of soldiers, where he was struck down by the vanguard. The Empress Dowager ordered that he be buried with the rites of a commoner, like the King of Changyi of the Han, and that Wang Jing and his family be handed over to the Commandant of Justice. Records, Wei 4 §98–102
The next day, when the Grand Tutor Sima Fu, the General-in-Chief Sima Zhao, the Grand Commandant Gao Rou and the Minister over the Masses Zheng Chong asked that he be shown grace and buried with the rites of a prince, the Empress Dowager agreed. Sima Zhao submitted a memorial stating that when the Duke of Gaogui Village came toward where he was, leading soldiers, his sword drawn and gongs and drums sounding, he had ordered that the Duke not be harmed, but that Cheng Ji, Retainer of the Heir Apparent, had rashly rushed into the ranks and struck the Duke so that he lost his life; he reported that he had dealt with Cheng Ji by military law and handed his family over to the Commandant of Justice. Wang Jing was executed for his involvement in the affair of the Duke of Gaogui Village. Records, Wei 4 §103–104 · 107–110Records, Wei 9 §130
In his assessment Chen Shou said that the Duke of Gaogui Village's talent and intelligence matured early, that he loved asking questions and esteemed literary composition, carrying on the cultivated manner of Emperor Wen, but that he was rash, impetuous, unable to restrain his anger and wilful, and so walked into great disaster of his own accord. Records, Wei 4 §153
In Chapter 109 of the Romance, when Sima Shi deposes Cao Fang and wants to set up Cao Ju, Prince of Pengcheng, the Empress Dowager objects that Cao Ju is her uncle and proposes instead Cao Mao, Duke of Gaogui Village, the gentle and respectful grandson of Emperor Wen, and Sima Fu supports this. Summoned from Yuancheng, Cao Mao hurriedly returns the bows of the officials who bow to him outside the Xiye Gate, and to the Grand Commandant Wang Su, who tries to stop him, he says, 'I too am a subject.' Saying that he does not know what the Empress Dowager's summons is for, he declines the imperial carriage, walks to the Eastern Hall of the Taiji Palace and bows first to Sima Shi, who comes to meet him. That same day he becomes the new ruler, changes the 6th year of Jiaping to the 1st year of Zhengyuan, and grants Sima Shi the yellow battle-axe. Romance, Ch. 109 §39–40 · 43–44
In Chapter 110, when Sima Shi dies, Cao Mao sends Sima Zhao an edict ordering him to stay at Xuchang to guard against Eastern Wu, but he is greatly alarmed when Sima Zhao brings his army back and camps south of the Luo River. On Wang Su's advice he makes Sima Zhao General-in-Chief and Intendant of the Affairs of the Imperial Secretariat, and from then on all affairs, great and small, inside and outside the court, are in Sima Zhao's hands. In Chapter 111, when Zhuge Dan rises in revolt, Sima Zhao asks the Empress Dowager and the Son of Heaven to lead the campaign in person; Cao Mao asks why he should go when the General-in-Chief commands all the armies of the realm, but, fearing Sima Zhao's power, he complies. Romance, Ch. 110 §28–30Romance, Ch. 111 §33–35
In Chapter 114 Jia Chong tells Sima Zhao that when yellow dragons appeared twice in a well at Ningling the year before, the Son of Heaven said that it was no auspicious sign, since the dragon was trapped in a well, and wrote the 'Poem of the Hidden Dragon'. In the summer, in the 4th month of the 5th year of Ganlu, Sima Zhao goes up into the hall wearing his sword and demands to know whether he should not receive the title of Duke of Jin and the Nine Bestowments, and when he charges that the poem likened them to loaches and eels, Cao Mao cannot answer. Cao Mao summons Wang Chen, Wang Jing and Wang Ye and says in tears, 'I cannot sit and suffer the disgrace of being deposed,' and when Wang Jing tries to stop him he refuses to yield, saying, 'If this can be endured, what cannot be endured?' Romance, Ch. 114 §4–9
