Sun Yu 孫瑜
| Occupation | RGeneral · General Who Displays Might | Faction | Wu |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wu |
| Born | R177 Unverified | Native place | Wu Commandery Fuchun County Unverified |
| Died | R215 Unverified | Place of death | |
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R9 |
Profile
Sun Yu, courtesy name Zhongyi, was the son of Sun Jing, the youngest brother of Sun Jian. He first led troops as Gongyi Colonel, and in the 9th year of Jian'an (204), when Sun Quan's younger brother Sun Yi was killed by those around him, Sun Quan had his elder cousin Sun Yu replace him. Sun Yu concurrently held the post of Administrator of Danyang. Records, Wu 6 §2 · 4 · 6Records, Wu 2 §8
Together with Zhou Yu he crushed the two encampments of Ma and Bao, and after being transferred to General Who Displays Might he garrisoned Niuzhu and won over the two commanderies of Lujiang. Even in the army he loved the ancient classics, and the sound of his reading never ceased; he died in the 20th year of Jian'an (215) at the age of thirty-nine. Records, Wu 6 §6–8
In the assessment of the Biographies of the Ruling House, Chen Shou said that he had recorded these various Suns in detail because they helped lay the first foundations of the state or guarded the frontiers and proved equal to their duties. In the Romance he appears only in Chapter 57, that is, in 1 of its 120 chapters, and no chapter has his name in its title. He appears as the younger brother sent by the Marquis of Wu to help Zhou Yu, who is about to attack Xichuan. Records, Wu 6 §52Romance, Ch. 57 §1
In the Records
Sun Yu's courtesy name was Zhongyi. His father Sun Jing was the youngest brother of Sun Jian; after Sun Ce pacified Kuaiji, Sun Jing did not take office but asked to stay behind and guard their home district, and when Sun Quan took charge of affairs he was promoted to Zhaoyi General of the Household and died at home. Sun Jing had five sons, and Sun Yu was one of them. Records, Wu 6 §2 · 4 · 6
Sun Yu first led troops as Gongyi Colonel. At this time many of the retainers and officers were men from Jiangxi, and Sun Yu, with an open mind, soothed and cared for them and won their hearts. In the 9th year of Jian'an (204), when Sun Quan's younger brother Sun Yi, the Administrator of Danyang, was killed by those around him, Sun Quan had his elder cousin Sun Yu replace Sun Yi. When Sun Yu concurrently took the post of Administrator of Danyang, people flocked to him until they numbered more than ten thousand, and he was given the additional title of General Who Pacifies the Distant. Records, Wu 6 §6Records, Wu 2 §8
In the 11th year of Jian'an (206) he attacked and crushed the two encampments of Ma and Bao together with Zhou Yu. The Biography of Zhou Yu records that Zhou Yu, supervising Sun Yu and others, attacked the two encampments, beheaded their chiefs and displayed the heads, captured more than ten thousand people, and then returned to stand guard. Records, Wu 6 §6Records, Wu 9 §8
Later he followed Sun Quan in resisting Lord Cao at Ruxu. When Sun Quan wanted to give battle, Sun Yu urged him to hold firm and act with caution, but Sun Quan did not listen, and the army indeed achieved nothing. Records, Wu 6 §6
He was transferred to General Who Displays Might while still holding the commandery, and moved his garrison from Liyang to Niuzhu. Sun Yu made Rao Zhu of Yong'an Chief of Xiang'an and Yan Lian of Wuxi Chief of Juchao and had them win over the two commanderies of Lujiang, and each of them gained people who came over in surrender. Records, Wu 6 §7
When Ma Pu of Jiyin proved devoted to learning and fond of antiquity, Sun Yu treated him with generous courtesy and had several hundred sons and younger brothers of the officers and clerks of the two offices go to study under him. In the end he established a school and personally attended its feasts and lectures. At this time the generals all concerned themselves only with military affairs, but Sun Yu loved the ancient classics, and even in the army the sound of his reading never ceased. Records, Wu 6 §7–8
In the Biography of Zhou Yu, Zhou Yu asked Sun Quan to let him advance with the General Who Displays Might to take Shu, then after taking Shu to annex Zhang Lu, and to leave the General Who Displays Might behind to hold that land firmly, and he received permission. But Zhou Yu, returning to Jiangling to prepare to set out, died of illness at Baqiu. Chen Shou's main text does not give the name of this General Who Displays Might, and the biography of Sun Yu does not record him setting out to attack Shu. Records, Wu 9 §21Records, Wu 6 §5–8
