Rebellion · Coup
Coup of Cao Mao 賈充弒君
About this event
The Coup of Cao Mao was the incident in which, on the jichou day of the 5th month of the 5th year of Ganlu (260) in Wei, the emperor Cao Mao (the Duke of Gaogui Village) drew his sword, led his attendants out through the Yunlong Gate, was struck down among the ranks of soldiers and died at the age of twenty. The General-in-Chief Sima Zhao said that Cheng Ji, a Retainer of the Crown Prince, had recklessly burst into the ranks and harmed the Duke, dealt with Cheng Ji under military law and handed his family over to the Commandant of Justice. The Duke of Gaogui Village was buried with the rites of a prince, and Cao Huang, the Duke of Changdao Village, was brought in to succeed Emperor Ming. Records, Wei 4 §98 · 101 · 104–105 · 107–109
Chen Shou recorded this affair in the Annals of the Three Young Emperors, Records of Wei 4, through the Empress Dowager's decree and Sima Zhao's memorial, and recorded in Records of Wei 9 that the Master of Writing Wang Jing was executed for his involvement in the affair of the Duke of Gaogui Village. The Romance depicts the affair in the first part of Chapter 114, "Cao Mao Dies at the Southern Gate; Jiang Wei Abandons His Grain to Defeat the Wei Army." Records, Wei 4 §97–110Records, Wei 9 §130Romance, Ch. 114 §4–23
Course of events in the Records
In the 4th month, in summer, of the 5th year of Ganlu (260), the emperor had the officials in charge carry out his earlier command, raising the General-in-Chief Sima Zhao to Chancellor of State, enfeoffing him as Duke of Jin and adding the Nine Bestowments. On the jichou day of the 5th month, Cao Mao, the Duke of Gaogui Village, died at the age of twenty. Records, Wei 4 §97–98
The Empress Dowager issued a decree setting out the Duke of Gaogui Village's offenses. According to her, he was violent by nature and grew angrier the more he was rebuked, slandered her and cut off contact between the two palaces, shot at her palace with a crossbow, and, on hearing that she had repeatedly told the General-in-Chief he should be deposed, bribed her attendants to put poison into her medicine. When the plot came to light, he meant to raise troops, enter the Western Palace to kill her and seize the General-in-Chief, and showed the edict he carried in his robe to the Palace Attendant Wang Chen, the Cavalier Regular Attendant Wang Ye and the Master of Writing Wang Jing, but Wang Chen and Wang Ye immediately informed the General-in-Chief. The Duke of Gaogui Village led his attendants out through the Yunlong Gate, beating war drums, drew his sword himself and went in among the ranks of soldiers, where he was struck down by the vanguard. Records, Wei 4 §98–101
The Empress Dowager ordered that he be buried with the rites of a commoner and that Wang Jing and his family be handed over to the Commandant of Justice. On the gengyin day, when the Grand Tutor Sima Fu, the General-in-Chief Sima Zhao, the Grand Commandant Gao Rou and the Minister over the Masses Zheng Chong asked that, as a further act of grace, he be buried with the rites of a prince, the Empress Dowager agreed. Wei sent the Central Protector of the Army Sima Yan to bring Cao Huang, the Duke of Changdao Village, to succeed Emperor Ming, and Sima Zhao firmly declined the posts of Chancellor of State and Duke of Jin and the Nine Bestowments. Records, Wei 4 §102–106
On the wushen day Sima Zhao submitted a memorial saying that when the Duke of Gaogui Village, leading his escort troops, drew his sword and came toward his quarters beating gongs and drums, he had ordered his officers and men not to harm him, but that Cheng Ji, Retainer of the Crown Prince and younger brother of the Cavalry Commander Cheng Cui, had recklessly burst into the ranks and harmed the Duke, causing his death. He had at once arrested Cheng Ji and applied military law, and under the law on great sedition and impiety had handed Cheng Ji's family over to the Commandant of Justice for judgment. The Empress Dowager thought Cheng Ji could not simply be treated as guilty of great sedition, but granted the request as submitted, saying that the General-in-Chief was earnest in his wish. Wang Jing was executed for his involvement in the affair of the Duke of Gaogui Village. Records, Wei 4 §107–110Records, Wei 9 §130
