RHeld firm on Tian Yu's plan and judged the moment for pursuit correctlyWei 19 §4Wei 19 §6
NCao Cao judged him brave but lacking in strategyCh. 78 §30
| Occupation | RGeneral · General of Valiant Cavalry NGeneral · Marquis of Yanling | Faction | Wei |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | R? Unverified | Native place | Pei Commandery Qiao County Unverified |
| Died | R223 Unverified | Place of death | |
| Cause of death | RIllness Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R11 |
Cao Zhang, courtesy name Ziwen, was a son of Taizu, Cao Cao, born of Empress Bian (Wuxuan), and a full brother of Emperor Wen, Cao Pi, and of Cao Zhi. From his youth he was skilled at archery and riding, and his physical strength surpassed that of other men. Records, Wei 19 §2Records, Wei 20 §2
In the 23rd year of Jian'an (218), when the Wuhuan of Dai Commandery rebelled, he set out as General of the Household of the North and acting General of Valiant Cavalry, pursued them as far as Sanggan and routed them, and Kebineng of the Xianbei also asked to submit. In the 3rd year of Huangchu (222) he became Prince of Rencheng, and in the 4th year (223), having come to court at the capital, he died of illness at his residence. Records, Wei 19 §4–6 · 9Records, Wei 2 §44
In his assessment, Chen Shou, author of the Records, said that he was 'martial in skill, sturdy and fierce, with the bearing of a commander.' In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 72, and he appears in 3 of its 120 chapters; no chapter has his name in its title. The Romance portrays the scene in which he comes to aid Cao Cao in Hanzhong and spears Wu Lan, and the scene in which, after Cao Cao's death, he arrives leading troops and, at Jia Kui's words, hands his troops and horses over to Cao Pi. Records, Wei 19 §69Romance, Ch. 72 §20 · 24Romance, Ch. 79 §1–3
Cao Zhang, Prince Wei of Rencheng, had the courtesy name Ziwen. From his youth he was skilled at archery and riding, and his physical strength surpassed that of other men, so that he grappled with fierce beasts bare-handed and did not shy from dangerous places. He followed many campaigns, and his spirit was bold and impassioned. Taizu checked him, saying that he gave no thought to reading books and aspiring to the way of the sages but liked only riding sweat-blooded horses and fencing, which was of no more use than a single man, and he set him to read the Book of Songs and the Book of Documents. Cao Zhang said to those around him that a true man should simply be like Wei Qing or Huo Qubing, leading a hundred thousand cavalry across the desert to drive out the Rong and Di and win merit; how could he become an Erudite? Records, Wei 19 §2
When Taizu asked each of his sons his ambition, Cao Zhang answered that he liked to be a commander: he would wear strong armor and grasp sharp weapons, not look back in the face of difficulty, go ahead of his soldiers, and make sure rewards were always given and punishments always kept faith. Taizu laughed heartily. In the 21st year of Jian'an (216) he was enfeoffed as Marquis of Yanling. Records, Wei 19 §3
In the 23rd year of Jian'an (218), when the Wuhuan of Dai Commandery rebelled, Taizu made Cao Zhang General of the Household of the North and acting General of Valiant Cavalry. The Annals of Emperor Wu record this rebellion as raised in the 4th month, in summer of that year, by Wuchendi and other Wuhuan of Dai and Shanggu. When he set out, Taizu warned him that at home they were father and son, but once he took up the task they were lord and subject, and he must act according to the king's law. When Cao Zhang entered the border of Zhuo Commandery, several thousand rebel Hu cavalry suddenly bore down on him, and as his troops and horses had not yet all assembled he had only a thousand foot soldiers and a few hundred horsemen. Using Tian Yu's plan, he held the strategic points firmly, and the enemy withdrew and scattered. The biography of Tian Yu also records that, as Chancellor, Tian Yu had the carts turned to form a circular formation and drove off the Hu, and that the pacification of Dai Commandery was all owing to Tian Yu's plans. Records, Wei 19 §4Records, Wei 1 §161Records, Wei 26 §28
