RJoined the faction that made Liu Cong heir, turning the brothers into enemiesWei 6 §91
NPlotted to kill Liu Bei, forged the will, and beheaded Li Gui for remonstratingCh. 34 §24Ch. 40 §16Ch. 40 §18
| Occupation | NGeneral · Grand Commander of the Navy | Faction | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | |
| Born | Native place | Xiangyang Commandery | |
| Cause of death | NExecuted Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R3 |
Cai Mao has no separate biography in the Records, and in Chen Shou's main text his name appears once, in the Biography of Liu Biao. When Liu Biao and his wife loved their youngest son Liu Cong and wanted to make him heir, he and Zhang Yun formed Liu Cong's faction, and when the eldest son Liu Qi went out as Administrator of Jiangxia, Liu Cong became heir. Records, Wei 6 §91
After Liu Biao died in the 13th year of Jian'an (208), Liu Cong surrendered to Cao Cao. Chen Shou's main text records neither what Cai Mao did in this surrender nor his later career and death. Records, Wei 1 §104Records, Wei 6 §91–94
In his assessment Chen Shou said that Yuan Shao and Liu Biao both set aside the rightful heir and set up a lesser son, so that their heirs were overthrown, but he did not name Cai Mao. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 6 as 'Cai Mao, a man of Xiangyang', and he appears in 11 of its 120 chapters, though his name is in no chapter title. As the elder brother of Liu Biao's second wife he tries to harm Liu Bei and sets up Liu Cong, then becomes Cao Cao's Grand Commander of the Navy, but in Chapter 45 he is beheaded by Cao Cao, who has fallen for Zhou Yu's ruse. Records, Wei 6 §96Romance, Ch. 6 §36Romance, Ch. 7 §37Romance, Ch. 34 §24Romance, Ch. 40 §16–18Romance, Ch. 41 §23Romance, Ch. 45 §53–54
In Chen Shou's main text Cai Mao appears once, in the passage of the Biography of Liu Biao on his youngest son Liu Cong. At first Liu Biao and his wife loved their youngest son Liu Cong and wanted to make him heir, and Cai Mao and Zhang Yun formed his faction. So the eldest son Liu Qi was sent out as Administrator of Jiangxia, the faction at last upheld Liu Cong as heir, and Liu Qi and Liu Cong became enemies because of this. Chen Shou's main text does not record Cai Mao's courtesy name, origin or offices. Records, Wei 6 §90–91
The Biography of Zhuge Liang also records that Liu Biao, listening to his second wife, favored his younger son Liu Cong and did not like Liu Qi. Liu Qi asked Zhuge Liang how to keep himself safe, and when Huang Zu happened to die, he went out and became Administrator of Jiangxia. The Biography of Zhuge Liang does not mention Cai Mao separately in this passage. Records, Shu 5 §9–10
In the autumn, the 7th month, of the 13th year of Jian'an (208), Cao Cao marched south against Liu Biao. In the 8th month Liu Biao died, and Liu Cong succeeded him and was stationed at Xiangyang. Kuai Yue, Han Song, the Officer of the Eastern Bureau Fu Xun and others urged Liu Cong to submit to Taizu, and when Liu Cong asked what would be wrong with holding the land of Chu and watching the realm, Fu Xun answered, citing the course of rebellion and obedience and the balance of strength and weakness, that not even Liu Bei could hold off Lord Cao. In the 9th month, when Cao Cao reached Xinye, Liu Cong at last surrendered. The Biography of Liu Biao records that when Taizu's army reached Xiangyang, Liu Cong surrendered with the whole province. Records, Wei 1 §104Records, Wei 6 §89 · 91–93
Taizu made Liu Cong Inspector of Qing Province and enfeoffed him as a full marquis. Fifteen men, Kuai Yue among them, were enfeoffed as marquises; Kuai Yue became Superintendent of the Imperial Household, Han Song became Grand Herald, and most of the rest also rose to high office. Chen Shou's main text does not name Cai Mao in this surrender and enfeoffment, nor does it record what became of him afterwards. Records, Wei 6 §91–94
In his assessment Chen Shou said that Yuan Shao and Liu Biao both had an imposing appearance and the bearing of capable men, but were outwardly tolerant and inwardly jealous, set aside the rightful heir and set up a lesser son, and abandoned propriety in favor of affection, so that it was no misfortune that their heirs were overthrown and their states toppled and fell. Cai Mao does not appear in this assessment. Records, Wei 6 §96
