Battle
Battle of Changban 長坂坡之戰
About this event
The Battle of Changban was the battle of the 13th year of Jian'an (208) in which Cao Cao, who had come south to attack Jing Province, pursued with elite cavalry Liu Bei, who was fleeing south from Fan, caught up with him at Changban in Dangyang and broke him. After Liu Cong surrendered, Liu Bei, leading a host of more than a hundred thousand and a baggage train of several thousand carts, was making ten-odd li a day when he was overtaken by Cao Cao's 5,000 horsemen, who had ridden more than three hundred li in a day and a night. Liu Bei abandoned his wife and children and fled with a few dozen horsemen including Zhuge Liang, Zhang Fei and Zhao Yun, met Guan Yu's boats at Hanjin, and reached Xiakou. Records, Wei 1 §104Records, Shu 2 §20–23
Chen Shou recorded this battle in greatest detail in the Biography of the First Sovereign (Records of Shu 2), and also included parts of it in the passages on Guan Yu, Zhang Fei and Zhao Yun in the Biographies of Guan, Zhang, Ma, Huang and Zhao (Records of Shu 6), the passage on Empress Gan in the Biographies of the Consorts and Sons of the Two Rulers (Records of Shu 4), the Biography of Zhuge Liang (Records of Shu 5), the Annals of Emperor Wu (Records of Wei 1), the passage on Cao Chun in the Biographies of the Xiahou and Cao Clans (Records of Wei 9), the biography of Wen Pin (Records of Wei 18), and the biography of Lu Su (Records of Wu 9). The Romance depicts this battle in Chapter 41, "Zhao Yun Rescues His Lord Single-Handed," and Chapter 42, "Zhang Yide raises havoc at Changban Bridge; Liu of Yuzhou flees in defeat to the Hanjin ford." Records, Shu 2 §20–23Records, Shu 6 §7 · 15–16 · 39Records, Shu 4 §3Records, Shu 5 §10Records, Wei 1 §104Records, Wei 9 §46Records, Wei 18 §35Records, Wu 9 §42Romance, Ch. 41 §31 · 36Romance, Ch. 42 §8 · 17–18
Course of events in the Records
In the 7th month of autumn in the 13th year of Jian'an (208) Cao Cao set out south to attack Liu Biao; in the 8th month Liu Biao died and his son Liu Cong succeeded him and was stationed at Xiangyang, while Liu Bei was stationed at Fan. In the 9th month, when Cao Cao reached Xinye, Liu Cong surrendered. The Biography of the First Sovereign says that the First Sovereign did not know Lord Cao had suddenly arrived and only heard of it when Lord Cao reached Wan, whereupon he left at the head of his followers. As they passed Xiangyang, Zhuge Liang said that if he attacked Liu Cong he could have Jing Province, but the First Sovereign said he could not bear to, halted his horse and called out to Liu Cong, and Liu Cong was too frightened to rise. Records, Wei 1 §104Records, Shu 2 §20
Many of Liu Cong's attendants and the people of Jing Province went over to the First Sovereign, so that by the time they reached Dangyang his followers numbered more than a hundred thousand and the wagons carrying the baggage several thousand, and they made ten-odd li a day. The First Sovereign separately had Guan Yu lead several hundred boats to meet him at Jiangling. When someone said that, with few men in armor, he should hurry to hold Jiangling, the First Sovereign said that to accomplish great things one must take people as the foundation, and that now that the people had come over to him, he could not bear to abandon them and leave. Records, Shu 2 §21
Lord Cao, fearing that the First Sovereign would seize Jiangling, where there were military stores, left his baggage behind and reached Xiangyang with a lightly equipped army. Hearing that the First Sovereign had already passed, he led 5,000 elite horsemen, rode more than three hundred li in a day and a night, and caught up with him at Changban in Dangyang. The First Sovereign abandoned his wife and children and fled with a few dozen horsemen including Zhuge Liang, Zhang Fei and Zhao Yun, and Lord Cao captured great numbers of his followers and baggage. Cao Chun pursued Liu Bei at Changban, captured his two daughters and his baggage and gathered up his scattered soldiers, and the biography of Wen Pin records that Wen Pin, too, pursued Liu Bei at Changban together with Cao Chun. The Biography of Zhuge Liang records that Xu Shu's mother was captured at this time, and that Xu Shu took leave of the First Sovereign and went to Lord Cao. Records, Shu 2 §22Records, Wei 9 §46Records, Wei 18 §35Records, Shu 5 §10–11
