Warlord
Liu Dai faction 劉岱
About this faction
This faction was a warlord power led by Liu Dai, Inspector of Yan Province at the end of the Eastern Han, who joined the armies against Dong Zhuo and based himself in Yan Province. Liu Dai, courtesy name Gongshan, was the elder brother of Liu Yao; he was serving as a Palace Attendant when Dong Zhuo appointed him Inspector of Yan Province, but on reaching his post he sought to attack Dong Zhuo together with the heads of other provinces and commanderies. In the first month of the 1st year of Chuping (190) he joined the armies east of the passes under Yuan Shao as alliance leader and was stationed at Suanzao. Records, Wu 4 §2Records, Shu 8 §3Records, Wei 6 §10Records, Wei 1 §7–8
Liu Dai killed Qiao Mao, Administrator of Dong Commandery, and made peace with Yuan Shao and Gongsun Zan, but in the 3rd year of Chuping (192) he was killed fighting the million Yellow Turbans of Qing Province who had entered Yan Province. Afterwards Bao Xin and others welcomed Cao Cao from Dong Commandery and had him take charge as Governor of Yan Province. Records, Wei 1 §14 · 20 · 22–23Records, Wei 14 §5
Chen Shou did not give Liu Dai a biography of his own; his affairs are scattered through the Annals of Emperor Wu, Records of Wei 14, Records of Wu 4 and elsewhere. The Romance first presents him in Chapter 5 as the fourth contingent, the Inspector of Yan Province, among the lords who answered Cao Cao's call to arms. Records, Wei 1 §7Records, Wei 14 §5Records, Wu 4 §2Romance, Ch. 5 §7
Rise and fall in the Records
Liu Dai was the elder brother of Liu Yao, a native of Muping in Donglai; his courtesy name was Gongshan, and he served as Palace Attendant and Inspector of Yan Province. Liu Yao's paternal uncle Liu Chong was Grand Commandant of the Han. Dong Zhuo trusted the Master of Writing Zhou Bi, the Colonel of the City Gates Wu Qiong and others, and sent out those they recommended, Han Fu, Liu Dai, Kong Zhou, Zhang Zi, Zhang Miao and others, as heads of provinces and commanderies; at this time Palace Attendant Liu Dai became Inspector of Yan Province. But on reaching their posts they all joined forces to attack Dong Zhuo, and Dong Zhuo, believing that Zhou Bi, Wu Qiong and the others had colluded with them, beheaded them all. Records, Wu 4 §2Records, Shu 8 §3Records, Wei 6 §10
In the first month of the 1st year of Chuping (190), Yuan Shu, Han Fu, Kong Zhou, Liu Dai, Wang Kuang, Yuan Shao, Zhang Miao, Qiao Mao, Yuan Yi and Bao Xin raised troops at the same time and acclaimed Yuan Shao as alliance leader. In the second month, when Dong Zhuo moved the Emperor to Chang'an, Zhang Miao, Liu Dai, Qiao Mao and Yuan Yi were stationed at Suanzao, but Dong Zhuo's troops were strong and no one dared to advance first. When the provinces and commanderies set up an altar and swore an oath at Suanzao, the oath read by Zang Hong said that Liu Dai, Inspector of Yan Province, and the others had gathered loyal troops and were hastening together to the rescue of the state in its distress. Records, Wei 1 §7–8Records, Wei 7 §37–38
Liu Dai fell out with Qiao Mao, Administrator of Dong Commandery, killed him and had Wang Gong serve concurrently as Administrator of Dong Commandery. Records, Wei 1 §14
In the Chuping era Liu Dai was on good terms with both Yuan Shao and Gongsun Zan: Yuan Shao had his wife and children live with Liu Dai, and Gongsun Zan sent his Attendant Officer Fan Fang with cavalry to help Liu Dai. When a rift opened between Yuan Shao and Gongsun Zan, and Gongsun Zan, having defeated Yuan Shao's army, demanded that Liu Dai send away Yuan Shao's wife and children and break with him, Liu Dai could not decide for several days. Cheng Yu, summoned on the recommendation of the Attendant Officer with Separate Carriage Wang Yu, said that abandoning Yuan Shao's nearby support to seek Gongsun Zan's distant help would be like borrowing a man from Yue to save a drowning child, and that Gongsun Zan would in the end be captured by Yuan Shao. Liu Dai followed his advice, and while Fan Fang was returning with his cavalry, Gongsun Zan was heavily defeated by Yuan Shao. Records, Wei 14 §5–7
In the 3rd year of Chuping (192), a million Yellow Turbans from Qing Province entered Yan Province, killed Zheng Sui, Chancellor of Rencheng, and turned toward Dongping. When Liu Dai sought to attack them, Bao Xin, Chancellor of Jibei, remonstrated that the enemy numbered a million and the soldiers had no will to fight, so they should hold firm, build up their strength and attack after the enemy had scattered. Liu Dai did not listen, fought them, and was indeed killed by them. Bao Xin went with the provincial official Wan Qian and others to Dong Commandery to welcome Cao Cao and had him take charge as Governor of Yan Province, and Cao Cao, on coming to Yan Province, summoned and employed Cheng Yu, who had not come when Liu Dai called him. Records, Wei 1 §20 · 22–23Records, Wei 14 §8
