Liu Dai 劉岱

RecordsRomance Liu Dai faction Courtesy name 公山 Gongshan유대공산刘岱

Profile
OccupationRNRuler · Inspector of Yan Province NGeneral · Lieutenant GeneralFactionLiu Dai faction
AppearsRNBiography in
BornR? UnverifiedNative placeDonglai Commandery Muping County Unverified
DiedR192 UnverifiedPlace of death
Cause of deathRKilled in battle Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR18

Profile

Liu Dai, courtesy name Gongshan, was the elder brother of Liu Yao, a man of Muping in Donglai. He was serving as Palace Attendant when, in Dong Zhuo's time, he was sent out as Inspector of Yan Province; on reaching his post he joined the heads of other provinces and commanderies in raising troops to attack Dong Zhuo. Records, Wu 4 §2Records, Shu 8 §3Records, Wei 6 §10

In the 1st year of Chuping (190) he joined the eastern armies with Yuan Shao as leader of the alliance and was stationed at Suanzao, and later he fell out with Qiao Mao, the Administrator of Dong Commandery, and killed him. In the 3rd year of Chuping (192), when a million Yellow Turbans from Qing Province entered Yan Province, he rejected Bao Xin's advice to hold fast, gave battle and was killed. Records, Wei 1 §7–8 · 14 · 21–23

The Records has no separate biography of him; he appears in the Annals of Emperor Wu and in the biographies of his younger brother Liu Yao, of Cheng Yu and others. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 5 as the Inspector of Yan Province, the fourth contingent among the lords attacking Dong Zhuo, and appears in 6 of its 120 chapters; his name is in the title of Chapter 22, 'Guan Yu and Zhang Fei Together Capture the Two Generals Wang Zhong and Liu Dai.' The Romance goes on to portray him as having later surrendered to Cao Cao and become a lieutenant general. Records, Wei 1 §7Records, Wu 4 §2Records, Wei 14 §5Romance, Ch. 5 §7Romance, Ch. 22 §31 · 45

In the Records

Liu Dai's younger brother Liu Yao, courtesy name Zhengli, was a man of Muping County in Donglai Commandery. The youngest son of King Xiao of Qi had been enfeoffed as Marquis of Muping, and his descendants made their home there; Liu Yao's paternal uncle Liu Chong was Grand Commandant of the Han. In Liu Yao's biography Chen Shou wrote that Liu Yao's elder brother Liu Dai, courtesy name Gongshan, served successively as Palace Attendant and Inspector of Yan Province. Records, Wu 4 §2

When Taoqiu Hong of Pingyuan wanted Liu Yao recommended as Flourishing Talent, the Inspector said, 'Last year I recommended Gongshan; how can I recommend Zhengli as well?' Taoqiu Hong replied that to employ Gongshan first and promote Zhengli afterwards would be to drive two dragons on a long road and gallop fine steeds over a thousand li. Records, Wu 4 §3–4

Dong Zhuo trusted the Master of Writing Zhou Bi, the Colonel of the City Gates Wu Qiong and others, and sent out the men they recommended—Han Fu, Liu Dai, Kong Zhou, Zhang Zi, Zhang Miao and others—as heads of provinces and commanderies. At this time the Palace Attendant Liu Dai became Inspector of Yan Province. But on reaching their posts, Han Fu and the others all joined forces to attack Dong Zhuo, and Dong Zhuo, believing that Zhou Bi, Wu Qiong and the others had been in collusion with them, had them all beheaded. Records, Shu 8 §3Records, Wei 6 §10

In the first month, spring, of the 1st year of Chuping (190), Yuan Shu, Han Fu, Kong Zhou, Liu Dai, Wang Kuang, Yuan Shao, Zhang Miao, Qiao Mao, Yuan Yi and Bao Xin raised troops at the same time. Each had tens of thousands of followers, and they chose Yuan Shao as leader of the alliance. In the second month, when Dong Zhuo moved the Son of Heaven to Chang'an, Zhang Miao, Liu Dai, Qiao Mao and Yuan Yi were stationed at Suanzao, but because Dong Zhuo's army was strong no one dared to advance first. Records, Wei 1 §7–8

At Suanzao, Zhang Miao introduced Zang Hong, whom his younger brother Zhang Chao valued highly, to Liu Gongshan of Yan Province and Kong Gongxu of Yu Province, and both became close to Zang Hong. When the provinces and commanderies set up an altar and swore an oath, the oath that Zang Hong read from the altar included the words that the Inspector of Yan Province Liu Dai and others had gathered loyal troops to hasten together to the aid of the state in its crisis. Records, Wei 7 §37–38

Liu Dai fell out with Qiao Mao, the Administrator of Dong Commandery, killed him, and had Wang Gong serve concurrently as Administrator of Dong Commandery. Records, Wei 1 §14

