Lou Xuan 樓玄

RecordsRomance Wu Courtesy name 承先 Chengxian楼玄누현승선

Profile
OccupationRNOfficial · Minister of AgricultureFactionWu
AppearsRNBiography inBook of Wu
BornNative placePei Commandery Qi County
Cause of deathRSuicide NExecuted Unverified
ExistenceHistoricalMentionsR14

Profile

Lou Xuan, courtesy name Chengxian, was a man of Qi County in Pei Commandery. Under Sun Xiu he became Censor Supervising Agriculture, and when Sun Hao took the throne he served as Palace Cavalier Regular Attendant and Administrator of Kuaiji before becoming Minister of Agriculture, and as Guard Commander of the Inner Palace (gongxia zhen jinzhong hou) he took charge of affairs within the palace. Records, Wu 20 §8

His frank and upright answers repeatedly went against Sun Hao's wishes, and when he was falsely accused of slandering the government together with He Shao, he was sent to Guang Province. Sun Hao then handed him over to Zhang Yi, a commander in Jiaozhi, and secretly ordered that he be killed; after Zhang Yi died suddenly, Lou Xuan saw that edict, went back and killed himself. Records, Wu 20 §8–9 · 12

In his assessment, Chen Shou quoted Xue Ying's remark that he was 'pure and principled, with talent and reasoning that flowed unimpeded,' and Hu Chong's remark that among Lou Xuan, He Shao and Wang Fan, if one had to choose, Lou Xuan should stand first. In the Romance he appears once, in Chapter 120, and no chapter has his name in its title. His name appears as that of the Minister of Agriculture who, seeing Sun Hao's lawlessness, remonstrated with outspoken words and was put to death together with Wan Yu and Liu Ping. Records, Wu 20 §84Romance, Ch. 120 §20

In the Records

Lou Xuan, courtesy name Chengxian, was a man of Qi County in Pei Commandery. Under Sun Xiu he became Censor Supervising Agriculture. When Sun Hao took the throne, he and Wang Fan, Guo Chuo and Wan Yu all became Palace Cavalier Regular Attendants; he went out to be Administrator of Kuaiji and then came back to court as Minister of Agriculture. Records, Wu 20 §8

Formerly the ruler had chosen those in charge of the palace from among his intimates, but Wan Yu submitted that close and confidential posts should be filled with good men. Sun Hao ordered the responsible office to seek loyal and incorruptible gentlemen, and in the end made Lou Xuan Guard Commander of the Inner Palace (gongxia zhen jinzhong hou) and put him in charge of affairs within the palace. Though one of the Nine Ministers, Lou Xuan took up a post bearing a sword as a guard, kept himself upright to lead the others and acted in accordance with the law. But his answers were earnest and frank and repeatedly went against Sun Hao's wishes, so that he gradually incurred reproach and anger. Records, Wu 20 §8

Later someone falsely reported that Lou Xuan and He Shao had met, stopped to whisper to each other, laughed loudly and slandered the government. Lou Xuan was censured by edict and sent to Guang Province. The biography of He Shao records that those close to the throne who feared He Shao together made this slander, so that both men were censured; Lou Xuan was sent to the southern province, while He Shao was pardoned and restored to office. Records, Wu 20 §9 · 29

The Director of the Eastern Pavilion Hua He submitted a memorial saying that among all the officials there was no one better than Lou Xuan to be trusted with affairs, and that Lou Xuan, incorruptible and loyal in serving the public, was foremost in his age, so that all admired his integrity. He then asked that Lou Xuan's past faults be pardoned so that he might renew himself, and that he be promoted to a ministerial post and called on to show results in future. Records, Wu 20 §10–11

When Chancellor Lu Kai fell ill in the 1st year of Jianheng (269), he told the Prefect of the Palace Secretariat Dong Chao, whom Sun Hao had sent, that Yao Xin, Lou Xuan, He Shao and several others were all pillars of the altars of state and fine supporters of the nation, and that they should be consulted on the affairs of the day. In the memorial Lu Kang submitted on hearing that Xue Ying had been imprisoned, he named the former Minister of Agriculture Lou Xuan, the Palace Cavalier Regular Attendant Wang Fan and the Minister Steward Li Xu as outstanding talents of the age, said that all of them had been executed or banished, and said that he had been hoping Lou Xuan would be pardoned and recalled. Records, Wu 16 §28–29Records, Wu 13 §77–78