Sun Yu died in the 20th year of Jian'an (215) at the age of thirty-nine. He had five sons, of whom Sun Man rose to general and was enfeoffed as a marquis. When Huang Gai and his elder brother Sun Yu died, his younger brother Sun Jiao took over their troops. Records, Wu 6 §8 · 10
In the assessment of the Biographies of the Ruling House, Chen Shou said that the bond of kindness and duty among kin is a constant principle of past and present, and that he had recorded these various Suns in detail because some helped lay the first foundations of the state and some held and guarded the frontiers, proved fully equal to their duties and did not disgrace their honor. Records, Wu 6 §52
In the Romance
At the opening of Chapter 57 of the Romance, Zhou Yu, his chest filled with rage, falls from his horse, and on hearing that Xuande and Kongming are drinking and making merry on the summit of the hill ahead, he grinds his teeth and swears that he will take Xichuan. Just then word comes that the Marquis of Wu has sent his younger brother Sun Yu. Zhou Yu receives him and tells him everything that has happened, and Sun Yu says that he has come on his elder brother's orders to help the Chief Commander. Romance, Ch. 57 §1
Zhou Yu at last urges the army forward, but when he reaches Baqiu, Liu Feng and Guan Ping block the waterway upstream, and Zhuge Liang sends a letter saying that attacking Xichuan is impossible. Zhou Yu writes a letter to be presented to the Marquis of Wu, charges his generals to serve the Marquis of Wu well, and then, lamenting, 'Having already given birth to Zhou Yu, why did Heaven also give birth to Zhuge Liang?', breathes his last at the age of thirty-six. Sun Yu appears only at the opening of this chapter and never appears again. Romance, Ch. 57 §2–5
Where the Romance differs
Relationship to Sun Quan: In Chapter 57 of the Romance, Sun Yu appears as the younger brother sent by the Marquis of Wu and calls Sun Quan his elder brother. In the Records, Sun Yu was the son of Sun Jing, the youngest brother of Sun Jian, and the Biography of the Lord of Wu records him as Sun Quan's elder cousin. Romance, Ch. 57 §1Records, Wu 6 §2 · 4Records, Wu 2 §8
The attack on Xichuan: In Chapter 57 of the Romance, Sun Yu comes to help Zhou Yu, who is setting out to attack Xichuan, and Zhou Yu, with the waterway blocked by Liu Feng and Guan Ping at Baqiu, receives Zhuge Liang's letter and breathes his last. In the Biography of Zhou Yu in the Records, Zhou Yu asked Sun Quan to let him take Shu together with the General Who Displays Might and received permission, but died of illness at Baqiu while returning to Jiangling to prepare. The blocking of the waterway by Liu Feng and Guan Ping and Zhuge Liang's letter are not in the Biography of Zhou Yu. Romance, Ch. 57 §1–5Records, Wu 9 §21 · 1–30
Administrator of Danyang: In the Biography of the Lord of Wu and the biography of Sun Yu in the Records, when Sun Yi was killed by those around him in the 9th year of Jian'an (204), Sun Yu replaced him and concurrently held the post of Administrator of Danyang. In Chapter 38 of the Romance, after Sun Yi's wife Lady Xu avenges him, Sun Quan makes Sun Gao and Fu Ying Generals of the Gate Banner to guard Danyang, and Sun Yu does not appear. Records, Wu 2 §8Records, Wu 6 §6Romance, Ch. 38 §37
Advice at Ruxu: In the biography of Sun Yu in the Records, Sun Yu urged Sun Quan, who wanted to give battle at Ruxu, to hold firm and act with caution, but Sun Quan did not listen and the army achieved nothing. In the Romance Sun Yu appears only in Chapter 57, and this episode is absent. Records, Wu 6 §6Romance, Ch. 57 §1
The school: In the Records, Sun Yu treated Ma Pu of Jiyin with courtesy and established a school, and even in the army the sound of his reading never ceased. The Romance does not show this side of him. Records, Wu 6 §7–8Romance, Ch. 57 §1
Death: In the Records, Sun Yu died in the 20th year of Jian'an (215) at the age of thirty-nine. The Romance does not record his death. Records, Wu 6 §8Romance, Ch. 57 §1
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Abilities
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
- LEA6245−17
- STR4038−2
- INT6038−22
- POL6235−27
- CHA6840−28
- VIR6045−15
- ADP4840−8
- SCH6833−35
- DIP4835−13
- DIS6033−27
Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more
2 similar abilities — show evidence
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
Romance chapters (1)
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
Allegiance history
- Wu · Records · Records vol. 51 「建安九年,領丹楊太守」
Family
| Parents | Sun Jing Records |
|---|---|
| Siblings | Sun Huan(孫奐) Records, Sun Jiao Records |
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.