RRecognized Gao Rou and Wang Ji when they were young and was praised as a judge of menWei 11 §66Wei 11 §59
NNo direct record — estimated from his roleCh. 32 §17
| Occupation | ROfficial · Minister of Ceremonies NOfficial · Attendant Officer with Separate Carriage | Faction | Wei |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | Native place | Beihai Commandery Yingling County | |
| Cause of death | RIllness Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R23 |
Wang Xiu, courtesy name Shuzhi, was a man of Yingling County in Beihai State. Under Kong Rong of Beihai he served as acting Prefect of Gaomi and of Jiaodong and held down the powerful clans, and whenever Kong Rong was in danger he rushed to his rescue. Later, as Attendant Officer with Separate Carriage to Yuan Tan, he remonstrated with him not to fight Yuan Shang. Records, Wei 11 §54–61
When Yuan Tan died, Wang Xiu went to Cao Cao and asked to be allowed to collect and bury the body, and was granted permission. Seeing that his house held less than ten hu of grain and only several hundred scrolls of books, Cao Cao summoned him and made him a clerk to the Minister of Works. After serving as Administrator of Wei Commandery, once the state of Wei was established he held the posts of Minister of Agriculture, Prefect of the Palace Gentlemen and Minister of Ceremonies, and died of illness in office. Records, Wei 11 §61–65
In his assessment, Chen Shou, author of the Records, said that 'Wang Xiu was loyal and upright, enough to correct the ways of the world'. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 32 as Yuan Tan's Attendant Officer with Separate Carriage and appears in 2 of its 120 chapters; no chapter has his name in its title. In Chapter 33 he weeps beneath Yuan Tan's displayed head and is brought before Cao Cao. Records, Wei 11 §111Romance, Ch. 32 §17Romance, Ch. 33 §20–21
Wang Xiu, courtesy name Shuzhi, was a man of Yingling County in Beihai State. He lost his mother at the age of seven; because she had died on the day of the sacrifice to the god of the soil, when the neighboring villages held that sacrifice the following year he thought of his mother and grieved bitterly. Hearing of this, the neighbors called off the sacrifice for his sake. At twenty he went to study in Nanyang and lodged in the house of Zhang Feng, and when Zhang Feng's whole household fell ill with no one to look after them, he cared for them himself and left only after they had recovered. Records, Wei 11 §54
In the Chuping era Kong Rong of Beihai summoned him as Registrar and made him acting Prefect of Gaomi. The retainers of the Sun family, a powerful and swaggering clan of Gaomi, had broken the law many times, and when a robber took refuge in their house, the officials could not seize him. Wang Xiu led the officials and people to surround the house and ordered that anyone who dared not attack would be punished for the same crime. The frightened Sun family handed over the robber, and from then on the powerful clans and the influential were cowed into submission. When he was recommended as Filial and Incorrupt he tried to yield the honor to Bing Yuan, but Kong Rong would not allow it, and as the realm was in turmoil he never went in the end. Records, Wei 11 §54–55
Shortly afterward, when a rebellion broke out in the commandery, Wang Xiu heard that Kong Rong was in danger and hurried to him by night. Kong Rong had just told his attendants that the only one who would brave the danger to come was Wang Xiu, when Wang Xiu arrived. He again became Officer of Merit, and because there were many bandits in Jiaodong he was made acting Prefect of Jiaodong. When Gongsha Lu of Jiaodong, relying on the strength of his clan, built camps and moats and refused to answer the levies, Wang Xiu rode in through his gate with only a few horsemen and beheaded Gongsha Lu and his brothers. Whenever Kong Rong met with danger, Wang Xiu never failed to come, even when he was home on leave, and Kong Rong always relied on him to escape harm. Records, Wei 11 §56–57
When Yuan Tan was in Qing Province he summoned Wang Xiu as Headquarters Officer, and the Attendant Officer with Separate Carriage Liu Xian repeatedly slandered him. Later, when Liu Xian was to be put to death over some matter, Wang Xiu defended him and saved him from death, and people thought all the more highly of him for this. Yuan Shao also summoned him and appointed him Prefect of Jimo, and later he again became Yuan Tan's Attendant Officer with Separate Carriage. After Yuan Shao's death, when Yuan Shang attacked Yuan Tan and Yuan Tan's army was defeated, Wang Xiu led officials and people to his rescue, and Yuan Tan rejoiced, saying that the one who had kept his army intact was Attendant Officer Wang. Records, Wei 11 §58
After Yuan Tan's defeat, when Liu Xun raised troops at Taiyin and many cities rose in support, Wang Xiu said that Guan Tong, the Administrator of Donglai, alone would not rebel and would surely come. Some ten days later Guan Tong did indeed abandon his wife and children and hurried to him, and his wife and children were killed by the rebels. When Yuan Tan wanted to attack Yuan Shang again, Wang Xiu remonstrated that brothers attacking each other was the road to ruin. Yuan Tan was displeased but recognized his loyalty. Records, Wei 11 §59–60
When Yuan Tan later asked him again for a plan, Wang Xiu said that brothers are like the left and right hands, and asked whether it could be right for a man about to fight to cut off his own right hand and claim he would surely win; slanderers were trying to sow discord between them to seek a single day's profit, so Yuan Tan should stop his ears, and if he beheaded a few flattering ministers and was reconciled with his brother, he could range freely across the realm. Yuan Tan did not listen, fought Yuan Shang and asked Cao Cao for help. After Cao Cao had taken Ji Province, Yuan Tan rebelled again, and Cao Cao attacked him at Nanpi. Wang Xiu, who was transporting grain at Le'an, heard that Yuan Tan was in danger and hurried to him with his soldiers and several dozen attendant officers, but on reaching Gaomi he heard that Yuan Tan was dead, dismounted and wailed, 'Without my lord, where shall I go?' The Annals of Emperor Wu records that Yuan Tan was beheaded in the 1st month, in spring of the 10th year of Jian'an (205). Records, Wei 11 §60–61Records, Wei 1 §88
Wang Xiu went to Cao Cao and asked to be allowed to collect and bury Yuan Tan's body. When Cao Cao, wishing to test his resolve, kept silent and did not answer, he said again that he had received great kindness from the Yuan family, and that if he could only collect and shroud the body, he would have no regrets even if he were put to death afterward. Cao Cao admired his righteousness and granted the request, and made him Superintendent of Army Provisions and sent him back to Le'an. All the cities submitted, but Guan Tong alone held Le'an and would not obey. Cao Cao ordered Wang Xiu to bring him Guan Tong's head, but Wang Xiu, regarding Guan Tong as a loyal minister of a fallen state, untied his bonds and sent him to Cao Cao, who was pleased and pardoned Guan Tong. Records, Wei 11 §62–63
Because the Yuan family's rule was lenient, those in office and power had amassed great wealth, and after taking Ye, Cao Cao confiscated the property of Shen Pei and others, which was counted in the tens of thousands. But when he inspected Wang Xiu's house after taking Nanpi, there was less than ten hu of grain and several hundred scrolls of books. Cao Cao sighed that a gentleman does not gain his reputation for nothing, summoned him with due courtesy as a clerk to the Minister of Works and made him acting General of the Household in Charge of Metals. Later he was transferred to Administrator of Wei Commandery, where he held down the strong, helped the weak and made rewards and punishments clear, and the people praised him. Records, Wei 11 §63
When the state of Wei was established, he became Minister of Agriculture and Prefect of the Palace Gentlemen. When Cao Cao discussed restoring mutilating punishments, Wang Xiu said that the time was not yet right, and Cao Cao accepted his view. After he was transferred to Minister of Ceremonies, when Yan Cai rose in revolt and attacked the side gate of the palace with several dozen followers, Wang Xiu called for his carriage and horses, and when they did not come, he led his subordinates on foot to the palace gate. Watching from the Bronze Sparrow Terrace, Cao Cao said that the man coming must be Wang Shuzhi. When the Chancellor of State Zhong Yao said that by old custom the Nine Ministers each stayed in their offices when there was trouble in the capital, Wang Xiu replied that one who eats a salary cannot avoid its troubles, and that staying in one's office was not the duty of rushing to meet danger. Shortly afterward he died of illness in office, and his son Wang Zhong rose to be Administrator of Donglai and Cavalier Regular Attendant. Records, Wei 11 §64–65