Sun Hao hated Lou Xuan's reputation, and he moved Lou Xuan and his son Lou Ju again, handing them over to Zhang Yi, a commander in Jiaozhi, to prove themselves in battle, while secretly issuing a separate order to Zhang Yi to kill him. Lou Ju died of illness on reaching Jiaozhi. Lou Xuan, alone, followed Zhang Yi in suppressing bandits, carrying a sword and wading across rivers on foot, and bowed to Zhang Yi every time he saw him, so that Zhang Yi could not bring himself to kill him. Records, Wu 20 §12

When Zhang Yi happened to die suddenly, Lou Xuan, while preparing Zhang Yi's body for burial, found the edict in a container, went back and at once killed himself. Chen Shou's main text does not record the year of his death. The biography of He Shao records that in the 1st year of Tiance (275), the year He Shao was put to death, an edict was also issued to kill Lou Xuan's sons and grandsons. Records, Wu 20 §12 · 29

In his assessment, Chen Shou, borrowing the words of Xue Ying, called Lou Xuan 'pure and principled, with talent and reasoning that flowed unimpeded.' He also recorded that Hu Chong held that 'Lou Xuan, He Shao and Wang Fan were all pure and outstanding in their time, with hardly any difference between them, but if one had to choose, Lou Xuan should stand first and He Shao next.' Records, Wu 20 §84

In the Romance

In Chapter 120 of the Romance, when Lu Kang submits a memorial saying that Jin cannot yet be attacked and urging him to cultivate virtue and be sparing with punishments, Sun Hao, declaring that Lu Kang is in league with the enemy, strips him of his military command and demotes him to Major (sima). The Romance goes on to record that from the time Sun Hao changed the era name to Jianheng until the 1st year of Fenghuang he ran wild as he pleased and mobilized troops without end, and that three men, the Chancellor Wan Yu, the general Liu Ping and the Minister of Agriculture Lou Xuan, seeing Sun Hao's lawlessness, remonstrated earnestly with outspoken words and were all put to death. Romance, Ch. 120 §19–20

In the same passage the Romance says that over some ten years Sun Hao killed more than forty loyal ministers and always went in and out escorted by fifty thousand armored cavalry, so that his ministers trembled with fear. Hearing that Lu Kang has lost his command and Sun Hao has lost his virtue, Yang Hu submits a memorial proposing an attack on Wu. In the Romance Lou Xuan's name appears only in this one passage. Romance, Ch. 120 §20–21

Where the Romance differs

How he died: In Chapter 120 of the Romance, Lou Xuan is put to death after remonstrating with Sun Hao in outspoken words. In the Records, Sun Hao handed him over to Zhang Yi, a commander in Jiaozhi, and secretly ordered him killed, but Zhang Yi could not bring himself to do it; after Zhang Yi died suddenly, Lou Xuan, while preparing the body for burial, saw the edict, went back and killed himself. Romance, Ch. 120 §20Records, Wu 20 §12

Why he was censured: Chapter 120 of the Romance gives his remonstrance with the lawless Sun Hao as the cause of his death. In the Records, someone falsely accused Lou Xuan of whispering with He Shao, laughing loudly and slandering the government, so he was censured and sent to Guang Province. It is recorded that Sun Hao later moved him to Jiaozhi because he hated his reputation. Romance, Ch. 120 §20Records, Wu 20 §9 · 12

Those who died with him: Chapter 120 of the Romance groups Wan Yu, Liu Ping and Lou Xuan together as three men who remonstrated together and all died. In the Biographies of the Three Successor Rulers in the Records, Wan Yu was reprimanded in the 1st year of Fenghuang (272) and died of anxiety. In the biographies of Lou Xuan and He Shao, the man censured together with Lou Xuan was He Shao; in the 1st year of Tiance (275) He Shao was shut up in the wine store and beaten and interrogated, but never said a single word, and was finally put to death. Romance, Ch. 120 §20Records, Wu 3 §64Records, Wu 20 §9 · 29

