Cai Yong 蔡邕

RecordsRomance Courtesy name 伯喈 Bojie채옹백개

Profile
OccupationRScholar · General of the Household of the Left NScholar · Palace AttendantFaction
AppearsRNBiography in
Cause of deathNExecuted Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR19

Profile

Cai Yong's courtesy name was Bojie. The Records give him no biography of his own, and in Chen Shou's main text the episodes involving him appear only in the biographies of Wang Can, Ruan Yu and Gu Yong. Around the time Emperor Xian moved west to Chang'an he was General of the Household of the Left, and he was so famous for his talent and learning that he was held in high esteem at court. Records, Wu 7 §27Records, Wei 21 §3 · 17

He welcomed the young Wang Can with his shoes on backwards and said he would give him all the books and writings in his house, and Ruan Yu and Gu Yong studied under him. Chen Shou's main text does not record his place of origin or his death, and he does not appear in Chen Shou's assessment either. Records, Wei 21 §3 · 17Records, Wu 7 §27

In the Romance he first appeared in Chapter 1 as a Court Gentleman for Consultation who was punished and banished to his home district after frankly stating the causes of calamities and portents, and appears in 7 of its 120 chapters; his name is not in any chapter title. In Chapter 4 he was summoned by Dong Zhuo and made Palace Attendant, and in Chapter 9, after weeping over Dong Zhuo's corpse, he was strangled in prison on Wang Yun's orders. Romance, Ch. 1 §5–6Romance, Ch. 4 §11Romance, Ch. 9 §31 · 34

In the Records

According to the biography of Wang Can, when Emperor Xian moved west, Wang Can also moved to Chang'an, and Cai Yong, General of the Household of the Left, saw him and thought him remarkable. At that time Cai Yong was so famous for his talent and learning and so highly esteemed at court that carriages and horses always filled his lane and guests filled his seats. Records, Wei 21 §3

When Cai Yong heard that Wang Can was at the gate, he rushed out to welcome him with his shoes on backwards. Wang Can was young and small in build, and the whole company was astonished, but Cai Yong said, 'This is the grandson of Lord Wang. He has extraordinary talent, and I am not his equal. All the books and writings in my house ought to be given to him.' Records, Wei 21 §3

Ruan Yu studied under Cai Yong when young. During the Jian'an era Cao Hong wanted to put Ruan Yu in charge of his documents and records, but he never yielded; later the Grand Progenitor (Cao Cao) made him, together with Chen Lin, Libationer of Military Planning for the Minister of Works and put him in charge of the records office. Records, Wei 21 §17

According to the biography of Gu Yong, when Cai Bojie (Cai Yong) returned from Shuofang, he once stayed in Wu to avoid enmity, and Gu Yong, a man of Wu Commandery, learned the qin and letters from him. Records, Wu 7 §27

These three biographies are the only places in Chen Shou's main text where Cai Yong appears. His place of origin, the beginning and end of his official career, his relationship with Dong Zhuo and his death are not recorded, and he does not appear in Chen Shou's assessment either. Records, Wei 21 §3 · 17Records, Wu 7 §27

In the Romance

In Chapter 1 of the Romance, as ill-omened portents followed one after another, the emperor issued an edict asking the reason, and Cai Yong, a Court Gentleman for Consultation, submitted a memorial stating very frankly that 'the falling rainbow and the hen turning into a cock were caused by women and eunuchs meddling in government.' While the emperor had risen to change his clothes, Cao Jie secretly read the memorial and told those around him, and Cai Yong was charged with another offence and banished to his home district. Romance, Ch. 1 §5–6

In Chapter 3, when Dong Zhuo drew his sword to kill Lu Zhi, the Palace Attendant Cai Yong, together with the Court Gentleman for Consultation Peng Bo, stopped him, saying that Master of Writing Lu was a man the whole realm looked up to, and that harming him first would make the realm tremble with fear. In Chapter 4, Li Ru recommended Cai Yong, urging Dong Zhuo to employ famous men in order to win popular support. When Cai Yong did not answer the summons, Dong Zhuo threatened to wipe out his clan if he did not come, and when Cai Yong came out of fear, Dong Zhuo welcomed him warmly, promoted him three times in one month to make him Palace Attendant, and treated him with great intimacy. Romance, Ch. 3 §33Romance, Ch. 4 §11