Cao Zhang pursued the enemy, fighting hand to hand himself and shooting the Hu horsemen, who fell one after another at the twang of his bowstring. After the fighting had gone on for more than half a day, several arrows were lodged in his armor, but his spirit grew all the fiercer, and he chased the fleeing enemy to Sanggan, more than two hundred li from Dai County. His Chief Clerk and commanders said that they had come a long way and were exhausted, and that they had received orders not to go beyond Dai County, so they must not advance deep. Cao Zhang declared that leading an army forward meant going wherever advantage lay, and that letting the enemy go in order to follow orders was not the mark of a good commander, and he ordered that anyone who set out late would be beheaded. Within a day and a night he caught up with the enemy and routed them, beheading and capturing them by the thousands, and he rewarded his officers and men at double the usual rate. Kebineng, a great chief of the Xianbei who was watching the balance of strength with several tens of thousands of horsemen, saw that Cao Zhang broke every force he struck, and asked to submit. Records, Wei 19 §5–6
When the north had all been pacified, Taizu, who was at Chang'an, summoned Cao Zhang to his headquarters. As Cao Zhang passed through Ye on his way from Dai County, the crown prince told him that, having newly won merit, he should not boast of it but should answer always as though he fell short, and Cao Zhang did as he said and gave the credit to his commanders. Taizu was delighted, took hold of his beard and said, 'My yellow-bearded boy has turned out truly remarkable!' When Taizu returned east, he made Cao Zhang acting General of the Elite Cavalry and left him at Chang'an. Records, Wei 19 §7–8
When Taizu reached Luoyang and fell ill, he summoned Cao Zhang by post horse, but Taizu died before he arrived. According to the biography of Jia Kui, while Jia Kui was in charge of the funeral arrangements, Cao Zhang, Marquis of Yanling, then acting General of the Elite Cavalry, came hurrying from Chang'an and asked where the late king's seal and ribbon were. Jia Kui replied sternly that the crown prince was at Ye, so the late king's seal and ribbon were not something His Lordship should ask about, and he escorted the coffin back to Ye. Records, Wei 19 §8Records, Wei 15 §74
When Emperor Wen succeeded to the kingship, Cao Zhang went to his fief along with the other lords. In an edict Emperor Wen declared that Cao Zhang had earlier received orders to campaign in the north and had pacified the northern lands, so his merit was great, and he added five thousand households to his fief, making ten thousand in all. In the 2nd year of Huangchu (221) his rank was raised to duke, and in the 3rd year (222) he was established as Prince of Rencheng. In the 4th year (223), having come to court at the capital, he died of illness at his residence and was given the posthumous name Wei; the Annals of Emperor Wen date his death to the day jiaxu of the 6th month. At his burial he was granted an imperial carriage with bells, dragon banners and a hundred Rapid as Tigers guards, after the precedent of the Prince of Dongping of the Han, and his son Cao Kai succeeded him. Records, Wei 19 §8–9Records, Wei 2 §44
In his assessment, Chen Shou said that the Prince of Rencheng was martial in skill, sturdy and fierce, with the bearing of a commander. Records, Wei 19 §69
In Chapter 72 of the Romance, when Cao Cao, who has abandoned Yangping Pass and fled, reaches the mouth of the Xie Valley, a body of troops appears; it is Cao Cao's second son, Cao Zhang. The Romance introduces him as having been skilled at riding and archery from his youth and able to kill fierce beasts with his bare hands. To Cao Cao's rebuke that he does not read books but loves only bow and horse, which is merely the valor of a common fellow, Cao Zhang replies that he will follow the example of Wei Qing and Huo Qubing, winning merit in the desert and leading a host of several hundred thousand across the realm. Asked what he would do as a commander, he says he would go ahead of his soldiers himself and make sure rewards and punishments always kept faith. Romance, Ch. 72 §19–21