Cao Mao has his guard Jiao Bo gather the palace guards, the servants and the palace boys, over three hundred men, and, sword in hand, mounts his carriage and sets out for the Southern Gate Towers. Brushing aside Wang Jing, who prostrates himself in tears before the carriage, he heads for the Yunlong Gate and runs into Jia Chong, who is leading the brothers Cheng Cui and Cheng Ji and several thousand palace troops. When the palace troops cannot move at his shout, 'I am the Son of Heaven!', Jia Chong says that Lord Sima's order is that only a dead man will do, and Cao Mao is stabbed in the chest by Cheng Ji's halberd and dies beside his carriage. Sima Zhao feigns shock and weeps, and Sima Fu weeps with Cao Mao's head resting on his thigh. Cheng Ji's three sets of kin are exterminated, and at Sima Fu's request Cao Mao is buried with the rites of a prince. Romance, Ch. 114 §10–17 · 22
How he was set up: In Chapter 109 of the Romance, Sima Shi first wants to set up Cao Ju, Prince of Pengcheng, and the Empress Dowager puts Cao Mao forward instead. In the Annals of the Three Young Emperors in the Records, after Sima Shi deposed the Prince of Qi, the Empress Dowager issued an order making Cao Mao the heir of Emperor Ming, and there is no mention of a plan to set up Cao Ju. Romance, Ch. 109 §39Records, Wei 4 §44 · 46
Etiquette on entering the palace: In Chapter 109 of the Romance, the Grand Commandant Wang Su tries to stop him from returning the bows, and Cao Mao bows first to Sima Shi in the Eastern Hall of the Taiji Palace. In the Records, it was the master of ceremonies who tried to stop him from bowing in return, and there is no record of his bowing to Sima Shi. Romance, Ch. 109 §43–44Records, Wei 4 §49
Leading the campaign in person: In Chapter 111 of the Romance, Sima Zhao asks for an imperial campaign in order to take the Son of Heaven with him, and Cao Mao complies reluctantly out of fear of his power. In the Records, Cao Mao issued an edict citing, among other precedents, Emperor Gaozu of Han's taking the field in person against the rebellion of Qing Bu, and declaring that he would go to the front together with the Empress Dowager; the imperial carriage stopped at Xiang. Romance, Ch. 111 §33–35Records, Wei 4 §82–83 · 85
The Poem of the Hidden Dragon: In Chapter 114 of the Romance, Cao Mao writes the 'Poem of the Hidden Dragon' on seeing the yellow dragons in the well at Ningling and incurs Sima Zhao's anger. The Records says only that in the 1st month of the 4th year of Ganlu (259) two yellow dragons appeared in a well in Ningling County, and the poem does not appear. Romance, Ch. 114 §5–6Records, Wei 4 §96
The enfeoffment as Duke of Jin and the month of his death: In Chapter 114 of the Romance, in the summer, in the 4th month of the 5th year of Ganlu, the ministers propose in the hall that Sima Zhao be made Duke of Jin, and afterwards Cao Mao rises up. In the Records, an edict in the 4th month of that year raised Sima Zhao to Chancellor of State and Duke of Jin, and Cao Mao died on the jichou day of the 5th month. Romance, Ch. 114 §6–7Records, Wei 4 §97–98
Who killed him: In Chapter 114 of the Romance, Jia Chong passes on to Cheng Ji Lord Sima's order that 'only a dead man will do', and Cheng Ji stabs Cao Mao. In the Records, Sima Zhao reported that he had ordered that Cao Mao not be harmed but that Cheng Ji, Retainer of the Heir Apparent, rashly rushed into the ranks, and Jia Chong's name does not appear in Chen Shou's main text of the Annals of the Three Young Emperors. Romance, Ch. 114 §12–13Records, Wei 4 §107–108
