Battle

Battle of Dongkou 洞口之戰

About this event

The Battle of Dongkou was the fight from the autumn to the winter of the 3rd year of Huangchu (222) in which Wei's Grand General Who Conquers the East Cao Xiu, leading Zhang Liao, Zang Ba and others, faced Wu's Lü Fan at Dongkou on the banks of the Yangtze; it was the eastern of the three routes of Cao Pi's invasions of Eastern Wu. Lü Fan, leading Xu Sheng, Quan Cong, Sun Shao (孫韶) and others, held them off with a fleet, but in the 11th month a great wind scattered his boats and several thousand men drowned. The Records of Wei record that Cao Xiu defeated Lü Fan at Dongpu, while the Records of Wu record that the remaining troops held out across the river until both sides withdrew. Records, Wu 2 §42 · 47Records, Wu 11 §37–38Records, Wei 9 §57Records, Wu 10 §85

Chen Shou recorded this battle in scattered places: the Biographies of the Xiahou and Cao Clans (Records of Wei 9), Records of Wei 14, 17 and 18, the Biography of the Lord of Wu (Records of Wu 2), and Records of Wu 10, 11, 12 and 15. The Romance deals with this battle only through Cao Xiu setting out for Dongkou at the end of Chapter 84 and the report in Chapter 85 that Cao Xiu has been defeated by Lü Fan. Records, Wei 9 §57Records, Wei 14 §70–72Records, Wei 17 §17Records, Wei 18 §29Records, Wu 2 §47Records, Wu 10 §85Records, Wu 11 §37–38Records, Wu 12 §78Records, Wu 15 §17 · 25Romance, Ch. 84 §12Romance, Ch. 85 §14

Course of events in the Records

In the 9th month of autumn of the 3rd year of Huangchu (222), Wei sent Cao Xiu, Zhang Liao and Zang Ba out to Dongkou. Cao Xiu, as Grand General Who Conquers the East and granted the yellow battle-axe, commanded Zhang Liao and others and more than twenty armies of the various provinces and commanderies, and Zhang Liao, though ill, also went by boat with Cao Xiu to Hailing and faced the Yangtze. Sun Quan had Lü Fan lead Xu Sheng, Quan Cong, Sun Shao (孫韶) and others to hold Dongkou with a fleet, and the camps of the two armies faced each other. Records, Wu 2 §42Records, Wei 9 §57Records, Wei 17 §17Records, Wu 11 §37Records, Wu 15 §25

Cao Xiu, having reached Dongpukou, submitted a memorial saying he would sweep south of the river with his elite troops, and Cao Pi, fearing that he would cross the river at once, sent an edict by post-horse to stop him. Dong Zhao, who was at the emperor's side, said that since Zang Ba and the others already enjoyed wealth and rank and would not risk danger, Cao Xiu could not cross on his own. Records, Wei 14 §70–72

In the 11th month a great wind blew, and the boats of Lü Fan and the others broke their cables and drifted away or capsized; several thousand drowned, and the boats that reached the shore were captured by the Wei army. The Biography of Dong Zhao records that the fierce wind drove all the enemy's boats to below the camps of Cao Xiu and the others, who beheaded and captured them so that the enemy scattered and fled, but that despite an edict urging them to cross the river quickly the army did not advance in time, and the enemy's rescue boats arrived. Wu Can, while the other boats were pushing people in the water away with spears, pulled them aboard and saved more than a hundred. Records, Wu 2 §47Records, Wu 11 §38Records, Wu 12 §78–79Records, Wei 14 §72

He Qi, having come late because of the long road, did not cross the river but stayed at Xinshi, so his army alone remained intact, and the generals relied on it to recover their momentum. Xu Sheng gathered the remaining soldiers and faced Cao Xiu across the river, and when Cao Xiu attacked with boats, he held them off with few troops. Cao Xiu had Zang Ba raid Xuling with 500 light boats and 10,000 men ready to die, burning the siege carts and killing or capturing several thousand people, and Quan Cong and Xu Sheng pursued them and beheaded the Wei general Yin Lu. Records, Wu 15 §17 · 25Records, Wu 10 §85Records, Wu 2 §47

In the Records of Wei, the biographies of Cao Xiu, Zang Ba and Jia Kui record that they defeated Lü Fan at Dongpu, and the Biography of Zhang Liao records that this year Zhang Liao, after defeating Lü Fan together with the other generals, grew gravely ill and died at Jiangdu. In the Records of Wu, the Biography of Xu Sheng says that both sides withdrew with their troops, and the Biography of Lü Fan records that after the army returned, Lü Fan was appointed Governor of Yang Province. Records, Wei 9 §57Records, Wei 18 §29Records, Wei 15 §78Records, Wei 17 §17Records, Wu 10 §85Records, Wu 11 §38

In the Romance

In Chapter 84 of the Romance, Cao Pi, taking advantage of the Wu army having gone west in pursuit of Shu, has Cao Xiu lead an army out to Dongkou, and Lu Xun, anticipating this, sends troops to block him. In Chapter 85 Wu has Lü Fan oppose Cao Xiu, and following the reports that Cao Ren and Cao Zhen have been defeated, a report comes in that Cao Xiu too has been defeated by Lü Fan. The Romance does not depict the fighting at Dongkou as a separate scene. Romance, Ch. 84 §12 · 48–49Romance, Ch. 85 §8 · 14

Where the Romance differs

Victory and defeat: In Chapter 85 of the Romance, Cao Xiu is defeated by Lü Fan. In the Records, the biographies of Cao Xiu and Zang Ba say that they defeated Lü Fan at Dongpu, the Biography of the Lord of Wu records that several thousand of Lü Fan's soldiers drowned in a great wind, and the Biography of Xu Sheng records that both sides withdrew. Romance, Ch. 85 §14Records, Wei 9 §57Records, Wei 18 §29Records, Wu 2 §47Records, Wu 10 §85

Zhang Liao's end: The Romance does not send Zhang Liao to Dongkou, and has him die after being hit by an arrow in the fighting at Guangling in Chapter 86. In the Biography of Zhang Liao in the Records, Zhang Liao, though ill, faced the Yangtze at Hailing with Cao Xiu, and after defeating Lü Fan that year he died of illness at Jiangdu. Romance, Ch. 84 §12Romance, Ch. 86 §45–46Records, Wei 17 §17

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsWeiWu
CommandersCao Xiu, Zhang Liao, Zang Ba, Jia Kui(賈逵)Lü Fan, Xu Sheng, Quan Cong, Sun Shao(孫韶), He Qi, Wu Can
Casualties追斬魏將尹盧。殺獲數百呂範等兵溺死者數千

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wu 2 §47

Romance chapters (2)

Records volumes (10)