RNo direct record — estimated from his being cited as a famous debaterWu 17 §35
NCould recite whatever he saw once, and his writing was widely known in his dayCh. 23 §8Ch. 60 §15
| Occupation | NOther · Retired Scholar | Faction | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appears | RN | Biography in | |
| Born | Native place | Pingyuan Commandery | |
| Died | Place of death | RXiakou NJiangxia Commandery | |
| Cause of death | RExecuted NExecuted Unverified | ||
| Existence | Historical | Mentions | R9 |
Mi Heng has no biography in the Records. In Chen Shou's main text his name appears only once, in Records of Wu 17, in the words of Hu Zong, who, assessing Yin Fan, a defector to Wu, for Sun Quan, said that 'his clever, nimble sophistry resembles Mi Heng'; his courtesy name, origin, offices and death are not recorded. Records, Wu 17 §34–35
The Romance portrays him as a retired scholar of Pingyuan with the courtesy name Zhengping. Recommended by Kong Rong, he comes before Cao Cao and disparages the men under him; before Cao Cao, who means to humiliate him by making him a drummer, he strips off his clothes and rebukes him; and after being sent as an envoy to Liu Biao in Jing Province, he is beheaded by Huang Zu in Jiangxia. Romance, Ch. 23 §7–8 · 13–17 · 19 · 22 · 27–28
In his assessment in Records of Wu 17, Chen Shou dealt only with Shi Yi, Xu Xiang and Hu Zong, and not with Mi Heng. In the Romance he first appears in Chapter 23 in Kong Rong's words and appears in 3 of the 120 chapters, and he is named by his courtesy name in the title of Chapter 23, 'Mi Zhengping Strips and Rails at the Traitor'. In Chapters 40 and 60 his name only comes up in other people's words. Records, Wu 17 §42Romance, Ch. 23 §7 · 16–17Romance, Ch. 40 §7–8Romance, Ch. 60 §15
Chen Shou's main text has no biography of Mi Heng, and his name appears once in Records of Wu 17. In the 2nd year of Huanglong (230), when Yin Fan of Qing Province defected to Wu and submitted a letter asking to be summoned for an audience, Sun Quan at once called him in. Yin Fan answered questions and set out the affairs of the day, and his eloquence was well worth seeing. Records, Wu 17 §34–35
Hu Zong, who was then sitting in attendance, answered Sun Quan's question of what he thought: 'Yin Fan's letter, in its boasting, resembles Dongfang Shuo, and its clever, nimble sophistry resembles Mi Heng. But in talent he falls short of both.' Sun Quan made Yin Fan Inspector under the Commandant of Justice, but Yin Fan later plotted rebellion, was discovered and executed. Chen Shou's main text records nothing further about Mi Heng himself. Records, Wu 17 §35–36
In Chapter 23 of the Romance, when Cao Cao wants to coax Liu Biao into submitting, Jia Xu says a scholar famed for his writing must be sent, and Xun You recommends Kong Rong. Kong Rong says, 'My friend Mi Heng, courtesy name Zhengping, is ten times more talented than I,' and submits a memorial recommending him to the emperor. The memorial introduces him as a retired scholar of Pingyuan, twenty-four years old, and praises him as one who can recite whatever he has seen once and never forgets what he has heard but briefly. Romance, Ch. 23 §6–8
Cao Cao summons him but does not invite him to sit. When Mi Heng sighs, 'Heaven and earth are so vast, yet how is there not a single man here?', Cao Cao names Xun Yu, Guo Jia, Zhang Liao, Xu Chu, Xiahou Dun, Cao Ren and others. Mi Heng disparages them one by one, saying for instance that Xun Yu is fit only for paying condolence calls and Zhang Liao only for beating drums and striking gongs, and calls the rest mere clothes racks, rice bags, wine casks and meat sacks. When Zhang Liao draws his sword to cut him down, Cao Cao makes him a drummer instead. He says that Mi Heng has an empty reputation, so that if he were killed the realm would say Cao Cao could not tolerate others, and that he means to humiliate him. Romance, Ch. 23 §11–15