In the same chapter, when the Wuhuan of Dai Commandery rebel in the 23rd year of Jian'an, Cao Cao gives Cao Zhang fifty thousand troops to attack them, warning him that at home they are father and son but once he takes up the task they are lord and subject, and that the law does not bend to personal feeling. North of Dai, Cao Zhang leads the battle line himself, fights his way as far as Sanggan and pacifies the north, and then, hearing that Cao Cao has been defeated at Yangping, comes to help in the fighting. Cao Cao is overjoyed, saying, 'Now that my yellow-bearded boy has come, defeating Liu Bei is certain,' and again pitches camp at the mouth of the Xie Valley. Romance, Ch. 72 §21–22
When Liu Feng and Meng Da come out on Liu Bei's side, Cao Zhang fights Liu Feng and sends him back badly beaten after only three bouts. But the troops of Ma Chao and Wu Lan charge in and Cao Cao's army collapses, and Cao Zhang, clashing with Wu Lan, knocks him from his horse with a single thrust of his halberd within a few bouts. Romance, Ch. 72 §22–24
In Chapter 78, before he dies, Cao Cao names to Cao Hong and others the four sons borne by Lady Bian, saying that his second son Cao Zhang is brave but lacks strategy, and he has his eldest son Cao Pi succeed him. When Cao Cao dies, word of the death is sent to Cao Zhang, Marquis of Yanling, as well, and while Cao Pi is holding a banquet after becoming King of Wei, a report arrives that Cao Zhang, Marquis of Yanling, is coming from Chang'an with a great army of a hundred thousand. Cao Pi is greatly alarmed, saying that his yellow-bearded younger brother, unyielding by nature and deeply versed in the martial arts, has come to contend with him for the throne. Romance, Ch. 78 §29–30 · 34 · 39
In Chapter 79 the Grand Master of Remonstrance Jia Kui goes out of the city to meet Cao Zhang. When Cao Zhang asks where the late king's seal and ribbon are, Jia Kui sternly replies that a family has its eldest son and a state its heir, so it is not something His Lordship should ask about. At the palace gate, asked whether he has come to mourn or to contend for the throne, Cao Zhang says he has come only to mourn, and when asked why, then, he enters with troops, he dismisses the commanders and soldiers around him, goes in alone and bows to Cao Pi. The two brothers embrace and weep aloud, and Cao Zhang hands over all the troops and horses under his command to Cao Pi, then departs on receiving the order to return to Yanling and guard it. The Romance does not afterwards depict Cao Zhang's death. Romance, Ch. 79 §1–3
A true man's words: In Chapter 72 of the Romance, Cao Zhang answers Cao Cao's rebuke that he does not read books directly to Cao Cao, saying that he will follow the example of Wei Qing and Huo Qubing and lead a host of several hundred thousand. In the Records, when Taizu set him to read the Book of Songs and the Book of Documents, Cao Zhang said to those around him that he would lead a hundred thousand cavalry across the desert. Romance, Ch. 72 §20Records, Wei 19 §2
Forces for the northern campaign: In Chapter 72 of the Romance, Cao Cao sends Cao Zhang off with fifty thousand troops. In the Records, Cao Zhang set out as General of the Household of the North and acting General of Valiant Cavalry, and when several thousand Hu horsemen bore down on him at the border of Zhuo Commandery, his troops and horses had not all assembled and he had only a thousand foot soldiers and a few hundred horsemen. Romance, Ch. 72 §21Records, Wei 19 §4
Course of the campaign: Chapter 72 of the Romance says only that Cao Zhang led the way himself, fought his way as far as Sanggan and pacified the north. In the Records, after driving off the enemy by holding the strategic points on Tian Yu's plan, he overrode his Chief Clerk and commanders, who tried to stop him citing orders not to go beyond Dai County, pursued for a day and a night and routed the enemy, and on seeing this Kebineng asked to submit. Romance, Ch. 72 §22Records, Wei 19 §4–6
The Hanzhong campaign: In Chapter 72 of the Romance, after pacifying the north, Cao Zhang comes to the mouth of the Xie Valley to help Cao Cao, defeated at Yangping, and drives back Liu Feng. In the Records, Taizu, who was at Chang'an, summoned Cao Zhang; Cao Zhang passed through Ye, came to Chang'an and gave the credit to his commanders, and Taizu left him at Chang'an when he returned east. The biography of Cao Zhang in the Records has no record of his taking part in the Hanzhong campaign. Romance, Ch. 72 §22–23Records, Wei 19 §7–8
