RDefended Mao Jie, and was so honest and poor that he sold his fields and house to support himselfWei 23 §7Wei 23 §14
NProposed elevating Cao Cao to King of WeiCh. 66 §33
| Occupation | ROfficial · Minister of Ceremonies NOfficial · Palace Attendant | Faction | Wei |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | Book of Wei |
| Born | Native place | Runan Commandery Xiping County | |
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R20 |
He Qia, courtesy name Yangshi, was a man of Xiping County in Runan Commandery. When Yuan Shao invited the gentry of Runan to join him, he alone did not respond and went to Liu Biao, then moved on to Wuling, and when the Grand Progenitor (Cao Cao) pacified Jing Province, he became a member of the Chancellor's staff. Records, Wei 23 §2–4
When the state of Wei was founded he became Palace Attendant and defended Mao Jie, who had been slandered, and he rose to Superintendent of the Imperial Household under Emperor Wen and Minister of Ceremonies under Emperor Ming. He was so honest and poor that he sold his fields and house to support himself, and after his death he was given the posthumous name Marquis Jian. Records, Wei 23 §6 · 10 · 14
In his assessment Chen Shou said of him that he 'was pure and mild and had a talent for managing affairs'. In the Romance he appears once, in Chapter 66, named as one of the four Palace Attendants who propose to elevate Cao Cao to King of Wei. Records, Wei 23 §75Romance, Ch. 66 §33
He Qia, courtesy name Yangshi, was a man of Xiping County in Runan Commandery. He was nominated as Filial and Incorrupt and was also summoned by the General-in-Chief, but declined both. When Yuan Shao, in Ji Province, sent envoys to invite the gentry of Runan, He Qia alone reasoned as follows: Ji Province had flat land and strong people and was coveted by heroes, a land open to war on all sides; Benchu (Yuan Shao) might grow strong, but with powerful men just now rising, nothing could be guaranteed. Liu Biao of Jing Province, on the other hand, had no further far-reaching ambitions, cherished people and delighted in scholars, and his land was rugged, so he would be easy to rely on. Records, Wei 23 §2
He Qia went south with his relatives and old friends to follow Liu Biao, who treated him as an honoured guest. But He Qia said that he had not followed Benchu in order to avoid a contested land, and that the ruler of a benighted age should not be approached too closely, for in time one would be in danger and there would surely be slanderers who would sow discord; he then crossed south to Wuling. Records, Wei 23 §3
When the Grand Progenitor pacified Jing Province, he summoned him and made him a member of the Chancellor's staff. At that time Mao Jie and Cui Yan put frugality and restraint first in selecting officials. He Qia said that the great vessels of the realm could not be judged by a single standard of conduct. Frugality beyond the proper measure was acceptable as one's own personal conduct, but if others were measured by it, gentlemen would deliberately soil their clothes and hide their carriages and robes, and falsehood was bound to hide in extreme and eccentric conduct. Records, Wei 23 §4–5
When the state of Wei was founded he became Palace Attendant. Later someone reported that Mao Jie had slandered the Grand Progenitor, and when the Grand Progenitor was furious, He Qia stated that Mao Jie's conduct had always had a sound foundation and asked that the matter be investigated to establish the facts. When the Grand Progenitor said that he would not investigate because he wished to keep both Mao Jie and the informer whole, He Qia replied that if Mao Jie had truly slandered the sovereign he should be executed in the marketplace and at court, and if not, the informer had falsely accused a high minister, and that he would feel uneasy if neither were investigated. The Grand Progenitor said that with military affairs in hand he could not open an investigation merely on someone's word. According to the Biography of Mao Jie, Huan Jie and He Qia spoke up to save Mao Jie, but Mao Jie was in the end dismissed and died at home. Records, Wei 23 §6–9Records, Wei 12 §34
According to the Biography of Du Xi, when the state of Wei was founded, Du Xi was employed as Palace Attendant together with Wang Can and He Qia. Wang Can often rode in the Grand Progenitor's carriage, but the respect shown him did not match that shown to He Qia and Du Xi. When Du Xi once had an audience alone with the Grand Progenitor until midnight, Wang Can fretted that he did not know what they were talking about, and He Qia said with a laugh, 'How could the affairs of the realm ever come to an end? It should be enough for you to attend him by day — do you want the nights as well!' Records, Wei 23 §38–39
When the Grand Progenitor defeated Zhang Lu, He Qia proposed that the army be withdrawn and the people moved in good time, which would save the cost of keeping a garrison. The Grand Progenitor did not accept this, but afterwards he did in the end move the people and abandon Hanzhong. He Qia went out to become Prefect of the Palace Gentlemen; when Emperor Wen (Cao Pi) ascended the throne he became Superintendent of the Imperial Household and was enfeoffed as Marquis of Ancheng Village, and when Emperor Ming (Cao Rui) ascended the throne he was advanced to Marquis of Xiling District with a fief of 200 households. Records, Wei 23 §10