Wang Xiu recognized Gao Rou when Gao Rou was about twenty and thought Wang Ji remarkable when he was a small child, and as both eventually rose to high positions, the world praised him as a judge of men. In his assessment, Chen Shou said that Tian Chou did not bend in his integrity and that Wang Xiu was loyal and upright, enough to correct the ways of the world, explaining why he had recorded the men of this volume together. Records, Wei 11 §66 · 111
In Chapter 32 of the Romance, Yuan Tan, resentful that Yuan Shang has succeeded their father, follows Guo Tu's plan to invite Yuan Shang to a drinking party and kill him. When he tells this plan to Wang Xiu, the Attendant Officer with Separate Carriage, who has just arrived from Qing Province, Wang Xiu remonstrates that brothers are like the left and right hands, and asks whether one can cut off one's own right hand while fighting others and still claim certain victory. When he says that slanderers are setting flesh and blood against each other to seek a single day's profit and that Yuan Tan should stop his ears, Yuan Tan angrily rebukes him and sends him away, and sends men to invite Yuan Shang. Romance, Ch. 32 §16–17
In Chapter 33, after Yuan Tan is killed by Cao Hong at Nanpi, Cao Cao hangs Yuan Tan's head outside the north gate and orders that anyone who weeps for him be beheaded. A man in a hemp cap and mourning clothes is brought in for weeping beneath the head; it is Wang Xiu, the Attendant Officer with Separate Carriage of Qing Province, who had been driven away after remonstrating with Yuan Tan. He had learned of Yuan Tan's death and come to mourn him. Romance, Ch. 33 §19–20
When Cao Cao asks whether he knew of the order, Wang Xiu answers that he did, and when asked whether he is not afraid of death, he says that having received Yuan Tan's summons in life, it would not be righteous not to mourn him in death, and that one who forgets righteousness for fear of death could not stand in the world. When he says that if only he can collect and bury Yuan Tan's body he will have no regrets even in death, Cao Cao exclaims at how many righteous men there are north of the Yellow River, and regrets that the Yuan family could not make use of them. Romance, Ch. 33 §21
Cao Cao lets him collect and bury Yuan Tan's body, treats Wang Xiu as an honored guest and makes him General of the Household in Charge of Metals. He then asks for a plan to capture Yuan Shang, who has gone to Yuan Xi, but when Wang Xiu does not answer, Cao Cao calls him a loyal minister and asks Guo Jia instead. Romance, Ch. 33 §22
The timing of his remonstrance: In Chapter 32 of the Romance, Wang Xiu remonstrates on hearing of Yuan Tan's plan to invite Yuan Shang to a drinking party and kill him, and is rebuked and sent away. In the Records, he remonstrated when Yuan Tan wanted to attack Yuan Shang again, and Yuan Tan, though displeased, recognized his loyalty and later asked him again for a plan. The drinking-party plot is not in Wang Xiu's biography in the Records. Romance, Ch. 32 §16–17Records, Wei 11 §59–61
At Yuan Tan's death: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, Wang Xiu, already driven away for remonstrating, learns of Yuan Tan's death and comes to mourn him. In the Records, Wang Xiu was transporting grain at Le'an at the time, and on hearing that Yuan Tan was in danger he hurried to him with his soldiers and several dozen attendant officers, but heard of Yuan Tan's death at Gaomi. Romance, Ch. 33 §20Records, Wei 11 §61
Where he mourned and Cao Cao's order: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, he weeps beneath Yuan Tan's head hung outside the north gate and is seized under Cao Cao's order to behead anyone who mourns. In the Records, he dismounted at Gaomi and wailed, then went to Cao Cao of his own accord and asked to be allowed to collect the body. The order to behead mourners is not in Wang Xiu's biography or in this passage of the Annals of Emperor Wu in the Records. Romance, Ch. 33 §20Records, Wei 11 §61–62Records, Wei 1 §88