Wu Lan's slayer: In Chapter 72 of the Romance, Cao Zhang spears Wu Lan to death with his halberd. In the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records, in the 23rd year of Jian'an (218), after Cao Hong defeated Wu Lan, in the 3rd month Qiang Duan of the Di of Yinping beheaded Wu Lan and sent his head. Romance, Ch. 72 §24Records, Wei 1 §160
The yellow beard: In Chapter 72 of the Romance, on seeing Cao Zhang arrive in Hanzhong, Cao Cao says, 'Now that my yellow-bearded boy has come, defeating Liu Bei is certain.' In the Records, when Cao Zhang, having come after pacifying the north, gave the credit to his commanders, Taizu took hold of his beard and said, 'My yellow-bearded boy has turned out truly remarkable!' Romance, Ch. 72 §22Records, Wei 19 §7
Cao Cao's last words: In Chapter 78 of the Romance, Cao Cao says in his last words that Cao Zhang is brave but lacks strategy. The biography of Cao Zhang in the Records has no such words and records that when Taizu fell ill at Luoyang he summoned Cao Zhang by post horse, but died before Cao Zhang arrived. Romance, Ch. 78 §30Records, Wei 19 §8
Asking for the seal: In Chapters 78 and 79 of the Romance, Cao Zhang comes to Cao Pi from Chang'an with a great army of a hundred thousand, asks Jia Kui, who has come out to meet him, about the seal, and then hands over all his troops and horses to Cao Pi. In the biography of Jia Kui in the Records, when Taizu had died at Luoyang and Jia Kui was in charge of the funeral arrangements, Cao Zhang came hurrying from Chang'an and asked about the seal and ribbon, and Jia Kui escorted the coffin back to Ye. The great army of a hundred thousand and the handover of troops and horses are not in the Records. Romance, Ch. 78 §39Romance, Ch. 79 §1–3Records, Wei 15 §74Records, Wei 19 §8
Afterwards: In Chapter 79 of the Romance, Cao Zhang departs on receiving the order to return to Yanling and guard it and does not appear again, and his death is not recorded. In the Records, his fief was increased to ten thousand households, he became Prince of Rencheng in the 3rd year of Huangchu (222), and in the 4th year (223), having come to court at the capital, he died of illness at his residence. Romance, Ch. 79 §3Records, Wei 19 §8–9
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RHeld firm on Tian Yu's plan and judged the moment for pursuit correctlyWei 19 §4Wei 19 §6
NCao Cao judged him brave but lacking in strategyCh. 78 §30
RGave double rewards so that all his officers and men rejoiced, and Kebineng submittedWei 19 §6
NNo direct record — estimated from Cao Cao's great delight at his arrivalCh. 72 §22
RPursued the Wuhuan of Dai Commandery, routed them and pacified the northWei 19 §4Wei 19 §6Wei 19 §7
NPacified the land north of Dai with fifty thousand troops and came to Hanzhong as reinforcementsCh. 72 §21Ch. 72 §22
RFought fierce beasts bare-handed and, fighting in person, shot down enemy horsemenWei 19 §2Wei 19 §5Wei 19 §69
NDrove off Liu Feng in three bouts and knocked Wu Lan from his horse with a halberd thrustCh. 72 §23Ch. 72 §24Ch. 72 §20
RNo direct record — no record of administrationWei 19 §9
NNo direct record — no record of administrationCh. 72 §21
RDid not read books, so Taizu set him the Book of Songs and the Book of DocumentsWei 19 §2
NDid not read books and loved only bow and horseCh. 72 §20
RNo direct record — estimated from his deedsWei 19 §4
NNo direct record — estimated from his deedsCh. 72 §21
RNMaster +25 Recorded as skilled at riding from his youthWei 19 §2Ch. 72 §20
RNMaster +25 Skilled at archery; enemy horsemen fell at each shotWei 19 §2Wei 19 §5
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
| Parents | Empress Bian (Wuxuan) Novel & History, Cao Cao Novel & History |
|---|---|
| Siblings | Cao Hui Records, Cao Chong Records, Cao Ang Novel & History, Cao Yu Records, Cao Jie Romance, Cao Jun(曹均) Records, Cao Lin(曹林) Records, Cao Biao Records, Cao Gun Records, Cao Xiong Novel & History, Cao Jun(曹峻) Records, Cao Zheng Records, Cao Zhi Novel & History, Princess Qinghe Romance, Cao Gan Records, Cao Pi Novel & History |
Based on Wikidata items for the historical and Romance figures. Relations without the Unverified badge were also confirmed in the Records.
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).