In Chapter 6 of the Romance, Cai Mao appears as 'a man of Xiangyang' who, together with Kuai Liang and Kuai Yue, assists Liu Biao. On the orders of Liu Biao, who has received Yuan Shao's letter, he and Kuai Yue lead ten thousand troops to block Sun Jian, but he is struck on his breastplate mirror by Huang Gai's whip and flees. In Chapter 7 he rejects Kuai Liang's plan to hold firm as 'a clumsy plan' and encamps on Mount Xian, but this man, whom Sun Jian calls 'the elder brother of Liu Biao's second wife', is beaten by Cheng Pu within a few bouts and flees to Xiangyang. Kuai Liang says he should be beheaded under military law, but Liu Biao, who has newly married his sister, does not punish him. Romance, Ch. 6 §36–37Romance, Ch. 7 §36–38
In Chapter 31, when Sun Qian says that Liu Bei wishes to take refuge with Liu Biao, Cai Mao slanderously proposes cutting off Sun Qian's head and presenting it to Cao Cao, and is rebuked by Liu Biao. In Chapter 34 he plots with his sister Lady Cai to kill Liu Bei at his lodging, but when Yi Ji warns Liu Bei in advance and he leaves, Cai Mao writes a poem on the wall and tells Liu Biao that Liu Bei has left behind a rebellious poem. Romance, Ch. 31 §40–42Romance, Ch. 34 §9 · 23–26
In the same chapter Cai Mao has a gathering of officials held at Xiangyang; he has his younger brother Cai He guard the main road to Mount Xian at the east gate, Cai Zhong the area outside the south gate and Cai Xun the area outside the north gate, and lays an ambush of five hundred troops inside the city. When Liu Bei, tipped off by Yi Ji, slips out through the west gate, Cai Mao pursues him with five hundred troops as far as the Tan Stream, but Liu Bei leaps across the stream on his horse Dilu. In Chapter 35, when Liu Biao, having heard what happened from Sun Qian, orders him beheaded, Lady Cai weeps and pleads for him and Sun Qian says, 'If you kill Cai Mao, the Imperial Uncle will not be able to stay here in peace,' so he is let off with a rebuke. Romance, Ch. 34 §30–31 · 36–37 · 39–42 · 44Romance, Ch. 35 §20–21
In Chapter 40, on Lady Cai's orders, Cai Mao guards the outer gate with Zhang Yun and turns away Liu Qi, who has come to visit his sick father. When Liu Biao dies, he forges a will with Lady Cai and Zhang Yun to set up Liu Cong as lord of Jing Province, and has the staff officer Li Gui, who denounces them for deposing the eldest and setting up the young son, dragged out and beheaded. In Chapter 41 he has arrows shot at Liu Bei, who has reached the walls of Xiangyang, and is reviled by Wei Yan as a 'traitor who sold out the state'. Romance, Ch. 40 §13–14 · 16–18Romance, Ch. 41 §10–11
In the same chapter Cai Mao goes with Zhang Yun to Fancheng and reports to Cao Cao that the troops of Jing Province number 280,000 in all and its warships, large and small, more than 7,000, and he is made Marquis Who Guards the South and Grand Commander of the Navy. When Xun You calls them a band of flatterers, Cao Cao replies that he is using them for the time being because the northern troops are not used to fighting on water. Romance, Ch. 41 §22–24
In Chapter 45, at Sanjiangkou, Cai Mao sends out his younger brother Cai Xun and loses him to Gan Ning's arrow, and with Zhang Yun he builds a water camp along the river with twenty-four water gates. Zhou Yu, who spies on it, judges that he can defeat Cao Cao only after first getting rid of the two men. When Jiang Gan steals from Zhou Yu's tent a letter inscribed 'Respectfully sealed by Cai Mao and Zhang Yun', Cao Cao beheads Cai Mao, who answers that the troops are not yet well trained, together with Zhang Yun, and only then realizes that he has fallen for a ruse. Romance, Ch. 45 §27–28 · 31 · 33 · 47–48 · 53–54
Origin and family: Chapters 6 and 7 of the Romance describe Cai Mao as 'a man of Xiangyang' and as the elder brother of Liu Biao's second wife. Chen Shou's main text in the Records records neither Cai Mao's origin nor his relationship to Liu Biao, saying only that when Liu Biao and his wife loved Liu Cong, he and Zhang Yun belonged to Liu Cong's faction. Romance, Ch. 6 §36Romance, Ch. 7 §37–38Records, Wei 6 §91
