Xu Chu 許褚

RecordsRomance Wei Courtesy name 仲康 Zhongkang허저중강호치虎癡许褚虎痴

Profile
OccupationRGeneral · General of the Martial GuardFactionWei
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wei
BornNative placePei Commandery Qiao County
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR17

Profile

Xu Chu, courtesy name Zhongkang, was a native of Qiao County in the State of Qiao. At the end of the Han he gathered young men and several thousand households of his kinsmen, built a fortified wall, and held off bandits; when Cao Cao campaigned through the region of the Huai and Ru rivers, he led his followers over to him. On seeing him, Cao Cao called him "my Fan Kuai," made him Chief Commandant (duwei) that very day, and put him in charge of the palace guard. Records, Wei 18 §48 · 50

Thereafter he always guarded Cao Cao's side, foiling the rebellion plotted by Xu Ta and others, and when fighting Ma Chao at Tong Pass he put Cao Cao aboard a boat and protected him as he crossed the river. Under Cao Pi he became General of the Martial Guard (wuwei jiangjun) and commanded the palace guard troops of the Central Army; under Cao Rui he was raised to Marquis of Mou District, and after his death he received the posthumous title Marquis Zhuang. Records, Wei 18 §50–52 · 56–57

In his assessment, Chen Shou, author of the Records, wrote that Xu Chu and Dian Wei, beating back the enemy's spearhead on the left and right, were like Fan Kuai of the Han. In the Romance he first appeared in Chapter 12 and featured in 31 of its 120 chapters, and his name appeared in the title of Chapter 59, "Xu Chu Strips to Fight Ma Chao." Records, Wei 18 §92Romance, Ch. 12 §27–31Romance, Ch. 59 §10

In the Records

Xu Chu stood over eight chi tall with a waist ten spans around; his bearing was imposing and resolute, and his strength and courage surpassed other men's. At the end of the Han he gathered young men and several thousand households of his kinsmen, and together they strengthened their fortified wall to hold off bandits. When more than ten thousand bandits from Gebei in Runan attacked the wall, Xu Chu's side, few in number, fought hard until utterly exhausted. When their weapons and arrows ran out, Xu Chu had the men and women inside the wall gather stones the size of cups and pecks and place them at the four corners. Records, Wei 18 §48

Xu Chu hurled the stones, and whatever they struck was smashed, so that the bandits dared not advance. When food ran short, he feigned peace with the bandits and agreed to trade oxen for their grain, but the oxen the bandits led away kept running back. Xu Chu went out before the lines and dragged an ox backward by its tail with one hand for more than a hundred paces, and the astonished bandits fled without daring to take the oxen. Because of this, all who heard of it in the region of the Huai, the Ru, Chen, and Liang feared him. Records, Wei 18 §49

When Cao Cao campaigned through the region of the Huai and Ru rivers, Xu Chu led his followers over to him. Impressed at the sight of him, Cao Cao said, "This is my Fan Kuai," appointed him Chief Commandant (duwei) that same day, and put him in charge of the palace guard. The knights-errant who had followed Xu Chu all became Tiger Warriors (hushi). He accompanied the campaign against Zhang Xiu, was first onto the walls, and took heads numbering in the tens of thousands, for which he was promoted to Colonel (xiaowei); he also accompanied the attack on Yuan Shao at Guandu. Records, Wei 18 §50

At that time Xu Ta and other soldiers of the constant retinue plotted rebellion, but because Xu Chu was always in attendance at Cao Cao's side, they feared him and dared not act. Waiting for a day when Xu Chu had withdrawn to rest, Xu Ta and the others came in with knives hidden in their clothes, but Xu Chu, having reached his quarters, felt uneasy and at once returned to his post. When Xu Ta entered the tent, saw Xu Chu, and changed color in great alarm, Xu Chu realized what was happening and struck Xu Ta and the others dead on the spot. Cao Cao drew him still closer and trusted him more, always keeping him at his side whenever he went in or out. For hard fighting at the siege of Ye, he was granted the rank of Marquis Within the Passes (guannei hou). Records, Wei 18 §50–51

When attacking Han Sui and Ma Chao at Tong Pass, Cao Cao, about to cross the Yellow River northward, sent his troops over first and stayed behind on the south bank with only Xu Chu and a hundred-odd Tiger Warriors to guard the rear. When Ma Chao charged in with more than ten thousand infantry and cavalry and arrows poured down like rain, Xu Chu helped Cao Cao into a boat. As the soldiers scrambled to board and the boat was about to sink, Xu Chu cut down those clinging to it and raised a saddle in his left hand to shield Cao Cao. When the boatman was struck dead by an arrow, he rowed the boat with his right hand and barely got across. Chen Shou wrote that had it not been for Xu Chu that day, Cao Cao would have come close to disaster. Records, Wei 18 §51–52