During the Chuping era Liu Dai summoned Cheng Yu, but Cheng Yu did not respond. At this time Liu Dai was on friendly terms with both Yuan Shao and Gongsun Zan: Yuan Shao had his wife and children stay with Liu Dai, and Gongsun Zan sent his Attendant Officer Fan Fang with cavalry to help Liu Dai. Later, having defeated Yuan Shao's army, Gongsun Zan told Liu Dai to send away Yuan Shao's wife and children and break with Yuan Shao, and separately instructed Fan Fang to bring the cavalry back if Liu Dai did not comply. Records, Wei 14 §5–6

When Liu Dai deliberated for several days without reaching a decision, his Attendant Officer with Separate Carriage Wang Yu recommended Cheng Yu as a man of resource. Liu Dai summoned Cheng Yu and asked his advice, and Cheng Yu said that to abandon Yuan Shao, the help close at hand, and seek Gongsun Zan's distant aid would be like borrowing a man from Yue to save a drowning child, and that Gongsun Zan would in the end be captured by Yuan Shao. Liu Dai followed his advice. While Fan Fang was on his way back with the cavalry, Gongsun Zan was heavily defeated by Yuan Shao. Liu Dai submitted a memorial to make Cheng Yu Chief Commandant of Cavalry, but Cheng Yu declined on the grounds of illness. Records, Wei 14 §6–7

In the 3rd year of Chuping (192), a million Yellow Turbans from Qing Province entered Yan Province, killed Zheng Sui, the Chancellor of Rencheng, and turned toward Dongping. When Liu Dai wanted to attack them, Bao Xin advised that since the enemy numbered a million and the soldiers had no will to fight, they should hold fast and build up their strength, and attack after the enemy had dispersed. Liu Dai did not listen, gave battle, and was indeed killed by them. Bao Xin went with the provincial officer Wan Qian and others to Dong Commandery and welcomed Cao Cao to take charge as Governor of Yan Province. Records, Wei 1 §21–23Records, Wei 14 §8

In the Romance

In Chapter 5 of the Romance, when Cao Cao circulates his call to arms, the lords of each contingent raise troops in response, and Liu Dai is listed as the fourth contingent, Inspector of Yan Province. In Chapter 6, as the lords are dispersing, Liu Dai, 'Administrator of Yan Province,' tries to borrow grain from Qiao Mao, the Administrator of Dong Commandery, and when refused leads his troops into Qiao Mao's camp, kills him and makes all his troops surrender. In Chapter 15 Liu Yao is introduced as the nephew of the Grand Commandant Liu Chong and the younger brother of Liu Dai, Inspector of Yan Province. Romance, Ch. 5 §7Romance, Ch. 6 §34Romance, Ch. 15 §20

In Chapter 22 Cao Cao gives 50,000 troops to Liu Dai of the vanguard and Wang Zhong of the rearguard and has them attack Liu Bei in Xu Province under the Chancellor's banner. The Romance explains that Liu Dai had formerly been Inspector of Yan Province and, when Cao Cao took Yan Province, surrendered and was employed as a lieutenant general. The two pitch camp a hundred li from Xu Province and only watch for news from Hebei, and when Cao Cao presses them to fight, Liu Dai says, 'I am the commander-in-chief; why should I go first?' and has them draw lots; Wang Zhong draws 'first' and goes to attack Xu Province. Romance, Ch. 22 §31–35

When Wang Zhong is captured by Guan Yu, Zhang Fei volunteers to capture Liu Dai, and Liu Bei tells him not to take him lightly, since Liu Dai was formerly Inspector of Yan Province and was the lord of one contingent when they attacked Dong Zhuo at Hulao Pass. Liu Dai holds fast and does not come out, but believing the words of a beaten soldier whom Zhang Fei deliberately lets go, he leaves his camp empty and sets an ambush. He is routed, however, by Zhang Fei's troops coming in three columns, and as he flees he runs into Zhang Fei on a narrow road and is captured after a single bout. Romance, Ch. 22 §40–45

Liu Bei unties Liu Dai's bonds with his own hands, entertains him together with Wang Zhong, and asks them to explain matters to Cao Cao on his behalf, and the two pledge the old and young of both their households as surety. On the way back, when Zhang Fei blocks their path, the two tremble on horseback and barely escape thanks to Guan Yu's intervention, pleading, 'Even if the Chancellor exterminates our three sets of kin, we will never come again.' Cao Cao orders the two beheaded, but when Kong Rong remonstrates he spares their lives and strips them of their ranks and stipends. In Chapter 24 Liu Bei tells Zhang Fei that when he captured Liu Dai earlier he made good use of stratagem. Romance, Ch. 22 §47–52Romance, Ch. 23 §1Romance, Ch. 24 §17

Where the Romance differs

Why he killed Qiao Mao: In Chapter 6 of the Romance, Liu Dai tries to borrow grain from Qiao Mao and, when refused, attacks his camp, kills him and takes over his troops. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, Liu Dai fell out with Qiao Mao, killed him, and had Wang Gong serve concurrently as Administrator of Dong Commandery. Romance, Ch. 6 §34Records, Wei 1 §14

