Luo Tong 駱統

RecordsRomance Wu Courtesy name 公緒 Gongxu낙통공서駱綂骆统

Profile
OccupationRGeneral · Lieutenant GeneralFactionWu
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wu
BornR193 UnverifiedNative placeKuaiji Commandery Wushang County
DiedR228 UnverifiedPlace of death
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR20

Profile

Luo Tong, courtesy name Gongxu, was a man of Wushang County in Kuaiji Commandery. When his father Luo Jun was killed by Yuan Shu and his mother remarried as a concubine of Hua Xin, he returned to Kuaiji at the age of eight. He became known for sharing out grain in charity during a famine. Records, Wu 12 §51–52

Under Sun Quan he served as Chancellor of Wucheng and as Officer of Merit before becoming General of the Household Who Establishes Loyalty and Lieutenant General, and at the beginning of Huangwu he held off the Wei army at Ruxu, was enfeoffed as Marquis of Xinyang Village and then became Commander of Ruxu. He submitted dozens of memorials, including one expressing concern over the decline of the population, and died in the 7th year of Huangwu (228) at the age of thirty-six. Records, Wu 12 §53–55 · 62

Chen Shou, author of the Records, said in his assessment that he upheld and made clear the great principles, his words earnest and his reasoning complete, but that he happened to meet a time when Sun Quan's mind was closed and would not open. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 38 as one of the scholars of Jiangdong whom Sun Quan took in, and appears in 2 of its 120 chapters; his name is not in any chapter title. In Chapter 43 he, together with Zhang Wen, is about to challenge Zhuge Liang. Records, Wu 12 §89Romance, Ch. 38 §26Romance, Ch. 43 §30

In the Records

Luo Tong, courtesy name Gongxu, was a man of Wushang County in Kuaiji Commandery. His father Luo Jun rose to be Chancellor of Chen but was killed by Yuan Shu. When his mother remarried and became a concubine of Hua Xin, Luo Tong, then eight years old, returned to Kuaiji with relatives and retainers. When his mother saw him off, Luo Tong bowed in farewell, got into the carriage and faced forward without looking back, while his mother wept behind him. When the driver said that the lady was still there, Luo Tong said he did not look back because he did not want to add to his mother's longing. He served his father's principal wife with great care. Records, Wu 12 §51

At that time there was a famine, and many of the local people and of the guests from afar were in want, so Luo Tong cut back on his own food and drink for their sake. When his elder sister, who had been widowed and returned to her family home, asked him the reason several times, Luo Tong said, 'When gentlemen do not even have enough dregs and husks, how could I have the heart to eat my fill alone?' His sister gave her own grain to Luo Tong and also told their mother, and their mother too thought him worthy and let him share it out in charity. Because of this he became known. Records, Wu 12 §52

When Sun Quan, as a general, also held the post of Administrator of Kuaiji, Luo Tong at twenty was made Chancellor of Wucheng on trial, and the people, more than ten thousand households, all praised his kindly government. Sun Quan commended him, summoned him as Officer of Merit with acting rank as Chief Commandant of Cavalry, and gave him the daughter of his cousin Sun Fu as a wife. Luo Tong set his mind on making up for shortcomings and keeping watch, and whenever he heard or saw something he reported it that evening without waiting for morning. He constantly urged Sun Quan to honour the worthy and receive scholars, and on days of banquets and gifts to have each man come forward separately so that he could ask after his circumstances and learn his aims and inclinations, and Sun Quan adopted this. Records, Wu 12 §53–54

Luo Tong was sent out as General of the Household Who Establishes Loyalty, in command of 3,000 martial archer officers, and when Ling Tong died he also took command of his troops. Records, Wu 12 §54

At this time, when levies and labour service were frequent and an epidemic was added to them so that the number of households declined, Luo Tong submitted a memorial. He said that wealth and strength, authority and blessings, virtue and righteousness all depended on the people, and that those who went out as soldiers lived in hardship and in death did not even have their bones returned, so that the people regarded conscription as the same as death. At every levy, he said, the weak and those with many dependants were sent first, those with some wealth paid bribes, and the agile fled to rugged places and joined bands of evildoers. He also said that among the common people many did not raise the children born to them, and that the poor soldiers of the agricultural garrisons also abandoned their children, and that a state's having its people was like water's having boats. Sun Quan was moved by Luo Tong's words and gave the matter deep attention. Records, Wu 12 §55–61

For his merit in following Lu Xun and defeating the Shu army at Yidu, Luo Tong was transferred to Lieutenant General. When Liu Bei stayed at Baidi, Xu Sheng, Pan Zhang, Song Qian and others asked to attack again, saying that Liu Bei could be captured, but Lu Xun, together with Zhu Ran and Luo Tong, held that since Cao Pi was assembling a large army they should return at once. Before long the Wei army did indeed set out. Records, Wu 12 §62Records, Wu 13 §28

At the beginning of Huangwu, when Cao Ren attacked Ruxu and had his subordinate general Chang Diao and others raid Zhongzhou, Luo Tong and Yan Gui together held them off and defeated them. For this merit he was enfeoffed as Marquis of Xinyang Village, and later became Commander of Ruxu. Records, Wu 12 §62

When Zhang Wen fell into disgrace, General Luo Tong submitted a memorial defending him, saying that Zhang Wen truly had no disloyal intent at heart and no trace of rebellion in his conduct, and was merely young and lacking in gravity. But Sun Quan in the end did not accept it. Records, Wu 12 §36–37 · 48

Luo Tong repeatedly presented proposals suited to the times, submitting dozens of documents in all, and Chen Shou wrote that they were all excellent but too long to record in full. In particular he said that private recruitment of soldiers (zhanmu) fostered evil among the people, ruined customs and bred disloyalty, and should be stopped at once; Sun Quan debated it with him back and forth many times and finally put it into effect. Luo Tong died in the 7th year of Huangwu (228) at the age of thirty-six. Records, Wu 12 §62

