Battle

Battle of Wuchao 烏巢之戰

About this event

The Battle of Wuchao was the fight in the 10th month of winter in the 5th year of Jian'an (200) in which Cao Cao, facing Yuan Shao at Guandu, personally attacked and crushed the grain escort under Chunyu Qiong and others that was stationed at Wuchao, 40 li north of Yuan Shao's camp. When Yuan Shao's strategist Xu You fled over and urged him to attack Chunyu Qiong and the others, Cao Cao left Cao Hong to guard his main camp, set out at night with 5,000 infantry and cavalry and arrived around daybreak. Chunyu Qiong and the others were all beheaded, and when Zhang He and Gao Lan, whom Yuan Shao had sent to attack Cao Cao's main camp, surrendered, Yuan Shao's army collapsed. Records, Wei 1 §68–70

Chen Shou recorded this fight in the Annals of Emperor Wu in Records of Wei 1 and the Biography of Yuan Shao in Records of Wei 6, and also spread it across the biographies of Xun Yu, Xun You and Jia Xu in Records of Wei 10 and the Biographies of Zhang Liao, Yue Jin, Yu Jin, Zhang He and Xu Huang in Records of Wei 17. It was the fight that decided the Battle of Guandu. The Romance depicts this fight in Chapter 30, "Fighting at Guandu, Benchu suffers a crushing defeat; raiding Wuchao, Mengde burns the grain." Records, Wei 1 §68–70Records, Wei 6 §53–54Records, Wei 10 §32 · 59–60Records, Wei 17 §21 · 42–44Romance, Ch. 30 §20–49

Course of events in the Records

Cao Cao and Yuan Shao held out against each other at Guandu for several months. Cao Cao beheaded enemy generals in every fight, but his troops were few and his provisions ran out, and his soldiers were exhausted; the Biography of Yuan Shao records that during the long standoff the common people grew weary and many rebelled to side with Yuan Shao. Cao Cao told the transport workers that in fifteen days he would defeat Yuan Shao and trouble them no more. In Jia Xu's biography, Jia Xu said that although Cao Cao surpassed Yuan Shao in four respects, he had failed to reach a decision in half a year because he was concerned with complete safety, and if he seized the decisive moment, he could settle it in no time. Records, Wei 1 §68Records, Wei 6 §53Records, Wei 10 §80–81

In the 10th month of winter Yuan Shao had grain carried by cart and had Chunyu Qiong and four others escort it with more than 10,000 troops, and Chunyu Qiong camped at Wuchao, 40 li from Yuan Shao's camp. In the Biography of Yuan Shao, Ju Shou proposed sending the general Jiang Qi to set up a separate detachment outside to cut off raids by Lord Cao, but Yuan Shao did not follow him. Zhang He's biography records that Chunyu Qiong and the others supervised the grain transport and were stationed at Wuchao. Records, Wei 1 §68Records, Wei 6 §53Records, Wei 17 §42

At this time Yuan Shao's strategist Xu You fled over and urged Cao Cao to attack Chunyu Qiong and the others. The Annals of Emperor Wu say this was because Xu You was greedy for wealth and Yuan Shao could not satisfy his desires, while Xun Yu's biography records that when Shen Pei arrested Xu You's wife and children over his family's lawbreaking, Xu You in anger betrayed Yuan Shao. In Xun You's biography, Xu You said that Chunyu Qiong and the others had come with more than 10,000 troops to meet the grain, and with the general arrogant and the soldiers lax, they could be intercepted and attacked. Those around Cao Cao were doubtful, but Xun You and Jia Xu urged him on. Records, Wei 1 §69Records, Wei 10 §32 · 59–60

Cao Cao left Cao Hong to guard the camp (Xun You's biography says Xun You and Cao Hong), personally led 5,000 infantry and cavalry out at night and reached Wuchao around daybreak. Chunyu Qiong and the others, seeing how few Cao Cao's troops were, drew up outside the gate of their camp, but when Cao Cao attacked swiftly they fell back to defend the camp. As Cao Cao was attacking the camp, cavalry sent by Yuan Shao drew near, and those around him proposed dividing the troops to hold them off. Cao Cao angrily said, "Report to me when the enemy is at our backs," and the soldiers all fought to the death, crushing Chunyu Qiong and the others and beheading them all. Yue Jin's biography records that he fought hard and beheaded Chunyu Qiong. Records, Wei 1 §69–70Records, Wei 10 §60Records, Wei 17 §21

In Zhang He's biography, Zhang He said that Cao Cao's troops were elite and that if Chunyu Qiong and the others were defeated the great cause would be finished, and urged a swift rescue, but Guo Tu said that if they attacked the main camp Cao Cao would surely return, and Zhang He countered that Cao Cao's camp was strong and could not be taken. Yuan Shao sent only light cavalry to rescue Chunyu Qiong and attacked Cao Cao's camp with his main army, but could not take it. The Annals of Emperor Wu record that Yuan Shao told his eldest son Yuan Tan that if they seized Cao Cao's camp while he was attacking Chunyu Qiong, Cao Cao would have nowhere to return to, and had Zhang He and Gao Lan attack Cao Hong. Records, Wei 17 §43Records, Wei 1 §70

On hearing that Chunyu Qiong had been defeated, Zhang He and the others came and surrendered. Zhang He's biography says that Zhang He, fearing slander from the shamed Guo Tu, came over, and Xun You's biography records that Zhang He and Gao Lan burned their siege towers and surrendered, and when Cao Hong was suspicious and would not accept them, Xun You had them accepted, saying they had come in anger because their plans were not used. Yuan Shao's army collapsed, and Yuan Shao and Yuan Tan abandoned their troops, fled and crossed the Yellow River. Xun Yu's biography records that a surprise force attacked Yuan Shao's separate encampment and beheaded Chunyu Qiong and the others, and Yuan Shao withdrew and fled. Records, Wei 1 §70Records, Wei 17 §44Records, Wei 10 §60 · 32