The punishment of Cheng Ji: In Chapter 114 of the Romance, Chen Tai says that Jia Chong should be beheaded, and Sima Zhao has Cheng Ji's tongue cut out and his three sets of kin exterminated. In the Records, Sima Zhao reported that he would deal with Cheng Ji by military law and hand his family over to the Commandant of Justice, and the Empress Dowager granted this. Chen Tai's words are not in the Annals of the Three Young Emperors. Romance, Ch. 114 §15–17Records, Wei 4 §107 · 109–110
The Empress Dowager's order: In the Records, the Empress Dowager issued an order stating that Cao Mao had shot at her palace with a crossbow and plotted to poison her, and directing that he be buried with the rites of a commoner; at the request of Sima Fu and others this was changed to the rites of a prince. Chapter 114 of the Romance does not have this order of the Empress Dowager, and he is buried with the rites of a prince at Sima Fu's request. Romance, Ch. 114 §22Records, Wei 4 §98–102 · 103–104
Wang Jing: In Chapter 114 of the Romance, Wang Jing tries to stop Cao Mao but follows him to the end, and after reviling Jia Chong he goes to his execution laughing, together with his mother. In the Records, Wang Jing and his family were handed over to the Commandant of Justice by order of the Empress Dowager, and Wang Jing was executed for his involvement in the affair of the Duke of Gaogui Village. His words trying to stop Cao Mao are not in Chen Shou's main text. Romance, Ch. 114 §8 · 13 · 19Records, Wei 4 §102Records, Wei 9 §130
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RRepeatedly rebutted the Erudites' answers in debates on the classicsWei 4 §65Wei 4 §70
NCould not answer when Sima Zhao took him to task over the poemCh. 114 §7
RModest and frugal, but the assessment says he could not restrain his anger and was wilfulWei 4 §49Wei 4 §52Wei 4 §153
NReturned the bows at his accession, saying he was a subject, and refused to endure the disgrace of being deposedCh. 109 §43Ch. 114 §9
RAssessment: his talent and intelligence matured early, but he was rash and impetuousWei 4 §153Wei 4 §62
NRead the dragon in the well as an omen of confinement, but rashly tried to strike at Sima ZhaoCh. 114 §5Ch. 114 §8
RCut back on luxury, sent envoys to look into wrongs suffered, and appointed the Thrice Venerable and the Fivefold ExperiencedWei 4 §52Wei 4 §53Wei 4 §93
NNo direct record — estimated from his conduct after taking the throneCh. 109 §44
RLeft the Erudites at a loss in debating the Changes and the Documents at the Imperial Academy. Assessment: esteemed literary compositionWei 4 §62Wei 4 §68Wei 4 §153
NRevealed his feelings by writing the Poem of the Hidden DragonCh. 114 §5Ch. 114 §6
RChose Wang Xiang and Zheng Xiaotong as the Thrice Venerable and the Fivefold Experienced, and honoured loyal commonersWei 4 §93Wei 4 §79
NWang Chen and Wang Ye, whom he trusted and summoned, informed on him to Sima ZhaoCh. 114 §10
RNo direct record — estimated from the record of his leading his attendants into the ranks of soldiersWei 4 §101
NSet out leading over three hundred guards and servants, and was warned it was like walking into a tiger's mouthCh. 114 §10
RDrew his sword himself and entered among the ranks of soldiers with his guardsWei 4 §101Wei 4 §99
NMounted his carriage sword in hand and set out, but was stabbed to death by Cheng Ji's halberdCh. 114 §10Ch. 114 §13
RWhen he took the throne, all the officials in attendance rejoicedWei 4 §49
NWhen he shouted that he was the Son of Heaven, the palace troops dared not moveCh. 114 §12Ch. 109 §43
RAssessment: rash and impetuous, he walked into great disaster of his own accordWei 4 §153Wei 4 §101
NBrushed aside Wang Jing's remonstrance and set out with a few hundred men to strike at Sima ZhaoCh. 114 §10Ch. 114 §11
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
| Parents | Cao Lin(曹霖) Novel & History |
|---|
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).