At a banquet the next day Mi Heng, still in his old clothes, beats the drum and plays 'The Three Rolls of Yuyang', and the guests are all so stirred that they shed tears. Rebuked to change his clothes, he strips them off before everyone and stands naked, then slowly puts on his trousers. When Cao Cao calls this a breach of propriety, he replies that it is deceiving one's sovereign and slighting one's superiors that is a breach of propriety, and rebukes Cao Cao in such terms as that his eyes are foul because he cannot tell the worthy from the foolish, and his heart is foul because he constantly harbors usurpation. Romance, Ch. 23 §15–18
When Kong Rong, fearing that Cao Cao will kill him, steps forward, Cao Cao sends Mi Heng as an envoy to Jing Province, saying that if Liu Biao comes to surrender he will make him one of the high ministers. When he refuses to go, Cao Cao has two men hold him on either side and take him along. At the farewell outside the east gate, when Xun Yu and the others do not rise, Mi Heng wails aloud, saying, 'I am walking among the coffins of the dead—how could I not weep?', and declares that he is a subject of the Han court and has not become one of Cao Man's gang. Romance, Ch. 23 §19–21
Arriving in Jing Province, Mi Heng pretends to extol Liu Biao's virtue while mocking him, and Liu Biao sends him to Huang Zu in Jiangxia. Liu Biao says that Cao Cao means to borrow his hand to kill Mi Heng and saddle him with the infamy of having harmed a worthy man. In Xudu, too, Cao Cao answers Xun Yu's question by saying that he means to borrow Liu Biao's hand to kill him. Romance, Ch. 23 §22 · 25
Drunk together with Huang Zu, Mi Heng names as the figures of Xudu 'the big boy Kong Wenju and the little boy Yang Dezu', and tells Huang Zu that he is like a god in a shrine, who receives sacrifices but has no power to answer them. Huang Zu, in a great rage, beheads him, and Mi Heng does not stop cursing until the moment he dies. Liu Biao sighs and has him buried by the shore of Parrot Isle, and Cao Cao laughs, saying, 'The pedantic scholar made a sword of his tongue, and it has cut his own life short instead.' Romance, Ch. 23 §27–28 · 30
In Chapter 40, Xi Lü slanders Kong Rong, saying that Kong Rong and Mi Heng praised each other as 'Confucius not dead' and 'Yan Hui reborn', and that it was Kong Rong who put Mi Heng up to insulting the Chancellor. Cao Cao, in a great rage, has Kong Rong arrested. In Chapter 60, when Yang Xiu says to Cao Cao, who has treated Zhang Song coldly, 'Your Excellency tolerated even someone like Mi Heng,' Cao Cao replies that he could not bring himself to kill Mi Heng because his writing was widely known in his day. Romance, Ch. 40 §7–8Romance, Ch. 60 §15
Courtesy name and origin: Chapter 23 of the Romance, through Kong Rong's memorial, introduces him as a retired scholar of Pingyuan with the courtesy name Zhengping, twenty-four years old. In Chen Shou's main text Mi Heng's name appears only once, in Hu Zong's words in Records of Wu 17, and his courtesy name, origin and age are not recorded. Romance, Ch. 23 §7–8Records, Wu 17 §35
Kong Rong's recommendation and the meeting with Cao Cao: In Chapter 23 of the Romance, recommended by Kong Rong, he comes before Cao Cao, disparages the men under him and is made a drummer. These events are not in Chen Shou's main text. Romance, Ch. 23 §7 · 11–15Records, Wu 17 §35
Stripping and rebuking: The performance of 'The Three Rolls of Yuyang' and the scene in which he rebukes Cao Cao naked in Chapter 23 of the Romance are not in Chen Shou's main text. Romance, Ch. 23 §16–18Records, Wu 17 §35