In Chapter 9, as Wang Yun was holding a banquet after Dong Zhuo's death, he was told that someone was weeping over Dong Zhuo's corpse, which had been left exposed in the marketplace; he had the man seized and brought in, and it was the Palace Attendant Cai Yong. Cai Yong admitted his guilt, saying he had wept only out of feeling for the recognition and favour he had once received, and begged to be allowed to complete the history of the Han even if his face were tattooed and his feet cut off. Romance, Ch. 9 §31–32

The officials, regretting the loss of his talent, did their best to save him, and the Grand Tutor Ma Midi also privately urged Wang Yun to spare him so that he could complete the history of the Han. Wang Yun refused, saying that in the past Emperor Xiaowu had not killed Sima Qian and so a slanderous book had been handed down to later ages, and had Cai Yong put in prison and strangled. All the scholar-officials who heard the news shed tears, and the Romance records that later people judged that, although Cai Yong was wrong to weep for Dong Zhuo, Wang Yun went too far in killing him. Romance, Ch. 9 §32–34

After that his name appears in the backgrounds of other characters. Chapter 29 calls Gu Yong, whom Zhang Hong recommended to Sun Quan, a disciple of Cai Yong the Zhonglang, and Chapter 40 records that when Wang Can as a child visited Cai Yong the Zhonglang, Cai Yong, in a room full of distinguished guests, went out to welcome him with his shoes on backwards and said, 'This child has extraordinary talent, and I am not his equal.' Romance, Ch. 29 §50Romance, Ch. 40 §22–23

In Chapter 71, as Cao Cao led his army out through Tong Pass, he passed Cai Yong's estate at Lantian. Cao Cao, who had always been on good terms with Cai Yong, had earlier ransomed his daughter Cai Yan, who had been carried off to the north, for a thousand pieces of gold and married her to Dong Si, and, remembering Cai Yong, he stopped at the estate. Cai Yan showed him a scroll of the inscription for the filial daughter Cao E (曹娥), and said that her father Cai Yong had read the inscription by feeling it with his hands in the dark after nightfall and written eight large characters on its back. Cao Cao could not solve them at once and understood only after leaving the estate and travelling three li, and the Registrar Yang Xiu interpreted them as meaning 'the most exquisite of writings.' Romance, Ch. 71 §6–12

Where the Romance differs

The memorial and banishment: In Chapter 1 of the Romance, Cai Yong, a Court Gentleman for Consultation, frankly stated the causes of the portents and was banished to his home district through Cao Jie's slander. This incident is not in the biographies of Wang Can, Ruan Yu and Gu Yong, where Cai Yong appears in Chen Shou's main text, and the biography of Gu Yong records that Cai Yong, returning from Shuofang, stayed in Wu to avoid enmity. Romance, Ch. 1 §5–6Records, Wei 21 §3 · 17Records, Wu 7 §27

Where he taught Gu Yong: Chapter 29 of the Romance says only that Gu Yong was a disciple of Cai Yong the Zhonglang. In the Biography of Gu Yong in the Records, Gu Yong, a man of Wu Commandery, learned the qin and letters from Cai Yong while Cai Yong was staying in Wu to avoid enmity. Romance, Ch. 29 §50Records, Wu 7 §27

Relationship with Dong Zhuo: In Chapter 4 of the Romance, Dong Zhuo summoned Cai Yong by threatening to wipe out his clan, and promoted him three times in one month to make him Palace Attendant. Chen Shou's main text has nothing about Cai Yong being summoned by Dong Zhuo, and the Biography of Wang Can records him as General of the Household of the Left around the time Emperor Xian moved to Chang'an. Romance, Ch. 4 §11Records, Wei 6 §1–17Records, Wei 21 §3

Death: In Chapter 9 of the Romance, Cai Yong wept over Dong Zhuo's corpse and was then strangled in prison on Wang Yun's orders. Chen Shou's main text does not record Cai Yong's death, and Cai Yong does not appear in the account of Dong Zhuo's death in the Biography of Dong Zhuo either. Romance, Ch. 9 §31 · 34Records, Wei 6 §16–17