In his assessment Chen Shou said that Luo Tong upheld and made clear the great principles, his words earnest and his reasoning complete, but that he happened to meet a time when Sun Quan's mind was closed and would not open. Records, Wu 12 §89

In the Romance

Chapter 38 of the Romance lists the scholars who came to Jiangdong when Sun Quan, having inherited Jiangdong after Sun Ce's death, opened a guesthouse and had Gu Yong and Zhang Hong receive guests from all quarters, and among them is 'Luo Tong of Wushang, courtesy name Gongxu.' The Romance says that Sun Quan treated these men with great courtesy. Romance, Ch. 38 §26

In Chapter 43, during Zhuge Liang's debate with Sun Quan's scholars, when Cheng Deshu cannot answer, Zhang Wen and Luo Tong, who are present, are about to challenge him further. But Huang Gai comes in and rebukes them, saying that with Cao Cao's great army approaching the border they are merely bandying words, which is no way to show respect to a guest, and they stop. Romance, Ch. 43 §30–31

Where the Romance differs

Recruitment: In Chapter 38 of the Romance, Luo Tong appears as one of the scholars who came to Jiangdong when Sun Quan opened a guesthouse to receive guests from all quarters. In the Records, when Sun Quan, as a general, also held the post of Administrator of Kuaiji, Luo Tong at twenty was made Chancellor of Wucheng on trial, and Sun Quan, commending his government, summoned him as Officer of Merit. Romance, Ch. 38 §26Records, Wu 12 §53

Debate with Zhuge Liang: In Chapter 43 of the Romance, he and Zhang Wen are about to challenge Zhuge Liang. Luo Tong's biography in the Records has no encounter with Zhuge Liang. Romance, Ch. 43 §30Records, Wu 12 §50–62

Relationship with Zhang Wen: In Chapter 43 of the Romance, Zhang Wen and Luo Tong appear side by side as scholars trying to put Zhuge Liang in a difficult position. In the Records, when Zhang Wen fell into disgrace, General Luo Tong submitted a memorial defending him, but Sun Quan did not accept it. Romance, Ch. 43 §30Records, Wu 12 §36 · 48

Who stopped Chang Diao: In Chapter 85 of the Romance, Zhu Huan cuts down Chang Diao with a single stroke of his blade before the city of Ruxu, and Luo Tong does not appear. In Luo Tong's biography in the Records, Luo Tong and Yan Gui together held off and defeated Chang Diao and the others who raided Zhongzhou. In Zhu Huan's biography in the Records, while Zhu Huan himself held off Cao Tai, his subordinate generals separately attacked Chang Diao and the others and hung up Chang Diao's head. Romance, Ch. 85 §12Records, Wu 12 §62Records, Wu 11 §51–52

Later career: The Romance does not bring Luo Tong back after Chapter 43. In the Records there follow his memorial expressing concern over the decline of the population, the defeat of the Shu army at Yidu, his time as Commander of Ruxu and his proposal to stop private recruitment, and he died in the 7th year of Huangwu (228) at the age of thirty-six. Romance, Ch. 43 §30Records, Wu 12 §55 · 62

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA5533−22
  • STR3831−7
  • INT5840−18
  • POL7840−38
  • CHA6245−17
  • VIR8245−37
  • ADP4540−5
  • SCH5555±0
  • DIP6442−22
  • DIS5538−17
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

PoliticsR78N40Unverified −38

RGood government at Wucheng · a memorial for preserving the people · carried through the abolition of private recruitmentWu 12 §55Wu 12 §62Wu 12 §89Wu 12 §53

NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a scholarCh. 38 §26

VirtueR82N45Unverified −37

RServed his father's principal wife with care and cut back his own meals for the hungryWu 12 §51Wu 12 §52

NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a scholarCh. 38 §26

LeadershipR55N33Unverified −22

RHeld off and defeated Chang Diao's raid on Zhongzhou and became Commander of RuxuWu 12 §62

NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a scholarCh. 38 §26

DiplomacyR64N42 −22

RThe assessment calls his words earnest and his reasoning complete · defended Zhang WenWu 12 §89Wu 12 §36

NWas about to debate Kongming but was stopped by Huang GaiCh. 43 §30

IntelligenceR58N40Unverified −18

RJoined in opposing the pursuit of Liu Bei · repeatedly presented proposals suited to the timesWu 13 §28Wu 12 §62

NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a scholarCh. 43 §30

CharismaR62N45Unverified −17

RBecame known for famine relief, and the people of Wucheng praised his kindnessWu 12 §52Wu 12 §53

NNo direct record — a scholar whom Sun Quan treated with great courtesyCh. 38 §26

DiscernmentR55N38Unverified −17

RUrged Sun Quan to honour the worthy and receive scholarsWu 12 §53

NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a scholarCh. 38 §26

3 similar abilities — show evidence
  • StrengthR38UnverifiedN31Unverified −7

    RNo direct record — recorded commanding troops as General of the Household Who Establishes LoyaltyWu 12 §54

    NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a scholarCh. 38 §26

  • AdaptabilityR45UnverifiedN40Unverified −5

    RNo direct record — estimated from his official careerWu 12 §62

    NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a scholarCh. 43 §30

  • ScholarshipR55N55 ±0

    RHis dozens of memorials were said to be all excellentWu 12 §55Wu 8 §28Wu 12 §62

    NA scholar who came to Jiangdong and was treated with courtesy by Sun QuanCh. 38 §26

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (2)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wu · Records · Records vol. 57 「試為烏程相」

Related events (2)

Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).