In the Romance

In Chapter 30 of the Romance, when Xu Huang and Shi Huan burn Han Meng's grain wagons, Shen Pei says that Wuchao is where the grain is stored and should be guarded by a large army. Yuan Shao sends Shen Pei back to Ye to supervise the provisions, and gives Chunyu Qiong, a hard-tempered man fond of drink, generals such as Sui Yuanjin and 20,000 men and horses to guard Wuchao. At Wuchao Chunyu Qiong drinks with his generals all day long. Romance, Ch. 30 §16–21

Xu You, who has got hold of Cao Cao's letter pressing for grain, urges a surprise attack on Xuchang, but Yuan Shao takes it for a ruse to lure him, and after reading a letter saying that Shen Pei has imprisoned Xu You's sons and nephews, he drives Xu You away. When Xu You comes to him, Cao Cao runs out barefoot to greet him, repeatedly lies about how much grain he has left, and is startled when Xu You produces his own letter. Xu You tells him to pretend to be Yuan Shao's general Jiang Qi come to guard the grain, and to burn the grain and baggage at Wuchao. Romance, Ch. 30 §21–32

Cao Cao reassures Zhang Liao, who suspects a trick, has Xun You, Jia Xu and Cao Hong guard the main camp together with Xu You and sets ambushes on both flanks, then personally sets out by night with 5,000 men flying Yuan Shao's banners and carrying grass and firewood. Ju Shou, in confinement, sees the planet Venus and urges that Wuchao be guarded, but Yuan Shao beheads the man who was watching over him. Reaching Wuchao at the fourth watch by pretending to be Jiang Qi's troops, Cao Cao sets fires on all sides, and Chunyu Qiong, who has been lying drunk, is caught with hooks and captured. When Sui Yuanjin and others come to the rescue, Cao Cao shouts, "Only when the enemy reaches our backs, turn and fight!" and the grain is burned to the last. Cao Cao cuts off Chunyu Qiong's ears, nose and fingers, ties him to a horse and sends him back to Yuan Shao's camp. Romance, Ch. 30 §33–41

Instead of following Zhang He, who wants to rescue Wuchao, Yuan Shao follows Guo Tu's advice to attack the main camp, which Guo Tu calls Sun Bin's stratagem, and has Zhang He and Gao Lan attack Cao Cao's camp with 5,000 men while Jiang Qi goes to rescue Wuchao with 10,000. Cao Cao deceives Jiang Qi by dressing his men in the clothes and banners of Chunyu Qiong's troops, and Zhang Liao beheads Jiang Qi. Zhang He and Gao Lan are badly beaten by Xiahou Dun, Cao Ren and Cao Hong, and Yuan Shao beheads Chunyu Qiong. When they are to be called to account because of Guo Tu's slander, Gao Lan beheads the envoy and surrenders to Cao Cao together with Zhang He. Romance, Ch. 30 §42–49

Where the Romance differs

Size of the escort: In Chapter 30 of the Romance, Chunyu Qiong guards Wuchao with 20,000 men and horses. In the Annals of Emperor Wu and Yuan Shao's biography in the Records, the troops led by Chunyu Qiong and his four colleagues numbered more than 10,000. Romance, Ch. 30 §20Records, Wei 1 §68Records, Wei 6 §53

Jiang Qi: In Chapter 30 of the Romance, Cao Cao reaches Wuchao by pretending to be Jiang Qi's troops, and Jiang Qi, on his way to rescue Wuchao, is beheaded by Zhang Liao. In the Biography of Yuan Shao in the Records, Jiang Qi appears only as the general Ju Shou named when he proposed setting up a separate detachment outside, and Yuan Shao did not follow that advice. Romance, Ch. 30 §39 · 43–44Records, Wei 6 §53

Chunyu Qiong's end: In Chapter 30 of the Romance, Chunyu Qiong is captured while drunk, sent back with his ears, nose and fingers cut off, and beheaded by Yuan Shao. In the Records, Cao Cao beheaded Chunyu Qiong and the others at Wuchao, and Yue Jin's biography records that Yue Jin took his head. Romance, Ch. 30 §39–41 · 47Records, Wei 1 §70Records, Wei 17 §21

The surrender of Zhang He and Gao Lan: In Chapter 30 of the Romance, the two are badly beaten by Xiahou Dun, Cao Ren and Cao Hong while attacking Cao Cao's main camp, and when they are summoned because of Guo Tu's slander, Gao Lan beheads the envoy and they surrender together. In Zhang He's biography in the Records, Yuan Shao's main army could not take Cao Cao's camp and Zhang He came over for fear of Guo Tu's slander, and Xun You's biography records that the two burned their siege towers and surrendered. Romance, Ch. 30 §46–49Records, Wei 17 §43–44Records, Wei 10 §60

Written by 3KDEX (not yet reviewed) — The tags at the end of each paragraph link to the exact passage in the Records volume or Romance chapter it is based on.

Belligerents

ItemAB
FactionsWeiYuan Shao faction
CommandersCao Cao, Xu You(許攸), Yue JinChunyu Qiong
Strength自將步騎五千人夜往使淳于瓊等五人將兵萬餘人送之

Factions, commanders, strength and casualties are checked against the source texts (3KDEX). Strength and casualties show only figures stated in the sources. Source: Wei 1 §70

Sub-events and Romance scenes (1)

Romance chapters (1)

Records volumes (4)