Battle

Battle of Dingtao 定陶之戰

About this event

The Battle of Dingtao was the fighting in the 2nd year of Xingping (195) in which Cao Cao defeated Lü Bu while recovering Yan Province, which Lü Bu had taken from him. Cao Cao made a surprise attack on Dingtao in spring but could not take it because the Administrator of Jiyin, Wu Zi, held the southern city; in summer he beheaded Lü Bu's commanders Xue Lan and Li Feng, who were stationed at Juye. When Lü Bu came to fight again with Chen Gong at the head of more than 10,000 men, Cao Cao, though short of troops, heavily defeated him with an ambush and surprise troops, and when Lü Bu fled by night he took Dingtao. Lü Bu fled east to Liu Bei. Records, Wei 1 §33–34

Chen Shou recorded this battle in the Annals of Emperor Wu, Records of Wei 1, and also distributed it among the Biographies of Lü Bu, Zhang Miao and Zang Hong in Records of Wei 7, which contain the biographies of Lü Bu and Zhang Miao, the biography of Xun Yu in Records of Wei 10, and the biography of Yu Jin in Records of Wei 17. The Romance depicts this battle at the end of Chapter 12, "Tao Gongzu Thrice Yields Xu Province; Cao Mengde Fights a Great Battle with Lü Bu," and continues with its aftermath at the start of Chapter 13. Records, Wei 1 §33–34Records, Wei 7 §14–15Records, Wei 10 §8–12Records, Wei 17 §28Romance, Ch. 12 §34–42Romance, Ch. 13 §1–3

Course of events in the Records

In the 1st year of Xingping (194) Cao Cao faced Lü Bu at Puyang for more than a hundred days, until swarms of locusts brought severe famine to the people and Lü Bu's provisions also ran out, and both sides withdrew. In the 9th month Cao Cao returned to Juancheng, while Lü Bu was defeated at Chengshi by Li Jin, a man of that county, and stationed himself to the east at Shanyang. That year a hu of grain cost more than 500,000 cash, and people ate one another. Records, Wei 1 §30–32

In the spring of the 2nd year of Xingping (195) Cao Cao made a surprise attack on Dingtao but could not take it because the Administrator of Jiyin, Wu Zi, held the southern city; when Lü Bu arrived just then, Cao Cao attacked and defeated him as well. In summer, when Lü Bu's commanders Xue Lan and Li Feng were stationed at Juye, Cao Cao attacked them; Lü Bu came to rescue Xue Lan, but Xue Lan was defeated and Lü Bu fled, and Cao Cao beheaded Xue Lan and the others. The biography of Xun Yu records that in the summer of that year, when Cao Cao was stationed at Chengshi, there was a great famine and people ate one another. Records, Wei 1 §33Records, Wei 10 §8

When Tao Qian died, Cao Cao wanted first to take Xu Province and then come back to subdue Lü Bu. Xun Yu dissuaded him, saying that since Li Feng and Xue Lan had already been defeated, if he divided his troops and attacked Chen Gong in the east, Chen Gong would not dare look west, and in the meantime he should harvest the ripe wheat and store up grain; Cao Cao followed this, gathered in a great harvest of wheat, and then fought Lü Bu again. Records, Wei 10 §9–12

Lü Bu came from Dongmin to fight again, together with Chen Gong, at the head of more than 10,000 men. Cao Cao's troops were few at this time, but he set an ambush, let loose surprise troops, attacked and heavily defeated him. When Lü Bu fled by night, Cao Cao attacked again, took Dingtao, and divided his troops to subdue the various counties. The biography of Yu Jin records that Yu Jin followed Cao Cao in attacking Shouzhang, Dingtao and Lihu and took them all, and the biography of Lü Bu records that over two years Cao Cao recovered all the cities and crushed Lü Bu at Juye. Records, Wei 1 §33Records, Wei 17 §28Records, Wei 7 §14

Lü Bu fled east to Liu Bei. Zhang Miao followed Lü Bu and had his younger brother Zhang Chao take the family and hold Yongqiu. Cao Cao surrounded Yongqiu in the 8th month, in autumn, and in the 10th month, in winter, the Son of Heaven appointed Cao Cao Governor of Yan Province. When Yongqiu collapsed in the 12th month, the Annals of Emperor Wu records that Zhang Chao killed himself, while the biography of Lü Bu records that Cao Cao massacred the city and beheaded Zhang Chao and his family. Zhang Miao was killed by his own followers while on his way to ask Yuan Shu for help, and Yan Province was pacified. Records, Wei 1 §34Records, Wei 7 §15

