Battle
Battle of Jiangling 江陵之戰
About this event
The Battle of Jiangling was the fight from the autumn of the 3rd year of Huangchu (222) to the spring of the 4th year (223) in which Wei's Cao Zhen, Xiahou Shang, Zhang He and others besieged Jiangling, held by Wu's Zhu Ran; it was the western of the three routes of Cao Pi's invasions of Eastern Wu. Cao Pi stayed at Wan and backed them up. Xiahou Shang defeated the army of Zhuge Jin, who had encamped on an island in the middle of the river, and Zhang He took the fortified camp on the island, but Zhu Ran held out for six months with the 5,000 men fit to fight in a city swept by a swelling sickness. Cao Pi, heeding a memorial from Dong Zhao, had the troops on the island pulled out, and when a great epidemic broke out the Wei army withdrew. Records, Wu 2 §42Records, Wu 11 §16–18Records, Wei 9 §94–95Records, Wei 17 §50Records, Wei 14 §73–76
Chen Shou recorded this battle in scattered places: the Biographies of the Xiahou and Cao Clans (Records of Wei 9), Records of Wei 14 and 17, the Biography of the Lord of Wu (Records of Wu 2), Records of Wu 10, and the Biographies of Zhu Zhi, Zhu Ran, Lü Fan and Zhu Huan (Records of Wu 11). The Romance deals with this battle only through Cao Zhen setting out for Nan Commandery at the end of Chapter 84 and the report in Chapter 85 that Cao Zhen and Xiahou Shang, besieging Nan Commandery, have been defeated. Records, Wei 9 §94–95Records, Wei 14 §73–76Records, Wei 17 §50Records, Wu 2 §42 · 49Records, Wu 10 §93–94Records, Wu 11 §16–18Romance, Ch. 84 §12Romance, Ch. 85 §13
Course of events in the Records
In the 9th month of autumn of the 3rd year of Huangchu (222), Wei had Cao Zhen, Xiahou Shang, Zhang He and Xu Huang besiege Nan Commandery, and Cao Pi stayed at Wan in person to back them up. Xiahou Shang, leading various armies, besieged Jiangling together with Cao Zhen, and the Wei army surrounded the city with a chain of encampments. Sun Quan had Zhuge Jin, Pan Zhang and Yang Can relieve Nan Commandery, and had General Sun Sheng hold the island in the middle of the river with 10,000 men as outside support for Zhu Ran. Records, Wu 2 §42Records, Wei 9 §94Records, Wu 11 §16
Zhuge Jin crossed onto the sandbar in the middle of the river and deployed his fleet in midstream. Xiahou Shang, taking many oiled boats at night, secretly crossed downstream with more than 10,000 foot and horse, burned those boats from both banks, attacked by land and water together and defeated Zhuge Jin's army. Zhang He separately led various armies across the river and took the fortified camp on the island, and when Sun Sheng could not hold and withdrew, Zhu Ran was cut off inside and out. The Biography of the Lord of Wu records that in the 1st month of the 2nd year of Huangwu (223) Cao Zhen divided his troops and occupied the middle isle at Jiangling. Records, Wei 9 §94–95Records, Wei 17 §50Records, Wu 11 §16Records, Wu 2 §49
In the city many soldiers suffered from a swelling sickness, and only 5,000 were fit to fight. When Cao Zhen and the others built earthen hills, dug tunnels and raised towers and shot arrows like rain, the officers and men turned pale, but Zhu Ran calmly encouraged his officials and soldiers and, watching for openings, broke two enemy encampments. When the siege had lasted six months, Yao Tai, Prefect of Jiangling, tried to collude with the enemy, but the plot came to light and Zhu Ran executed him. Records, Wu 11 §17–18
When 30,000 Wei troops laid a pontoon bridge and crossed onto Baili Isle, Pan Zhang said that Wei's momentum was at its height and the water was shallow, so they could not yet fight; 50 li upstream he made great rafts out of several million bundles of reeds, intending to set them alight and burn the pontoon bridge when the water rose. Dong Zhao submitted a memorial saying that the encampment in the middle of the island was extremely deep, crossing by a pontoon bridge was extremely dangerous and moving along a single road was extremely narrow, and that since the time for the river to rise had come, the troops should be pulled out. Records, Wu 10 §93Records, Wei 14 §73–75
Cao Pi saw the sense of Dong Zhao's words and had Xiahou Shang and the others come out quickly. The Wu army advanced from both ends together while the Wei army withdrew by a single road, and the generals Shi Jian and Gao Qian barely escaped with their lives. Ten days after the troops came out, the river suddenly rose. Pan Zhang's rafts went unused because Xiahou Shang happened to withdraw. The Biography of Xiahou Shang says that before the city fell a great epidemic broke out and he withdrew his army by imperial order, and the Annals of Emperor Wen record that in the 3rd month of the 4th year of Huangchu Cao Pi returned from Wan to Luoyang and that a great epidemic broke out that month. Through this battle Zhu Ran's fame spread to the enemy state. Records, Wei 14 §76Records, Wu 10 §94Records, Wei 9 §95Records, Wei 2 §42Records, Wu 11 §18
In the Romance
In Chapter 84 of the Romance, Cao Pi has Cao Zhen lead an army out to Nan Commandery, and in Chapter 85 Wu has Zhuge Jin oppose Cao Zhen at Nan Commandery. After Cao Ren is defeated at Ruxu, a report comes in that Cao Zhen and Xiahou Shang, besieging Nan Commandery, have been heavily defeated by a pincer attack from inside and outside, with Lu Xun inside and Zhuge Jin lying in ambush outside. The Romance does not depict the fighting at Jiangling as a separate scene. Romance, Ch. 84 §12Romance, Ch. 85 §8 · 13
Where the Romance differs
Victory, defeat and the defense: In Chapter 85 of the Romance, Cao Zhen and Xiahou Shang are heavily defeated by a pincer attack from inside and outside by Lu Xun and Zhuge Jin. In the Records, the man who held Jiangling was Zhu Ran, Xiahou Shang in fact defeated Zhuge Jin's army, and the Wei army withdrew because of Dong Zhao's memorial and a great epidemic. The Biography of Lu Xun says only that Lu Xun foresaw that the Wei army would come out, and does not place him in the fighting at Jiangling. Romance, Ch. 85 §13Records, Wu 11 §16–18Records, Wei 9 §94–95Records, Wei 14 §76Records, Wu 13 §28
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Belligerents
| Item | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| Factions | Wei | Wu |
| Commanders | Cao Pi, Cao Zhen, Xiahou Shang, Zhang He, Xu Huang | Zhu Ran, Pan Zhang, Zhuge Jin |
| Strength | 分前部三萬人作浮橋,渡百里洲上 | 時然城中兵多腫病,堪戰者裁五千人 |
Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wu 11 §18