In the Romance
In Chapter 5 of the Romance, Liu Dai was named as the fourth contingent, the Inspector of Yan Province, among the lords who answered Cao Cao's call to arms. In Chapter 6, as the lords were dispersing, Liu Dai, whom the Romance calls 'Administrator of Yan Province', tried to borrow grain from Qiao Mao, Administrator of Dong Commandery, and when refused he led his troops into Qiao Mao's camp, killed him and made all his troops surrender. Chapter 15 introduces Liu Yao as the younger brother of Liu Dai, Inspector of Yan Province. Romance, Ch. 5 §7Romance, Ch. 6 §34Romance, Ch. 15 §20
In Chapter 22 the Romance explains that Liu Dai had formerly been Inspector of Yan Province but surrendered when Cao Cao took Yan Province and was employed as a subordinate general. Cao Cao gave 50,000 troops to Liu Dai, commanding the van, and Wang Zhong, commanding the rear, and had them fly the Chancellor's banner and attack Liu Bei in Xu Province, but the two pitched camp a hundred li from Xu Province and only watched for news from Hebei. Pressed to fight, Liu Dai said that as the chief commander he could hardly go first and had them draw lots, and Wang Zhong, who went first, was captured by Guan Yu. Romance, Ch. 22 §31–35 · 40
Liu Bei warned that Liu Dai should not be taken lightly, since he had formerly been Inspector of Yan Province and had been one of the lords commanding a contingent when they attacked Dong Zhuo at Hulao Pass. Liu Dai held firm, but trusting the word of a beaten soldier whom Zhang Fei had deliberately let go, he emptied his camp and set an ambush; he was routed by Zhang Fei's troops, who came in three columns, and was captured by Zhang Fei as he fled. Romance, Ch. 22 §41 · 43–45
Liu Bei untied him with his own hands, entertained him together with Wang Zhong and asked them to explain matters to Cao Cao on his behalf, and the two pledged the old and young of their two households as surety. Trembling before Zhang Fei, who blocked their way home, the two escaped only when Guan Yu restrained him, and begged that they would never come again even if the Chancellor exterminated their three sets of kin. Cao Cao was about to behead them both, but when Kong Rong remonstrated he spared their lives and stripped them of their ranks and stipends. Romance, Ch. 22 §47–52Romance, Ch. 23 §1
Where the Romance differs
Why he killed Qiao Mao: In Chapter 6 of the Romance, Liu Dai tried to borrow grain from Qiao Mao and, when refused, attacked his camp, killed him and took over his troops. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, Liu Dai and Qiao Mao fell out, Liu Dai killed Qiao Mao, and he had Wang Gong serve concurrently as Administrator of Dong Commandery. Romance, Ch. 6 §34Records, Wei 1 §14
His title: Chapter 6 of the Romance calls him 'Administrator of Yan Province'. In the Records, both the Annals of Emperor Wu and Records of Wu 4 call him Inspector of Yan Province. Romance, Ch. 6 §34Records, Wei 1 §7Records, Wu 4 §2
Between Yuan Shao and Gongsun Zan: In Records of Wei 14 of the Records, Liu Dai hesitated for several days between Yuan Shao and Gongsun Zan before following Cheng Yu's advice and staying on Yuan Shao's side. The Liu Dai of the Romance appears only among the lords attacking Dong Zhuo, in the scene where he kills Qiao Mao, and in the fighting at Xu Province; this episode is absent. Records, Wei 14 §5–7Romance, Ch. 5 §7Romance, Ch. 6 §34Romance, Ch. 22 §31
How Yan Province was lost: Chapter 22 of the Romance says that when Cao Cao took Yan Province, Liu Dai surrendered and became a subordinate general. In the Records, in the 3rd year of Chuping (192) Liu Dai ignored Bao Xin's remonstrance, fought the Yellow Turbans of Qing Province and was killed, after which Bao Xin and others welcomed Cao Cao and made him Governor of Yan Province. Romance, Ch. 22 §31Records, Wei 1 §22–23Records, Wei 14 §8
Liu Dai at Xu Province: In Chapters 22 and 23 of the Romance, Liu Dai, the former Inspector of Yan Province, attacked Liu Bei together with Wang Zhong, was captured by Zhang Fei, and after his release lost his ranks and stipends at Cao Cao's hands. The Annals of Emperor Wu and the Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records also record that Cao Cao sent Liu Dai and Wang Zhong to attack Liu Bei without success, but they do not say that this general of Cao Cao's had been Inspector of Yan Province, nor that he was captured. Liu Dai, Inspector of Yan Province, had already died earlier, in the 3rd year of Chuping. Romance, Ch. 22 §31 · 45Romance, Ch. 23 §1Records, Wei 1 §56 · 22–23Records, Shu 2 §16
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Lineage
- Absorbed by: Wei (192~192) — 「迎太祖領兖州牧」(sgz-wei-01:s23) · 「太祖臨兗州」(sgz-wei-14:s8)
- Destroyed by: Yellow Turbans (192~192) — 「岱不從,遂與戰,果爲所殺」 · 「劉岱為黃巾所殺」