In the Romance

In Chapter 12 of the Romance, Cao Cao, having pacified Runan and Yingchuan and won over Xu Chu, hears that Xue Lan and Li Feng in Yan Province have gone out plundering and left their city empty, and rushes straight to Yan Province. Xu Chu beheads Li Feng within two bouts, Xue Lan, fleeing toward Juye, is shot from his horse by Lü Qian's arrow, and Cao Cao recovers Yan Province. Romance, Ch. 12 §33–35

At Puyang, Lü Bu is attacked from both sides by six generals including Xu Chu, Dian Wei, Xiahou Dun, Xiahou Yuan and Yue Jin and returns to the city, but the Tian family inside the city have already surrendered to Cao Cao and will not open the gate, so he flees to Dingtao. Following Liu Ye's advice, Cao Cao pursues him to Dingtao. At this time Lü Bu, Zhang Miao and Zhang Chao are in the city of Dingtao, while Gao Shun, Zhang Liao, Zang Ba and Hou Cheng are out foraging for provisions. Romance, Ch. 12 §36–38

Cao Cao withdraws 40 li from Dingtao and reaps the wheat; seeing that Lü Bu has turned back, suspecting an ambush in the woods, he has many banners planted in the woods and hides picked troops on the embankment west of his camp. The next day Lü Bu comes to set fire to the woods and is heavily defeated by the ambush on the embankment, and his attendant general Cheng Lian is killed by Yue Jin's arrow. Chen Gong and Gao Shun abandon Dingtao, protecting Lü Bu's family; when the city falls, Zhang Chao cuts his own throat and Zhang Miao flees to Yuan Shu. Romance, Ch. 12 §39–42

In Chapter 13, Lü Bu gathers his defeated troops by the sea and wants to fight a decisive battle again, but Chen Gong dissuades him, and on news that Yuan Shao has given Yan Liang 50,000 men to help Cao Cao, Lü Bu goes to seek refuge with Liu Bei in Xu Province. Romance, Ch. 13 §1–3

Where the Romance differs

Xue Lan and Li Feng: In Chapter 12 of the Romance, Li Feng is beheaded by Xu Chu, and Xue Lan, fleeing toward Juye, is killed by Lü Qian's arrow. The Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records says only that when Cao Cao attacked Xue Lan and Li Feng, who were stationed at Juye, and Lü Bu, who had come to their rescue, fled, Cao Cao beheaded Xue Lan and the others. Romance, Ch. 12 §34–35Records, Wei 1 §33

Who held Dingtao: In Chapter 12 of the Romance, Lü Bu, Zhang Miao and Zhang Chao are in the city of Dingtao, and Chen Gong and Gao Shun guard the city and then abandon it. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, the man who held the southern city when Cao Cao made his surprise attack on Dingtao in spring was the Administrator of Jiyin, Wu Zi, and Dingtao fell only after Cao Cao defeated Lü Bu, who had come from Dongmin. Romance, Ch. 12 §38 · 41–42Records, Wei 1 §33

The final fight: In Chapter 12 of the Romance, Lü Bu leaves Chen Gong and Gao Shun in the city, comes out to set fire to the woods, and is defeated by the ambush on the embankment. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, Lü Bu came from Dongmin together with Chen Gong at the head of more than 10,000 men, and Cao Cao, who was short of troops, set an ambush, let loose surprise troops and heavily defeated him. Romance, Ch. 12 §40–42Records, Wei 1 §33

Cheng Lian: In Chapter 12 of the Romance, Lü Bu's commander Cheng Lian is shot dead by Yue Jin's arrow in the fighting at Dingtao. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, Cheng Lian is Lü Bu's valiant commander whom Cao Cao captured at Xiapi in the 3rd year of Jian'an (198). Romance, Ch. 12 §42Records, Wei 1 §48

The end of Zhang Miao and Zhang Chao: In Chapter 12 of the Romance, Zhang Chao cuts his own throat when Dingtao falls, and Zhang Miao flees to Yuan Shu. In the Records, Zhang Chao died while holding Yongqiu when the city collapsed in the 12th month, and Zhang Miao was killed by his own followers while on his way to ask Yuan Shu for help. Romance, Ch. 12 §42Records, Wei 1 §34Records, Wei 7 §15

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsWeiLü Bu faction
CommandersCao CaoChen Gong, Lü Bu, Xue Lan, Li Feng(李封)
Strength布復從東緍與陳宮將萬餘人來戰

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 1 §33

Romance chapters (2)

Records volumes (4)