In the Romance
In Chapter 114 of the Romance, Jia Chong reports that Cao Mao, in his "Poem of the Hidden Dragon" about a dragon trapped in a well, likened Sima Zhao to a loach, and Sima Zhao is enraged. In the 4th month, in summer, of the 5th year of Ganlu, Sima Zhao goes up into the hall wearing his sword, extracts the dukedom of Jin and the Nine Bestowments, and demands an explanation of the poem. Cao Mao summons Wang Chen, Wang Jing and Wang Ye and says he will attack Sima Zhao, and when Wang Jing tries to stop him, he says that if this can be endured, what cannot be endured, and goes to inform the Empress Dowager. Romance, Ch. 114 §4–9
Wang Chen and Wang Ye hurry to report to Sima Zhao, and Cao Mao has Jiao Bo gather the palace guards, the servants and others, over three hundred men, mounts his carriage sword in hand and sets out for the Southern Gate Towers. Heading for the Yunlong Gate, Cao Mao runs into Jia Chong leading Cheng Cui, Cheng Ji and the iron-armored palace troops, and when Jia Chong says that Lord Sima wants only a dead man, Cheng Ji stabs Cao Mao to death with his halberd. Romance, Ch. 114 §10–13
Sima Zhao pretends to be greatly shocked and weeps. When Chen Tai says that only beheading Jia Chong would offer the realm even a small apology, Sima Zhao shifts the blame to Cheng Ji, exterminates his three sets of kin, and has the tongue cut out of Cheng Ji, who cries out that Jia Chong had passed on the order. Wang Jing goes to his execution smiling, together with his mother. Sima Zhao rebuffs Jia Chong and the others who urge him to accept an abdication, and in the 6th month sets up Cao Huang, the Duke of Changdao Village, and has him change his name to Cao Huan. Romance, Ch. 114 §14–23
Where the Romance differs
Jia Chong: In Chapter 114 of the Romance, Jia Chong reports the "Poem of the Hidden Dragon," leads out the palace troops and orders Cheng Ji to kill. Jia Chong does not appear in Chen Shou's text, and Sima Zhao's memorial states that Cheng Ji, younger brother of the Cavalry Commander Cheng Cui, recklessly burst into the ranks. Romance, Ch. 114 §4–6 · 12–13Records, Wei 4 §107
The cause of the rising: In Chapter 114 of the Romance, Cao Mao rises up saying that Sima Zhao harbors designs of usurpation and he cannot sit and suffer the disgrace of deposition. In Chen Shou's text, the Empress Dowager's decree states that the Duke of Gaogui Village slandered her and plotted to poison her, and when this came to light meant to kill her and seize the General-in-Chief. Romance, Ch. 114 §8–9Records, Wei 4 §98–100
Chen Tai: In Chapter 114 of the Romance, the Deputy Director of the Imperial Secretariat Chen Tai comes in mourning clothes and says that Jia Chong must be beheaded. The biography of Chen Tai in Chen Shou's text does not have this episode and only states that he died in the 1st year of Jingyuan (260) and was posthumously made Minister of Works. Romance, Ch. 114 §15–16Records, Wei 22 §56
The funeral of the Duke of Gaogui Village: In Chapter 114 of the Romance, the Grand Tutor Sima Fu asks that he be buried with the rites of a prince. In Chen Shou's text, when the Empress Dowager ordered that he be buried with the rites of a commoner, Sima Fu, Sima Zhao, Gao Rou and Zheng Chong together asked for the rites of a prince. Romance, Ch. 114 §22Records, Wei 4 §102–104
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Belligerents
| Item | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| Factions | ||
| Commanders | Cao Mao(曹髦), Wang Jing | Jia Chong, Sima Zhao, Cheng Ji(成濟) |
Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 4 §98