The envoy to Jing Province and Han Song: In Chapter 23 of the Romance, Cao Cao sends Mi Heng to Liu Biao as an envoy, and at about the same time Liu Biao sends Han Song to Xudu to observe how things stand. The Biography of Liu Biao in the Records states only that when Cao Cao and Yuan Shao were facing each other at Guandu, the Attendant Gentleman Han Song and others urged Liu Biao to side with Lord Cao, and Liu Biao sent Han Song to Taizu to find out how matters really stood; Mi Heng does not appear. Romance, Ch. 23 §19 · 23–25Records, Wei 6 §86–88
Death: In Chapter 23 of the Romance, Huang Zu, enraged at being called 'a god in a shrine' over drinks, beheads him, and Liu Biao buries him by the shore of Parrot Isle. Chen Shou's main text does not record Mi Heng's death. Romance, Ch. 23 §27–28Records, Wu 17 §35
Kong Rong's death: In Chapter 40 of the Romance, Xi Lü slanders Kong Rong by citing how Kong Rong and Mi Heng praised each other and how Mi Heng insulted the Chancellor. The Biography of Cui Yan in the Records states only that Taizu was jealous by nature, and that Kong Rong of Lu, together with Xu You and Lou Gui of Nanyang, relied on old ties, were not respectful and were put to death; Mi Heng does not appear. Romance, Ch. 40 §7–8Records, Wei 12 §19
The comparison with Zhang Song: In Chapter 60 of the Romance, Yang Xiu and Cao Cao speak of Mi Heng in comparison with Zhang Song. The Biography of Liu Zhang in the Records states only that, having already pacified Jing Province and driven off the First Sovereign, Cao Cao no longer paid any attention to Zhang Song; Mi Heng does not appear. Romance, Ch. 60 §15Records, Shu 1 §14
Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.
The Records score (Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms, main text) is the baseline. Each ability compares how the Romance redrew the same person, and the evidence from both sources explains the difference.
RNo direct record — estimated from his being cited as a famous debaterWu 17 §35
NCould recite whatever he saw once, and his writing was widely known in his dayCh. 23 §8Ch. 60 §15
RNo direct record — mentioned only as a comparisonWu 17 §35
NInsulted Cao Cao and Liu Biao and was beheaded for mocking Huang ZuCh. 23 §17Ch. 23 §22Ch. 23 §27
RNo direct record — mentioned only as a comparisonWu 17 §35
NDismissed all the talents under Cao Cao as clothes racks and rice bagsCh. 23 §12Ch. 23 §14
RNo direct record — mentioned only as a comparisonWu 17 §35
NKong Rong praised his loyalty and uprightness, but he was naked and insolent at the banquetCh. 23 §9Ch. 23 §16Ch. 23 §17
RNo direct record — mentioned only as a comparisonWu 17 §35
NNo direct record — estimated as a retired scholarCh. 23 §14
RNo direct record — mentioned only as a comparisonWu 17 §35
NNo direct record — estimated as a retired scholarCh. 23 §14
RNo direct record — mentioned only as a comparisonWu 17 §35
NNo direct record — estimated as a retired scholarCh. 23 §14
RNo direct record — mentioned only as a comparisonWu 17 §35
NKnown far and wide, yet all of Cao Cao's officials wanted to kill himCh. 23 §15Ch. 23 §20
RCited as the model of clever, nimble sophistryWu 17 §35
NHis arguments welled up like a spring, but as envoy he mocked Liu Biao and failedCh. 23 §9Ch. 23 §22
NMaster +25 Beat out 'The Three Rolls of Yuyang' on the drum so exquisitely that all the guests shed tearsCh. 23 §16
Records Romance Unverified No direct record; scored from their actions (evidence grade C)
3KDEX scoring — the Records use the main text of Chen Shou’s Records of the Three Kingdoms; the Romance uses the 120-chapter Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Click a source tag to open that passage in the reader.
AppearsNot present Chapter list →
Includes automatic matching from Wikipedia infoboxes and source keywords (unverified).