The fight with Sun Jian: In Chapters 6 and 7 of the Romance, Cai Mao tries to block Sun Jian and is beaten in turn by Huang Gai and Cheng Pu. The Biography of Liu Biao in the Records only records that Sun Jian, attacking Liu Biao on Yuan Shu's orders, was struck by a stray arrow and died, and Cai Mao does not appear in this fighting. Romance, Ch. 6 §37Romance, Ch. 7 §37Records, Wei 6 §83
The attempt on Liu Bei's life: In Chapter 34 of the Romance, Cai Mao tries to kill Liu Bei at his lodging and at the gathering in Xiangyang, and Liu Bei escapes by leaping across the Tan Stream on his horse Dilu. The Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records records that when the men of mark of Jing Province flocked to Liu Bei, Liu Biao himself suspected his intentions and secretly guarded against him, and the Biography of Liu Biao records that Liu Biao treated Liu Bei generously but could not make use of him. There is no record that Cai Mao tried to harm Liu Bei. Romance, Ch. 34 §24 · 39–44Records, Shu 2 §19Records, Wei 6 §89
How Liu Cong was set up: In Chapter 40 of the Romance, after Liu Biao's death Lady Cai, Cai Mao and Zhang Yun forge a will to set up Liu Cong and behead Li Gui, who opposes them. In the Records, while Liu Biao was still alive, he and his wife wanted to make Liu Cong heir and sent Liu Qi out as Administrator of Jiangxia, and Cai Mao and Zhang Yun belonged to that faction. The forged will and Li Gui do not appear. Romance, Ch. 40 §16–18Records, Wei 6 §91
Before the walls of Xiangyang: In Chapter 41 of the Romance, when Liu Bei calls for Liu Cong at the east gate of Xiangyang, Cai Mao and Zhang Yun have arrows shot at him. The Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records records only that Liu Bei stopped his horse and called out to Liu Cong, but Liu Cong was too afraid to get up, and Cai Mao does not appear. Romance, Ch. 41 §10Records, Shu 2 §20
The surrender and his treatment afterwards: In Chapter 41 of the Romance, Cai Mao goes with Zhang Yun to Fancheng to meet Cao Cao and becomes Marquis Who Guards the South and Grand Commander of the Navy. In the Records, those who urged Liu Cong to submit were Kuai Yue, Han Song and Fu Xun, and the text says only that Cao Cao enfeoffed fifteen men, Kuai Yue among them, as marquises; Cai Mao's name and office are absent. Romance, Ch. 41 §22–23Records, Wei 6 §91–94Records, Wei 1 §104
Death: In Chapter 45 of the Romance, Cai Mao is beheaded by Cao Cao because of the letter Jiang Gan stole from Zhou Yu's tent, and Cao Cao entrusts his post to Mao Jie and Yu Jin. After his single appearance in the Biography of Liu Biao, Chen Shou's main text in the Records does not mention Cai Mao again, so his death does not appear. Romance, Ch. 45 §47 · 54 · 57Records, Wei 6 §91–94
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RJoined the faction that made Liu Cong heir, turning the brothers into enemiesWei 6 §91
NPlotted to kill Liu Bei, forged the will, and beheaded Li Gui for remonstratingCh. 34 §24Ch. 40 §16Ch. 40 §18
RNo direct record — estimated from his standing as a senior retainer under Liu BiaoWei 6 §91
NTrained the navy so well that Zhou Yu was worried; routed at Mount XianCh. 45 §33Ch. 45 §57Ch. 7 §38
RNo direct record — estimated from the record of his forming the faction that upheld Liu CongWei 6 §91
NReviled as a traitor who sold out the stateCh. 41 §11Ch. 41 §21
RNo direct record — estimated from his standing as a senior retainer under Liu BiaoWei 6 §91
NManaged the troops of Jing Province and more than 7,000 warshipsCh. 41 §22Ch. 41 §23
RNo direct record — estimated from his standing as a senior retainer under Liu BiaoWei 6 §91
NFlattered Cao Cao and obtained the post of Grand Commander of the NavyCh. 41 §22Ch. 41 §23
RNo direct record — estimated from his standing as a senior retainer under Liu BiaoWei 6 §91
NHis words and manner before Cao Cao were thoroughly sycophanticCh. 41 §22
NMaster +25 Seeing his water camp, Zhou Yu was astonished that he had deeply grasped the secrets of naval warfareCh. 45 §31Ch. 45 §33
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
| Siblings | Cai Xun Unverified Romance, Lady Cai Romance |
|---|
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).