Later, when Cao Cao met Han Sui and Ma Chao to talk, each side riding out on a single horse, he took only Xu Chu with him. Ma Chao, trusting his own strength, meant to lunge at Cao Cao, but suspecting that the rider in attendance was Xu Chu, he asked, "I hear you have one called the Tiger Marquis (huhou). Where is he?" When Cao Cao pointed to Xu Chu, Xu Chu glared at him with wide-open eyes, and Ma Chao dared not move. A few days later, when Ma Chao and the others were routed in battle, Xu Chu cut off enemy heads with his own hand, and he was promoted to General of the Household of the Martial Guard (wuwei zhonglang jiang). The title "Martial Guard" originated at this time. In the army he was called the Tiger Fool (huchi), because his strength was like a tiger's but he was simple-minded; that was why Ma Chao asked about the Tiger Marquis, and everyone in the realm took it to be his name. Records, Wei 18 §53–54

Xu Chu was cautious by nature and upheld the law, weighty in manner and sparing of words. When Cao Ren came from Jing Province to attend court, he met Xu Chu outside the hall and called him to come sit and talk in a side room, but Xu Chu said, "The King is about to come out," and went back inside the hall. To someone who reproached him for this, Xu Chu replied that although Cao Ren was a kinsman and an important minister, he was a guardian of the outer frontier, while Xu Chu himself was a servant attending within, so talking where many were present was enough. Hearing of this, Cao Cao cherished him all the more and promoted him to General of the Firm Center (zhongjian jiangjun). Records, Wei 18 §55–56

When Cao Cao died, Xu Chu wailed until he vomited blood. When Cao Pi ascended the throne, he advanced Xu Chu's fief to Marquis of Wansui Precinct and made him General of the Martial Guard (wuwei jiangjun), commanding the palace guard troops of the Central Army. Earlier, Cao Cao had judged all the Tiger Warriors under Xu Chu to be stalwart men and made them officers on the same day; of these, dozens later earned merit to become generals and be enfeoffed as marquises, and more than a hundred became Chief Commandants and Colonels, all of them swordsmen. Records, Wei 18 §56

When Cao Rui ascended the throne, he raised Xu Chu to Marquis of Mou District with a fief of 700 households and granted one of his sons the rank of Marquis Within the Passes. When Xu Chu died, he was given the posthumous title Marquis Zhuang, and his son Xu Yi succeeded him. During the Taihe era, Cao Rui, mindful of Xu Chu's loyalty and filial devotion, praised him in an edict and again granted two of his descendants the rank of Marquis Within the Passes. Later, when Zhong Hui invaded Shu, dividing his forces to enter by the Xie Valley and the Luo Valley, Xu Yi went ahead as a Gate Commander (yamen jiang) to clear the road; when a hole in a bridge trapped a horse's hoof, Zhong Hui had him beheaded. The biography of Zhong Hui recorded that he was not pardoned even though he was the son of Xu Chu, who had rendered service to the royal house. Records, Wei 18 §57Records, Wei 28 §102–103

In his assessment, Chen Shou said that Xu Chu and Dian Wei, beating back the enemy's spearhead on the left and right, were indeed like Fan Kuai of the Han. Records, Wei 18 §92

In the Romance

He first appeared in Chapter 12 of the Romance as a stalwart who, in a single bout, seized He Yi of the Yellow Turbans as he fled toward Gebei and carried him off under his arm. Eight chi tall with a waist ten spans around, he fought Dian Wei, who had come in pursuit, from early morning until dusk without either gaining the upper hand. Cao Cao had Dian Wei feign defeat, dug a pit to trap and capture him, and then untied his bonds with his own hands. Xu Chu told how he had driven off bandits by hurling stones and had dragged two oxen by their tails with both hands for more than a hundred paces, then surrendered and became a Chief Commandant. In the same chapter he fought Lü Bu at Puyang for 20 bouts. Romance, Ch. 12 §27–33 · 37

In Chapter 14 he cut down Li Xian, nephew of Li Jue, with a single stroke, then also slew Li Bie, who had tumbled from his horse in fright, and came back carrying both heads; Cao Cao patted him on the back and said, "You truly are my Fan Kuai!" In Chapter 33, at the east gate of Ye, he killed Xu You, who was boasting of his own merit, with his sword, and was sharply rebuked by Cao Cao for it. Romance, Ch. 14 §13Romance, Ch. 33 §7–8

At the banquet at the Bronze Sparrow Terrace in Chapter 56, trying to seize the brocade battle robe that Xu Huang had won at archery, he dragged Xu Huang out of his saddle and grappled with him by the collar, and the robe was torn to shreds. In Chapter 58, when Ma Chao pursued Cao Cao, who was trying to cross the Wei River, to within a hundred-odd paces, he carried Cao Cao on his back and leapt aboard a boat. He hacked with his sword at the hands gripping the gunwales, raised a saddle in his left hand to fend off the arrows, and drove the boat along by gripping the rudder between his legs and pushing with a pole in one hand. Romance, Ch. 56 §15–16Romance, Ch. 58 §41–44

In Chapter 59, when Ma Chao asked where the Tiger Marquis was, he shouted, "I am Xu Chu of Qiao Commandery!" and made Ma Chao draw back, and from then on the army called him the Tiger Marquis. The next day he fought Ma Chao for over a hundred bouts, then changed horses and fought over a hundred more without a decision, whereupon he threw off his helmet and armor, went out stripped to the skin, and fought over thirty bouts more. Clamping Ma Chao's spear under his arm and wrestling for it, he snapped the shaft, and the two traded blows each holding half; when Cao Cao sent out Xiahou Yuan and Cao Hong and the fighting turned into a melee, he was struck in the arm by two arrows. Ma Chao said he had never seen anyone fight as fiercely as Xu Chu and called him "a true Tiger Fool." Romance, Ch. 59 §6–12

At Ruxu in Chapter 61, when Sun Quan's cavalry gave chase, he held off Han Dang and Zhou Tai so that Cao Cao could return to camp. In Chapter 66, on a night when Cao Cao lay drunk, he stood guard at the hall door leaning on his sword and refused to let Cao Ren in, saying that though Cao Ren was a kinsman he was an official of an outer garrison; Cao Cao exclaimed that he was "truly a loyal subject." In Chapter 72, escorting grain supplies, he set out on the road at night while heavily drunk, was stabbed in the shoulder by Zhang Fei's spear, fell from his horse, and lost all the grain. Romance, Ch. 61 §39–40Romance, Ch. 66 §52–53Romance, Ch. 72 §14–17

In Chapter 79, on Cao Pi's orders, he led 3,000 men of the Tiger Guard to Linzi, beheaded the garrison commander who barred his way, bound Cao Zhi, Ding Yi (丁儀), Ding Yi (丁廙), and others, who lay collapsed in drink, and sent them under escort to Ye Commandery. In Chapter 86, on Cao Pi's campaign against Wu, he guarded the central army together with Lü Qian. In Chapter 116, Zhong Hui made his son Xu Yi the vanguard and then had him beheaded because a horse's hoof sank through a bridge, refusing to listen even when the generals pleaded for pardon on account of his father Xu Chu's merit. Romance, Ch. 79 §10Romance, Ch. 86 §28Romance, Ch. 116 §4 · 19–20

Where the Romance differs

Coming over to Cao Cao: In Chapter 12 of the Romance, he fought Dian Wei at Gebei, fell into a pit dug on Cao Cao's orders, was captured, and then surrendered. In the Records he led his followers over when Cao Cao campaigned through the region of the Huai and Ru rivers, and neither the fight with Dian Wei nor the pit appears in the biography of Xu Chu. Romance, Ch. 12 §28–30Records, Wei 18 §47–57

The stronghold at Gebei: In Chapter 12 of the Romance, Xu Chu said he had gathered several hundred of his kinsmen and dragged two oxen by their tails with both hands. In the Records he gathered young men and several thousand households of his kinsmen, and dragged an ox backward by its tail with one hand for more than a hundred paces. Romance, Ch. 12 §31–32Records, Wei 18 §48–49

"My Fan Kuai": In Chapter 14 of the Romance, Cao Cao said this when Xu Chu came back carrying the heads of Li Xian and Li Bie. In the Records, Cao Cao said it when Xu Chu first came over, impressed at the sight of him. Romance, Ch. 14 §13Records, Wei 18 §50

Xu You: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, Xu Chu killed the insolent Xu You with his sword, and Cao Cao rebuked him. The biography of Xu Chu in the Records does not contain this episode, and the biography of Cui Yan recorded that Xu You, presuming on old ties, behaved disrespectfully and was put to death. Romance, Ch. 33 §7–8Records, Wei 18 §47–57Records, Wei 12 §19

The river-crossing boat: In Chapter 58 of the Romance, Xu Chu carried Cao Cao on his back and leapt aboard, then gripped the rudder between his legs and pushed the boat along with a pole. In the Records he helped Cao Cao into the boat and, when the boatman was struck dead by an arrow, rowed with his right hand. Both accounts agree that he raised a saddle in his left hand to shield Cao Cao. Romance, Ch. 58 §42–44Records, Wei 18 §52

Tiger Marquis and Tiger Fool: In Chapter 59 of the Romance, the army called him the Tiger Marquis after Xu Chu shouted, "I am Xu Chu of Qiao Commandery!" In the Records, Ma Chao asked about the Tiger Marquis because the army called Xu Chu the Tiger Fool for being as strong as a tiger but simple-minded, and Xu Chu glared at him with wide-open eyes. Romance, Ch. 59 §6–7Records, Wei 18 §53–54

The duel with Ma Chao: The scene in Chapter 59 of the Romance in which he fought Ma Chao stripped to the skin and snapped the spear shaft does not appear in the biography of Xu Chu in the Records. The Records states only that when Ma Chao and the others were routed a few days later, Xu Chu cut off enemy heads with his own hand. Romance, Ch. 59 §9–11Records, Wei 18 §53

Turning away Cao Ren: In Chapter 66 of the Romance, on a night when Cao Cao lay drunk, Xu Chu stood guard at the hall door leaning on his sword and would not let Cao Ren in. In the Records, the episode was that when Cao Ren came to attend court and called Xu Chu from outside the hall to talk in a side room, Xu Chu said the King was about to come out and went back inside the hall. Romance, Ch. 66 §52–53Records, Wei 18 §55

The wound from Zhang Fei: The story in Chapter 72 of the Romance in which he was drunk, stabbed in the shoulder by Zhang Fei's spear, and robbed of the grain supplies does not appear in the biography of Xu Chu in the Records. Romance, Ch. 72 §15–17Records, Wei 18 §47–57

Arresting Cao Zhi: In Chapter 79 of the Romance, Xu Chu went to Linzi and brought back Cao Zhi, Ding Yi (丁儀), Ding Yi (丁廙), and others in bonds. The biography of Xu Chu in the Records does not contain this, and the biography of Prince Si of Chen recorded that when Cao Pi took the throne as king, he put both Ding Yis and the male members of their families to death, and that Cao Zhi went to his fief together with the other lords. Romance, Ch. 79 §10Records, Wei 18 §47–57Records, Wei 19 §18

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA5545−10
  • STR9493−1
  • INT2522−3
  • POL3230−2
  • CHA6550−15
  • VIR9082−8
  • ADP7055−15
  • SCH3130−1
  • DIP3030±0
  • DIS4035−5
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

CharismaR65N50 −15

RGathered several thousand households of kinsmen; the knights-errant who followed him became generals and colonelsWei 18 §48Wei 18 §56

NSummoned several hundred of his kinsmen and surrendered together with themCh. 12 §31

AdaptabilityR70N55 −15

RAt Tong Pass judged the moment to withdraw; would not meet privately with Cao Ren of the ruling clanWei 18 §52Wei 18 §55

NSaved Cao Cao by carrying him onto the boat, but ruined matters through drinkCh. 58 §42Ch. 72 §15

LeadershipR55N45 −10

RLed the Tiger Warriors and commanded the palace guard troops — few records of commanding in battleWei 18 §56

NWhile escorting grain, pushed through rough terrain drunk and lost it to Zhang FeiCh. 72 §14

7 similar abilities — show evidence
  • StrengthR94N93 −1

    RStrength and courage beyond other men; drove off bandits by dragging an ox by its tail; assessment: likened to Fan KuaiWei 18 §48Wei 18 §52Wei 18 §92

    NFought Ma Chao for over 200 bouts; Ma Chao said no one fought as fiercely as Xu ChuCh. 59 §9Ch. 12 §28Ch. 12 §37

  • IntelligenceR25N22 −3

    RCalled the Tiger Fool for being as strong as a tiger but simple-mindedWei 18 §54

    NTrusting in courage enough to face ten thousand men, entered rough terrain by nightCh. 72 §15

  • PoliticsR32UnverifiedN30Unverified −2

    RNo direct record — estimated from his role as a law-abiding palace guard commanderWei 18 §55

    NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a palace guard commanderCh. 66 §53

  • VirtueR90N82 −8

    RCautious and law-abiding; vomited blood after Cao Cao's death; his loyalty and filial devotion were honoredWei 18 §55Wei 18 §56

    NGuarded the drunken, sleeping Cao Cao and barred Cao Ren, and Cao Cao called him a loyal subjectCh. 66 §52

  • ScholarshipR31UnverifiedN30Unverified −1

    RNo direct record — estimated from his being a taciturn palace guard commanderWei 18 §55

    NNo direct record — estimated from the fact that only his martial prowess is describedCh. 12 §31

  • DiplomacyR30N30Unverified ±0

    RRecorded as weighty in manner and sparing of wordsWei 18 §55

    NNo direct record — no more than issuing a challenge by letterCh. 59 §8

  • DiscernmentR40UnverifiedN35Unverified −5

    RNo direct record — estimated from his leading the Tiger WarriorsWei 18 §56

    NNo direct record — estimated from the absence of any record of recommending talentCh. 12 §33

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (31)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wei · Records · Records vol. 18 「褚以眾歸太祖」

Family

ChildrenXu Yi(許儀) Romance

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related events (13)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).

Related works (1)

Linked via Wikidata "depicts" and character names in titles (unverified) — not yet reviewed.