Between Yuan Shao and Gongsun Zan: In Cheng Yu's biography in the Records, Liu Dai spends several days unable to decide which side to take between Yuan Shao and Gongsun Zan, and on Cheng Yu's advice stays on Yuan Shao's side. In the Romance Liu Dai appears only as one of the lords attacking Dong Zhuo and in the scene where he kills Qiao Mao, and this episode is absent. Records, Wei 14 §5–7Romance, Ch. 5 §7Romance, Ch. 6 §34

How Yan Province was lost: Chapter 22 of the Romance explains that when Cao Cao took Yan Province, Liu Dai surrendered and became a lieutenant general. In the Records, in the 3rd year of Chuping (192) Liu Dai ignored Bao Xin's advice, fought the Yellow Turbans of Qing Province and was killed, and only afterwards did Bao Xin and others welcome Cao Cao to take charge as Governor of Yan Province. Romance, Ch. 22 §31Records, Wei 1 §22–23Records, Wei 14 §8

The Liu Dai who attacked Liu Bei: In Chapter 22 of the Romance, this Liu Dai, the former Inspector of Yan Province, goes with Wang Zhong to attack Liu Bei in Xu Province, is captured by Zhang Fei and is released. The Biography of the First Sovereign and the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records also record that Cao Cao sent Liu Dai and Wang Zhong to attack Liu Bei without success, but they do not say that this Liu Dai had been Inspector of Yan Province, nor that he was captured. Liu Dai, the Inspector of Yan Province, had already died earlier, in the 3rd year of Chuping. Romance, Ch. 22 §31 · 45 · 48Records, Shu 2 §16Records, Wei 1 §56 · 23

Death: The Romance does not show Liu Dai's death; his last appearance is in Chapter 23, when Cao Cao spares his life and he loses his ranks and stipends. In the Records he was killed fighting the Yellow Turbans of Qing Province. Romance, Ch. 23 §1Records, Wei 1 §23

Title of office: Chapter 6 of the Romance calls him 'Administrator of Yan Province.' The Records gives Inspector of Yan Province. Romance, Ch. 6 §34Records, Wei 1 §7

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA3025−5
  • STR3525−10
  • INT3226−6
  • POL4235−7
  • CHA4235−7
  • VIR3530−5
  • ADP4532−13
  • SCH3832−6
  • DIP5240−12
  • DIS5031−19
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

DiscernmentR50N31Unverified −19

RSummoned Cheng Yu, followed his plan, and memorialized to make him Chief Commandant of CavalryWei 14 §6

NNo direct record — estimated from his handling of his subordinate generalCh. 22 §35

AdaptabilityR45N32 −13

RStayed on Yuan Shao's side on Cheng Yu's advice, and Gongsun Zan was soon heavily defeatedWei 14 §6

NThough commander-in-chief, sent Wang Zhong first by drawing lots and only held fastCh. 22 §35Ch. 22 §43

DiplomacyR52N40 −12

RWas on friendly terms with both Yuan Shao and Gongsun Zan and received help from bothWei 14 §5

NPromised to speak for Liu Bei and reported to Cao Cao just as promisedCh. 22 §48Ch. 22 §52

StrengthR35UnverifiedN25 −10

RNo direct record — estimated from his taking the field as InspectorWei 1 §23

NWas captured by Zhang Fei on a narrow road after a single boutCh. 22 §45

6 similar abilities — show evidence
  • LeadershipR30N25 −5

    RCould not advance from Suanzao, and died fighting the Yellow Turbans after ignoring adviceWei 1 §8Wei 1 §22

    NLed 50,000 men but dared not advance, and was routed by Zhang Fei's surprise attackCh. 22 §34Ch. 22 §45

  • IntelligenceR32N26 −6

    RCould not decide for days between Yuan Shao and Gongsun Zan, and also rejected Bao Xin's planWei 1 §22Wei 14 §6

    NBelieved a false deserter's story and set an ambush, only to be counterattackedCh. 22 §44

  • PoliticsR42UnverifiedN35Unverified −7

    RNo direct record — estimated from his appointing an Administrator of Dong Commandery as Inspector of Yan ProvinceWei 1 §14

    NNo direct record — estimated from his career as Inspector of Yan ProvinceCh. 6 §34

  • CharismaR42UnverifiedN35Unverified −7

    RNo direct record — estimated from his joining the campaign against Dong Zhuo with tens of thousands of followersWei 1 §7

    NNo direct record — estimated from his leading one of the lords' contingentsCh. 5 §7

  • VirtueR35N30 −5

    RKilled Qiao Mao when they fell outWei 1 §14

    NAttacked and killed Qiao Mao, who had refused him grain, but kept his promise to speak for Liu BeiCh. 6 §34Ch. 22 §48

  • ScholarshipR38UnverifiedN32Unverified −6

    RNo direct record — estimated from his career as Palace AttendantShu 8 §3

    NNo direct record — estimated from his family line as an imperial kinsmanCh. 15 §20

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (6)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Liu Dai faction · Records

Relations

Family

SiblingsLiu Yao(劉繇) Novel & History

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (1)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).