Offices: In the Romance he appears only with the title Minister of Agriculture. In the Records he served under Sun Xiu as Censor Supervising Agriculture and under Sun Hao as Palace Cavalier Regular Attendant, Administrator of Kuaiji and Minister of Agriculture, and on Wan Yu's proposal he became Guard Commander of the Inner Palace, bearing a sword as a guard and taking charge of affairs within the palace. Romance, Ch. 120 §20Records, Wu 20 §8

Son and descendants: In the Records, his son Lou Ju was moved to Jiaozhi with him and died of illness, and in the 1st year of Tiance (275) an edict was issued to kill Lou Xuan's sons and grandsons. The Romance tells nothing of his family. Records, Wu 20 §12 · 29Romance, Ch. 120 §20

Those who valued him: In the Records, Hua He memorialized that Lou Xuan be pardoned and promoted to a ministerial post, Lu Kai, facing death, named him as a pillar of the altars of state, and Lu Kang too, in a memorial, hoped that Lou Xuan would be pardoned and recalled. Lu Kang's memorial in Chapter 120 of the Romance concerns only that Jin cannot yet be attacked, and Lou Xuan does not appear in it. Records, Wu 20 §11Records, Wu 16 §28Records, Wu 13 §78Romance, Ch. 120 §19

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Abilities

The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.

LEASTRINTPOLCHAVIRADPSCHDIPDIS
Records (solid) vs Romance (dashed)
  • LEA3533−2
  • STR4533−12
  • INT4542−3
  • POL6848−20
  • CHA6040−20
  • VIR8872−16
  • ADP3240+8
  • SCH4238−4
  • DIP4542−3
  • DIS4035−5
Records · Romance scores and difference (Romance − Records · left = lowered by the Romance · right = raised)

Abilities shaped by the Romance — where it differs from the Records Differences of 10 or more

PoliticsR68N48Unverified −20

RAdministrator of Kuaiji and Minister of Agriculture; foremost among those trusted with public affairs, with unimpeded talentWu 20 §8Wu 20 §11Wu 20 §84

NNo direct record — estimated from his post as Minister of AgricultureCh. 120 §20

CharismaR60N40Unverified −20

RSaid to be so admired for his integrity that no one could vie with himWu 20 §11

NNo direct record — estimatedCh. 120 §20

VirtueR88N72 −16

RForemost in his age for incorruptibility and loyalty; the assessment calls him pure and principledWu 20 §11Wu 20 §84

NRemonstrated outspokenly against Sun Hao's lawlessness and was put to deathCh. 120 §20

StrengthR45N33Unverified −12

RFollowed the campaign against bandits alone, carrying a sword and wading rivers on footWu 20 §12

NNo direct record — estimatedCh. 120 §20

6 similar abilities — show evidence
  • LeadershipR35UnverifiedN33Unverified −2

    RNo direct record — estimatedWu 20 §12

    NNo direct record — estimatedCh. 120 §20

  • IntelligenceR45UnverifiedN42Unverified −3

    RNo direct record — estimatedWu 20 §8

    NNo direct record — estimatedCh. 120 §20

  • AdaptabilityR32N40Unverified +8

    RHis earnest, frank answers repeatedly crossed the ruler, leading to exile and suicideWu 20 §8Wu 20 §12

    NNo direct record — estimatedCh. 120 §20

  • ScholarshipR42UnverifiedN38Unverified −4

    RNo direct record — estimatedWu 20 §8

    NNo direct record — estimatedCh. 120 §20

  • DiplomacyR45N42Unverified −3

    RRecorded as earnest and frank in his answersWu 20 §8

    NNo direct record — estimated from his remonstranceCh. 120 §20

  • DiscernmentR40UnverifiedN35Unverified −5

    RNo direct record — estimatedWu 20 §8

    NNo direct record — estimatedCh. 120 §20

Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)

3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.

Romance chapters (1)

AppearsNot present Chapter list →

Allegiance history

  1. Wu · Records · Records vol. 65 「孫休時為監農御史」