According to the biography of Zhang Fei, when the First Sovereign heard that Lord Cao had suddenly arrived, he abandoned his wife and children and fled, having Zhang Fei hold the rear with twenty horsemen. Zhang Fei, using the river as his defense, cut the bridge, glared, leveled his spear and said, "I am Zhang Yide! Come and let us fight it out to the death!" None of the enemy dared approach, and so in the end they escaped. The biography of Zhao Yun says that Zhao Yun himself carried the infant son, the Later Sovereign, and protected the Later Sovereign's mother, Lady Gan, so that all escaped, and the passage on Empress Gan likewise records that, the situation being desperate, the First Sovereign abandoned Lady Gan and the Later Sovereign, but they escaped the disaster under Zhao Yun's protection. Records, Shu 6 §16 · 39Records, Shu 4 §3
At the same time Lu Su, sent by Sun Quan, was coming to offer condolences to Liu Biao's two sons when he heard at Nan Commandery that Liu Cong had already surrendered and that Liu Bei meant to cross the river southward; he went straight to meet him and met Liu Bei at Changban in Dangyang. Lu Su conveyed Sun Quan's intentions and urged Liu Bei to join forces with Sun Quan, and formed a friendship with Zhuge Liang, who was with Liu Bei. Records, Wu 9 §42
The First Sovereign headed obliquely by a byway toward Hanjin, happened to meet Guan Yu's boats, crossed the Mian River, and reached Xiakou together with the more than ten thousand followers of Liu Qi, Liu Biao's eldest son and Administrator of Jiangxia. Cao Chun advanced and received the surrender of Jiangling, and the Annals of Emperor Wu record that Cao Cao advanced on Jiangling and issued an order to the officials and people of Jing Province that they would make a fresh start together. Zhuge Liang, who went from Xiakou to Sun Quan, said that although the army of the Governor of Yu had been defeated at Changban, the soldiers who had returned together with Guan Yu's naval elite troops made ten thousand, and that Cao Cao's light cavalry, who had ridden more than three hundred li in a day and a night in pursuit of the Governor of Yu, were in the situation of a powerful crossbow bolt that at the end of its flight cannot pierce even the thin silk of Lu. Records, Shu 2 §23Records, Shu 6 §7Records, Wei 9 §46Records, Wei 1 §104Records, Shu 5 §15
In the Romance
In Chapter 41 of the Romance, Liu Bei led the people of the two counties of Xinye and Fancheng across the river, but when Liu Cong would not open the gates at Xiangyang, he headed for Jiangling. Since the soldiers and people following him numbered more than a hundred thousand and the carts several thousand, they could make only ten-odd li a day, and his generals urged him to abandon the people and go on ahead, but Liu Bei refused in tears, saying that one who undertakes great things must take people as the foundation. Liu Bei sent Guan Yu and then Zhuge Liang to Liu Qi in Jiangxia to ask for help, had Zhang Fei cut off pursuit at the rear, and entrusted his household to Zhao Yun. Romance, Ch. 41 §7–8 · 10 · 13 · 15–17 · 19 · 32–33
Cao Cao, having received Liu Cong's surrender, heard a report that Liu Bei was no more than three hundred-odd li away, and picked out 5,000 elite armored horsemen to catch up with him within a day and a night. The Romance sets the time at the turn from late autumn to early winter; Liu Bei, encamped at Mount Jing in Dangyang County, was badly defeated by Cao Cao's troops, who fell upon him in the fourth watch, and fled east with Zhang Fei's help. When day broke and he looked around, only a hundred-odd horsemen were following him. Romance, Ch. 41 §25 · 30–31 · 35–37
Word went round that Zhao Yun, having lost the household, had gone over to Cao Cao, but Zhao Yun found Lady Gan and escorted her to the Changban slope, rescued Mi Zhu, and then went back into the encirclement. Lady Mi, so as not to be a burden, handed A Dou to Zhao Yun and threw herself into a dry well, and Zhao Yun, holding A Dou to his breast, broke through layer upon layer of encirclement. Cao Cao, seeing him from the top of Mount Jing, ordered that no arrows be shot at him and that he be taken alive. Romance, Ch. 41 §38 · 41 · 45–48 · 55 · 57 · 61–62
In Chapter 42 Zhang Fei halted his horse on Changban Bridge and, in the woods east of the bridge, raised clouds of dust with branches tied to his horses' tails to make it look as if troops were lying in ambush. As his shouts of "Zhang Yide of Yan is here!" rang out again and again, Xiahou Jie fell from his horse and Cao Cao turned his horse and fled, after which Zhang Fei cut the bridge and returned. Liu Bei said that by cutting the bridge he had instead revealed that they had no troops, and hurried by a byway toward Hanjin. Romance, Ch. 41 §40Romance, Ch. 42 §6–10 · 14–15
When Cao Cao threw pontoon bridges across and pursued them to near Hanjin, Guan Yu, who had borrowed ten thousand men and horses from Jiangxia, appeared from behind a hillside, and Cao Cao withdrew, saying he had again fallen into Zhuge Liang's trap. Liu Bei boarded a boat at Hanjin, met the boats of Liu Qi and Zhuge Liang and went to Jiangxia, while Guan Yu held Xiakou. Cao Cao hastened through the night to Jiangling and received its surrender. Romance, Ch. 42 §16–19 · 20–25 · 26
Where the Romance differs
Zhuge Liang's whereabouts: In Chapter 41 of the Romance, Zhuge Liang had left for Jiangxia with Liu Feng before the battle, and in Chapter 42 he came out with Liu Qi leading boats to meet Liu Bei. In the Biography of the First Sovereign in the Records, the First Sovereign fled from Changban with a few dozen horsemen including Zhuge Liang, Zhang Fei and Zhao Yun, and in the biography of Lu Su, too, Zhuge Liang was with Liu Bei when Lu Su met him at Changban. Romance, Ch. 41 §32–33Romance, Ch. 42 §22–23Records, Shu 2 §22Records, Wu 9 §42
The bridge at Changban: In Chapter 42 of the Romance, Zhang Fei cut the bridge only after driving off Cao Cao with his shouts from the bridge, and Liu Bei reproached him for cutting it. In the biography of Zhang Fei in the Records, Zhang Fei, with twenty horsemen and using the river as his defense, cut the bridge first, then glared and challenged the enemy to come and fight it out to the death, and the enemy did not dare approach. Romance, Ch. 42 §8–10 · 14Records, Shu 6 §16
A Dou and the ladies: In Chapter 41 of the Romance, Lady Mi handed A Dou to Zhao Yun and threw herself into a well, and Zhao Yun, holding A Dou to his breast, killed more than fifty famous generals of Cao Cao's army. The biography of Zhao Yun and the passage on Empress Gan in the Records say only that Zhao Yun carried the Later Sovereign and protected Lady Gan so that all escaped, and Lady Mi does not appear. The passage on Cao Chun records that Cao Chun captured Liu Bei's two daughters at this time. Romance, Ch. 41 §55 · 62Records, Shu 6 §39Records, Shu 4 §3Records, Wei 9 §46
Guan Yu's boats: In Chapter 41 of the Romance, Guan Yu went to Jiangxia to ask for help, and in Chapter 42 he came back with ten thousand borrowed men and horses and drove off Cao Cao on the road to Hanjin. In the Biography of the First Sovereign and the biography of Guan Yu in the Records, Guan Yu had from the outset been set to lead several hundred boats to meet Liu Bei at Jiangling, and the First Sovereign happened to meet Guan Yu's boats at Hanjin, crossed the Mian River and reached Xiakou. Romance, Ch. 41 §19Romance, Ch. 42 §18–19Records, Shu 2 §21 · 23Records, Shu 6 §7
Where Lu Su was met: In Chapter 42 of the Romance, Lu Su came to Jiangxia to offer condolences on Liu Biao and met Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang. In the biography of Lu Su in the Records, Lu Su reached Changban in Dangyang, met Liu Bei and urged him to join forces with Sun Quan. Romance, Ch. 42 §29–33Records, Wu 9 §42
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Belligerents
| Item | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| Factions | Wei | Shu |
| Commanders | Cao Chun, Cao Cao, Wen Pin | Liu Bei, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun |
| Strength | 曹公將精騎五千急追之 | 眾十餘萬,輜重數千兩 |
Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Shu 2 §22