Welcoming Wang Can: Chapter 40 of the Romance presents this as Wang Can's visit to Cai Yong as a child. In the Biography of Wang Can in the Records, it happened after Wang Can moved to Chang'an when Emperor Xian moved west, and Cai Yong also added that all the books and writings in his house ought to be given to Wang Can. Romance, Ch. 40 §22–23Records, Wei 21 §3

His daughter Cai Yan and the eight characters on the inscription: In Chapter 71 of the Romance, Cao Cao stopped at Cai Yong's estate and met his daughter Cai Yan, and Yang Xiu interpreted the eight characters Cai Yong had written on the back of the Cao E inscription. Neither Cai Yan nor the eight characters of the Cao E inscription appear in Chen Shou's main text. Romance, Ch. 71 §6–12Records, Wei 21 §3 · 17Records, Wu 7 §27

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA3131±0
  • STR3130−1
  • INT4250+8
  • POL4245+3
  • CHA6265+3
  • VIR5060+10
  • ADP4020−20
  • SCH9688−8
  • DIP4058+18
  • DIS7272±0
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

AdaptabilityR40UnverifiedN20 −20

RNo direct record — estimated from the record of his going to Wu to avoid enmityWu 7 §27

NWent to Dong Zhuo under threat, wept at his death and was executed by Wang YunCh. 4 §11Ch. 9 §31

DiplomacyR40UnverifiedN58 +18

RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a scholarWei 21 §3

NRemonstrated with Dong Zhuo and kept him from killing Lu ZhiCh. 3 §33

VirtueR50UnverifiedN60 +10

RNo direct record — estimated from the record of his staying in Wu to avoid enmityWu 7 §27

NBanished for a frank memorial, known for filial conduct, and wept over Dong Zhuo's corpseCh. 1 §5Ch. 9 §32

7 similar abilities — show evidence
  • LeadershipR31UnverifiedN31Unverified ±0

    RNo direct record — estimated from his civil career as General of the Household of the LeftWei 21 §3

    NNo direct record — estimated from his civil career as Palace AttendantCh. 4 §11

  • StrengthR31UnverifiedN30Unverified −1

    RNo direct record — estimated from his civil careerWei 21 §3

    NNo direct record — estimated from his civil careerCh. 4 §11

  • IntelligenceR42UnverifiedN50 +8

    RNo direct record — estimated from the record of his being esteemed at courtWei 21 §3

    NPointed out that the portents were caused by women and eunuchs meddling in governmentCh. 1 §5

  • PoliticsR42UnverifiedN45Unverified +3

    RNo direct record — estimated from his post as General of the Household of the LeftWei 21 §3

    NNo direct record — estimated from the record of his submitting a memorial as Court Gentleman for ConsultationCh. 1 §5

  • CharismaR62N65 +3

    RCarriages and horses filled his lane and guests filled his seatsWei 21 §3Wu 7 §27

    NThe officials, valuing his talent, tried to save him, and all the scholar-officials wept at his deathCh. 9 §32

  • ScholarshipR96N88 −8

    RFamous for talent and learning; Gu Yong and Ruan Yu studied under him, and his writings were avidly readWei 21 §3Wu 7 §27Shu 12 §82

    NAsked to complete the history of the Han; a talent rare in his age; wrote eight characters on the back of the Cao E inscriptionCh. 9 §32Ch. 71 §9Ch. 40 §22

  • DiscernmentR72N72 ±0

    RWelcomed the young Wang Can with his shoes on backwards and said Wang Can surpassed himWei 21 §3

    NRecognized the young Wang Can's talent; his disciple Gu Yong was promoted by Sun QuanCh. 40 §22Ch. 29 §50

Special — talents Records +10 · Romance +0

  • Music

    RSkilled +10 Gu Yong learned the zither and letters from himWu 7 §27

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (7)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Family

ChildrenCai Yan Romance

Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.

Related works (1)

Linked via Wikidata "depicts" and character names in titles (unverified) — not yet reviewed.