During the Taihe era, when the Cavalier Regular Attendant Gaotang Long memorialized that the seasonable winds did not blow because officials were not diligent in their duties, Emperor Ming issued an edict widely soliciting opinions. He Qia said that the people were few and the farmers fewer while those who ate without working were many, and that since spring and summer the people had been exhausted by labour service and farming had been neglected, which might be the cause. Nothing was greater than economy and frugality for averting calamity, so burdensome labour service should be halted, and for the defence of the frontiers plans should be fixed in advance and troops should not be raised again and again out of contempt for a petty enemy. Records, Wei 23 §11–13
He was transferred to Minister of Ceremonies, and kept so honest, poor and frugal that he came to sell his fields and house to support himself. When Emperor Ming heard of this, he granted him additional grain and silk. When he died he was given the posthumous name Marquis Jian, and his son He Li succeeded him. He Li's younger brother He You rose to Commandant of Justice and Master of Writing for Personnel. Records, Wei 23 §14
In his assessment Chen Shou said that He Qia was pure and mild and had a talent for managing affairs, and that together with Chang Lin, Yang Jun, Du Xi, Zhao Yan and Pei Qian he was one of the fine gentlemen of his age. Records, Wei 23 §75
He appears once in the Romance, in Chapter 66. After Cao Cao reads a letter from the Army Adviser Fu Gan and abandons his southern campaign, the four Palace Attendants Wang Can, Du Xi, Wei Ji and He Qia propose to elevate Cao Cao to King of Wei. When the Prefect of the Palace Secretariat Xun You objects that the Chancellor has already been made Duke of Wei with the added honour of the Nine Bestowments and that his rank has reached its limit, Cao Cao is angered, saying, 'Does this man mean to imitate Xun Yu?' Xun You falls ill from worry and resentment and dies, and Cao Cao drops the matter of becoming King of Wei. Romance, Ch. 66 §31–34
Proposing him as King of Wei: In Chapter 66 of the Romance, He Qia proposes together with Wang Can, Du Xi and Wei Ji to elevate Cao Cao to King of Wei. This does not appear in the Biography of He Qia in the Records, which says only that he became Palace Attendant when the state of Wei was founded. Romance, Ch. 66 §33Records, Wei 23 §1–15
Xun You's opposition and death: In Chapter 66 of the Romance, the Prefect of the Palace Secretariat Xun You opposes the proposal of He Qia and the others, incurs Cao Cao's anger, falls ill and dies. In the Biography of Xun You in the Records, Xun You became Prefect of the Masters of Writing when the state of Wei was first founded, and died on the road while accompanying the campaign against Sun Quan. Romance, Ch. 66 §33Records, Wei 10 §63 · 65
His career: In the Records, He Qia appears as a minister who avoided Yuan Shao and went to Liu Biao before coming to Cao Cao, defended Mao Jie, and proposed the withdrawal from Hanzhong and economy and frugality. In the Romance, He Qia is named only in a single scene of Chapter 66, and none of this is portrayed. Records, Wei 23 §2–3 · 6–8 · 10–12Romance, Ch. 66 §33
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RDefended Mao Jie, and was so honest and poor that he sold his fields and house to support himselfWei 23 §7Wei 23 §14
NProposed elevating Cao Cao to King of WeiCh. 66 §33
RSaw that Ji Province was a contested land, and his proposal to withdraw from Hanzhong was eventually carried outWei 23 §2Wei 23 §10
NNo direct record — only his title of Palace AttendantCh. 66 §33
RProposed measures for farming and economy, and the assessment credits him with a talent for managing affairsWei 23 §11Wei 23 §75
NNo direct record — only his title of Palace AttendantCh. 66 §33
RAvoided Yuan Shao and also left Liu Biao's side, keeping away from contested landsWei 23 §2Wei 23 §3
NFell in with Cao Cao's wishes and took part in proposing him as King of WeiCh. 66 §33
RArgued that officials should not be judged by frugality aloneWei 23 §4Wei 23 §5
NNo direct record — only his title of Palace AttendantCh. 66 §33
RArgued logically for an investigation of the Mao Jie affair, but was not heededWei 23 §8Wei 12 §34
NNo direct record — only his title of Palace AttendantCh. 66 §33
RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil officialWei 23 §10
NNo direct record — only his title of Palace AttendantCh. 66 §33
RNo direct record — estimated from his career as a civil officialWei 23 §10
NNo direct record — only his title of Palace AttendantCh. 66 §33
RNo direct record — only the record of his moving together with relatives and old friendsWei 23 §3
NNo direct record — only his title of Palace AttendantCh. 66 §33
RNo direct record — estimated from the assessment of him as a pure and mild gentlemanWei 23 §75
NNo direct record — estimated from his title of Palace AttendantCh. 66 §33
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →