Battle
Battle of White Wolf Mountain 白狼山之戰
About this event
The Battle of White Wolf Mountain was the campaign of the 12th year of Jian'an (207) in which Cao Cao attacked the Wuhuan of the Three Commanderies, with whom the brothers Yuan Shang and Yuan Xi had taken refuge, and in the 8th month crushed the army of Tadun, Chanyu of Liaoxi, at Mount Bailang. When floods blocked the coastal road, Cao Cao took Tian Chou as his guide, went out through the Lulong Pass, cut through more than five hundred li of broken road and headed for Liucheng; at Mount Bailang he struck the enemy's tens of thousands of horsemen, whom he met unexpectedly, with Zhang Liao in the van, and beheaded Tadun and the renowned kings beneath him. Yuan Shang and Yuan Xi, who fled to Liaodong, were beheaded by Gongsun Kang in the 9th month. Records, Wei 1 §98–101Records, Wei 11 §45–47
Chen Shou recorded this battle in the Annals of Emperor Wu (Records of Wei 1) and the Biographies of the Wuhuan, Xianbei and Eastern Yi (Records of Wei 30), and also included parts of it in the biography of Tian Chou in the Biographies of Yuan, Zhang, Liang, Guo, Tian, Wang, Bing and Guan (Records of Wei 11), the biography of Guo Jia in the Biographies of Cheng, Guo, Dong, Liu, Jiang and Liu (Records of Wei 14), the Biographies of Zhang, Yue, Yu, Zhang and Xu (Records of Wei 17) and elsewhere. The Romance depicts this battle in Chapter 33, "Guo Jia's Last Plan Settles Liaodong." Records, Wei 1 §96–102Records, Wei 30 §11–12Records, Wei 11 §44–48Records, Wei 14 §38–41Records, Wei 17 §6Romance, Ch. 33 §30–48
Course of events in the Records
The Wuhuan of the Three Commanderies had taken advantage of the chaos in the realm to break into You Province and carry off and hold more than a hundred thousand households of Han people. Yuan Shao set up their chieftains as Chanyu and married them to girls of his household whom he adopted as his own daughters, and Tadun, Chanyu of Liaoxi, was especially strong and was treated generously by Yuan Shao. The Yuan Shang brothers took refuge with Tadun and repeatedly came inside the frontier to do harm, and Cao Cao, intending to attack them, dug the Pinglu Canal from the Hutuo to the Gu River and the Quanzhou Canal from the mouth of the Ju River to the Lu River, giving access to the sea. Records, Wei 1 §96Records, Wei 30 §9–10
When Cao Cao was about to attack the Wuhuan of the Three Commanderies in the north, his generals said that Yuan Shang was merely a fugitive captive, that the barbarians were greedy and would not let themselves be used by Yuan Shang, and that if he went deep into their lands Liu Bei would persuade Liu Biao to make a surprise attack on Xu. Only Guo Jia urged the campaign, saying that the barbarians, trusting in their remoteness, would make no preparations, and that Liu Biao was a man who only sat and talked and would not be able to use Liu Bei. On reaching Yi County, Guo Jia said that in war speed is what counts, and that they should leave the baggage train behind and press on along the road with light troops. Records, Wei 1 §98Records, Wei 14 §38–40
In the 5th month of summer Cao Cao reached Wuzhong, but in the 7th month of autumn there were great floods and the coastal road was impassable. Tian Chou said that the road from Pinggang, the old seat of Beiping Commandery, through Lulong to Liucheng had been cut off for nearly two hundred years, but that a narrow track remained, and that if they secretly turned the army back and crossed the perilous ground of Baitan from the Lulong pass, they could take Tadun's head without a battle. Cao Cao deceived the enemy scouts by setting up a sign by the road at the water's edge saying that, as it was the height of summer and the roads were impassable, he would wait for autumn and winter before advancing again. Records, Wei 1 §98Records, Wei 11 §44–46
Cao Cao took Tian Chou as his guide and went out through the Lulong Pass. Beyond the frontier the road was cut off, so they cut through hills and filled in valleys for more than five hundred li, passed Baitan and Pinggang, crossed the court of the Xianbei and headed east toward Liucheng, and the enemy only became aware of them when they were two hundred li away. Yuan Shang and Yuan Xi, together with Tadun, Louban, Chanyu of Liaoxi, Nengchen Dizhi, Chanyu of Youbeiping, and others, met them with tens of thousands of horsemen. Records, Wei 1 §99Records, Wei 11 §47
In the 8th month Cao Cao climbed Mount Bailang and suddenly met the enemy, who were very numerous. With the carts and baggage behind and few men in armor, everyone around him was afraid, but Cao Cao climbed to a height, saw that the enemy's ranks were not in order, and attacked with Zhang Liao in the van. The biography of Zhang Liao records that Zhang Liao urged battle with such fervor that Cao Cao gave him the command banner he held in his hand, and that Zhang Liao crushed the enemy and beheaded Tadun. The biography of Cao Chun records that horsemen of Cao Chun's unit captured Tadun. The enemy collapsed completely, Tadun and the renowned kings beneath him were beheaded, and more than 200,000 Hu and Han people surrendered. Records, Wei 1 §99–100Records, Wei 17 §6Records, Wei 9 §46
The Biographies of the Wuhuan, Xianbei and Eastern Yi record this expedition as an event of the 11th year of Jian'an. According to them, Cao Cao advanced secretly by byways and the enemy only became aware of him when he was a hundred-odd li away; Yuan Shang and Tadun met him in battle at Fancheng, and Cao Cao, seeing from a height that the enemy's formation was wavering slightly, attacked and cut off Tadun's head on the field. Records, Wei 30 §11
Supuwan, Chanyu of Liaodong, and others fled to Liaodong together with Yuan Shang and Yuan Xi. Cao Cao did not attack them, saying that Gongsun Kang would behead them and send their heads, and when he returned from Liucheng in the 9th month, Gongsun Kang sent the heads of Yuan Shang, Yuan Xi, Supuwan and the others. Cao Cao explained that Gongsun Kang had always feared Yuan Shang and the others, so that if pressed they would join forces, and if left alone they would plot against each other. Guo Jia fell gravely ill on the way back from Liucheng and died at thirty-eight, and in the 11th month, when Cao Cao reached the Yi River, the acting Chanyu of the Wuhuan of Dai and Shang Commanderies came to congratulate him. Records, Wei 1 §100–102Records, Wei 14 §41
In the Romance
In Chapter 33 of the Romance, when Cao Cao, having pacified Bing Province, discussed attacking the Wuhuan, Cao Hong and others worried that Liu Bei and Liu Biao would attack Xudu, but Guo Jia urged the campaign, saying that the desert peoples would make no preparations and that Liu Biao could not make use of Liu Bei. Amid yellow sand and fierce winds Guo Jia fell ill, unsuited to the climate, and told Cao Cao to march with light troops, covering two days' distance in one, but to find a guide. Romance, Ch. 33 §30–33
Cao Cao left Guo Jia at Yizhou to recuperate and, taking Yuan Shao's former officer Tian Chou as his guide, crossed the perilous ground of Baitan from the Lulong pass and headed for Liucheng. When, on reaching Mount Bailang, he met the tens of thousands of horsemen of Yuan Xi, Yuan Shang and Tadun, Cao Cao saw that the enemy troops were not in order and gave Zhang Liao the command banner. Zhang Liao, with Xu Chu, Yu Jin and Xu Huang, came down the mountain by four routes, beheaded Tadun and received the surrender of the rest, and Yuan Xi and Yuan Shang fled to Liaodong with a few thousand horsemen. Romance, Ch. 33 §34–37
When Cao Cao enfeoffed Tian Chou as Marquis of Liu Village, Tian Chou declined, saying he could not accept a reward for selling the Lulong fortress. On the way back the weather was cold and dry and there was no water for two hundred li, so they ate their horses and dug deep into the earth for water. Reaching Yizhou, Cao Cao learned that Guo Jia had already died and wept bitterly, and when, as Guo Jia's last letter advised, he waited without attacking Liaodong, Gongsun Kang sent the heads of Yuan Xi and Yuan Shang. Romance, Ch. 33 §37–47
Where the Romance differs
Tadun's end: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, Zhang Liao spurred his horse forward and cut Tadun down. The biography of Zhang Liao in the Records says that Zhang Liao crushed the enemy and beheaded Tadun, but the biography of Cao Chun says that horsemen of Cao Chun's unit captured Tadun, and the Biography of the Wuhuan records that Tadun's head was cut off on the field. Romance, Ch. 33 §37Records, Wei 17 §6Records, Wei 9 §46Records, Wei 30 §11
Guo Jia's death and the Liaodong plan: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, Guo Jia, left behind at Yizhou during the expedition, died before Cao Cao returned and left behind in writing his plan, foreseeing that Gongsun Kang would kill the Yuan brothers. In the Records, Guo Jia fell gravely ill and died on the way back from Liucheng, and in the Annals of Emperor Wu it is Cao Cao himself who reckons that Gongsun Kang will behead the Yuan Shang brothers and send their heads. Romance, Ch. 33 §34 · 40–47Records, Wei 14 §41Records, Wei 1 §101–102
Year and place of the battle: Chapter 33 of the Romance depicts it as a battle at Mount Bailang and does not give the year. The Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records says the battle was fought at Mount Bailang in the 8th month of the 12th year of Jian'an (207), while the Biographies of the Wuhuan, Xianbei and Eastern Yi record it as an event of the 11th year of Jian'an in which Yuan Shang and Tadun met Cao Cao at Fancheng. Romance, Ch. 33 §36Records, Wei 1 §99Records, Wei 30 §11
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
Belligerents
| Item | A | B |
|---|---|---|
| Factions | Wei | Wuhuan, Yuan Shang faction |
| Commanders | Cao Cao, Cao Chun, Xu Huang, Zhang He, Zhang Liao, Tian Chou | Yuan Shang, Yuan Xi |
| Strength | 將數萬騎逆軍 | |
| Casualties | 胡、漢降者二十餘萬口 |
Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 1 §100