Cao Cao's response: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, Cao Cao regrets that there are so many righteous men north of the Yellow River and the Yuan family could not use them. In the Records, Cao Cao kept silent without answering to test Wang Xiu's resolve, and when Wang Xiu asked again, he admired his righteousness and granted the request. Romance, Ch. 33 §21Records, Wei 11 §62
How he became General of the Household in Charge of Metals: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, on the spot where Cao Cao allows Yuan Tan's burial, he treats Wang Xiu as an honored guest and makes him General of the Household in Charge of Metals. In the Records, Cao Cao first sent him back to Le'an as Superintendent of Army Provisions, and only after taking Nanpi and seeing that his house held less than ten hu of grain and only several hundred scrolls of books did he summon him as a clerk to the Minister of Works and make him acting General of the Household in Charge of Metals. Romance, Ch. 33 §22Records, Wei 11 §62–63
A plan against Yuan Shang: In Chapter 33 of the Romance, when Cao Cao asks for a plan to capture Yuan Shang, Wang Xiu does not answer, and Cao Cao calls him a loyal minister. This exchange is not in Wang Xiu's biography in the Records; instead, ordered to bring Guan Tong's head, he regarded Guan Tong as a loyal minister of a fallen state, untied his bonds and sent him to Cao Cao. Guan Tong does not appear in the Romance. Romance, Ch. 33 §22Records, Wei 11 §62–63
His life before and after: The Romance depicts only his time as Yuan Tan's Attendant Officer with Separate Carriage and the scene in Chapter 33. The Records covers everything from his service under Kong Rong as acting Prefect of Gaomi and of Jiaodong and his rescue of Yuan Tan, to his posts as Administrator of Wei Commandery, Minister of Agriculture, Prefect of the Palace Gentlemen and Minister of Ceremonies, when he hurried on foot to the palace gate during Yan Cai's revolt. Romance, Ch. 32 §17Romance, Ch. 33 §22Records, Wei 11 §54–65
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RRecognized Gao Rou and Wang Ji when they were young and was praised as a judge of menWei 11 §66Wei 11 §59
NNo direct record — estimated from his roleCh. 32 §17
RCowed the powerful clans, governed Wei Commandery with clear rewards and punishments, and delayed mutilating punishmentsWei 11 §55Wei 11 §63Wei 11 §64
NNo direct record — estimated from his appointment as General of the Household in Charge of MetalsCh. 33 §22
RRode into Gongsha Lu's house with a few horsemen and beheaded him and his brothersWei 11 §56
NNo direct record — estimated from his role as a civil officialCh. 32 §17
RLed officials and people to Yuan Tan's aid and kept his defeated army intactWei 11 §58
NNo direct record — estimated from his post as Attendant Officer with Separate CarriageCh. 32 §17
RKong Rong always relied on him to escape harm, and the people of Wei Commandery praised himWei 11 §57Wei 11 §63
NNo direct record — estimated from Cao Cao calling him a righteous manCh. 33 §21
RCorrectly foresaw that Guan Tong would come, and warned that fighting between brothers was the road to ruinWei 11 §59Wei 11 §60
NSaw through the slanderers trying to set flesh and blood against each otherCh. 32 §17
RWon Cao Cao's recognition by asking to bury his former lord, and rushed to meet dangerWei 11 §62Wei 11 §65
NMourned prepared to die, but was treated with courtesy by Cao CaoCh. 33 §21
RRisked death to ask for Yuan Tan's body and had no grain at home; assessment: loyal and uprightWei 11 §62Wei 11 §63Wei 11 §111
NWept beneath Yuan Tan's head despite knowing the ban, and never offered a plan against his former lord's familyCh. 33 §20Ch. 33 §21Ch. 33 §22
RStudied in Nanyang and had several hundred scrolls of books at homeWei 11 §54Wei 11 §63
NNo direct record — estimated from his roleCh. 32 §17
RDefended Liu Xian, who faced execution, and saved him, and persuaded Cao Cao to let him bury Yuan TanWei 11 §58Wei 11 §62
NLikened brothers to hands in his remonstrance but was rebuffed by Yuan Tan, while winning Cao Cao's admirationCh. 32 §17Ch. 33 §21
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →